The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

[QUOTE=cryssy19;274374]Talk about getting OWNED. It will be Massacre part 2. The rookie guys just aren't up to par and the rookie girls barely are. No idea why everyone likes to add Johanna to any cast. Although I can see Laurel, CM, Kelly-Anne and CT winning it at the end.[/QUOTE] The only reason I added Johanna was for drama purposes. Otherwise I'd replace her with Tonya or Jillian. I'm not a fan of Wes or Johnny(I only like him when he's with Evan and Kenny), but they bring drama and I'd love to see CT stomp on Wes and Johnny in a Ruin.

[QUOTE=cryssy19;274357]Why would you do this to them?! I'd substitute Eric for Vinny, Luke, anyone else really. And it would be nice to see another FM girl who could hold her own, maybe Aviv. I like the concept... many other people said they'd want to see this concept, but I wonder if the RR people are up for it. They seem to have moved on.[/QUOTE]Entertainment value. It would be interesting to see how Laurel, Evelyn, Kenny, and Evan would react to having Big Easy on their team. It's not like they would be around for long either. Edit: If I were to replace Big Easy I would put Brandon in. I completely forgot about him when I made the cast.

How about a Challenge with 20 Newbies (never done a challenge) Vs. 20 Rookies? (people who have only done 1 challenge) I am sick of seeing the same faces! 1 Guy and 1 Girl face off each elimination. So 2 people go home each day. Cast: Newbies: Bronne-Cancun Erika-D.C Mike-D.C Devyn-Brooklyn Ryan-Brooklyn Scott-Brooklyn Dustin-LV2 Nany-LV2 Heather M-LV2 Sahar-NO2 Knight-NO2 Stephen-Denver Trisha-Sydney Parisa-Sydney Joey-Hollywood Jose-Key West Sarah-Philli Willi-Philli Brynn-LV Christina-Paris Rookies: Emilee-Cancun CJ-Cancun Sandy-Fresh Meat 2 Pete-Fresh Meat 2 Emily-D.C Adam R.-LV2 Leroy-LV2 Alex-Denver Isaac-Sydney Brittini-Hollywood David-Hollywood Bri-Hollywood Svetlana-Key West Shavonda-Phili Zack-Key West Steven-LV Irulan-LV Mallory-Paris Angela-RR X-treme Dave-RR South Pacific This would be a good challenge, and maybe some new RW/RR drama would occur!

this is awesome news!! as for challenges i would like to see: -The Duel 3 (if they can get an amazing cast) -Battle of the Seasons (using new RW seasons only) -Inferno 4 (lots of new bad ***** and good guys for this one) or original challenges since they are always exciting and something new to watch: ideas such as Battle of the Exes, Blondes Vs. Brunettes, Old School Vs. New School, Brains Vs. Brawns, Real World vs. Jersey Shore (j/k, but would be entertaining lol) I'm sure whatever they do will be good! such great news :D

Inferno/Gauntlet 4 would be best imo. They can put together a pretty good gauntlet 4 cast atm, Inferno 4 maybe, with CT on good guys now ^^

Rivals 2: Females- Ashley & Erika (DC) Coral & Trishelle or Julie Tonya & Veronica Jonna & Camilla Cooke & Naomi or Nany Kelly Anne & Johanna Brianna & Kim Males- Abe & Adam Ryan & Preston Mike & Dustin Brad & Darrell Wes & CT Ty & Adam Danny & Pete

[QUOTE=lvking05;274393]How about a Challenge with 20 Newbies (never done a challenge) Vs. 20 Rookies? (people who have only done 1 challenge) I am sick of seeing the same faces! This would be a good challenge, and maybe some new RW/RR drama would occur![/QUOTE] I definitely won't watch that.

I wouldn't mind a Ruins 2 with CT, LeRoy and Laurel leading the Challengers team like in Gauntlet 2 where Alton, Landon and Kina lead that rookies team. It would be a lot more fair than another Gauntlet or Inferno. Imagine that team going against the likes of JEK, Wes, and Paula. Now that would be epic.

[QUOTE=V1man;274410]In my opinion, Duel 3 would be a major fail for MTV if done without Evelyn. She will be back in school in the fall, so that removes her from the next challenge, assuming that it occurs before the end of the year.[/QUOTE] I agree. I think it's time for another two team challenge. Actually i would love if they did a 3 team challenge and with a rookie team consisting Hollywood-San Diego 2(Fresh Meat 2 included), a veteran team which includes Philadelphia-Sydney(fresh meat and RR:VR included), and a legends team with any season from New York to San Diego(all Road rules seasons except viewers revenge included). 3 ten person teams, they could call it Cutthroat:Legends or something completely different. Either way, i think this would be an awesome idea.

[QUOTE=prototype;274445]I wouldn't mind a Ruins 2 with CT, LeRoy and Laurel leading the Challengers team like in Gauntlet 2 where Alton, Landon and Kina lead that rookies team. It would be a lot more fair than another Gauntlet or Inferno. Imagine that team going against the likes of JEK, Wes, and Paula. Now that would be epic.[/QUOTE] ruins 2 with those 3 as the anchors of the challengers team would be so cool, love that idea maybe even more than dual 3.

Anything but a Ruins 2, please. The only way I'd want to see a Ruins 2 would be if they changed the way you vote people into the Ruins. The Ruins is the perfect format for alliances to skate by without seeing an elimination round.

I'm definitely voting for Battle of the Seasons - seems to be the most interesting option for me, and could include a lot of recent cast members, "spicy" pairs and would not be as predictable as Ruins 2.

Ruins 2 Champions: Johnny Evan Kenny Wes Tyler Nehemiah Dunbar Paula Susie Katie Evelyn Carley Jillian Tonya Challengers: CT LeRoy Brandon Noor Adam Pete Bronne Laurel Cara Maria Kelly Ann Jasmine Jonna Emily Tina I know people are going to think the male Champions team is unfair but think of how much backstabbing is going to happen to avoid elimination. All the guys there want to avoid it and they are all friends now. I put Dunbar in there because he doesn't seem to get along with JEK so he would be kind of like a Wes of this Ruins. Also Wes would have the numbers to throw in one of JEK this time around. On the females side, Paula and Evelyn do not like or get along with Susie so there's bound to be fireworks there. Katie and Tonya are there to hold the team back. I want to see Carley prove herself without the help of Landon and Jillian is there because I don't remember her being to fond of Wes and JEK during Gauntlet 3 but I think she made amends with Kenny. It was a little hard to find good males on the Challengers team that could match up to the Champions team but I think the guys I've picked could go toe to toe with the men Champions team in an elimination round. I haven't watched Bronne's season but he looks athletic and I remember Vevmo being disappointed they didn't get to see him on Cutthroat. I think the group of females I've chosen could work well and be able to beat most of the female Champions. What I hated about the first Ruins was they had too many ****** females but they had a slim list to choose from. Now they have a greater selection to choose from and I chose females who are proven competitors and the biggest thing, non-quitters.

[QUOTE=prototype;274445]I wouldn't mind a Ruins 2 with CT, [B]LeRoy[/B] and Laurel leading the Challengers team like in Gauntlet 2 where Alton, Landon and Kina lead that rookies team. It would be a lot more fair than another Gauntlet or Inferno. Imagine that team going against the likes of JEK, Wes, and Paula. Now that would be epic.[/QUOTE] Lol, Leroy's done one challenge and didn't necessarily shine 'til the end. And there's a big difference between CT, Leroy, Laurel and Landon, Alton, and Kina. Landon, Kina and Alton were respected and were great leaders. Laurel and CT can't hold their temper and Laurel is shady, I don't think anyone would listen to them. I would like a challenge with teams though, a duel would suck imo with or without Evelyn.

[QUOTE=lvking05;274393]How about a Challenge with 20 Newbies (never done a challenge) Vs. 20 Rookies? (people who have only done 1 challenge) I am sick of seeing the same faces! 1 Guy and 1 Girl face off each elimination. So 2 people go home each day.[/QUOTE] Sorry but I agree with cryssy19 on this one. The only Newbie name I even recognized was Christina from RW Paris. I stopped watching RW years ago because it became utterly predictable (7 or 8 beautiful people getting drunk, fighting, hooking up, pretending to do their required job but not really doing it at all but not getting penalized, blah blah blah). I always say I'm going to give the new ones a try but after seeing the trailers, they just leave me cold. I know there's going to be at least 1 "social problem du jour" that's going to be focused on for 1 or 2 episodes but then forgotten about so that they can show more of the drinking, fighting, and hooking up. I have no doubt that those people would bring the same dynamic to a challenge and honestly, don't we have enough drinking, fighting, and hooking up with the people who are repeatedly cast as it is? I wouldn't mind some of the Rookies you mentioned because I can't stand JEK and I want to see someone humble them to their core and send them home with their tails between their legs. It's obviously going to have to be some fairly new people because the current ones have totally gone over to the dark side and won't dare say a word against them. Sorry for the long post. For all my ranting, even if they do cast all new people, I know I'll still watch because I've never missed a challenge yet. I won't be looking forward to it as much if there's no chance for JEK to be blown up but maybe we'll get lucky and there will be another gem like Leroy.

[QUOTE=jesses_girl;274460]Lol, Leroy's done one challenge and didn't necessarily shine 'til the end. And there's a big difference between CT, Leroy, Laurel and Landon, Alton, and Kina. Landon, Kina and Alton were respected and were great leaders. Laurel and CT can't hold their temper and Laurel is shady, I don't think anyone would listen to them. I would like a challenge with teams though, a duel would suck imo with or without Evelyn.[/QUOTE] At least if she's not there, it makes wondering who'd win a lot more interesting. If Ev does do it, how many people won't look at the show and be like "Ev wins" before the season even starts? Though her losing it would be more interesting to me than her winning.

[QUOTE=dagr317;274464]Sorry but I agree with cryssy19 on this one. The only Newbie name I even recognized was Christina from RW Paris. I stopped watching RW years ago because it became utterly predictable (7 or 8 beautiful people getting drunk, fighting, hooking up, pretending to do their required job but not really doing it at all but not getting penalized, blah blah blah). I always say I'm going to give the new ones a try but after seeing the trailers, they just leave me cold. I know there's going to be at least 1 "social problem du jour" that's going to be focused on for 1 or 2 episodes but then forgotten about so that they can show more of the drinking, fighting, and hooking up. I have no doubt that those people would bring the same dynamic to a challenge and honestly, don't we have enough drinking, fighting, and hooking up with the people who are repeatedly cast as it is? I wouldn't mind some of the Rookies you mentioned because I can't stand JEK and I want to see someone humble them to their core and send them home with their tails between their legs. It's obviously going to have to be some fairly new people because the current ones have totally gone over to the dark side and won't dare say a word against them. Sorry for the long post. For all my ranting, even if they do cast all new people, I know I'll still watch because I've never missed a challenge yet. I won't be looking forward to it as much if there's no chance for JEK to be blown up but maybe we'll get lucky and there will be another gem like Leroy.[/QUOTE] How is Leroy a "GEM"? I was more impressed by Emily on Cutthroat. I do think he's good though but overrated because of his personality. A rookie challenge would be nice, Cutthroat was my favorite challenge in a long time because it was unpredictable up until the finale. Different hookups, different rivals, different winners, different challenge dominators. Good stuff. You didn't watch Vegas but you love Leroy, just think of the many new cast members you'd be introduced to.

[QUOTE=Nightwolf;274465]At least if she's not there, it makes wondering who'd win a lot more interesting. If Ev does do it, how many people won't look at the show and be like "Ev wins" before the season even starts? Though her losing it would be more interesting to me than her winning.[/QUOTE] She'd only be a guaranteed win if she make it to the final. But before then, i think she'd be just as vulnerable as the other girls. They never know what the eliminations are like, it could be a simple reverse tug of war with Evelyn vs Emily/Aneesa/Laurel/almost any girl.

[QUOTE=jesses_girl;274507]She'd only be a guaranteed win if she make it to the final. But before then, i think she'd be just as vulnerable as the other girls. They never know what the eliminations are like, it could be a simple reverse tug of war with Evelyn vs Emily/Aneesa/Laurel/almost any girl.[/QUOTE] That was the same thing for this show but I pretty much wrote it off as either Ev or Laurel would win Rivals before it started. They'd need to provide people who can beat her if she's on it, and there's not much that she'd lose at.

ruins 2 cast champs males- abram, johnny, wes, landon, evan, nehemiah, dunbar females- rachel, veronica, suzie ,paula, jillian, evelyn, katie non champs males- ct, adam, brandon, noor, leroy, chet, vinny females- laurel, sarah, camilla, emily, jonna, robin, diem @mtv-make it happen

[QUOTE=jesses_girl;274460]Lol, Leroy's done one challenge and didn't necessarily shine 'til the end. And there's a big difference between CT, Leroy, Laurel and Landon, Alton, and Kina. Landon, [B]Kina and Alton were respected and were great leaders.[/B] Laurel and CT can't hold their temper and Laurel is shady, I don't think anyone would listen to them. I would like a challenge with teams though, a duel would suck imo with or without Evelyn.[/QUOTE] Gauntlet 2 was Kina's second Challenge, having been eliminated very early on and without doing anything memorable during her first Challenge...just saying.

[QUOTE=Youssarian;274664]Gauntlet 2 was Kina's second Challenge, having been eliminated very early on and without doing anything memorable during her first Challenge...just saying.[/QUOTE] Yeah except a good amount of the people on Kina's team already new and respected her, and early on she proved herself in the challenges and showed a lot of heart and fight in the eliminations.

[QUOTE=jesses_girl;274499]How is Leroy a "GEM"? You didn't watch Vegas but you love Leroy, just think of the many new cast members you'd be introduced to.[/QUOTE] I loved Leroy's personality and realness (not sure that's actually a word) even though he wasn't the best competitor I've ever seen. Mike, Jonna and Jasmine were completely new to me too and I was okay with them but they didn't make as good an impression on me as Leroy did. As for Adam R, it only took me a few minutes to come to the conclusion that he was a jerk and I'm glad he took himself out of Rivals. I hope that out of the recent crop of Real World'ers/potential challengers, there will be another one who'll have the same "it" factor for me that Leroy did, whether it be a guy or a girl. I just can't get motivated enough to watch an entire season of the same tired Real World formula (drink, fight, hook up day after day after day) so I'll just wait until the next challenge to see who, if any of them, gets cast. If it turns out to be someone who goes against JEK, I'll be their biggest fan!!

Rivals II: Wes and Johanna (Ruins) Danny and Melinda (Austin) Evan and Coral (Gauntlet III) Joey and Ayiiia (Cancun) Ty and Emily (D.C.) Dunbar and Paula (Cutthroat) Abram and Laurel (Cutthroat) Adam R. and Nany (B2 LV) Frank and Tori (Gauntlet III) Dan and Robin (Island) Johnny and Evelyn (Island) C.T. and Mandi (Rivals) Will and Janelle (Hollywood)

My Dream The Ruins 2 Cast :girl_dance: [B]The Ruins 2 [/B][U]Champions[/U] Johnny (RW: KW) Tyler (RW: KW) Landon (RW: Philly) Brad (RW: SD) Dunbar (RW: Sydney) Abram (RR: SP) Frank (RW: LV) Paula (RW: KW) Carley (FMII) Susie (RR: DU) Jillian (RR: Xtreme) Julie (RW: NO) Tonya (RW: Chicago) Coral (RR: NY2) [U]Challengers[/U] CT (RW: Paris) Adam (RW: Paris) Leeroy (RW: LV2) Michael (RW: LV2) Luke (FMII) Vinny (FMII) Pete (FMII) Kimberly (RW: Hollywood) Brianna (RW: Hollywood) or Mandi (FMII) Aneesa (RW: Chicago) Tina (RR: SP) or Cara Maria (FMII) Jenn (RW: Denver) Camila (Spring Break Challenge) Laurel (FMII) Others for Consideration for Challengers: Jonna/Jasmine/Beth I think this would be a good even cast :nasty:

The Duel 3 Derrick Dan Frank CT Adam Kenny Dunbar Bronne Knight Leroy Dustin Pete Females: Susie Jillian Melinda Paula Kellyanne Sarah Emilee Jasmine Emily Jemmye Ashlee Nany

For Duel 2 (or any other format as long as teams were picked schoolyard style): Guys: CT Evan Wes Pete Noor Leroy SD Guy Jamie (RW:NO) Mark Kenny Tyler Chet Landon Dan (RR:Northern Trail) Abram Adam (RR:Quest) Girls: Laurel Evelyn Rachel (RR:Campus Crawl) Jodi Christena (RW:Paris) Kelly Anne Diem or Aviv Tonya Emily (RR:USA2) Emily (RW: DC) Sarah (RW:Brooklyn) SD Girl Cooke or Nany Jonna Jillian or Kina Mallory (RW:Paris) I don't see the point in casting people on a Duel that have absolutely no chance of winning, like Katie or Casey. I think all of the people I have chosen have a legitimate shot (yes, even Tonya), although some would have a tougher time than others and could be considered underdogs. I always love a good underdog story. Obviously, I would want the "SD Guy" and "SD Girl" to be the most athletic choices from their cast. Some of the others I chose like Nany and Jonna might be a stretch but I don't think we know enough about them yet to completely count them out and I wanted some new blood. It always irritated me that the final of the Duel II was not actually a duel because there were three players of each *** and they had to do that partner bit, but I understand why a final with three players could be considered more entertaining than one with two by the producers. In that case a new concept that is still basically a singles challenge could be called "Battle Royal" in which: a. Cast members compete on their own. b. The winner of each challenge chooses one person for elimination. c. The loser of each challenge automatically goes into elimination. d. The loser chooses a third person for elimination, but cannot choose that day's winner. e. Only one person is eliminated each round. f. The final has three guys and three girls. I think this would break down a lot of alliances and could make for some really interesting strategizing. The only flaw would be that the elimination rounds would have to be races or puzzles or some other timed events, but could not have any physical contact or wrestling. Even a game like "Name That Coconut" wouldn't work out with 3 people because 2 could gang up on 1.

Duel 3: Same format as the first.. Females- Evelyn Laurel Jillian Rachel (Campus Crawl) Kelly Anne Brianna Tonya Beth Jonna Ashley (DC) Nany/Naomi Cooke Males- Mark Wes CT Leroy Kenny Derrick Johnny Alton Darrell Brandon Abe Landon I think this would be some of the best males and females in one challenge (excluding the newbies we haven't seen yet).

[QUOTE=gamer73;274742]Duel 3: Same format as the first.. Females- Evelyn Laurel Jillian Rachel (Campus Crawl) Kelly Anne Brianna Tonya Beth Jonna Ashley (DC) Nany/Naomi Cooke Males- Mark Wes CT Leroy Kenny Derrick Johnny Alton Darrell Brandon Abe Landon [B]I think[/B] this would be some of the [B]best males and females[/B] in one challenge (excluding the newbies we haven't seen yet).[/QUOTE] Whoa, I like this list, but for the girls side you don't think Jodi nor Kina were good? I'm just curious. Are you trying a mix of before and after challengers? I'm just trying to understand your format.

My first post was of a realistic cast, honestly though I would love to see some of the older names come back to shake things up. Something like old school vets vs new school vets vs Fresh Meat and on vets/rookies(3 teams) Theo vs Derrick vs Wes Abe vs Brad vs Johnny CT vs Landon vs Evan Darrell vs MJ vs Brandon Shane vs Frank vs Noor Mark vs Randy vs Leroy Adam vs Adam K vs Chet Rachel vs Susie vs Evelyn Veronica vs Robin vs Paula Coral vs Jodi vs Laurel Tina vs Kina vs Emily Ruthie vs Jillian vs Camila Aneesa vs Ibis vs Jonna Trishelle vs Cara vs Jasmine