[QUOTE=Superboy;232406]Timmy was better than Derrick, on the Inferno 1 he was Road Rules best competitor, better than Abram and Darrell, both whom are stronger than Derrick.[/QUOTE]
I know you aren't going to change your mind, but do you really not see how irrational your logic is? Timmy was Road Rules' best competitor on Inferno 1, a challenge Derrick wasn't even on.
So because in your eyes, Darrell and Abram are better players than Derrick, and Timmy was better than those two on a challenge, then Timmy is better than Derrick?
So then, let's say the Bulls beat the Bucks, then the Bucks beat the Pistons, by your logic the Bulls would have to beat the Pistons right? But what if they don't? How do you explain that?
Transitive property will only get you so far.
[QUOTE=Adrian!!!!!!;232407]He wasn't on the Gauntlet 2 until he played Derrick in a game he had an advatage in and he definitely wasn't better than Derrick on the Inferno 3.[/QUOTE]
He had an injured leg, but still..... he basically beat Abram(who was the leader of the Bad *****).
[QUOTE]
I know you aren't going to change your mind, but do you really not see how irrational your logic is? Timmy was Road Rules' best competitor on Inferno 1, a challenge Derrick wasn't even on.
[/QUOTE]
Do you believe that Abram and Darrell are superior to Derrick all time? If not, than i see why you asked me this question.
[QUOTE]
So because in your eyes, Darrell and Abram are better players than Derrick, and Timmy was better than those two on a challenge, then Timmy is better than Derrick?
[/QUOTE]
That is one of many examples of Timmy being better than Derrick.
Here is another example.....at 3:10
[url=http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=EzQYW3-DCro]YouTube - RR/RW Inferno: Climbing Wall Part 2[/url]
[QUOTE]
So then, let's say the Bulls beat the Bucks, then the Bucks beat the Pistons, by your logic the Bulls would have to beat the Pistons right? But what if they don't? How do you explain that?
Transitive property will only get you so far.
[/QUOTE]
No, by my logic Abram and Darrell were ALWAYS better competitors than Derrick.......and since Timmy was superior to both on the Inferno 1, and actually beat Derrick(badly), he is better than Derrick all time.
[QUOTE=Superboy;232413]He had an injured leg, but he still,[B] he basically beat [/B][B]Abram(who was the leader of the Bad *****).[/B][/QUOTE]
Technicalities... rules are rules. Abram followed those rules and Timmy did not (accidentally, of course) therefore Timmy lost because of it. And injured leg or not Derrick still performed better than Timmy did on the Inferno 3.
[QUOTE=Adrian!!!!!!;232415]Technicalities... rules are rules. Abram followed those rules and Timmy did not (accidentally, of course) therefore Timmy lost because of it. And injured leg or not Derrick still performed better than Timmy did on the Inferno 3.[/QUOTE]
But Timmy still proved to be stronger than Abram, because Abram couldn't break through the glass floor(even though he got to it before Timmy), while Timmy did. Also, Timmy was like Darrell, he didn't win a bunch of lifesavers, but when he was motivated, he was a BEAST......much stronger than Derrick. Johnny words on Timmy on the Inferno 3 were dead on[B]......."Timmy is a proven warrior, he is the biggest asset to our team. Why would we want to get rid of a guy who wasn't 100% but still was one of our strongest players".[/B] That was what Johnny said before Timmy went in against Abram.
When Timmy needed to win the lifesaver, he lost it to Kendall and ended up having to get saved by her. Let's not act like Timmy is some unstoppable force....
[QUOTE=Superboy;232406]Timmy was better than Derrick, on the Inferno 1 he was Road Rules best competitor, [B]better than Abram(who he basically beat on the Inferno 3)[/B] and Darrell, both whom are stronger than Derrick.
[/QUOTE]
Are you talking about the Inferno? Timmy got DQ'ed because he didn't break all the panes of glass. Abram was almost done when Timmy finished, so the time it would have taken to break that last piece of glass would have very likely allowed Abram the time to win straight up.
[QUOTE=Superboy;232418]But Timmy still proved to be stronger than Abram, because Abram couldn't break through the glass floor(even though he got to it before Timmy), while Timmy did.[B] Also, Timmy was like Darrell, he didn't win a bunch of lifesavers, but when he was motivated, he was a BEAST......much stronger than [/B][B]Derrick.[/B][/QUOTE]
Ehhh, I think I'm going to agree with you, nah I change my mind... I'd pick Brad, Derrick, Wes, Abram, Johnny, Kenny..... a lot of guys for my team over Timmy.
I don't know that breaking through a glass floor would make one person stronger than another. Timmy is obviously heavier than Abram. I'm sure that came into play largely.
Ok seriously, the last few days this thread has been plagued by ridiculous arguments that have no proof or even basis for reasoning and it's getting annoying now. All we can say is that Timmy weighs more than Derrick and the rest of the pairs never faced each other one on one. That's it and nothing else.
[QUOTE=Nightwolf;232423]Ok seriously, the last few days this thread has been plagued by ridiculous arguments that have no proof or even basis for reasoning and it's getting annoying now. All we can say is that Timmy weighs more than Derrick and the rest of the pairs never faced each other one on one. [B]That's it and nothing else.[/B][/QUOTE]
Nnnnnnnnnno, I can definitely say that the 85 Bears are better than Dan Setzler. :D
[QUOTE=Adrian!!!!!!;232421]Ehhh, I think I'm going to agree with you, nah I change my mind... I'd pick Brad, Derrick, Wes, Abram, Johnny, Kenny..... a lot of guys for my team over Timmy.[/QUOTE]
That's because you don't know competitors.
[QUOTE=Insider;232422]I don't know that breaking through a glass floor would make one person stronger than another. Timmy is obviously heavier than Abram. I'm sure that came into play largely.[/QUOTE]
Nope, that's wrong. It was all about your punching power.
[QUOTE=Superboy;232427]That's because you don't know competitors.[/QUOTE]
Ha Ha !! It's too easy to get a reply from you !! Timmy's nothing special and Dan's not all that ..... *waits for next reply saying how great both are*
[QUOTE=Adrian!!!!!!;232432]Ha Ha !! It's too easy to get a reply out of you !! Timmy's nothing special and Dan's not all that ..... *waits for next reply saying how great both are*[/QUOTE]
Again, you don't know about the old school competitors.......all you know is Johnny, Wes, Kenny, Brad, Evan.....guys that aren't(all time) on the level of a Mark, Timmy, Dan(RR5), and Theo V.
[QUOTE=Adrian!!!!!!;232432]Ha Ha !! It's too easy to get a reply from you !! Timmy's nothing special and Dan's not all that ..... *waits for next reply saying how great both are*[/QUOTE]
Perhaps the best option is to ignore him and let him slip back into being irrelevant. Egging him on is not exactly appreciated.
[QUOTE=molds13;232437]Perhaps the best option is to ignore him and let him slip back into being irrelevant. Egging him on is not exactly appreciated.[/QUOTE]
( ; You're right, ignoring him is the best way to go.....
When there is only a sample size of one, the result is not statically relevant. Opinion is not fact, no matter how much wants the opinion to be true. With the challenges, if one is attempting to connect opinion with fact based on a highly edited TV show, then one is compounding the illusion.
[QUOTE=Superboy;232427]Nope, that's wrong. It was all about your punching power.[/QUOTE]
What is this? Super Mario Brothers?
[url=http://vevmo.com/vbimghost.php?do=displayimg&imgid=8807][img]http://vevmo.com/imagehosting/7564d350a1f86bac.jpg[/img][/url]
[QUOTE=Insider;232456]What is this? Super Mario Brothers?[/QUOTE]
But Insider, by Superboy's logic, Mario is significantly stronger then Bowser because he wins against him. But he seems to forget Bowser is bigger then obviously more powerful. Bowser can spit fire out of his mouth but Mario has to pick up flowers to throw fireballs. Maybe the list should be: 1) Mario, 2) Bowser, 3) Peach, 4) Toad, 5) Luigi and 6) Dan RR. Superboy, jump in, we all know how much you love lists.
[QUOTE=V1man;232449]When there is only a sample size of one, the result is not statically relevant. Opinion is not fact, no matter how much wants the opinion to be true. With the challenges, if one is attempting to connect opinion with fact based on a highly edited TV show, then one is compounding the illusion.[/QUOTE]
I agree with you 100% on this.
No way. If they were on a challenge, we all know Bowser would win. He's larger and more powerful. There's no way a small guy like Mario could beat him.
[QUOTE=Insider;232461]No way. If they were on a challenge, we all know Bowser would win. He's larger and more powerful. There's no way a small guy like Mario could beat him.[/QUOTE]
Wait, are you suggesting that Derek and Mario are related?
[QUOTE=V1man;232463]Wait, are you suggesting that Derek and Mario are related?[/QUOTE]
I highly doubt it. According to Superboy, Derrick is only good at getting underneath people, whether it's a sexual joke or not, but Mario can fly, throw fireballs, and don't you see how fast he climbs ladders? Not even CT has something on Mario, that fool can go down pipes like no one's business!
C'mon, everyone knows Yoshi is the best!!
[url=http://vevmo.com/vbimghost.php?do=displayimg&imgid=8808][img]http://vevmo.com/imagehosting/15244d350d106f0ca.jpg[/img][/url]
[QUOTE=faceless;232465]I highly doubt it. [B]According to Superboy, Derrick is only good at getting underneath people[/B], whether it's a sexual joke or not, but Mario can fly, throw fireballs, and don't you see how fast he climbs ladders? Not even CT has something on Mario, that fool can go down pipes like no one's business![/QUOTE]
I said that is his greatest strength! Not the only thing he's good at.
[QUOTE=Superboy;232464]No......there is a good chance that i will never debate about competitors again.[/QUOTE]
You're not just trying to get our hopes up, are you?
Ah. I totally forgot about Yoshi! He can eat things that get in his way... and he spits the shells back out. My vote is for Yoshi! Can we get him cast on the next challenge?
Yoshi?! No way! One hit from this guy, or in fact, any other bad guy and Yoshi goes running for the hills. Btw, lets all get a petition to get BMP to cast this guy:
[url=http://vevmo.com/vbimghost.php?do=displayimg&imgid=8810][img]http://vevmo.com/imagehosting/13634d350e6fcfb70.png[/img][/url]
Pages