Haha and Evan on Duel 2...2nd most challenge wins and most elimination wins and best political game on that show. Of the 3 who made it Brad was the one who didn't belong.
Haha and Evan on Duel 2...2nd most challenge wins and most elimination wins and best political game on that show. Of the 3 who made it Brad was the one who didn't belong.
Landon should have had Evan's spot. He did better than him and pretty much every guy that season. Him winning would've made up for the whole season which was painfully boring.
Laurel shouldnt have on free agents final? Why the girl with the most elimination wins that season?
Because its debut and laurel is fresh meat
Her being Fresh Meat has nothing to do with it. Like I said before her being there just made the women's side predictable as all hell. She doesn't make it to the end or isn't on the season at all the game becomes more interesting.
Laurel shouldnt have on free agents final? Why the girl with the most elimination wins that season?
Because its debut and laurel is fresh meat
Her being Fresh Meat has nothing to do with it. Like I said before her being there just made the women's side predictable as all hell. She doesn't make it to the end or isn't on the season at all the game becomes more interesting.
Really that's interesting because you say Landon was the best competitor so he should make the final but laurel shouldn't because she was the best girl?
That doesn't make sense
Laurel shouldnt have on free agents final? Why the girl with the most elimination wins that season?
Because its debut and laurel is fresh meat
Her being Fresh Meat has nothing to do with it. Like I said before her being there just made the women's side predictable as all hell. She doesn't make it to the end or isn't on the season at all the game becomes more interesting.
Really that's interesting because you say Landon was the best competitor so he should make the final but laurel shouldn't because she was the best girl?
That doesn't make sense
Darrell should've been in The Ruins final. He would've received his fifth win had it not been for Brad instigating -_-
agreed. i can't believe someone hasn't mentioned that before. including me.
But be careful Justin. people will come u with the B.S. of "Well Darrell should have been able to control himself..." when i know good and well most of those people would have done the same thing.
Oh. I thought this topic was based on who legitimately did and did not deserve to make the final. If it's just based on who we don't like and wish wasn't there, things make a lot more sense. My list is then as follows
Exes 2: Jay
Free Agents: Zach (sure he tied for most wins that season, but I don't like him so he didn't deserve it)
Rivals 2: Wes, Cara, Cooke, Wes, Jemmye, Wes, maybe Frank, and also Wes
Seasons: Frank, Zach, Sam, Trishelle
Rivals: Wes. They should've let Kenny compete by himself.
im tired of people saying Darrell could have controlled himself but no one says Brad could have controlled himself.
& vica versa.
if you said brad should've made the final, i would've said the EXACT same thing but he only mentioned darrell.
fact is they both could've controlled themselves and had a good chance of making the final. brad SHOULD'VE not instigated it and not let the alchohol influence him and likewise.
Oh. I thought this topic was based on who legitimately did and did not deserve to make the final. If it's just based on who we don't like and wish wasn't there, things make a lot more sense. My list is then as follows
Exes 2: Jay
Free Agents: Zach (sure he tied for most wins that season, but I don't like him so he didn't deserve it)
Rivals 2: Wes, Cara, Cooke, Wes, Jemmye, Wes, maybe Frank, and also Wes
Seasons: Frank, Zach, Sam, Trishelle
Rivals: Wes. They should've let Kenny compete by himself.
Cutthroat: Brad, Dunbar, Tori, Luke
Fresh Meat 2: Carley
Duel: Wes
Fresh Meat: Wes
I think It can be either/or honestly. No set criteria.
And honestly Darrell could've controlled himself. He could've just as easily walked out of the room instead of sitting there looking stupid.
And THANK GOD the picture of this thread changed. I don't know WTF that other one was.
Darrell should've been in The Ruins final. He would've received his fifth win had it not been for Brad instigating -_-
agreed. i can't believe someone hasn't mentioned that before. including me.
But be careful Justin. people will come u with the B.S. of "Well Darrell should have been able to control himself..." when i know good and well most of those people would have done the same thing.
Haha yeah. Graphik mentions this a lot. Brad was clearly jealous that Darrell had won all of his challenges up until that point while he didn't win any. Darrell remained cool in their argument until Brad got all up in his face.
CT should've been in the Rivals final. Kenny shouldn't have been in the Rivals final because he performed terrible in the missions and Wes had to carry him all season. If it wasn't for Wes, Kenny/Wes would've lost to Brandon/Ty in the jungle.
David shouldn't have been in The Gauntlet 2 final. Derrick should've taken his spot.
CT should've been in the Rivals final. Kenny shouldn't have been in the Rivals final because he performed terrible and Wes had to carry him all season. If it wasn't for Wes, Kenny/Wes would've lost to Brandon/Ty in the jungle.
David shouldn't have been in The Gauntlet 2 final. Derrick should've taken his spot.
These are good ones. CT definetly should have been in Rivals 1 final. It would've been even better had he and Adam won and became cool with each other.
I agree about David. Sad thing about it is that actually could've happened but the vets decided to be idiots that round.
Darrell should've been in The Ruins final. He would've received his fifth win had it not been for Brad instigating -_-
agreed. i can't believe someone hasn't mentioned that before. including me.
But be careful Justin. people will come u with the B.S. of "Well Darrell should have been able to control himself..." when i know good and well most of those people would have done the same thing.
Haha yeah. Graphik mentions this a lot. Brad was clearly jealous that Darrell had won all of his challenges up until that point while he didn't win any. Darrell remained cool in their argument until Brad got all up in his face.
to be fair, it was casey's fault.. most of the time.
do you have good reasons on why Laurel shouldn't have been in the Final other than she's not a true cast member?
and i'm surprised you didn't include Kenny on any of these.
Laurel shouldnt have on free agents final? Why the girl with the most elimination wins that season?
Haha and Evan on Duel 2...2nd most challenge wins and most elimination wins and best political game on that show. Of the 3 who made it Brad was the one who didn't belong.
and with the second most amount of Mission wins.
There are so many threads that should just be part of the Generic one. Why the need for so many unnecessary new threads?
CT could have taken Easy out. IIRC, that was one of the reasons the rookies did not want to vote for CT because they felt like he would take Easy out
Yes I do...It was just predictable that Laurel was going to win that final. Had she not been there it would've been more interesting I feel like.
And I forgot about Kenny..I don't think he and Wes should have been in the final(but I do think they deserved to win it though).
Oh and Wes/Theresa should have been in the Exes 2 final.
Because its debut and laurel is fresh meat
Because its debut and laurel is fresh meat
Landon should have had Evan's spot. He did better than him and pretty much every guy that season. Him winning would've made up for the whole season which was painfully boring.
Her being Fresh Meat has nothing to do with it. Like I said before her being there just made the women's side predictable as all hell. She doesn't make it to the end or isn't on the season at all the game becomes more interesting.
Really that's interesting because you say Landon was the best competitor so he should make the final but laurel shouldn't because she was the best girl?
That doesn't make sense
I like Landon. I hate Laurel.
Makes sense now?
Darrell should've been in The Ruins final. He would've received his fifth win had it not been for Brad instigating -_-
fights go two ways. he could have restrained himself (but yes... i would've liked to see him in a final.)
if brad was there too, and if he made the finals, the final challenge would've been closer and the champs would've had a run for their $$
agreed. i can't believe someone hasn't mentioned that before. including me.
But be careful Justin. people will come u with the B.S. of "Well Darrell should have been able to control himself..." when i know good and well most of those people would have done the same thing.
^^^ See what i mean Justin!!!! lol.
im tired of people saying Darrell could have controlled himself but no one says Brad could have controlled himself.
Oh. I thought this topic was based on who legitimately did and did not deserve to make the final. If it's just based on who we don't like and wish wasn't there, things make a lot more sense. My list is then as follows
Exes 2: Jay
Free Agents: Zach (sure he tied for most wins that season, but I don't like him so he didn't deserve it)
Rivals 2: Wes, Cara, Cooke, Wes, Jemmye, Wes, maybe Frank, and also Wes
Seasons: Frank, Zach, Sam, Trishelle
Rivals: Wes. They should've let Kenny compete by himself.
Cutthroat: Brad, Dunbar, Tori, Luke
Fresh Meat 2: Carley
Duel: Wes
Fresh Meat: Wes
& vica versa.
if you said brad should've made the final, i would've said the EXACT same thing but he only mentioned darrell.
fact is they both could've controlled themselves and had a good chance of making the final. brad SHOULD'VE not instigated it and not let the alchohol influence him and likewise.
well i was referring to not only you but a bunch of other people who have said that in the past.
fair.
I think It can be either/or honestly. No set criteria.
And honestly Darrell could've controlled himself. He could've just as easily walked out of the room instead of sitting there looking stupid.
And THANK GOD the picture of this thread changed. I don't know WTF that other one was.
Haha yeah. Graphik mentions this a lot. Brad was clearly jealous that Darrell had won all of his challenges up until that point while he didn't win any. Darrell remained cool in their argument until Brad got all up in his face.
CT should've been in the Rivals final. Kenny shouldn't have been in the Rivals final because he performed terrible in the missions and Wes had to carry him all season. If it wasn't for Wes, Kenny/Wes would've lost to Brandon/Ty in the jungle.
David shouldn't have been in The Gauntlet 2 final. Derrick should've taken his spot.
These are good ones. CT definetly should have been in Rivals 1 final. It would've been even better had he and Adam won and became cool with each other.
I agree about David. Sad thing about it is that actually could've happened but the vets decided to be idiots that round.
to be fair, it was casey's fault.. most of the time.
I'll start recent and go back to Duel 2. The only finals where everyone deserved to be in the finals were Rivals 2, Exes 1 and Fresh Meat 2
Battle of the Exes 2
Should have - Wes/Theresa
Shoudn't have - Jay/Jenna
(side note - Imagine if the finals would have been Jordan/Sarah, Banany and Wes/Theresa? Would have been epic.)
Free Agents
Should have - Cara Maria (healthy), Theresa
Shouldn't have - Devyn (still love her)
Battle of the Seasons 2
Should have - Nany
Shouldn't have - Trishelle
Rivals 1
Should have - CT/Adam
Shouldn't have - Leroy/Mike
Cutthroat
Should have - Derrick, Bananas, Theresa, Camila
Shouldn't have - Tori
The Ruins
Should have - Kimberly
Shouldn't have - Kenny, Evan
Duel 2
Should have - Landon (biggest disappointment not making a final ever)
Shouldn't have - Brad
You're kidding....
The 2 that come to mind most as of recently are
Nany should have been in the Seasons Final
Wes/Theresa should have been in the Exes 2 Final
I'm not......
Pages