The Challenge: All Stars (Season 1)- Spoilers Discussion

7437 posts / 0 new
Last post

 

If people want to talk about boring, Yes is the defintion of that. Sorry not sorry.  

None of these guys are entertaining but nobody will admit that because they are using their old school & Nostagia Goggles.

From Darrell to Yes to Derrick to Syrus to Mark to Nehemiah. None of these guys should be consider for season two.

 

if you are grouping them all together then you might as well say the whole cast.

 

What exactly do any of you find interesting?

Personally I think some of you are just outgrowing the show.

What did Mark, Derrick, Yes, Syrus, Darrell and Nehemiah did that you found interesting?

Maybe I am out growing this show or maybe I just don't have the Nostagia goggles like you guys do since I haven't really watch old seasons but there were a lot of dull cast members with a predictable boring format.

I never said I found any of them interesting. I'm just asking a question because y'all keep complaining about people being boring and while yes it's true, some of them are boring but I also think that there's nothing that will satisfy you guys anymore either.

Miss me with that nostalgia goggles shit

 

 

If people want to talk about boring, Yes is the defintion of that. Sorry not sorry.  

None of these guys are entertaining but nobody will admit that because they are using their old school & Nostagia Goggles.

From Darrell to Yes to Derrick to Syrus to Mark to Nehemiah. None of these guys should be consider for season two.

 

if you are grouping them all together then you might as well say the whole cast.

I think a minimal percentage of the cast brought anything guys and girls. They need to do a lot of changes for season 2/3 just like Champs vs stars that I though the first seasons were bad but they got it together for the last one with a less predictable format & longer filming time. It's unrealistic to think they can film this show for 2.5 weeks without content getting hurt or feeling rush.

 

If people want to talk about boring, Yes is the defintion of that. Sorry not sorry.  

None of these guys are entertaining but nobody will admit that because they are using their old school & Nostagia Goggles.

From Darrell to Yes to Derrick to Syrus to Mark to Nehemiah. None of these guys should be consider for season two.

 

I agree they were "boring" but I've never had an issue with "boring" cast members. I find most of the refreshing. I have no interest in any non game related drama. A better format can provide that instead of people volunteering to go in pretty much every time. 

 

 

 

If people want to talk about boring, Yes is the defintion of that. Sorry not sorry.  

None of these guys are entertaining but nobody will admit that because they are using their old school & Nostagia Goggles.

From Darrell to Yes to Derrick to Syrus to Mark to Nehemiah. None of these guys should be consider for season two.

 

I disagree on Darrell but I agree on the rest. But you Mark is going to be back.... I'm sure it won't be long before we see production favorites Wes, Bananas, Brad 

While he can be funny on confessionals he still didn't brought anything on this season like he didn't on Double agents and invasion-Dirty 30. I can see Mark doing behind the scene work, he has never been as entertaining like think he is.

While it's unrealistic Season 2 need a brand new cast with minimal come backs. 

I anticipate them bringing back all of the people none of us want to see for season 2 and not bringing back the ones who should be back.  Like for certain they'll ask back Jemmye, Aneesa, etc. but I wouldn't be shocked if someone like Kendal for example isn't asked back / gets the "well if we NEED her..." status.

 

 

If people want to talk about boring, Yes is the defintion of that. Sorry not sorry.  

None of these guys are entertaining but nobody will admit that because they are using their old school & Nostagia Goggles.

From Darrell to Yes to Derrick to Syrus to Mark to Nehemiah. None of these guys should be consider for season two.

 

I agree they were "boring" but I've never had an issue with "boring" cast members. I find most of the refreshing. I have no interest in any non game related drama. A better format can provide that instead of people volunteering to go in pretty much every time. 

The constant volunteering and giving people what they want was annoying/boring.

IMO the girls have always carried this show from an entertainment standpoint

i hate to admit it cause i cant stand him but Big Easy has been one of the more enjoyable guys on this in terms of storylines and such

but the only guy i really found entertaining was Teck and the only other one i really enjoyed watching was Laterrian 

derrick mark and nehemiah are always doing the most (esp derrick and nehemiah you can tell how bad they wanna be back on the main show)

darrell is a good narrator, syrus thinks hes way more of a beast than he is, Yes is sweet and likeable but boring, ace was barely there but hes daddy, and alton i always find to be so pompous and self righteous

You can't put Wes/Bananas in All Stars because they are too strong.

You really shouldn't have anybody that could still do the main show...and I'd throw Mark/Yes and KellyAnne/Kendal in that category because they COULD do the regular challenge if asked....and they could at least hang physically and would know the social game.

 

IMO the girls have always carried this show from an entertainment standpoint

i hate to admit it cause i cant stand him but Big Easy has been one of the more enjoyable guys on this in terms of storylines and such

but the only guy i really found entertaining was Teck and the only other one i really enjoyed watching was Laterrian 

derrick mark and nehemiah are always doing the most (esp derrick and nehemiah you can tell how bad they wanna be back on the main show)

darrell is a good narrator, syrus thinks hes way more of a beast than he is, Yes is sweet and likeable but boring, ace was barely there but hes daddy, and alton i always find to be so pompous and self righteous

Agreed. The women have always carried the show. Point blank period.

I agree that the women carried the show.

I actually think if the did good guys vs ******** or even a rivals theme season with an "og" cast it cam be interesting clearly some of these girls have let their past beef go

Hoping some random girlies/guys watched this and got the itch to return

top 3 more random girls id want: Christena Pyle, Jill Z, and Irulan

top 3 more random guys: Adam L, David Burns, and Steven Hill

The ones I'm sure will be asked back: Kendall, Beth, Kelly Anne, Jemmye, Aneesa, Jisela (when healthy), Teck, LT, Mark, Darrell

I know it would never happen bc of the lawsuit, but id love to see Tonya on this just for her to show how much she has grown since we last saw her, i remember her saying in an interview 4 years or so ago (i think around dirty 30) that she was in a really good place and happier/healthier than ever and would love for everyone to see that

I do agree once you take out the nostalgia out this season was very underwhelming 

Am i the only one that thought the editing was kind of weird/janky?

I'll admit this show wasn't too entertaining but honestly I'll take it over the last 2 seasons of the regular show. I feel like part of it was the format as it doesn't really lead to alot of interesting happenings within the game. Also, I feel like part of it is these people are older now and they aren't gonna be too crazy and provide the crazyness that we see on the regular show. I mean even the drama we saw...it was tame and kind of mellow compared to the shit we see now.

Now with that being said I do hope they make some legit changes to season 2.

 

What exactly do any of you find interesting?

Personally I think some of you are just outgrowing the show.

What did Mark, Derrick, Yes, Syrus, Darrell and Nehemiah did that you found interesting?

Maybe I am out growing this show or maybe I just don't have the Nostagia goggles like you guys do since I haven't really watch old seasons but there were a lot of dull cast members with a predictable boring format.

Like you said, a lot of people love watching the OG people bc we watched the older seasons. But out of that whole group you mentioned, Darrell was easily giving the best confessionals and it wasn't close.

Which guys on the main show do you find interesting? Cory? Fessy? Mechie? I'm curious since in general the woman provide more of the "drama" if that's what you like. But not everyoen tunes in for that, a lot of people just like watching good entertaining competitors. 

I actually think if the did good guys vs ******** or even a rivals theme season with an "og" cast it cam be interesting clearly some of these girls have let their past beef go

they'd have to lie to a lot of contestants then bc im sure its an instant "no" if they find out its a rivals season 

I'll admit this show wasn't too entertaining but honestly I'll take it over the last 2 seasons of the regular show. I feel like part of it was the format as it doesn't really lead to alot of interesting happenings within the game. Also, I feel like part of it is these people are older now and they aren't gonna be too crazy and provide the crazyness that we see on the regular show. I mean even the drama we saw...it was tame and kind of mellow compared to the shit we see now.

Now with that being said I do hope they make some legit changes to season 2.

I actually think if the did good guys vs ******** or even a rivals theme season with an "og" cast it cam be interesting clearly some of these girls have let their past beef go

ive been thinking they should do that for season 2. At least with how many people they said are interested, there will be a wider pool of people they can cast. I dont think the individual format works because people just volunteer, at least with partners or a team, there is potential for more drama with the gameplay

The ones I'm sure will be asked back: Kendall, Beth, Kelly Anne, Jemmye, Aneesa, Jisela (when healthy), Teck, LT, Mark, Darrell

I have trouble seeing them asking KA back. They ghosted her all season. She by far has the least amount of confessionals of all the people remaining. She barely just passed Teck on last weeks episode.

 

The ones I'm sure will be asked back: Kendall, Beth, Kelly Anne, Jemmye, Aneesa, Jisela (when healthy), Teck, LT, Mark, Darrell

I have trouble seeing them asking KA back. They ghosted her all season. She by far has the least amount of confessionals of all the people remaining. She barely just passed Teck on last weeks episode.

ruthie and her are tied for least. they could've shown KA sticking up for Kendal and Kendal and her's friendship a lot more, it's not like she didn't have stuff for them to put in

I'd bring back Mark and Darrell and Jisela and Kendall. 

I think partly making the episodes longer would help, since they were so short a lot of it was taken up by the challenge / elimination. The cast has been spilling so much tea about arguments that weren't shown or discussions and things in the house that would have been entertaining to watch

I like having a few more 'boring' but likeable characters on, like Yes and Jonna. But I agree they need to be balanced by the people who bring the drama. Agree a Rivals or Good Guys vs Bad ***** would be amazing, especially with how the feuds these OGs have wasn't just for the call back or clout like the fake rivalries nowadays... I just wanna see Beth, Tina, Veronica, Julie and those people all together again, feel like it would be great drama

no like i said Nostlagia carried this if you don't have that like a few of us it was objectively a bad season. it was predictable and boring the format was absolutely horrible and then they made it worse by putting in the pair twist like what??? 

the first Champs vs whatever wasn't that interesting and got better as it got more seasons so hopefully the next one has more than "look here's old faces you once loved who are now old and we're going to give them the worst theme known to man" 

A lot of people think Sophia is boring for some reason. Don't you want balance? 

I wasn't entertained per say, but I was engaged and that's more than enough for me. I knew barely any of the cast coming into the season too. Obviously it depends what you're looking for in the show, and for me I enjoyed watching them so its all good.

I don't want any returning players for s2 so its fine with me if they don't ask any of them

I agree nostalgia helped a ton, but I still think it was more engaging than the regular season. Even the boring characters have a story arc and past relationships and dynamics that make it interesting, vs. new rookies that we see one season and never see again (Mechie, for example), or people with 0 personality (like Kaycee), or seeing the same people over and over and over again (like Josh, Nany) with the same storyline each time

100% agree though that the format needs work, and the pair twist was stupid though... hope they iron some of that out for future seasons

A lot of people think Sophia is boring for some reason. Don't you want balance? 

I think the alts for season 1 should be on season 2 (if scheduling works out). Who's Sophia close to?

Pages

Topic locked