Best and Worst Rookie Classes

95 posts / 0 new
Last post

I forgot  Cutthroat's rookie class that season.

i always considered Cory about of the Invasion rookie class for some reason 

His relationships are far more tethered to that specific class cause I feel the same.

Nelson, Ashley, Amanda, Latoya and Marie all debuted before Invasion and yet don't entirely resonate with the classes before. (Outside of maybe Latoya but FA barely had a freshmen class, and Marie is so far removed from the other BOTS2 debuts).

And although they amounted to nothing, the BOTS2 rookies could've been something. Drama magents who could hold their own in challenges.

I wish they stuck with the idea of Old School v. New School instead of Rivals 2 because we could've had a far more interesting season competitively and drama wise.

Bloodlines - worst with Rivals 3 and Vendettas trailing behind

Exes 1 rookies were bad too. Besides Dustin, we got Naomi, Heather, Priscila and Nate,

Exes 1 rookies were bad too. Besides Dustin, we got Naomi, Heather, Priscila and Nate,

Heather could've been a good addition if she did more than one challenge, she was small but a good character and I feel like she'd hold her own. And personally I would've liked seeing Priscilla again. Nate and Naomi were bad though.

 

Battle of the Seasons 2 was a good Rookie class. 

ehhh...

Atleast they brought the drama lol. The gameplay was messy. So i can see why people are eh on them.

 

i always considered Cory about of the Invasion rookie class for some reason 

His relationships are far more tethered to that specific class cause I feel the same.

Nelson, Ashley, Amanda, Latoya and Marie all debuted before Invasion and yet don't entirely resonate with the classes before. (Outside of maybe Latoya but FA barely had a freshmen class, and Marie is so far removed from the other BOTS2 debuts).

that's why i tend to go by eras after those people establish themselves, i thought WOTW was gonna establish its self but they're kinda non existent now. we'll see if Double Agents establishes a new era but i doubt it tbh. 

Invasion era will probably be the last true class. they move on from people really quick now 

The inferno 3, it had Rachel, collie, davis, Tyriee.  Janelle and jenn save it but a lot of people hate jenn 

The worst has to be bloodlines imo. Wotw2 had a bad group but the bloodlines added so little to the show. 

yea. Bloodline has to be the worst; they added so little to the show and even the season they debuted. 

I think Nicole Briana Cory Raphy Tony & Shane all delivered something during that season. I would actually consider bloodlines to be an okay season. It's far from the best but I wouldn't mind rewatching it

I think Nicole Briana Cory Raphy Tony & Shane all delivered something during that season. I would actually consider bloodlines to be an okay season. It's far from the best but I wouldn't mind rewatching it

youre right. Oversight on my end cause I forgot there were people outside of being 'blood lines' that debuted in that season too

best - FM1 or WotW1

worst - Dirty 30 or WotW2

Rivals 3 was lowkey great - Ashley, Amanda, Nelson, and (hate him but he's a big character) Devin. a handful of duds but it had high highs.

same with Rivals 2 - Jordan, Marlon, and Cooke. if only the last two did a couple seasons after, it would look better in retrospect. they should've been the regulars, not Jess.

Both Fresh Meats stick out to me at least in terms of impact of the show. Many insufferable people like KVM mentioned (Evan, Kenny, Cara, Big Easy) but a huge amount of both of their casts returned and were centers of the show for a good while.

Both Fresh Meats stick out to me, at least in terms of the impact of the show. Many insufferable people like KVM mentioned (Evan, Kenny, Cara, Big Easy), but a huge amount of both of their casts returned and were centers of the show for a good while.

For me, the pre-Fresh Meat challenge sticks out to me regarding the impact of the challenge.  Are Battle of Seasons(2002). Battle of the Sexes, Battle of the  Sexes II, The Gauntlet, The Inferno,  The Gauntlet  II, and The Inferno II.  

Exes 1 rookies were bad too. Besides Dustin, we got Naomi, Heather, Priscila and Nate,

I'll give you Naomi and Nate. Heather only got to do one challenge but was a varsity track runner and black belt in karate. I think she would have been fine if she and Dustin lasted longer. To be fair to prisicila, the one challenge she competed in, she didn't even truly get to compete Bc Nate kept messing up.

i always considered Cory about of the Invasion rookie class for some reason 

How does that make any sense whatsoever? Invasion was Cory's 3rd or 4th challenge.

 

i always considered Cory about of the Invasion rookie class for some reason 

How does that make any sense whatsoever? Invasion was Cory's 3rd or 4th challenge.

Many people consider Invasion a turning point season for the eras and Cory has more relationships with people of that era/season like Nelson, Hunter, Kailah, Lavender Ladies, Tony, etc

 

i always considered Cory about of the Invasion rookie class for some reason 

How does that make any sense whatsoever? Invasion was Cory's 3rd or 4th challenge.

They are talking eras not debut season

Best rookie class: WOTW 1 is the first that comes to mind on the male side. 

Theo and Bear shook up the challenge house. 

Maybe not the best but Vendettas as this brought over Paulie and Natalie. And Joss from a pure athletic aspect.  

Best rookie class: WOTW 1 is the first that comes to mind on the male side. 

Theo and Bear shook up the challenge house. 

Maybe not the best but Vendettas as this brought over Paulie and Natalie. And Joss from a pure athletic aspect.  

Paulie debuted on Final Reckoning...

 

Best rookie class: WOTW 1 is the first that comes to mind on the male side. 

Theo and Bear shook up the challenge house. 

Maybe not the best but Vendettas as this brought over Paulie and Natalie. And Joss from a pure athletic aspect.  

Paulie debuted on Final Reckoning...

I meant to put Kyle my bad. 

Rivals 2 had a good rookie class. Marlon, Jordan, and Cooke. 

Anastasia at least brought drama. Jessica was the only bad one. 

i'm not explaining something that is self explanatory lmaoo 

Cutthroat had the most unforgettable rookie class. Derek, Emilee, Aiiyya, Mandi, lmbo who else

Even though they all are pretty much never coming back now lmao WOTW1 had some good ones at the time: Turbo, Theo, Bear, Georgia, Cain.......Dee

But also some flops: Nolan twins, Morgan, Zahida

Then there's Ninja and Mattie lol

Crazy to think how much controversy there is surrounding this group lmao

 

WOTW 1 was lackluster on the female side for sure. But the male side was dominant. 

Cutthroat had the most unforgettable rookie class. Derek, Emilee, Aiiyya, Mandi, lmbo who else

Mandi was Fresh Meat 2 debut.  Camila, Emily S & Ty all brought something

The inferno 3, it had Rachel, collie, davis, Tyriee.  Janelle and jenn save it but a lot of people hate jenn 

To this day it still ****** me off that Rachel is a champion and Jenn isn't. I don't know how she went the entire Gauntlet 3 without even seeing an elimination. 

 

Cutthroat had the most unforgettable rookie class. Derek, Emilee, Aiiyya, Mandi, lmbo who else

Mandi was Fresh Meat 2 debut.  Camila, Emily S & Ty all brought something

Mhmmm, they brought racism too, and now one is banned and the other probably won't be back because of the 1st incident with the former....Mess

 

Cutthroat had the most unforgettable rookie class. Derek, Emilee, Aiiyya, Mandi, lmbo who else

Mandi was Fresh Meat 2 debut.  Camila, Emily S & Ty all brought something

Damn it I forgot about Mandi. Unpopular opinion but I count Camilla's debut as The Terrible Springbreak Challenge they had. Emily was a good competitor I'll give you that. Ty was the best out of those 3 overall in drama/athleticsm. 

Pages