Survivor: Generic Thread (No Spoilers)

7191 posts / 0 new
Last post

Is the season Kristie won pretty good?

Yes. The premerge is better but her final tribal preformance was amazing.

 

Has anyone watched the Australian seasons? I'm starting them, starting with Sarah Tilleke's season obviously. Is the one before it any good or should I skip it? Are all worth watching or any I should skip?

all stars and blood vs water are the two seasons i'd say can be skipped. the rest were either good or great.

what's funny is after Kristie's season the only one I watched was half of Allstars and Blood vs Water lol. The other themes sound dumb and under editing of so many people is horrendous. Though their tribals are waaay more suspenseful than USA

I do agree that the fact that the editing is sucks and I hate how they ignore people for several. Even late in the game. I need to google a confessional count chart for these shows, it's gotta be wild how unbalanced it is.

I do agree that the fact that the editing is sucks and I hate how they ignore people for several. Even late in the game. I need to google a confessional count chart for these shows, it's gotta be wild how unbalanced it is.

100% All-Stars confessional count is terrible. Basically like Samoa

Is the season Kristie won pretty good?

I'd say they were still finding their footing, especially casting wise. Too many people weren't willing to lie or betray allies to advance their game, which i remember being pretty frustrating and boring as a viewer

I do agree that the fact that the editing is sucks and I hate how they ignore people for several. Even late in the game. I need to google a confessional count chart for these shows, it's gotta be wild how unbalanced it is.

would u be surprised rachel from survivor 47 has the most confessionals of the women of all time

 

Is the season Kristie won pretty good?

I'd say they were still finding their footing, especially casting wise. Too many people weren't willing to lie or betray allies to advance their game, which i remember being pretty frustrating and boring as a viewer

I need to rewatch the season. It was a good reboot for the series imo. 

 

I do agree that the fact that the editing is sucks and I hate how they ignore people for several. Even late in the game. I need to google a confessional count chart for these shows, it's gotta be wild how unbalanced it is.

would u be surprised rachel from survivor 47 has the most confessionals of the women of all time

Yes and no. This season had more episodes than any other season and the 90 minute epsiodes didn't start till 45 so her confessionals really can't be compared before that. Surprised Dee or Kenzi didn't have more though, they had more dynamic personalities.

Who are some of yalls favorite Aussie players? From the Sarah Tilleke season obviously I love Sarah. Michelle was amazing. I loved Jericho and Luke too.

I hope survivor 50 is an eras theme. They can afford to borrow from the challenge, the challenge borrowed the blood vs water theme concept for its 27th season.

I hope survivor 50 is an eras theme. They can afford to borrow from the challenge, the challenge borrowed the blood vs water theme concept for its 27th season.

Jeff did say it's a celebration of all seasons or something. How would you break up the eras for Survivor?

Who are some of yalls favorite Aussie players? From the Sarah Tilleke season obviously I love Sarah. Michelle was amazing. I loved Jericho and Luke too.

Shonee is character gold. I love Simon dispite his messy gameplay. Nina is a Queen. So many good players from that show is makes US Survivor look like some youtube survivor game.

 

I hope survivor 50 is an eras theme. They can afford to borrow from the challenge, the challenge borrowed the blood vs water theme concept for its 27th season.

Jeff did say it's a celebration of all seasons or something. How would you break up the eras for Survivor?

they COULD do like the challenge did, just including 41-49 and have 5 tribes of 6.  

but I also considered classic survivor 1-15, fans vs favorites era 16-26, theme era 27-39, and new era 41-49.... maybe 4 tribes of 6 again?

Jeff needs to go all out and copy Australian Survivor format of 24 people and 50 days since it's the 50th season.

But knowing Jeff he'll ruin it somehow and make it worse then the new era.

 

Who are some of yalls favorite Aussie players? From the Sarah Tilleke season obviously I love Sarah. Michelle was amazing. I loved Jericho and Luke too.

Shonee is character gold. I love Simon dispite his messy gameplay. Nina is a Queen. So many good players from that show is makes US Survivor look like some youtube survivor game.

Casting and gameplay is so much better! Love watching Survivor with attractive people again and not just tons of nerds and without Probst's corny kumbaya. The editing is soooo bad though.

I'm excited for Shonee, I've heard so much about her but haven't seen a second of her play. Watching the 2016 season and then I'll do her first one next.

but I also considered classic survivor 1-15, fans vs favorites era 16-26, theme era 27-39, and new era 41-49.... maybe 4 tribes of 6 again?

That is actually a really good split! I hope they do a cast of 24. Play like the original season with 39 days. Have a couple double eliminations PRE-MERGE and then a couple extra episodes.

Based on your eras here is how I would cast:

Era 1

  1. Greg 1
  2. Sean 4
  3. Shane 12
  4. Teresa 3
  5. Ghandia 5
  6. Heidi 6

Era 2

  1. Albert 23
  2. Pete 25
  3. Eddie 26
  4. Crystal 17
  5. Sierra 18
  6. Naonka 21

Era 3

  1. Brice 28
  2. Davie 37
  3. Dean 39
  4. So 30
  5. Cydney 32
  6. Angelina 32

Era 4

  1. Jesse 43
  2. Kaleb 45
  3. Q 46
  4. Drea 42
  5. Venus 46
  6. Genevieve 47

So could probably be replaced but I felt there needed to be some kind of Asian female representation and she was the only spot I could think to fill. Replace her with Nadia maybe. Or if 48/49 have someone good then replace Drea with them. I did it based on Probst calling it 2nd chances, so I did no returnees or winners.

No Abi Maria OS?

No Abi Maria OS?

I only picked one-time players.

I'd be rooting for my girl Na'Onka though!!!

There's no world where they go over 20 players for 50. Might even end up being 18 since it's a 26 day season 

There's no world where they go over 20 players for 50. Might even end up being 18 since it's a 26 day season 

Hopefully they'll bump it to at least 30 days...

There's no world where they go over 20 players for 50. Might even end up being 18 since it's a 26 day season 

so old school (1-39) vs new school (41-49)

Naonka is the greatest personality from all 47 seasons of this show. 

Y'all think survivor will go on to 100 seasons? Or until probst is dead? Would the show be as successful if they replace him?

Y'all think survivor will go on to 100 seasons? Or until probst is dead? Would the show be as successful if they replace him?

Probst is 63 years old and a raging narcissist. He'll either go until he's dead or attempt to kill it when we wants to retire, in 5-7 years from now.

The first player from 49 has been revealed. https://x.com/iamcamillap/status/1873763673161801747?s=46

The first player from 49 has been revealed. https://x.com/iamcamillap/status/1873763673161801747?s=46

first boot!!!

Y'all think survivor will go on to 100 seasons? Or until probst is dead? Would the show be as successful if they replace him?

The show is over once he retires. He's in good shape for 60's but probably in 10 years so about season 70 which is a good number to end on.

Pages