Ashley quit because she had lost all her luggage and she knew she wasnt in the right mental state at the time. You can count it against her if you want but its no where near as bad as being removed for punching someone/trying to kill them.
Quitting because you're not in the right mental state devalues that person as a competitor...competitors don't quit because their luggage didn't arrive
How do you know all these other girls you have in your top 10 wouldnt do the same?
When have any quit or threatened to quit? This isnt an isolated incident with Ashley. We don't have to agree bit her quitting in that manner is a huge strike and greatly reduces her ranking IMO.
I mean she's never quit mid-challenge so i dont think that really that puts her down as a competitor. As long as she has her luggage, she's a great competitor.
Great competitors dont walk away because they dont have their luggage nor do they threaten to quit 100 times on Invasion. Didn't she quit or threaten to quit on when she was on one of the Champs vs whatever?
She was going through her Dads health issues and then death around the time she quit, didn’t she? I don’t really think that should be counted against her.
Ashley really SHOWED TF OUT this season lmaooooooooo! Me and gamer told y’all she played her best game and served at least one, maybe two, elimination wins.
Ashley quit because she had lost all her luggage and she knew she wasnt in the right mental state at the time. You can count it against her if you want but its no where near as bad as being removed for punching someone/trying to kill them.
Quitting because you're not in the right mental state devalues that person as a competitor...competitors don't quit because their luggage didn't arrive
How do you know all these other girls you have in your top 10 wouldnt do the same?
When have any quit or threatened to quit? This isnt an isolated incident with Ashley. We don't have to agree bit her quitting in that manner is a huge strike and greatly reduces her ranking IMO.
I mean she's never quit mid-challenge so i dont think that really that puts her down as a competitor. As long as she has her luggage, she's a great competitor.
Great competitors dont walk away because they dont have their luggage nor do they threaten to quit 100 times on Invasion. Didn't she quit or threaten to quit on when she was on one of the Champs vs whatever?
She was going through her Dads health issues and then death around the time she quit, didn’t she? I don’t really think that should be counted against her.
Dont go if you mentally cant do it. It is definitely held against her. To dismiss that is ridiculous IMO.
Ashley quit because she had lost all her luggage and she knew she wasnt in the right mental state at the time. You can count it against her if you want but its no where near as bad as being removed for punching someone/trying to kill them.
Quitting because you're not in the right mental state devalues that person as a competitor...competitors don't quit because their luggage didn't arrive
How do you know all these other girls you have in your top 10 wouldnt do the same?
When have any quit or threatened to quit? This isnt an isolated incident with Ashley. We don't have to agree bit her quitting in that manner is a huge strike and greatly reduces her ranking IMO.
I mean she's never quit mid-challenge so i dont think that really that puts her down as a competitor. As long as she has her luggage, she's a great competitor.
Great competitors dont walk away because they dont have their luggage nor do they threaten to quit 100 times on Invasion. Didn't she quit or threaten to quit on when she was on one of the Champs vs whatever?
When hasn't she threatened to quit? She's a big baby and cries and quits/threatens to quit when things don't go her way.
Agreed. Elites don't quit. Cara broke her hand and still continued to compete. I'm pretty sure Ashley has threatened to quit, or has quit every season she's been on.
Ashley really SHOWED TF OUT this season lmaooooooooo! Me and gamer told y’all she played her best game and served at least one, maybe two, elimination wins.
Ashley really SHOWED TF OUT this season lmaooooooooo! Me and gamer told y’all she played her best game and served at least one, maybe two, elimination wins.
meanwhile people are in here talking about how she isn’t elite. i have to laugh!
Ashley really SHOWED TF OUT this season lmaooooooooo! Me and gamer told y’all she played her best game and served at least one, maybe two, elimination wins.
meanwhile people are in here talking about how she isn’t elite. i have to laugh!
She isnt but I'm looking forward to some great gameplay from her.
Cara is one of the game's greatest players and performers. Consistently makes a final every year she 's on the show. From a likebale underdog to fans and unlikebale player to fellow challenge players in her early seasons to a force in the game. Fans use to love Cara for being different and weird. But now she is so annoying in the game now but actually a down to earth person in real life.
Here's my problem with Ashley being top 10 all time. If this was a schoolyard pick team set up how many girls would you take before Ashley. Ninja Cara and Laurel aren't even debatable. I'd also take Georgia and Kam for sure. I'd probably also take Dee Tori and Nany. Maybe Jenn. Shed likely be my 10th pick on this season and shes in her prime.
But at the same time, Ashley's mission on these shows is to win money any way possible. Not to be a team player or work well with others or be the superior athlete. Her record has to say something about her game especially for someone who isn't an athlete like Ninja or Laurel. It's like saying Susie isn't that good because she's not the competitor Laurel or Emily is.
Here's my problem with Ashley being top 10 all time. If this was a schoolyard pick team set up how many girls would you take before Ashley. Ninja Cara and Laurel aren't even debatable. I'd also take Georgia and Kam for sure. I'd probably also take Dee Tori and Nany. Maybe Jenn. Shed likely be my 10th pick on this season and shes in her prime.
But at the same time, Ashley's mission on these shows is to win money any way possible. Not to be a team player or work well with others or be the superior athlete. Her record has to say something about her game especially for someone who isn't an athlete like Ninja or Laurel. It's like saying Susie isn't that good because she's not the competitor Laurel or Emily is.
I think Ashley is a very good player like Cara. But no, I do not think her elite. I think she won because twice Amanda threw her game for Ashley. If she hadn't Ashley wouldn't have made the finals imo. The fact that she made it this far without having her group around is very impressive. And once I see her performance and hopefully she doesn't threaten to quit or throw hissy fits constantly, I will have more information in which to form my opinion.
Here's my problem with Ashley being top 10 all time. If this was a schoolyard pick team set up how many girls would you take before Ashley. Ninja Cara and Laurel aren't even debatable. I'd also take Georgia and Kam for sure. I'd probably also take Dee Tori and Nany. Maybe Jenn. Shed likely be my 10th pick on this season and shes in her prime.
But at the same time, Ashley's mission on these shows is to win money any way possible. Not to be a team player or work well with others or be the superior athlete. Her record has to say something about her game especially for someone who isn't an athlete like Ninja or Laurel. It's like saying Susie isn't that good because she's not the competitor Laurel or Emily is.
I think Ashley is a very good player like Cara. But no, I do not think her elite. I think she won because twice Amanda threw her game for Ashley. If she hadn't Ashley wouldn't have made the finals imo. The fact that she made it this far without having her group around is very impressive. And once I see her performance and hopefully she doesn't threaten to quit or throw hissy fits constantly, I will have more information in which to form my opinion.
Her being without her friends and still making it to the end solidified it for me that's she's top ten. Regardless of how she got there she did she's been a lucky player but luck can only get you so far. If she won she may even be higher than some of these "elites" you guys like.
Ashley quit because she had lost all her luggage and she knew she wasnt in the right mental state at the time. You can count it against her if you want but its no where near as bad as being removed for punching someone/trying to kill them.
Quitting because you're not in the right mental state devalues that person as a competitor...competitors don't quit because their luggage didn't arrive
How do you know all these other girls you have in your top 10 wouldnt do the same?
When have any quit or threatened to quit? This isnt an isolated incident with Ashley. We don't have to agree bit her quitting in that manner is a huge strike and greatly reduces her ranking IMO.
I mean she's never quit mid-challenge so i dont think that really that puts her down as a competitor. As long as she has her luggage, she's a great competitor.
Hasn't she had to be talked into staying a time or two? Imagine if others didn't do that, she may have quit more.
Here's my problem with Ashley being top 10 all time. If this was a schoolyard pick team set up how many girls would you take before Ashley. Ninja Cara and Laurel aren't even debatable. I'd also take Georgia and Kam for sure. I'd probably also take Dee Tori and Nany. Maybe Jenn. Shed likely be my 10th pick on this season and shes in her prime.
But at the same time, Ashley's mission on these shows is to win money any way possible. Not to be a team player or work well with others or be the superior athlete. Her record has to say something about her game especially for someone who isn't an athlete like Ninja or Laurel. It's like saying Susie isn't that good because she's not the competitor Laurel or Emily is.
I'm good with putting her on the level of Susie. She is a great competitor and strategist. Shes just not elite overall. I've never said Ashley isn't good or even great. I'm saying there's a valid argument against top 10. if you want to put her in the top 10 that's fine just dont pretend it's a fact or needs to be universally agreed upon.
Yikes imagine holding Ashley's father's death against her.
Dont go if you're not ready to compete. Her dad didn't die when she was on location. she signed up for it, went there then quit. It's not about her dad.
She was going through her Dads health issues and then death around the time she quit, didn’t she? I don’t really think that should be counted against her.
Ashley really SHOWED TF OUT this season lmaooooooooo! Me and gamer told y’all she played her best game and served at least one, maybe two, elimination wins.
Dont go if you mentally cant do it. It is definitely held against her. To dismiss that is ridiculous IMO.
Agreed. Elites don't quit. Cara broke her hand and still continued to compete. I'm pretty sure Ashley has threatened to quit, or has quit every season she's been on.
She beat two layups?
meanwhile people are in here talking about how she isn’t elite. i have to laugh!
the fact that she even made a final again after “stealing” hunter’s money proves that she’s one of the best.
Cara really controlled the game & sent bananas, tori, & josh in huh? Legend elite vibes
She isnt but I'm looking forward to some great gameplay from her.
The **** it does
Cara is one of the game's greatest players and performers. Consistently makes a final every year she 's on the show. From a likebale underdog to fans and unlikebale player to fellow challenge players in her early seasons to a force in the game. Fans use to love Cara for being different and weird. But now she is so annoying in the game now but actually a down to earth person in real life.
Cara > Ashley for sure. Cara has made 8 finals and 3 wins (including champs vs. pros).
But at the same time, Ashley's mission on these shows is to win money any way possible. Not to be a team player or work well with others or be the superior athlete. Her record has to say something about her game especially for someone who isn't an athlete like Ninja or Laurel. It's like saying Susie isn't that good because she's not the competitor Laurel or Emily is.
This show isn't always who's the best athlete. It's usually a combination of being well rounded, good social game and some luck. Ashley is top 10.
period.
I've been calling Ashley Mitchell to win for weeks. Just based off her being there past the halfway point. I'm gonna laugh if it's true ****
Hoping for a CT and Tori win
I think Ashley is a very good player like Cara. But no, I do not think her elite. I think she won because twice Amanda threw her game for Ashley. If she hadn't Ashley wouldn't have made the finals imo. The fact that she made it this far without having her group around is very impressive. And once I see her performance and hopefully she doesn't threaten to quit or throw hissy fits constantly, I will have more information in which to form my opinion.
Yikes imagine holding Ashley's father's death against her.
Her being without her friends and still making it to the end solidified it for me that's she's top ten. Regardless of how she got there she did she's been a lucky player but luck can only get you so far. If she won she may even be higher than some of these "elites" you guys like.
Hasn't she had to be talked into staying a time or two? Imagine if others didn't do that, she may have quit more.
I'm good with putting her on the level of Susie. She is a great competitor and strategist. Shes just not elite overall. I've never said Ashley isn't good or even great. I'm saying there's a valid argument against top 10. if you want to put her in the top 10 that's fine just dont pretend it's a fact or needs to be universally agreed upon.
Dont go if you're not ready to compete. Her dad didn't die when she was on location. she signed up for it, went there then quit. It's not about her dad.
I shouldnt be shocked but somehow you always manage to outdo yourself.
Find a mirror
Is Veronica top 10 all time? Is Susie? Is Camila? Is Cara? Let's see these top 10 lists with Ashley
Pages