American Idol Season 9 - Discussion

437 posts / 0 new
Last post
Anonymous
Anonymous's picture
I don't want to ruin the results for those of you in the west, but... [SPOILER]I 100% disagree with Joe Munoz going home.. or even being in the bottom for that matter.[/SPOILER]
Wow.... [spoiler]He was one of the only half good singers last night...[/spoiler]
[SPOILER]I can't believe that Tim (the guy who got to come back) got to stay! He was aweful![/SPOILER]
Anonymous
Anonymous's picture
I completely agree with you Phoenix.
Wow, that is a surprise! I think he just got lost in the shuffle, especially since he didn't get much airtime before top 24.
wow i can't believe Tyler got eliminated. He was a favorite to make it pretty far just for being a novelty character.
Im not suprised Tyler is gone, he was bad. But Tim should have been gone and not Joe. Im really suprised by both of the girls that went home. Lacey should have been gone for sure she was terrible and Paige was pretty bad also.
Anonymous
Anonymous's picture
Is anyone watching?
I am!
I actually really liked John Park this week but I totally understand what they mean about authenticity. It seems like he's just trying to go out there and sing it note for note exactly like the singer. Like Lee Deewyze is by far the most authentic out there. He just goes with what he feels.
Big Mike and Casey both did really well. Casey has really impressed me the first 2 weeks. John's performance was better than last week but it wasnt that good.
Anonymous
Anonymous's picture
I really like Alex Lambert. There's something so real and likeable about him.
I dont think Alex did as good as the judges said he did. Todrick did pretty well, i hope he sticks around. Jermaine was decent, he has a good voice but he has picked odd songs. Andrew did good, the judges need to quit trying to put him in a box. I agree with them that he hasnt been as good as when he sang straight up, but he is one of the most talented people in the competition.
Rankings from tonights performances 1. Casey 2.Lee 3. Big Mike 4. Andrew 5. Aaron 6. Todrick 7. Tim 8. Alex 9. Jermaine 10 John
Man I don't know, I am just not digging any of these guys. I really liked Casey after Hollywood week, but his performance last night was so cliche. Lee has a very distinct voice, but so far has not reached out and touched me, darn!
I disagree with what the judges said about Katie. She did really well. I really dont get what they see in Crystal, in my opinion Katie is a whole lot better than her. Lacey was much better than last week and Haeley was terrible.
[QUOTE=Lionsfan780;159099]Rankings from tonights performances 1. Casey 2.Lee 3. Big Mike 4. Andrew 5. Aaron 6. Todrick 7. Tim 8. Alex 9. Jermaine 10 John[/QUOTE] I do not agree with this list at all. First off I like Casey just as much as the rest of you but Alex Lambert was phenomenal last night and tim was way better than Aaron and Todrick. I don't know how you culd have Todrick so high. The only ones I agree on are Jermaine, John, big Mike, and Lee
I have not heard anything I have liked the few times I have tuned in... And either have the judges.
Haha this was supposed to be "the year for the girls"
OMG. She is killing (in a bad way) this song. I might never be able to listen to coldplay again, as I'll just hear her...
It is so bad tonight, they judges actually have to say something nice as they know this season is going down the drain.
I really liked Crystal and glad that she was able to perform. I thought she did better than last week and she is definitely my favorite! I hate Haeley, or however you spell it. The nasal voice, the lisp, the "look how cute I am! twee" vibe I get from her, just ugh. I'm sure I would like her a lot more in 2-3 years when she matures and learns how to control her voice. Lacey was meh. I'll forget her in 5 minutes. Katie is adorable and I want to really like her and root for her but she needs to step it up. Plus I already hated that song so it probably didn't help much to begin with.
Creed? blech. They are like the American Nickelback. edit: Also what was with those stupid gloves? Heck, what was with her whole outfit? Lily was fine. Not sure it was the right song choice, I think she was better last week. Still like her, but not sure if I wanted her to mess with such an iconic song. Kaitlyn was good. Judges were right, it was too slow. I liked her much better when I didn't watch her. To me she comes off like she is cheesing it up to the camera too much, too fake. Also I'm glad she has finally stopped talking about her parents divorce. It was to the point where it was like "We get it! Lots of peoples parents have divorced, including mine, stop whining about it."
Man, really liking Sioban! To go from 'Wicked Games' to 'Think' and sound great in both of them? She is totally the dark horse of the competition. Loving little quirky Sioban. Can we just skip to the top 6 or so now? Keep Crystal, Lily, Sioban...heck I don't really care who else after those 3.
Also, someone needs to put Ryan in his place this season. He is even douchier than I ever thought possible lately.
I miss Paula and her "special candy" :(
[QUOTE=tatertots;159338]I really liked Crystal and glad that she was able to perform. I thought she did better than last week and she is definitely my favorite! [/QUOTE] I agree, Crystal FTW!
[QUOTE=andrewsz1991;159192]Haha this was supposed to be "the year for the girls"[/QUOTE] yeah i think the guys are more talented overall than the girls. I dont really care much for many of the girls. I think Michelle and Katie are good. I really like Didi, she has a really likeable quality about her, but she hasnt done as good as she can. Siobhan impressed me last night. I think Paige, Lacey and Haeley are all pretty bad. I know alot of people like Lilly and Crystal but im just not feeling them so far. Katelyn is decent. As for the guys. I think Casey, Lee, Big Mike and Andrew are all really good. Aaron is a step below them but i like him too. I know that Todrick could be really good if he would just pick the right song. Jermaine has a good voice but he hasnt picked good songs either and he may be gone tonight. Alex is decent to me. Tim did much better this week but his performance last week was so bad, so thats not saying too much. John is bad.
Andrew is not that good. He did a relaly good straight up but since eh's done absolutely nothing. He's losing his status as a front runner.
[QUOTE=andrewsz1991;159519]Andrew is not that good. He did a relaly good straight up but since eh's done absolutely nothing. He's losing his status as a front runner.[/QUOTE] Andrew is very good. You should watch some of his videos on youtube and you would see how talented he really is. I will agree he hasnt been as good as straight up but that performance set the bar very high for him. He isnt leaving the competition anytime soon.

Pages