The Challenge: What Ifs

2827 posts / 0 new
Last post

What if they got Brooklyn team: Katellyn/Scott/Devyn/JD for Seasons 2?

All I have to say is poor Scott.

I think a team of Ryan/Scott/Baya/Sarah would have killed that season and won. 

What if they got Brooklyn team: Katellyn/Scott/Devyn/JD for Seasons 2?

All I have to say is poor Scott.

I think a team of Ryan/Scott/Baya/Sarah would have killed that season and won. 

Totally!

What if they got Brooklyn team: Katellyn/Scott/Devyn/JD for Seasons 2?

Theyd get sent home by Fresh Meat.

Not necessarily. Assuming Eric still does what he did in that elimination and San Diego does what they do at the end I think they make it to the end.


But at the same time, Brooklyn also won two missions after that and can they do that with two people dragging their team down?

No. But they wouldn't get last.

What if they got Brooklyn team: Katellyn/Scott/Devyn/JD for Seasons 2?

Theyd get sent home by Fresh Meat.

Not necessarily. Assuming Eric still does what he did in that elimination and San Diego does what they do at the end I think they make it to the end.


But at the same time, Brooklyn also won two missions after that and can they do that with two people dragging their team down?

No. But they wouldn't get last.


I'm not sure they wouldn't and even then, what's to say they're not thrown in again?

idkkk, I think bananas and nany might have beaten Wes and Theresa. Theresa beat nany in x battle but that's mostly about leverage. Nany was so mad that she probably would have mowed Theresa down. and bananas would have gotten Wes for sure because Wes really sucked on that elimination 

No way would Nany beat Theresa in Hall Brawl. 

idkkk, I think bananas and nany might have beaten Wes and Theresa. Theresa beat nany in x battle but that's mostly about leverage. Nany was so mad that she probably would have mowed Theresa down. and bananas would have gotten Wes for sure because Wes really sucked on that elimination 

No way would Nany beat Theresa in Hall Brawl. 

idkkk, I think bananas and nany might have beaten Wes and Theresa. Theresa beat nany in x battle but that's mostly about leverage. Nany was so mad that she probably would have mowed Theresa down. and bananas would have gotten Wes for sure because Wes really sucked on that elimination 

No way would Nany beat Theresa in Hall Brawl. 

What if the Road Rules team of Darrell, Derrick, Rachel and either Susie or Katie was cast on BOTS? Yes, they would've been in the minority, but I doubt many, if any, pairs could beat the Darrell (or Derrick) and Rachel duo in an elimination. Probably would've been the power team quite a few times, too.

 

What if they got Brooklyn team: Katellyn/Scott/Devyn/JD for Seasons 2?

Theyd get sent home by Fresh Meat.

Not necessarily. Assuming Eric still does what he did in that elimination and San Diego does what they do at the end I think they make it to the end.


But at the same time, Brooklyn also won two missions after that and can they do that with two people dragging their team down?

No. But they wouldn't get last.


I'm not sure they wouldn't and even then, what's to say they're not thrown in again?

They're a weak team. In a season like that it pays to keep teams whom are weaker because they most likely won't win.

But honestly they probably would've gotten thrown in at some point anyway so I see your point.

idkkk, I think bananas and nany might have beaten Wes and Theresa. Theresa beat nany in x battle but that's mostly about leverage. Nany was so mad that she probably would have mowed Theresa down. and bananas would have gotten Wes for sure because Wes really sucked on that elimination 

No way would Nany beat Theresa in Hall Brawl. 

Just depends how much of an advantage she would have. A lot of people say Theresa lost because she didn't have enough room to run and gain momentum while Nia was already 3/4th of the way through. Bananas would have easily beaten Wes so it just depends how far he push Wes back. 1v1 Theresa beats Nany in Hall Brawl but with a big advantage I wouldn't be suprised if Nany wins. 

What if Theresa/Wes vs Nia/Leroy in Hall wasn't a relay race and started in seperate heats? How well would Nia have done against Theresa without the head start and started equally?

What if Theresa/Wes vs Nia/Leroy in Hall wasn't a relay race and started in seperate heats? How well would Nia have done against Theresa without the head start and started equally?

Hard to say Nia is kind of unproven so if I had to choose I'd probaby say Theresa but if Nia won I wouldn't be suprised. It could go either way. 

I just realized , during the relay part of hall brawl, wouldnt it make sense to stay in it longer, like if Wes went really slow and plowed Nia over giving Theresa a clear path lol. Probably against the rules but could that work?

idkkk, I think bananas and nany might have beaten Wes and Theresa. Theresa beat nany in x battle but that's mostly about leverage. Nany was so mad that she probably would have mowed Theresa down. and bananas would have gotten Wes for sure because Wes really sucked on that elimination 

No way would Nany beat Theresa in Hall Brawl. 

Just depends how much of an advantage she would have. A lot of people say Theresa lost because she didn't have enough room to run and gain momentum while Nia was already 3/4th of the way through. Bananas would have easily beaten Wes so it just depends how far he push Wes back. 1v1 Theresa beats Nany in Hall Brawl but with a big advantage I wouldn't be suprised if Nany wins. 

that's what i was trying to say! i think it would definitely be possible for bananas and nany to win. which was why i said might and probably lol

StuffAndThings
Anonymous's picture

I just realized , during the relay part of hall brawl, wouldnt it make sense to stay in it longer, like if Wes went really slow and plowed Nia over giving Theresa a clear path lol. Probably against the rules but could that work?

I couldn't stop laughing from reading this.

Delete

I just realized , during the relay part of hall brawl, wouldnt it make sense to stay in it longer, like if Wes went really slow and plowed Nia over giving Theresa a clear path lol. Probably against the rules but could that work?

Wasn't Nia on the same side as Wes though? Not sure if that would've worked lol

what if theresa/camila made it to the finals on rivals 1?  imagine a finals with paula/evelyn, cara maria/laurel and theresa/camila. 

what if theresa/camila made it to the finals on rivals 1?  imagine a finals with paula/evelyn, cara maria/laurel and theresa/camila. 

That would be a horrible final.

what if theresa/camila made it to the finals on rivals 1?  imagine a finals with paula/evelyn, cara maria/laurel and theresa/camila. 


Intense final with 3 great teams, would have been unpredictable

what if theresa/camila made it to the finals on rivals 1?  imagine a finals with paula/evelyn, cara maria/laurel and theresa/camila. 

That would have been perfect. I could see them getting 2nd or even 1st for sure.

I just realized , during the relay part of hall brawl, wouldnt it make sense to stay in it longer, like if Wes went really slow and plowed Nia over giving Theresa a clear path lol. Probably against the rules but could that work?

Wasn't Nia on the same side as Wes though? Not sure if that would've worked lol


Oh yeah lol

what if theresa/camila made it to the finals on rivals 1?  imagine a finals with paula/evelyn, cara maria/laurel and theresa/camila. 

That would have been perfect. I could see them getting 2nd or even 1st for sure.


Idk Evelyn and Paula are some of the best girls you can have in a final, especially Evelyn. Still can't believe she won with broken ribs haha

What if Casey actually beat Susie in that last elimination in the Ruins? KA, Sarah and Casey vs JEKD in final>>>>

I just realized , during the relay part of hall brawl, wouldnt it make sense to stay in it longer, like if Wes went really slow and plowed Nia over giving Theresa a clear path lol. Probably against the rules but could that work?

Wasn't Nia on the same side as Wes though? Not sure if that would've worked lol

I just realized , during the relay part of hall brawl, wouldnt it make sense to stay in it longer, like if Wes went really slow and plowed Nia over giving Theresa a clear path lol. Probably against the rules but could that work?

Wasn't Nia on the same side as Wes though? Not sure if that would've worked lol


I already said never mind

I just realized , during the relay part of hall brawl, wouldnt it make sense to stay in it longer, like if Wes went really slow and plowed Nia over giving Theresa a clear path lol. Probably against the rules but could that work?

Wasn't Nia on the same side as Wes though? Not sure if that would've worked lol

I already said never mind

and so what. i can post it again if i want to.

what if theresa/camila made it to the finals on rivals 1?  imagine a finals with paula/evelyn, cara maria/laurel and theresa/camila. 

Evelyn and Paula would have still won. And I still think Laurel/Cara Maria would have gotten 2nd with Camila/Theresa 3rd, but they would have probably reached day 2 as opposed to Jenn and Mandi lol.

Yeah thats how it probably would have gone . But im happy to see the evoultion of cara over the years shes become a great competitor . If she gets the chance to come back shell win

What if on BOTS2, they had 2 Fresh Meat teams:

Fresh Meat 1 : Kenny/Evan/Ev/Diem

Fresh Meat 2 : Noor/Pete/Laurel/Cara Maria

Pages