The Challenge: All Stars (Season 1)- Spoilers Discussion

Do you think she would be interested? Don't get me wrong, I welcome debuts. I'll gladly give a list. Let's start with Mary Beth.

I do, but unfortunately she won't get a call. She'll forever be a huge missed opportunity.

Didn't she drop last minute and decline multiple times before that?

All I recall is that she had to decline Gauntlet 2 because she was in a friends wedding and then she wasn't called again.

I thought she originally accepted G2 then had to drop due to the wedding.  I also thought she declined calls for The Gauntlet (maybe The Inferno but I think The Gauntlet) and Sexes 2 but it's been a long time so I could be wrong but I'm pretty sure that's right.

I thought it was just the Gauntlet 2 because I remember being enraged that was the only opportunity they gave her. I think you are right that she dropped out. She was just so strategic and crafty in the mission where they pranked Vegas and when they came back to compete against South Pacific. I think should have offered a lot gamewise.

if teck could get cast, then i hope this beauty gets casted next

RW9-Melissa-1422651492.jpg

along with irulan, i could've sworn she was gonna be on this season at some point but she disappeared

along with irulan, i could've sworn she was gonna be on this season at some point but she disappeared

Irulan is at the top of my wishlists. Not only is she one of the prettiest girls ever on the show but she was such a cool and amazing personality. It's also a shame we only got one season of her. I remember PR saying she is a possibility for season 2. I hope it happens!!!  

Melissa would be great too, so many one hit wonders and greats who never even debuted. I hated her originally on Sexes, but rewatching she became one of my favorites. She is hilarious. I wish we got her and Coral on a season together. Prayers this will be the one lol. 

I believe Melissa has been said to not be interested.

I thought it was just the Gauntlet 2 because I remember being enraged that was the only opportunity they gave her. I think you are right that she dropped out. She was just so strategic and crafty in the mission where they pranked Vegas and when they came back to compete against South Pacific. I think should have offered a lot gamewise.

I always wanted to see her as well. I wish Vevmo kept old messages lol. I'm almost certain she declined multiple times. 

I believe Melissa has been said to not be interested.

That isn't surprising but disappointing. 

I remember on the Sexes 1 reunion, Melissa said that she hated doing the missions. Now that they are more extreme, I can def see her saying hell no. Lol

I remember on the Sexes 1 reunion, Melissa said that she hated doing the missions. Now that they are more extreme, I can def see her saying hell no. Lol

New Orleans would be an amazing Homecoming season. Hopefully we get her on that, seems more her speed lol.

I remember on the Sexes 1 reunion, Melissa said that she hated doing the missions. Now that they are more extreme, I can def see her saying hell no. Lol

New Orleans would be an amazing Homecoming season. Hopefully we get her on that, seems more her speed lol.

NOLA would be perfect for that--would Kelley do it though?

 

I remember on the Sexes 1 reunion, Melissa said that she hated doing the missions. Now that they are more extreme, I can def see her saying hell no. Lol

New Orleans would be an amazing Homecoming season. Hopefully we get her on that, seems more her speed lol.

NOLA would be perfect for that--would Kelley do it though?

As Pink said before, everyone has a price.

I can't wait for whenever the All Stars 2 pre season cast thread starts to happen ( whenever it does )

good luck finding guys to do confessionals if there's no darrell in season 2 

 

I remember on the Sexes 1 reunion, Melissa said that she hated doing the missions. Now that they are more extreme, I can def see her saying hell no. Lol

New Orleans would be an amazing Homecoming season. Hopefully we get her on that, seems more her speed lol.

NOLA would be perfect for that--would Kelley do it though?

I don't see why not. I don't think she's above it. It is a positive show so it wouldn't hurt her image. She has a podcast or something so I think it would be great promotion. I think everyone would love her too. It's such short filming too. 

I can't wait for whenever the All Stars 2 pre season cast thread starts to happen ( whenever it does )

SAME!!!!!

 

I can't wait for whenever the All Stars 2 pre season cast thread starts to happen ( whenever it does )

SAME!!!!!

in guessing it will start sometime in July ( depending if producers are leaning towards filming in August )

PR said a month, so not sure if that is filming in a month or speculation/final calls start next month. 

PR said a month, so not sure if that is filming in a month or speculation/final calls start next month. 

i think the list of people who are likely, in the air, and unlikely will be posted some time next month and may go into filming in August. Hopefully we see good names that we haven't seen on All Stars 1

PR said a month, so not sure if that is filming in a month or speculation/final calls start next month. 

\

Is TJ going to host it? Because if so? damn man. Season 37 is still filming. That is a quick turnaround. Maybe bring back Johnny Mosely for Season 2 and give it a true OG feel! lol.

 

PR said a month, so not sure if that is filming in a month or speculation/final calls start next month. 

\

Is TJ going to host it? Because if so? damn man. Season 37 is still filming. That is a quick turnaround. Maybe bring back Johnny Mosely for Season 2 and give it a true OG feel! lol.

Having Johnny over TJ would be AMAZING. Even though I'd rather hage them on the cast I think Miz or Blair would be great host. I recall PR saying Blair was considered for it last season. Devyn would be another amazing option as would either host from the reunion. However, I do think the casuals love TJ and having him ties it into the regular show so from their perspective I see him returning. That is a lot of filming for him though.

TJ basically gets a paid vacation and has to work 4 days a week for a few hours.  Not a bad gig.  I'd like to see Jonny or Blair host as well buy TJ is essentially a face of the show  at this point. 

Gamer said on Twitter that it seems like they are going into the JEK era for the cast. Ugh 

Gamer said on Twitter that it seems like they are going into the JEK era for the cast. Ugh 

To be fair that already happened and they went past it with Jemmye. I don't even  consider Jonna in that era. 

It could be okay depending on who it is. I'd take any of the Hollywood women or Jenn Paula etc. The guys from that era are pretty useless but there's good female options

We knew when they said over 100 people it had to be newer people as well. Expecting people that debuted from Cutthroat through Seasons 2012...maybe as late as Free Agents

Gamer said on Twitter that it seems like they are going into the JEK era for the cast. Ugh 

I knew it would happen. I was REALLY hoping we could squeeze one more season of mainly true OGs before they went that route. I'll stay optimistic though. Hopefully it's just a couple like how we had Jimmy, Jonna, and Kellyanne.