The Challenge: What Ifs

2827 posts / 0 new
Last post

 

What if Susie was on The Duel 2?

She would've finally been eliminated. The Duel format is awful for her gameplay.

Eh she would have made it far based on politics but they are definitely people on the cast that could have taken her out.

True. I think she'd do good. I could see her beating every female there besides Rachel, Aneesa, and Brittini. She could've definetly beat Aneesa in Spot On though. 

What if Emily was on Challenge 2000 instead of Piggy or Holly?  Would she & Veronica have bonded, paving the way for their alliance in future challenges, thus depriving us of  one of the greatest challenge rivalries of all time??

I think they would of bonded because back then veronica was a lot more likeable, as well as emily b and i think they would of been friends. On battle of the seasons they were friendly, their hatred for eachother did not come about until battle of the sexes

What if Jonna didn't lost her passport and was actually a alumni on Fresh Meat 2 instead of Evelyn replacing her? How well do yous guys think she would done in those missions and exiles? And interacting with that cast?

What if Jonna didn't lost her passport and was actually a alumni on Fresh Meat 2 instead of Evelyn replacing her? How well do yous guys think she would done in those missions and exiles? And interacting with that cast?

Assuming she was partners with Luke, what do you think the elimination order would have looked like?

She  probably would have been in Wes's alliance since cj was with Wes. I can see Wes throwing her in before Danny. So I think Jillian and Pete would have eliminated them early.

What if Kimberly had picked Paula for "Push Over" instead of Jenn on The Duel 2?

What if Battle of the Exes 2 was scraped last minute and we got The Duel 3?

*Not including CT/Diem

This is what I think would've went down:

The Elevator

JJ -> Knight

Back Off

Simone -> Jemmye

Push Over

Adam -> Thomas

Duel Pole Dancing

Brittany -> Hailey

Spot On

Dustin -> Knight

Back Off

Jessica -> Simone

The Elevator

Adam -> Jay

Push Over

Hailey -> Jonna

Spot On

Adam -> Dustin

Back Off

Jessica -> Jenna

Duel Pole Dancing

Dustin -> Jordan

Push Over

Averey -> Jonna

The Elevator

Dustin -> Johnny

Back Off

Jessica -> Nany

Spot On

Wes -> Johnny

Push Over

Nia -> Nany

Duel Pole Dancing

Wes -> Bananas

The Elevator

Averey -> Sarah

 

FINAL CHALLENGE

Winners - Bananans and Sarah

Second Place - Zach and Theresa

Third Place - Leroy and Nia

 

The Elevator needs to return. One of the best eliminations. It would be EPIC to see Bloodlines face off in it, a battle of who wants it more.

Leroy with no alliance is never in eliminiation round?

I don't think any of the guys would call Leroy out.

What if Battle of the Exes 2 was scraped last minute and we got The Duel 3?

*Not including CT/Diem

This is what I think would've went down:

The Elevator

JJ -> Knight

Back Off

Simone -> Jemmye

Push Over

Adam -> Thomas

Duel Pole Dancing

Brittany -> Hailey

Spot On

Dustin -> Knight

Back Off

Jessica -> Simone

The Elevator

Adam -> Jay

Push Over

Hailey -> Jonna

Spot On

Adam -> Dustin

Back Off

Jessica -> Jenna

Duel Pole Dancing

Dustin -> Jordan

Push Over

Averey -> Jonna

The Elevator

Dustin -> Johnny

Back Off

Jessica -> Nany

Spot On

Wes -> Johnny

Push Over

Nia -> Nany

Duel Pole Dancing

Wes -> Bananas

The Elevator

Averey -> Sarah

 

FINAL CHALLENGE

Winners - Bananans and Sarah

Second Place - Zach and Theresa

Third Place - Leroy and Nia

No way does Sarah beat Theresa in an individual final challenge.

What if Battle of the Exes 2 was scraped last minute and we got The Duel 3?

*Not including CT/Diem

This is what I think would've went down:

The Elevator

JJ -> Knight

Back Off

Simone -> Jemmye

Push Over

Adam -> Thomas

Duel Pole Dancing

Brittany -> Hailey

Spot On

Dustin -> Knight

Back Off

Jessica -> Simone

The Elevator

Adam -> Jay

Push Over

Hailey -> Jonna

Spot On

Adam -> Dustin

Back Off

Jessica -> Jenna

Duel Pole Dancing

Dustin -> Jordan

Push Over

Averey -> Jonna

The Elevator

Dustin -> Johnny

Back Off

Jessica -> Nany

Spot On

Wes -> Johnny

Push Over

Nia -> Nany

Duel Pole Dancing

Wes -> Bananas

The Elevator

Averey -> Sarah

 

FINAL CHALLENGE

Winners - Bananans and Sarah

Second Place - Zach and Theresa

Third Place - Leroy and Nia

No way does Sarah beat Theresa in an individual final challenge.

The thought of Bananas winning his sixth challenge makes me cringe lmaooo

What if Battle of the Exes 2 was scraped last minute and we got The Duel 3?

*Not including CT/Diem

This is what I think would've went down:

The Elevator

JJ -> Knight

Back Off

Simone -> Jemmye

Push Over

Adam -> Thomas

Duel Pole Dancing

Brittany -> Hailey

Spot On

Dustin -> Knight

Back Off

Jessica -> Simone

The Elevator

Adam -> Jay

Push Over

Hailey -> Jonna

Spot On

Adam -> Dustin

Back Off

Jessica -> Jenna

Duel Pole Dancing

Dustin -> Jordan

Push Over

Averey -> Jonna

The Elevator

Dustin -> Johnny

Back Off

Jessica -> Nany

Spot On

Wes -> Johnny

Push Over

Nia -> Nany

Duel Pole Dancing

Wes -> Bananas

The Elevator

Averey -> Sarah

 

FINAL CHALLENGE

Winners - Bananans and Sarah

Second Place - Zach and Theresa

Third Place - Leroy and Nia

No way does Sarah beat Theresa in an individual final challenge.

Trust me I would want Theresa to win really bad considering she's one of my favorites but I just went off of what went down on Battle of the Exes 2 final.

What if... Free Agents was scraped last minute and it turns out to be The Duel.

Balls In

Chet -> Preston

LaToya -> Emilee

Wrecking Wall

Dustin -> Swift

Nia -> Jasmine

Looper

Chet -> Cohutta

LaToya -> Jemmye

Oppenheimer

Isaac -> Brandon

Jessica -> Jonna

Balls In

Chet -> Isaac

Jessica -> LaToya

Wrecking Wall

Jordan -> Dustin

Nia -> Devyn

Looper

Chet -> Dustin

Jessica -> Camila

Oppenheimer

Johnny -> Dustin

Nia -> Nany

Balls In

Frank -> Johnny

Aneesa -> Laurel

Wrecking Wall

Johnny -> Leroy

Nia -> Camila

Looper

Zach -> Bananas

Nia -> Cara Maria

 

FINAL CHALLENGE

1st - CT AND CARA MARIA

2nd - LEROY AND THERESA

3rd - ZACH AND ANEESA

What if Battle of the Exes 2 was scraped last minute and we got The Duel 3?

*Not including CT/Diem

This is what I think would've went down:

The Elevator

JJ -> Knight

Back Off

Simone -> Jemmye

Push Over

Adam -> Thomas

Duel Pole Dancing

Brittany -> Hailey

Spot On

Dustin -> Knight

Back Off

Jessica -> Simone

The Elevator

Adam -> Jay

Push Over

Hailey -> Jonna

Spot On

Adam -> Dustin

Back Off

Jessica -> Jenna

Duel Pole Dancing

Dustin -> Jordan

Push Over

Averey -> Jonna

The Elevator

Dustin -> Johnny

Back Off

Jessica -> Nany

Spot On

Wes -> Johnny

Push Over

Nia -> Nany

Duel Pole Dancing

Wes -> Bananas

The Elevator

Averey -> Sarah

 

FINAL CHALLENGE

Winners - Bananans and Sarah

Second Place - Zach and Theresa

Third Place - Leroy and Nia

No way does Sarah beat Theresa in an individual final challenge.

The thought of Bananas winning his sixth challenge makes me cringe lmaooo

What if Knight/Jemmye face off against JJ/Simone in a physical Exile if Knight never DQ and injured his shoulder? Who would win?

What if... Free Agents was scraped last minute and it turns out to be The Duel.

Balls In

Chet -> Preston

LaToya -> Emilee

Wrecking Wall

Dustin -> Swift

Nia -> Jasmine

Looper

Chet -> Cohutta

LaToya -> Jemmye

Oppenheimer

Isaac -> Brandon

Jessica -> Jonna

Balls In

Chet -> Isaac

Jessica -> LaToya

Wrecking Wall

Jordan -> Dustin

Nia -> Devyn

Looper

Chet -> Dustin

Jessica -> Camila

Oppenheimer

Johnny -> Dustin

Nia -> Nany

Balls In

Frank -> Johnny

Aneesa -> Laurel

Wrecking Wall

Johnny -> Leroy

Nia -> Camila

Looper

Zach -> Bananas

Nia -> Cara Maria

 

FINAL CHALLENGE

1st - CT AND CARA MARIA

2nd - LEROY AND THERESA

3rd - ZACH AND ANEESA

I would be happy with this!

What if Knight/Jemmye face off against JJ/Simone in a physical Exile if Knight never DQ and injured his shoulder? Who would win?

Knight and Jemmye

What if Knight/Jemmye face off against JJ/Simone in a physical Exile if Knight never DQ and injured his shoulder? Who would win?

Probably Knight & Jemmye but they would have been sent home by Bananas & Nany the next week anyway so it would have all been for nothing.

Idk call me crazy but I don't think CT wins duel 1 hands down. He definitely wouldn't have won the soccer shoot out, really Wes would have wrecked anyone in that probably. The 2 minutes definitely helped a lot though. Also I don't think that CT completes his puzzle faster than Brad did. He also could have gassed, who knows? It was definitely a tough final and they didn't do it justice it seemed since they were only 30 minute long episodes then. Also the thing about that puzzle, you could easily just sneak a peek at what the other competitor is doing and somehow copy it. I remember Brad was done in seconds after Wes was, and took a couple peeks. But yeah I think it would've been closer than many would probably think between Wes and CT.

What if... Free Agents was scraped last minute and it turns out to be The Duel.

Balls In

Chet -> Preston

LaToya -> Emilee

Wrecking Wall

Dustin -> Swift

Nia -> Jasmine

Looper

Chet -> Cohutta

LaToya -> Jemmye

Oppenheimer

Isaac -> Brandon

Jessica -> Jonna

Balls In

Chet -> Isaac

Jessica -> LaToya

Wrecking Wall

Jordan -> Dustin

Nia -> Devyn

Looper

Chet -> Dustin

Jessica -> Camila

Oppenheimer

Johnny -> Dustin

Nia -> Nany

Balls In

Frank -> Johnny

Aneesa -> Laurel

Wrecking Wall

Johnny -> Leroy

Nia -> Camila

Looper

Zach -> Bananas

Nia -> Cara Maria

 

FINAL CHALLENGE

1st - CT AND CARA MARIA

2nd - LEROY AND THERESA

3rd - ZACH AND ANEESA


1. There is no way Frank could lose to Johnny R.
2. There is no way Jordan was left to be last. He had strongest alliance there
3. There is no way Aneesa could beat Laurel
but overall I like it

What if... Free Agents was scraped last minute and it turns out to be The Duel.

Balls In

Chet -> Preston

LaToya -> Emilee

Wrecking Wall

Dustin -> Swift

Nia -> Jasmine

Looper

Chet -> Cohutta

LaToya -> Jemmye

Oppenheimer

Isaac -> Brandon

Jessica -> Jonna

Balls In

Chet -> Isaac

Jessica -> LaToya

Wrecking Wall

Jordan -> Dustin

Nia -> Devyn

Looper

Chet -> Dustin

Jessica -> Camila

Oppenheimer

Johnny -> Dustin

Nia -> Nany

Balls In

Frank -> Johnny

Aneesa -> Laurel

Wrecking Wall

Johnny -> Leroy

Nia -> Camila

Looper

Zach -> Bananas

Nia -> Cara Maria

 

FINAL CHALLENGE

1st - CT AND CARA MARIA

2nd - LEROY AND THERESA

3rd - ZACH AND ANEESA

1. There is no way Frank could lose to Johnny R. 2. There is no way Jordan was left to be last. He had strongest alliance there 3. There is no way Aneesa could beat Laurel but overall I like it

Well Frank and Chet were basically tied in Balls In until Chet forfeited so I think Johnny would do pretty well against Frank. But yeah the Aneesa one was hard to judge. 

What if Svetlana was on the Gauntlet 3 instead of Janelle replacing her? I would see Svetlana beasted those "Ball Brawls" Eliminations

What if Johanna or Rachel were on BOTS instead of Lacy?

What if Johanna or Rachel were on BOTS instead of Lacy?

They still would've went home first

What if Johanna or Rachel were on BOTS instead of Lacy?

They still would've went home first

I laughed at that for some reason.

Now this is a better one: what if Team Fresh Meat was actually Pete, Brandon, Carley, and Camila?

Now this is a better one: what if Team Fresh Meat was actually Pete, Brandon, Carley, and Camila?

They definitely would have went far. Maybe make it to the end.(although they would run into problems with Carly there)

Now this is a better one: what if Team Fresh Meat was actually Pete, Brandon, Carley, and Camila?

They definitely would have went far. Maybe make it to the end.(although they would run into problems with Carly there)

Yeah. I don't see Brandon and Carley as an asset in the end. Pete and Camila though would be a decent showing in a final.

Pages