The Challenge: What Ifs

2827 posts / 0 new
Last post

Pete/Camila would actually be interesting together, if Pete still is as competitive and intense as he was in FM2. Very similar

What if Jemmye didn't pulled the kill card on Free Agents? That means Camilla has to go against Latoya in "Balls In"? How well Toya would do? (Jemmye and Camilla was the last 2 girls standing in The Draw)

What if Jemmye didn't pulled the kill card on Free Agents? That means Camilla has to go against Latoya in "Balls In"? How well Toya would do? (Jemmye and Camilla was the last 2 girls standing in The Draw)

I would probably give that one to Camila, it'd be a great match though.

What if Johanna or Rachel were on BOTS instead of Lacy?

Rachel would lose it and have another pathetic meltdown for losing an elimination round lol

It'd be kind of interesting to see Johanna get paired with Wes because the whole team of Austin would have been exes but they would still probably get sent home early. I loved Lacey though. 

What if Jemmye didn't pulled the kill card on Free Agents? That means Camilla has to go against Latoya in "Balls In"? How well Toya would do? (Jemmye and Camilla was the last 2 girls standing in The Draw)

Camila would kill her. Toya is no punk tho!!

What if Jemmye didn't pulled the kill card on Free Agents? That means Camilla has to go against Latoya in "Balls In"? How well Toya would do? (Jemmye and Camilla was the last 2 girls standing in The Draw)

Actually Theresa was also still standing in the Draw. Camila was the 2nd to last and Theresa was the last. Latoya would've lost to both of them though.

What if Landon and Shavonda were on Battle of the Exes? I love both of them and it would be great seeing Landon pull an underdog win once again (taking a weak competitor to the finals and beating everyone) 

What if Landon and Shavonda were on Battle of the Exes? I love both of them and it would be great seeing Landon pull an underdog win once again (taking a weak competitor to the finals and beating everyone) 

Totally would have won it.

What if Landon and Shavonda were on Battle of the Exes? I love both of them and it would be great seeing Landon pull an underdog win once again (taking a weak competitor to the finals and beating everyone) 

Totally would have won it.

Frank is better than Dustin and Nia is better than Nany. I think Zach&Aneesa is weak pair and I just can not see them making into finale. Only thing they are good is physical.

no not really. well at least in Zach's case. and tbh i'm not really sure if you could say nia is better than Nany other than at puzzles and physcial match-up. everything else i would take Nany over Nia. plus her and dutin have strong team chemistry between each other so i can see them taking out Dustin and Nia.

Frank is better than Dustin and Nia is better than Nany. I think Zach&Aneesa is weak pair and I just can not see them making into finale. Only thing they are good is physical.

no not really. well at least in Zach's case. and tbh i'm not really sure if you could say nia is better than Nany other than at puzzles and physcial match-up. everything else i would take Nany over Nia. plus her and dutin have strong team chemistry between each other so i can see them taking out Dustin and Nia.


I can't see Dustin taking out Frank tbh.

Frank is better than Dustin and Nia is better than Nany. I think Zach&Aneesa is weak pair and I just can not see them making into finale. Only thing they are good is physical.

no not really. well at least in Zach's case. and tbh i'm not really sure if you could say nia is better than Nany other than at puzzles and physcial match-up. everything else i would take Nany over Nia. plus her and dutin have strong team chemistry between each other so i can see them taking out Dustin and Nia.

I can't see Dustin taking out Frank tbh.

Most of the time Frank would take out Dustin but Frank is gonna be held back by Nia in most things. Daily challenges Nia sucks so Dustin and Nany would beat them. If it's an elimination like Knot So Fast I could see Dustin/Nany winning but anything strength/weight wise Frank/Nia would win. In a final? Don't know how Nia would do so it could probably go either way but leaning toward Dustin/Nany cause they both have experienced a final.

What if Team Sydney stayed on Seasons 2 and the ninth team (Team Road Rules - Darrell, Derrick, Katie, Rachel) was added into the game before the first mission? The outcome of that challenge would've been completely different. 

What if Team Sydney stayed on Seasons 2 and the ninth team (Team Road Rules - Darrell, Derrick, Katie, Rachel) was added into the game before the first mission? The outcome of that challenge would've been completely different. 

Honestly, Road Rules would've probably won a majority of the missions and probably the entire challenge. Derrick, Darrell, and Rachel make up a deadly combination and Katie is no slouch. Would they have been targeted as a top team and a serious threat? Yes sir, but no female on that season was beating Rachel in Hall Brawl. Derrick and Darrell wouldn't lose Balls In, they are too competitive to half *** the elimination and would've went balls to the wall the entire time. That's half the eliminations that I don't see RR losing, if they played it correctly.

There were a couple crapshoot missions that season, but a majority of them, Road Rules would've had the best chance of winning. Each one of the four are not only champions, but they've all been teammates with each other at one point in time. They probably would've had a Cancun vibe where everyone got along and each one of them had their own strengths that would contribute to a solid team.

Alton and Derrick were always good friends, Vegas probably would've aligned with them and, honestly, I think both teams would've controled the challenge. Freah Meat could've been part of that alliance as well.

God I wish they let Road Rules compete. It would've been awesome to see four of the most memorable champions go out on top one last time together.

What if Team Sydney stayed on Seasons 2 and the ninth team (Team Road Rules - Darrell, Derrick, Katie, Rachel) was added into the game before the first mission? The outcome of that challenge would've been completely different. 

Honestly, Road Rules would've probably won a majority of the missions and probably the entire challenge. Derrick, Darrell, and Rachel make up a deadly combination and Katie is no slouch. Would they have been targeted as a top team and a serious threat? Yes sir, but no female on that season was beating Rachel in Hall Brawl. Derrick and Darrell wouldn't lose Balls In, they are too competitive to half *** the elimination and would've went balls to the wall the entire time. That's half the eliminations that I don't see RR losing, if they played it correctly.

There were a couple crapshoot missions that season, but a majority of them, Road Rules would've had the best chance of winning. Each one of the four are not only champions, but they've all been teammates with each other at one point in time. They probably would've had a Cancun vibe where everyone got along and each one of them had their own strengths that would contribute to a solid team.

Alton and Derrick were always good friends, Vegas probably would've aligned with them and, honestly, I think both teams would've controled the challenge. Freah Meat could've been part of that alliance as well.

God I wish they let Road Rules compete. It would've been awesome to see four of the most memorable champions go out on top one last time together.

That's why I'm personally glad they didn't use them. To have a bunch of veterans dominate and win a season that's suppose to showcase and new group of challengers would've really made no sense and tainted the season. I'm willing to bet that's probably why they dropped them too.

What if the Exiles on Fresh Meat were like they were on Fresh Meat II where the teams had the same amount of weight? How much different would that season have turned out?

What if they brought in Laura as Sarah's alternate for Rivals 2? How far would they have made it?

What if they brought in Laura as Sarah's alternate for Rivals 2? How far would they have made it?

No impact what so ever. They'd be thrown in real quick.

What if the Exiles on Fresh Meat were like they were on Fresh Meat II where the teams had the same amount of weight? How much different would that season have turned out?

a lot different.  wes and casey had a huge advantage carrying a lot less weight. wes and casey had 113 lbs to carry.  johnnie and tonya had 253 lbs, danny and ev had 150 lbs.  those two exiles would have been closer.  

What if Katie was brought in as Sarahs replacement on Rivals 2?

as long as sarah and her partner didnt get last, i can see them lasting long.  i dont think the guys would have voted them into an elimination.  

What if they brought in Laura as Sarah's alternate for Rivals 2? How far would they have made it?

No impact what so ever. They'd be thrown in real quick.

They would have made it decently far. Sarah was in with the majority alliance so she would have made it at least past Nany/Jonna if they never came in last. Laura is average/solid and Sarah is good/great so they would have done well overall. Probably as well as Diem/Aneesa and Camila/Jeymme did. 

What if Katie was brought in as Sarahs replacement on Rivals 2?

that would have been sooooooo great. but i still don't see them making it to the end. tbh they would have gotten themselves thrown in because katie ****** up a mission, just like katelynn did to sarah on rivals 1

What if Exes were Duel III? (Dustin&Heather and Vinny&sarah stays)

Final females:

Rachel

Emily

Camilla/Cara Maria

Guys:

CT

Abram

Mark/Leroy

What if Exes were Duel III? (Dustin&Heather and Vinny&sarah stays)

Final females:

Rachel

Emily

Camilla/Cara Maria

Guys:

CT

Abram

Mark/Leroy


I'd say bananas over Abram, Abram lost to ty after all.

What if Abram beat Ty in X Battle? and it went to a coin toss and Abram beat him again? Do you think Abram and Cara would've had a greater impact?

What if Abram beat Ty in X Battle? and it went to a coin toss and Abram beat him again? Do you think Abram and Cara would've had a greater impact?

I'm 90 percent sure they would have been out next because Cara wouldn't have beat any of those girls up that slope in the next challenge. But even if they didn't get last, they would just be voted into the Dome. If would have been Dunbar and Paula vs. Abram and Cara Maria in the "Banded Together" Dome, I think they would have lost because I cannot see the old Cara Maria being able to make it all the way. 

So in the end, if they did beat Ty and Emily they would be sent home next, and Dunbar and Paula would have been in the final. 

What if Team Sydney stayed on Seasons 2 and the ninth team (Team Road Rules - Darrell, Derrick, Katie, Rachel) was added into the game before the first mission? The outcome of that challenge would've been completely different. 

Honestly, Road Rules would've probably won a majority of the missions and probably the entire challenge. Derrick, Darrell, and Rachel make up a deadly combination and Katie is no slouch. Would they have been targeted as a top team and a serious threat? Yes sir, but no female on that season was beating Rachel in Hall Brawl. Derrick and Darrell wouldn't lose Balls In, they are too competitive to half *** the elimination and would've went balls to the wall the entire time. That's half the eliminations that I don't see RR losing, if they played it correctly.

There were a couple crapshoot missions that season, but a majority of them, Road Rules would've had the best chance of winning. Each one of the four are not only champions, but they've all been teammates with each other at one point in time. They probably would've had a Cancun vibe where everyone got along and each one of them had their own strengths that would contribute to a solid team.

Alton and Derrick were always good friends, Vegas probably would've aligned with them and, honestly, I think both teams would've controled the challenge. Freah Meat could've been part of that alliance as well.

God I wish they let Road Rules compete. It would've been awesome to see four of the most memorable champions go out on top one last time together.

All of this, except FM woudn't have been apart of the game altogether lol

Road Rules being on would've helped the rookies for future seasons imo...most people didn't take too kindly to Zach/Frank/Knight at first; SD winning certainly didn't help things. Road Rules could've been used to gradually introduce the new people instead of having so many new ones on at once...I liked all the new people but there needed to be a balance.

Season 2 should have been Vegas 1 , Sydney , Brooklyn , Cancun , D.C , NOLA , Vegas 2 and San Diego 2 IMHO it would have been a crazy mix. Road Rules like FM would defeat the premise of the the actual season .

What if Katie was brought in as Sarahs replacement on Rivals 2?

They go home instead of Ana and Jess.

Pages