The Challenge: Unpopular Opinions

9849 posts / 0 new
Last post

Mount Rushmore as to be old old school. IMO that's the only way it works.

My list:

1. Coral

2. Veronica

3. Emily Bailey

4. Ellen Cho

Yes I know some of you don't know those last two but Cara , Ev etc are too new . These women imo are influential on what the Challenge shaped up to be . They help define strategy and entertainment. 

 

 Like imo Nany had a greater impact on the Challenge than Ashley.

We just making shit up today, huh? That lil girl has never made an impact other than like Seasons.

noodles n teeth? 

Evelyn is not too new lmaooo she debuted Season 11. She should be considered as ancient as Coral tbh

 Like imo Nany had a greater impact on the Challenge than Ashley.

We just making shit up today, huh? That lil girl has never made an impact other than like Seasons.

Nany has given us countless arguments on this show. How y'all stan Amanda and Nurys but not Nany? Y'all just a hater. She's one of the top 5 female faces of the franchise if we're being honest. 

Evelyn is not too new lmaooo she debuted Season 11. She should be considered as ancient as Coral tbh

season 12

If you have been a female face of the show you made a major impact and are high on that list and that is Nany sorry to break it to yall 

 

 

 

Coral, Nia, Cara, Beth. 

I was gonna say something snarky but this list is solid so nvm

Say it !!!

you're lucky nia served back then or else she wouldn't even be a contender. She's a flop and kinda boring now

It's my personal opinion. I know she wouldn't be considered by most, but in my eyes Nia saved the real world, and by default saved the challenge. She brought me to this show and I will forever show my gratitude to the queen. 

Beth definitely needs to be on any challenge Mount Rushmore, idgaf what anybody says.

Beth definitely needs to be on any challenge Mount Rushmore, idgaf what anybody says.

I'm surprised more people don't ! I def put her in mine. 

I love Noemi! I don't understand the hate she gets. She was my fav on BOTS2012

Evelyn is not too new lmaooo she debuted Season 11. She should be considered as ancient as Coral tbh

So a whole 10 (11 actually) seasons past before her?

FM is the start of era 2 that's not the same tier as era 1.

And honestly if I was including the overall challenge Id be 

Coral, V , Scatty Maria and the fourth is a toss up. But honestly Ev doesn't feel right. Idk but she's missing something 

Cory needs to ditch Tori and align with girls that would actually place him at #1. He's too satisfied with being a #3 or #4 Sad

Impact:

Cara, Coral, Veronica

Best in terms of competition:

Cara, Evelyn, Laurel 

I can't pick a 4th for either because it's too many factors. Like imo Nany had a greater impact on the Challenge than Ashley.

Cara isn't close to a lot of women in terms of being a competitor.  Start with Emily S and Jenny.

No clue how Cara is in the same breath as Coral or Veronica in terms of impact.  Laurel had a bigger impact.  Tori had a bigger impact. 

 

Impact:

Cara, Coral, Veronica

Best in terms of competition:

Cara, Evelyn, Laurel 

I can't pick a 4th for either because it's too many factors. Like imo Nany had a greater impact on the Challenge than Ashley.

Cara isn't close to a lot of women in terms of being a competitor.  Start with Emily S and Jenny.

No clue how Cara is in the same breath as Coral or Veronica in terms of impact.  Laurel had a bigger impact.  Tori had a bigger impact. 

Now I don't love Cara but you can't deny the impact she's had on this show. To me one of the biggest names of all time and in terms of fans/stans likely number 1. No one has a fan base like her and that's impact. 

Cara is one of the most recognizable faces/mugs associated with the challenge for casual viewers, especially with that kool-aid pirate hair of hers. She's one of the few true faces of the show. Coral was as well, 20 years ago (way more than Veronica). If Tori stopped doing challenges she would easily be forgotten just like Paula has been. Same CANNOT be said for Cara, or even Coral. If you can't forget about their impact despite their absence from the series, that is what qualifies them to be on a Mount Rushmore. Argue with your momma about it.

 

Impact:

Cara, Coral, Veronica

Best in terms of competition:

Cara, Evelyn, Laurel 

I can't pick a 4th for either because it's too many factors. Like imo Nany had a greater impact on the Challenge than Ashley.

Cara isn't close to a lot of women in terms of being a competitor.  Start with Emily S and Jenny.

No clue how Cara is in the same breath as Coral or Veronica in terms of impact.  Laurel had a bigger impact.  Tori had a bigger impact. 

Laurel was never the face of the show. Cara is/was. Tori took up that space for little bit, but not to the level of Cara. You don't have to like Cara to admit that. I love Jenny, but she is era 4. I can't put anyone from era 4 guy or girl in the Mt. Rushmore conversation . Maybe in a few years.

You know good and damn well Laurel ain't have more of an impact on the challenge than Cara Maria lmao. 

yall would be delusional to say even if you hate her that cara shouldn't be on the mount rushmore. Wasn't she used on a main poster with only her and bananas on it lol. She is one of faces of the show even after the hiatus.

Coral, Veronica, Laurel, and Ashley. Point Blank Period Smile

For the MEN: Darrell, Shane, Jordan, and Cory

For the MEN: Darrell, Shane, Jordan, and Cory

I mean you kinda snuck Shane in there.... he was in the background until his return 

 

For the MEN: Darrell, Shane, Jordan, and Cory

I mean you kinda snuck Shane in there.... he was in the background until his return 

um he's one of the few gay challengers that can compete and he's from era 1. He MUST be on there.

 

 

For the MEN: Darrell, Shane, Jordan, and Cory

I mean you kinda snuck Shane in there.... he was in the background until his return 

um he's one of the few gay challengers that can compete and he's from era 1. He MUST be on there.

Not how that works, Shane was very irrelevant to the plot back then. I only remember something about him being saved with the Ion Lifesaver in Sexes iirc, which only let him survive an extra round or two because they voted based off scoreboard. And Steven slaping him during Sexes 2 during the final 7/6? daily. He had a cute run with Linette during Fresh Meat emerging as mid-game contenders after Coral's removal tho.

Girl idgaf I picked Shane bc I didn't wanna put ObesCT's *** up there Smile

Killakashhh is so spicy!

Coral, Veronica, Laurel, Tori

Darrell, Landon, CT, (Bananas even tho I loathe him)

Impact:

Cara, Coral, Veronica

Best in terms of competition:

Cara, Evelyn, Laurel 

I can't pick a 4th for either because it's too many factors. Like imo Nany had a greater impact on the Challenge than Ashley.

Cara isn't close to a lot of women in terms of being a competitor.  Start with Emily S and Jenny.

No clue how Cara is in the same breath as Coral or Veronica in terms of impact.  Laurel had a bigger impact.  Tori had a bigger impact. 

Now I don't love Cara but you can't deny the impact she's had on this show. To me one of the biggest names of all time and in terms of fans/stans likely number 1. No one has a fan base like her and that's impact. 

What impact?   She needed John and Laurel to even be relevant.

Impact:

Cara, Coral, Veronica

Best in terms of competition:

Cara, Evelyn, Laurel 

I can't pick a 4th for either because it's too many factors. Like imo Nany had a greater impact on the Challenge than Ashley.

Cara isn't close to a lot of women in terms of being a competitor.  Start with Emily S and Jenny.

No clue how Cara is in the same breath as Coral or Veronica in terms of impact.  Laurel had a bigger impact.  Tori had a bigger impact. 

Laurel was never the face of the show. Cara is/was. Tori took up that space for little bit, but not to the level of Cara. You don't have to like Cara to admit that. I love Jenny, but she is era 4. I can't put anyone from era 4 guy or girl in the Mt. Rushmore conversation . Maybe in a few years.

Cara was never the "face of the show"--Tori was/is

I don't dislike Cara--I think she's overrated as a competitor.   Jenny shouldn't be on "A Mount Rushmore" but nor should Cara.

Coral, Veronica, Laurel, Tori

Darrell, Landon, CT, (Bananas even tho I loathe him)

This is the most reasonable one--unfortunately I'd bump my favorite (Landon) for Jordan (who i actually do hate unlike Cara)

Cara is sooo overrated imo Wink

Pages