The Challenge: Unpopular Opinions

9995 posts / 0 new
Last post

Rivals 3 Simone should be in contention for one of the finest women to hit The Challenge. 

Yup! She doesn't get talked about enough.

If I actually made a list of who I thought was attractive that would be unpopular even though it shouldn't.

I'm not shocked Tony (and ********) got calls after Rivals III.

But, Tony's number should've been lost after D30. I'm all for growth but if certain people had four terrible seasons in a row, very few people would be open to their competitive growth.

Like Flyguy was saying about Faysal being one of the best daily performers of the current gen, despite that, he still was getting heat for not eating in one final he was already losing, and his final losses were used to diminish his competitive ability more than most. If he started off like Tony, they'd really hate him.

Katie Doyle is a toxic alcoholic and isn't as entertaining as some of you might remember 

Agreed with all that !! @GR

Had Candice & Leroy not gotten DQ'd, they atleast make top 5

 

Candice was on the red team that won all the challenges, so that would exempt her from the female days, and I doubt Leroy goes in on the blue team for the male days, and if he does, I believe he wins against those guys. 

Had Candice & Leroy not gotten DQ'd, they atleast make top 5

 

Candice was on the red team that won all the challenges, so that would exempt her from the female days, and I doubt Leroy goes in on the blue team for the male days, and if he does, I believe he wins against those guys. 

John and Vince probably win the season too. Abe/Mike wouldn't come in to help cara/Jamie.  Probably a vince/Bananas, leroy/Candice, nany/Nicole, anthony/Kelly Anne then one of the explosion cory or jenna teams in the top 5.

Katie Doyle is a toxic alcoholic and isn't as entertaining as some of you might remember 

Katie is horribly mid outside of Inferno 1.

Had Candice & Leroy not gotten DQ'd, they atleast make top 5

 

Candice was on the red team that won all the challenges, so that would exempt her from the female days, and I doubt Leroy goes in on the blue team for the male days, and if he does, I believe he wins against those guys. 

I was one of the original Candice stans, loved her.

Katie is horribly mid outside of Inferno 1.

She was also a Derrick Kosinski enabler. 

Belou is the best challenger of all time~*

Idk if this is unpopular , Tony should've been banned after rivals 3. Two seasons in a row of showing violent behavior is crazy.  

Camila as well, rivals 3 should've been both of their farewells. 

the fact that she was able to continue after her slurs on Dirty 30 was arguably a disappointing set back for the whole franchise 

 

Idk if this is unpopular , Tony should've been banned after rivals 3. Two seasons in a row of showing violent behavior is crazy.  

Camila as well, rivals 3 should've been both of their farewells. 

the fact that she was able to continue after her slurs on Dirty 30 was arguably a disappointing set back for the whole franchise 

 

Idk if this is unpopular , Tony should've been banned after rivals 3. Two seasons in a row of showing violent behavior is crazy.  

Camila as well, rivals 3 should've been both of their farewells. 

the fact that she was able to continue after her slurs on Dirty 30 was arguably a disappointing set back for the whole franchise 

Its sad they waited so long to ban her. She was a liability almost every challenge. Them they waited for her to assault a production person on champs vs stars before finally banning her.

Katie is horribly mid outside of Inferno 1.

I dont think anyone would argue this. Lol. Tbh I wouldnt even consider her mid. Katie is weak athletically but a decent puzzle person.

 

Katie is horribly mid outside of Inferno 1.

I dont think anyone would argue this. Lol. Tbh I wouldnt even consider her mid. Katie is weak athletically but a decent puzzle person.

She wasn't really entertaining after Inferno 1 is what I meant. Her Sexes 2 run was cute tho.

 

 

Katie is horribly mid outside of Inferno 1.

I dont think anyone would argue this. Lol. Tbh I wouldnt even consider her mid. Katie is weak athletically but a decent puzzle person.

She wasn't really entertaining after Inferno 1 is what I meant. Her Sexes 2 run was cute tho.

I 100% remember feeling meh about her always appearing on the gauntlet 3, ruins, cut throat casts. I can't remember who anymore, but i'd almost always wish someone else was on over her spot. 

 

 

Katie is horribly mid outside of Inferno 1.

I dont think anyone would argue this. Lol. Tbh I wouldnt even consider her mid. Katie is weak athletically but a decent puzzle person.

She wasn't really entertaining after Inferno 1 is what I meant. Her Sexes 2 run was cute tho.

I thought she was entertaining gauntlet 3, ruins, and cutthroat. And i liked her on Allstars 1 and 2. 

Rivals 3 is the last season with fun dailies.

Also, not unpopular, but Leroy and Averey were winning that season if they stayed. Leroy is great on his feet and that was a no-swimming final.

I actually think the competition could've been stiffer but too many teams were still too early in their careers (Ashley/Cory) or were in terrible shape (Nany/Wes).

Katie was fine.  She wasn't a good competitor but she wanted to make it as far as she could.  She had some drama on most seasons.  And because she wasn't going to win every season inviting her back over and over again was fine.

Katie was fine.  She wasn't a good competitor but she wanted to make it as far as she could.  She had some drama on most seasons.  And because she wasn't going to win every season inviting her back over and over again was fine.

They dropped Angel for Katie on cut throat, so you are wrong. Angel mouth'ed off tina and she would have done the same to Tori Hall and paula

Angel should have had Camila's spot not Katie's. The Challenge would be in a much better state if Camila never stole a spot.

What about Ivory?  I think she supposedly wanted to have sex with Kina according to the Viewers' Revenge intro special and that was enough to creep Kina out more than anything I can recall about Angel wanting the same.

Johnny is Lowkey a better competitor than Ct 

In a final: Johnny>>>>>> Ct 

Which RW Theo from the OG days would have done better had they competed more?  Real World New Orleans Theo or Real World Chicago Theo?

Which RW Theo from the OG days would have done better had they competed more?  Real World New Orleans Theo or Real World Chicago Theo?

there wasn't a Theo on real world New Orleans.

 

Which RW Theo from the OG days would have done better had they competed more?  Real World New Orleans Theo or Real World Chicago Theo?

there wasn't a Theo on real world New Orleans.

I got confused with David "Tokyo" from RWNO1...  Thanks for clearing that up.  How about whether Chicago Theo or Road Rules Theo Von from the OG days?

 

 

Which RW Theo from the OG days would have done better had they competed more?  Real World New Orleans Theo or Real World Chicago Theo?

there wasn't a Theo on real world New Orleans.

I got confused with David "Tokyo" from RWNO1...  Thanks for clearing that up.  How about whether Chicago Theo or Road Rules Theo Von from the OG days?

theo von probably wins at least another team season up to cutthroat.

i think rw Chicago Theo could make a final on one of the team challenges, but I don't think he'd win. His best shot was the gauntlet 1, but he got screwed in the last elimination...they should've sent in coral.

 

 

Which RW Theo from the OG days would have done better had they competed more?  Real World New Orleans Theo or Real World Chicago Theo?

there wasn't a Theo on real world New Orleans.

I got confused with David "Tokyo" from RWNO1...  Thanks for clearing that up.  How about whether Chicago Theo or Road Rules Theo Von from the OG days?

I could see Theo Von winning another one. Hes still in good shape. Doubt we will ever see him again tho.

Pages