The Challenge: Shouldn't/Should Have Been in Final

411 posts / 0 new
Last post

Fresh Meat - Derrick and Diem instead of Wes and Casey (although I'm glad they beat everyone, they got lucky that their luggage was the lightest)

Duel - Diem instead of Svetlana

Inferno 3 - Timmy instead of Johnny

Gauntlet 3 - Danny instead of Eric

Island - Dunbar instead of Johnny

Duel 2 - Landon instead of Mark

Rivals 2 - Aneesa and Diem instead of Camila and Jemmye

Free Agents - CT and Theresa instead of Zach and Devyn

 

 

Dunbar didn't even do anything on The Island lol

He didn't but Evelyn should have taken Johnny's key....pretty much on Evelyn did anything on The Island

Where to start Jay/Jenna Battle of the Exes 2 Devyn Free Agents Camila/Jemmye Rivals 2 JD/Devyn Battle of the Seasons Leroy/Michael Rivals Jenn/Mandi Rivals Jenn & Sarah Cutthroat Noor/Jenn Fresh Meat 2 Aneesa Duel 2 Jenn, Ryan, Paula, & Robin The Island Big Easy, Rachel, & Johanna Gauntlet 3 Wes/Casey Fresh Meat


What's your reasons for the ones bolded?

Because Camila,Jemmye, Aneesa, Jenn, & Noor didn't pose any threat of winning in the finals and kind of took the Spot from people who could of posed a threat in the end. On Cutthroat Jenn really should of gone in either one of the last 2 Gulags instead of Theresa and Emily she really didn't stand out as a competitor at all that season to get a free ride to the final.

Where to start Jay/Jenna Battle of the Exes 2 Devyn Free Agents Camila/Jemmye Rivals 2 JD/Devyn Battle of the Seasons Leroy/Michael Rivals Jenn/Mandi Rivals Jenn & Sarah Cutthroat Noor/Jenn Fresh Meat 2 Aneesa Duel 2 Jenn, Ryan, Paula, & Robin The Island Big Easy, Rachel, & Johanna Gauntlet 3 Wes/Casey Fresh Meat


What's your reasons for the ones bolded?

Because Camila,Jemmye, Aneesa, Jenn, & Noor didn't pose any threat of winning in the finals and kind of took the Spot from people who could of posed a threat in the end. On Cutthroat Jenn really should of gone in either one of the last 2 Gulags instead of Theresa and Emily she really didn't stand out as a competitor at all that season to get a free ride to the final.

I will say for sure that jenn got a free ride on rivals and cutthroat .. but fresh meat she went in the last elimination

Where to start
Jay/Jenna Battle of the Exes 2
Devyn Free Agents
Camila/Jemmye Rivals 2
JD/Devyn Battle of the Seasons
Leroy/Michael Rivals
Jenn/Mandi Rivals
Jenn & Sarah Cutthroat
Noor/Jenn Fresh Meat 2
Aneesa Duel 2
Jenn, Ryan, Paula, & Robin The Island
Big Easy, Rachel, & Johanna Gauntlet 3
Wes/Casey Fresh Meat

Aneesa won 3 duels... she fought her *** off to make it.
You clearly just despise Jenn but she killed cutthroat, she was the second best girl there. Sarah was much better than cara which is why she didnt go in.

Oddly enough I actually don't mind Jenn as a person or competitor it's just that all of the finals she's been in I don't think she necessarily deserved to be in. As for Aneesa winning 3 Duels doesn't mean much if you're not a long distance runner which she isn't she posed zero threat to Rachel and Britini in the end and she inadvertently killed Mark's chances of winning the Duel 2

Where to start Jay/Jenna Battle of the Exes 2 Devyn Free Agents Camila/Jemmye Rivals 2 JD/Devyn Battle of the Seasons Leroy/Michael Rivals Jenn/Mandi Rivals Jenn & Sarah Cutthroat Noor/Jenn Fresh Meat 2 Aneesa Duel 2 Jenn, Ryan, Paula, & Robin The Island Big Easy, Rachel, & Johanna Gauntlet 3 Wes/Casey Fresh Meat

What's your reasons for the ones bolded?

Because Camila,Jemmye, Aneesa, Jenn, & Noor didn't pose any threat of winning in the finals and kind of took the Spot from people who could of posed a threat in the end. On Cutthroat Jenn really should of gone in either one of the last 2 Gulags instead of Theresa and Emily she really didn't stand out as a competitor at all that season to get a free ride to the final.

Your delusional if you think Jenn should have gone in.  Even Theresa and Laurel didn't think she should.  She was by far the best girl on the team.  The Jenn hatred blinds people.  I think Emily's one of the best girls ever and Theresa is underestimate but on CUTTHROAT Jenn outperformed both consistently.  

Where to start Jay/Jenna Battle of the Exes 2 Devyn Free Agents Camila/Jemmye Rivals 2 JD/Devyn Battle of the Seasons Leroy/Michael Rivals Jenn/Mandi Rivals Jenn & Sarah Cutthroat Noor/Jenn Fresh Meat 2 Aneesa Duel 2 Jenn, Ryan, Paula, & Robin The Island Big Easy, Rachel, & Johanna Gauntlet 3 Wes/Casey Fresh Meat

What's your reasons for the ones bolded?

Because Camila,Jemmye, Aneesa, Jenn, & Noor didn't pose any threat of winning in the finals and kind of took the Spot from people who could of posed a threat in the end. On Cutthroat Jenn really should of gone in either one of the last 2 Gulags instead of Theresa and Emily she really didn't stand out as a competitor at all that season to get a free ride to the final.

Your delusional if you think Jenn should have gone in.  Even Theresa and Laurel didn't think she should.  She was by far the best girl on the team.  The Jenn hatred blinds people.  I think Emily's one of the best girls ever and Theresa is underestimate but on CUTTHROAT Jenn outperformed both consistently.  

I hate Jenn but I have to agree. Jenn was the best girl on the blue team. She deserved her Fresh Meat 2/Cutthroat and Rivals 1 finals IMO

Where to start Jay/Jenna Battle of the Exes 2 Devyn Free Agents Camila/Jemmye Rivals 2 JD/Devyn Battle of the Seasons Leroy/Michael Rivals Jenn/Mandi Rivals Jenn & Sarah Cutthroat Noor/Jenn Fresh Meat 2 Aneesa Duel 2 Jenn, Ryan, Paula, & Robin The Island Big Easy, Rachel, & Johanna Gauntlet 3 Wes/Casey Fresh Meat


What's your reasons for the ones bolded?

Because Camila,Jemmye, Aneesa, Jenn, & Noor didn't pose any threat of winning in the finals and kind of took the Spot from people who could of posed a threat in the end. On Cutthroat Jenn really should of gone in either one of the last 2 Gulags instead of Theresa and Emily she really didn't stand out as a competitor at all that season to get a free ride to the final.

I will say for sure that jenn got a free ride on rivals and cutthroat .. but fresh meat she went in the last elimination


Yeah but her & Noor didn't complete the final they were helicoptered to the finish line at the end to be with the 3 teams who did complete the final if Evelyn & Luke made it to the finals I don't see Evelyn quitting or letting Luke quit so they would of made it an interesting final

Where to start Jay/Jenna Battle of the Exes 2 Devyn Free Agents Camila/Jemmye Rivals 2 JD/Devyn Battle of the Seasons Leroy/Michael Rivals Jenn/Mandi Rivals Jenn & Sarah Cutthroat Noor/Jenn Fresh Meat 2 Aneesa Duel 2 Jenn, Ryan, Paula, & Robin The Island Big Easy, Rachel, & Johanna Gauntlet 3 Wes/Casey Fresh Meat

What's your reasons for the ones bolded?

Because Camila,Jemmye, Aneesa, Jenn, & Noor didn't pose any threat of winning in the finals and kind of took the Spot from people who could of posed a threat in the end. On Cutthroat Jenn really should of gone in either one of the last 2 Gulags instead of Theresa and Emily she really didn't stand out as a competitor at all that season to get a free ride to the final.

Your delusional if you think Jenn should have gone in.  Even Theresa and Laurel didn't think she should.  She was by far the best girl on the team.  The Jenn hatred blinds people.  I think Emily's one of the best girls ever and Theresa is underestimate but on CUTTHROAT Jenn outperformed both consistently.  

I hate Jenn but I have to agree. Jenn was the best girl on the blue team. She deserved her Fresh Meat 2/Cutthroat and Rivals 1 finals IMO

Someone could argue Rivals I suppose but she was great on Cutthroat and played on of the best political games ever on FM2--it just gets lost because of the Kenny-Wes rivalry

Bananas and Derrick deserved their Cutthroat final. Bananas/Derrick/Jenn/Emily would have easily crushed the Cutthroat final

Where to start Jay/Jenna Battle of the Exes 2 Devyn Free Agents Camila/Jemmye Rivals 2 JD/Devyn Battle of the Seasons Leroy/Michael Rivals Jenn/Mandi Rivals Jenn & Sarah Cutthroat Noor/Jenn Fresh Meat 2 Aneesa Duel 2 Jenn, Ryan, Paula, & Robin The Island Big Easy, Rachel, & Johanna Gauntlet 3 Wes/Casey Fresh Meat

What's your reasons for the ones bolded?

Because Camila,Jemmye, Aneesa, Jenn, & Noor didn't pose any threat of winning in the finals and kind of took the Spot from people who could of posed a threat in the end. On Cutthroat Jenn really should of gone in either one of the last 2 Gulags instead of Theresa and Emily she really didn't stand out as a competitor at all that season to get a free ride to the final.
I will say for sure that jenn got a free ride on rivals and cutthroat .. but fresh meat she went in the last elimination
Yeah but her & Noor didn't complete the final they were helicoptered to the finish line at the end to be with the 3 teams who did complete the final if Evelyn & Luke made it to the finals I don't see Evelyn quitting or letting Luke quit so they would of made it an interesting final

Evelyn played a sloppy game...this bullshit that you're basing it on the final is just that.  Jenn earned both of those final spots...much more than Evelyn and Luke would have

Bananas and Derrick deserved their Cutthroat final. Bananas/Derrick/Jenn/Emily would have easily crushed the Cutthroat final


You're definitely right on that if CT didn't turn Johnny Bananas into Johnny Backpack they would have won Cutthroat. But in all honesty I think Tyler would of beaten Bananas if it was a straight up 1 on 1 elimination round because Tyler was the bigger man and in that elimination round size did matter and at that time Tyler was hungry to prove himself so I think what ended up happening in the end was going to happen regardless of production bringing in the heavy hitters

Tina should've been in the Sexes 2 final

Where to start Jay/Jenna Battle of the Exes 2 Devyn Free Agents Camila/Jemmye Rivals 2 JD/Devyn Battle of the Seasons Leroy/Michael Rivals Jenn/Mandi Rivals Jenn & Sarah Cutthroat Noor/Jenn Fresh Meat 2 Aneesa Duel 2 Jenn, Ryan, Paula, & Robin The Island Big Easy, Rachel, & Johanna Gauntlet 3 Wes/Casey Fresh Meat

What's your reasons for the ones bolded?

Because Camila,Jemmye, Aneesa, Jenn, & Noor didn't pose any threat of winning in the finals and kind of took the Spot from people who could of posed a threat in the end. On Cutthroat Jenn really should of gone in either one of the last 2 Gulags instead of Theresa and Emily she really didn't stand out as a competitor at all that season to get a free ride to the final.

Your delusional if you think Jenn should have gone in.  Even Theresa and Laurel didn't think she should.  She was by far the best girl on the team.  The Jenn hatred blinds people.  I think Emily's one of the best girls ever and Theresa is underestimate but on CUTTHROAT Jenn outperformed both consistently.  

I hate Jenn but I have to agree. Jenn was the best girl on the blue team. She deserved her Fresh Meat 2/Cutthroat and Rivals 1 finals IMO

Bananas and Derrick deserved their Cutthroat final. Bananas/Derrick/Jenn/Emily would have easily crushed the Cutthroat final

They would've killed it for sure. I really wanted the Blue or Grey team to win because I hated the Red team.

Tina should've been in the Sexes 2 final

Ummm...actually it should have been Coral, Ruthie & Arissa.  Coral made the power move when she should have to take out Ruthie but her deal with Sophia should have been--Coral & Arissa were captains--Sophia & Ruthie were non-captains....the men would have thrown it--Sophia goes home.  Doesn't change the end result though

Where to start Jay/Jenna Battle of the Exes 2 Devyn Free Agents Camila/Jemmye Rivals 2 JD/Devyn Battle of the Seasons Leroy/Michael Rivals Jenn/Mandi Rivals Jenn & Sarah Cutthroat Noor/Jenn Fresh Meat 2 Aneesa Duel 2 Jenn, Ryan, Paula, & Robin The Island Big Easy, Rachel, & Johanna Gauntlet 3 Wes/Casey Fresh Meat


What's your reasons for the ones bolded?

Because Camila,Jemmye, Aneesa, Jenn, & Noor didn't pose any threat of winning in the finals and kind of took the Spot from people who could of posed a threat in the end. On Cutthroat Jenn really should of gone in either one of the last 2 Gulags instead of Theresa and Emily she really didn't stand out as a competitor at all that season to get a free ride to the final.

I will say for sure that jenn got a free ride on rivals and cutthroat .. but fresh meat she went in the last elimination


Yeah but her & Noor didn't complete the final they were helicoptered to the finish line at the end to be with the 3 teams who did complete the final if Evelyn & Luke made it to the finals I don't see Evelyn quitting or letting Luke quit so they would of made it an interesting final

Ok but to say they didn't deserve the final come on ... They might not have did good in the actually final ... But overall they derseved to be there .

Tina should've been in the Sexes 2 final

Robin too.

Tina should've been in the Sexes 2 final

Robin too.

No, no, no, no

Fresh Meat - Derrick and Diem instead of Wes and Casey (although I'm glad they beat everyone, they got lucky that their luggage was the lightest)

Duel - Diem instead of Svetlana

Inferno 3 - Timmy instead of Johnny

Gauntlet 3 - Danny instead of Eric

Island - Dunbar instead of Johnny

Duel 2 - Landon instead of Mark

Rivals 2 - Aneesa and Diem instead of Camila and Jemmye

Free Agents - CT and Theresa instead of Zach and Devyn

 

Diem did not deserve a spot in The Duel final. Svetlana earned her *** a trip to the end.

Fresh Meat - Derrick and Diem instead of Wes and Casey (although I'm glad they beat everyone, they got lucky that their luggage was the lightest)

Duel - Diem instead of Svetlana

Inferno 3 - Timmy instead of Johnny

Gauntlet 3 - Danny instead of Eric

Island - Dunbar instead of Johnny

Duel 2 - Landon instead of Mark

Rivals 2 - Aneesa and Diem instead of Camila and Jemmye

Free Agents - CT and Theresa instead of Zach and Devyn

Okay--you're clearly a Diem fan but she absolutely didn't deserve a spot in FM or The Duel...she also performed horribly on Rivals 2.

 

You're right haha some of it was personal preference.  I don't think Svet should have been in the Duel final because she lucked out with Beth's DQ, but she was a little less likeable in Rivals 2 though. I do, however, think that she absolutley deserves to be in the finals of Fresh Meat.

Fresh Meat - Derrick and Diem instead of Wes and Casey (although I'm glad they beat everyone, they got lucky that their luggage was the lightest)

Duel - Diem instead of Svetlana

Inferno 3 - Timmy instead of Johnny

Gauntlet 3 - Danny instead of Eric

Island - Dunbar instead of Johnny

Duel 2 - Landon instead of Mark

Rivals 2 - Aneesa and Diem instead of Camila and Jemmye

Free Agents - CT and Theresa instead of Zach and Devyn

 

No Svet got really lucky that Beth "DQ'ed".

 

Diem did not deserve a spot in The Duel final. Svetlana earned her *** a trip to the end.

Fresh Meat - Derrick and Diem instead of Wes and Casey (although I'm glad they beat everyone, they got lucky that their luggage was the lightest)

Duel - Diem instead of Svetlana

Inferno 3 - Timmy instead of Johnny

Gauntlet 3 - Danny instead of Eric

Island - Dunbar instead of Johnny

Duel 2 - Landon instead of Mark

Rivals 2 - Aneesa and Diem instead of Camila and Jemmye

Free Agents - CT and Theresa instead of Zach and Devyn

Okay--you're clearly a Diem fan but she absolutely didn't deserve a spot in FM or The Duel...she also performed horribly on Rivals 2.

 

You're right haha some of it was personal preference.  I don't think Svet should have been in the Duel final because she lucked out with Beth's DQ, but she was a little less likeable in Rivals 2 though. I do, however, think that she absolutley deserves to be in the finals of Fresh Meat.

Diem made an awful decision on FM which is why, IMO, she deserved to lose.  Diem was never good at making decisions regarding eliminations.  Yes. Svet lucked out but Aneesa is probably the person that "should have been there" if we're going with someone else.

Bananas and Derrick deserved their Cutthroat final. Bananas/Derrick/Jenn/Emily would have easily crushed the Cutthroat final

You're definitely right on that if CT didn't turn Johnny Bananas into Johnny Backpack they would have won Cutthroat. But in all honesty I think Tyler would of beaten Bananas if it was a straight up 1 on 1 elimination round because Tyler was the bigger man and in that elimination round size did matter and at that time Tyler was hungry to prove himself so I think what ended up happening in the end was going to happen regardless of production bringing in the heavy hitters

had they not done the "heavy hitter" idea, i doubt they would have used that elimination, because production would have wanted something that favored johnny. probably the dice elimination again

Tina should've been in the Sexes 2 final

Ummm...actually it should have been Coral, Ruthie & Arissa.  Coral made the power move when she should have to take out Ruthie but her deal with Sophia should have been--Coral & Arissa were captains--Sophia & Ruthie were non-captains....the men would have thrown it--Sophia goes home.  Doesn't change the end result though

From a competitive standpoint (which is what this thread is clearly about) Tina should of been in the final, her and Coral were the best female performers.

Tina should've been in the Sexes 2 final

Ummm...actually it should have been Coral, Ruthie & Arissa.  Coral made the power move when she should have to take out Ruthie but her deal with Sophia should have been--Coral & Arissa were captains--Sophia & Ruthie were non-captains....the men would have thrown it--Sophia goes home.  Doesn't change the end result though

From a competitive standpoint (which is what this thread is clearly about) Tina should of been in the final, her and Coral were the best female performers.

I never thought this was about "the best players reach the finals" but about "what should have happened"...such as Beth and CT not being DQ'd, Brad not resorting to shady tactics, Evelyn and other making better strategic decisions.  Also, I disagree that Tina was the second best girl.  Ruthie & Sophia were better than her.  Probably Veronica as well.  Rachel ****** up so she got what she deserved

Tina should've been in the Sexes 2 final

Ummm...actually it should have been Coral, Ruthie & Arissa.  Coral made the power move when she should have to take out Ruthie but her deal with Sophia should have been--Coral & Arissa were captains--Sophia & Ruthie were non-captains....the men would have thrown it--Sophia goes home.  Doesn't change the end result though

From a competitive standpoint (which is what this thread is clearly about) Tina should of been in the final, her and Coral were the best female performers.

I never thought this was about "the best players reach the finals" but about "what should have happened"...such as Beth and CT not being DQ'd, Brad not resorting to shady tactics, Evelyn and other making better strategic decisions.  Also, I disagree that Tina was the second best girl.  Ruthie & Sophia were better than her.  Probably Veronica as well.  Rachel ****** up so she got what she deserved

Tina was better than both, I analyzed that challenge. You're clearly just going off what you think, and didn't analyze the missions. Also, this thread is clearly about those who didn't deserve to be in the final based off their performance, not politics.

Cara Maria and Theresa with Laurel on Free Agents.

Wes and Theresa on Exes 2.

Diem and Aneesa on Rivals 2.

Marie and Rob instead of Devyn and JD on BOTS

I wouldn't want CM in the final in that condition. I would have been fine with a Laurel/Theresa/Nany final

I wasn't refering to CM with the broken hand. If she didn't get hurt I think it would have been a great final 3. Laurel/Theresa/Nany Nany gets third.

Tina should've been in the Sexes 2 final

Ummm...actually it should have been Coral, Ruthie & Arissa.  Coral made the power move when she should have to take out Ruthie but her deal with Sophia should have been--Coral & Arissa were captains--Sophia & Ruthie were non-captains....the men would have thrown it--Sophia goes home.  Doesn't change the end result though

From a competitive standpoint (which is what this thread is clearly about) Tina should of been in the final, her and Coral were the best female performers.

I never thought this was about "the best players reach the finals" but about "what should have happened"...such as Beth and CT not being DQ'd, Brad not resorting to shady tactics, Evelyn and other making better strategic decisions.  Also, I disagree that Tina was the second best girl.  Ruthie & Sophia were better than her.  Probably Veronica as well.  Rachel ****** up so she got what she deserved

Tina was better than both, I analyzed that challenge. You're clearly just going off what you think, and didn't analyze the missions. Also, this thread is clearly about those who didn't deserve to be in the final based off their performance, not politics.

It isn't clearly about that...hence people saying Dunbar on The Island

Coral took Sophia over Tina...tell you exactly who she felt performed better.  I think you "analyzing a challenge" is you ignoring facts.  LOL--"going off what you think"--you're ******* dumb as ****.  

Coral took Sophia over Tina because they're friends...

 

Bananas and Derrick deserved their Cutthroat final. Bananas/Derrick/Jenn/Emily would have easily crushed the Cutthroat final

You can thrown Theresa in there too if it wasn't for that stupid heavy hitters twist. She would have beaten Tori in that elimination.

Pages