The Challenge: Generic Thread

[QUOTE=auldx;426445]I want Emily to come back! And Cooke, Cara, Sarah & Laurel for Duel III. And then whomever else. That would be a great female cast[/QUOTE] Imagine this cast for a duel: Laurel Emily Cooke Evelyn Rachel Theresa Cara Maria Camila Ruthie Arielle Kina Jodi Ashlee KellyAnne Baya It would be super epic, but sadly is never happening.

[QUOTE=kollanekoer;426447]Sarah swims faster and is probably way better at puzzles too. It depends i guess. I think Sarah vs Theresa would be interesting fight.[/QUOTE] They just have different set of skills. Sarah is a better swimmer, "good" at puzzles and has stamina, and Theresa is more athletic, quicker and I think she also has endurance. In an elimination I think Theresa has a better chance and in a final Sarah has a better chance.

Who would win in Balls In? Theresa vs. Laurel Cooke vs. Emily Nany vs. Marie Nia vs. KellyAnne Sarah vs. Cara Maria Jonna vs. Jemmye Kimberly vs. Jessica Rachel vs. Evelyn

[QUOTE=nevidcm;426450]Who would win in Balls In? Theresa vs. Laurel Cooke vs. Emily Nany vs. Marie Nia vs. KellyAnne Sarah vs. Cara Maria Jonna vs. Jemmye Kimberly vs. Jessica Rachel vs. Evelyn[/QUOTE] Laurel Emily Marie KellyAnne Sarah considering she's bigger and cara struggled against Jessica Sadly Jemmye Sadly Jessica Evelyn

More balls in match ups Bananas vs Dustin Jordan vs Leroy Darrell vs CT Zach vs Tyler Frank vs CJ Laurel vs Emily Aneesa vs Cooke Theresa vs Cara Maria Nany vs KellyAnne Camila vs Marie

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;426462]Laurel Emily Marie KellyAnne Sarah considering she's bigger and cara struggled against Jessica Sadly Jemmye Sadly Jessica Evelyn[/QUOTE] I think the Laurel vs. Theresa can be a great matchup. Obviously Laurel is bigger and stronger than Theresa, but Theresa has a basketball background and it can really benefit her in this elimination.

delete

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;426462]Laurel Emily Marie KellyAnne [B]Sarah considering she's bigger and cara struggled against Jessica [/B] Sadly Jemmye Sadly Jessica Evelyn[/QUOTE] I am not so sure about that. Jess had 20lbs on Cara(according to twitter each had their weight listed publically), Cara had 0 strategy she even admitted she had no strategy and just ran straight at her not trying to juke at all, and still Jess scored 0 pts. Jess does crossfit too and had the weight advantage, so I don't give her as much credit for her fight as others do. The credit I give her is that she actually is trying to get better, and not the girl that thinks she is hot and is happy to be there and doesn't want to get her nails dirty. So I am glad if she is going to keep getting asked, at least she is trying to improve herself. I can't count a sweep as a great elimination round, I just can't. that's like saying when the cavs got swept by the spurs in 2004 or whatever that was an epic series. May have had some cool moments, but it was a sweep. It can only be considered average to me

[QUOTE=jojorules;426465]I am not so sure about that. Jess had 20lbs on Cara, Cara had 0 strategy she even admitted she had no strategy and just ran straight at her not trying to juke at all, and still Jess scored 0 pts. Jess does crossfit too and had the weight advantage, so I don't give her as much credit for her fight as others do. The credit I give her is that she actually is trying to get better, and not the girl that thinks she is hot and is happy to be there and doesn't want to get her nails dirty. So I am glad if she is going to keep getting asked, at least she is trying to improve herself.[/QUOTE] Sarah is bigger and does crossfit too

[QUOTE=jojorules;426466]I am not so sure about that. Jess had 20lbs on Cara(according to twitter each had their weight listed publically), Cara had 0 strategy she even admitted she had no strategy and just ran straight at her not trying to juke at all, and still Jess scored 0 pts. Jess does crossfit too and had the weight advantage, so I don't give her as much credit for her fight as others do. The credit I give her is that she actually is trying to get better, and not the girl that thinks she is hot and is happy to be there and doesn't want to get her nails dirty. So I am glad if she is going to keep getting asked, at least she is trying to improve herself. I can't count a sweep as a great elimination round, I just can't. that's like saying when the cavs got swept by the spurs in 2004 or whatever that was an epic series. May have had some cool moments, but it was a sweep. It can only be considered average to me[/QUOTE] I agree with you, I'm not saying Sarah couldn't win, I just think she is not that good at physical eliminations. I'll give it to Cara Maria. EDIT: I actually don't remember her being in any physical eliminations. Ruins: Oh Ring (Katie scored one point, that must say something) and Crunch Fresh Meat 2: Exile Cutthroat: She didn't go in Rivals: Unburied (she lost to Jonna in a puzzle, which she is supposely really good at) Battle of the Exes: None Battle of the Seasons: Knot So Fast (I'll give her that, she is really good at endurance and strategy) and Balls Out Rivals 2: None So I can't really know if she'll be that good. I'm not saying she is a bad competitor, she is really good, but I feel that people hype her too much.

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;426469]Sarah is bigger and does crossfit too[/QUOTE] I wasn't referencing Sarah at all in their head to head, I was just responding to your saying that Cara struggled with Jess.

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;426462]More balls in match ups Bananas vs Dustin Jordan vs Leroy Darrell vs CT Zach vs Tyler Frank vs CJ Laurel vs Emily Aneesa vs Cooke Theresa vs Cara Maria Nany vs KellyAnne Camila vs Marie[/QUOTE] Bananas Leroy CT Zach Toss up, gonna go with CJ Laurel Cooke Theresa KellyAnne Camila

[QUOTE=Fresh Meat;426476]Bananas Leroy CT Zach Toss up, gonna go with CJ Laurel Cooke Theresa KellyAnne Camila[/QUOTE] Same for me, Frank and CJ could go either way. I'll give the edge to Frank, but I wouldn't be surprise if CJ wins. Camila vs. Marie could be real interesting, I hope to see that match in the future.

Frank vs CJ and CT VS Darrell would be great and Laurel vs Emily would be the best female elimination ever! Tbh I think all the ones I put could be really good

[QUOTE=nevidcm;426477]Same for me, Frank and CJ could go either way. I'll give the edge to Frank, but I wouldn't be surprise if CJ wins. Camila vs. Marie could be real interesting, I hope to see that match in the future.[/QUOTE] We saw something pretty good between Camila and Marie on Seasons with the oil wrestling mission, too.

I wish so many people didn't throw the oil wresting mission because I liked that one.

I just noticed that last week they scheduled a Challenge marathon for today, but now it's just Ridiculousness and a Jersey Shore marathon.... boooooo MTV!

[QUOTE=nevidcm;426450]Who would win in Balls In? Theresa vs. Laurel Cooke vs. Emily Nany vs. Marie Nia vs. KellyAnne Sarah vs. Cara Maria Jonna vs. Jemmye Kimberly vs. Jessica Rachel vs. Evelyn[/QUOTE] Laurel Emily Nany KellyAnne Cara Maria Jemmye (due to Jonna's size) Jessica Evelyn [QUOTE=Challenge 17;426462]More balls in match ups Bananas vs Dustin Jordan vs Leroy Darrell vs CT Zach vs Tyler Frank vs CJ Laurel vs Emily Aneesa vs Cooke Theresa vs Cara Maria Nany vs KellyAnne Camila vs Marie[/QUOTE] Bananas Leroy Tossup Zach True tossup! Also a tossup, lol. Aneesa Theresa KellyAnne Camila

[QUOTE=metalking;426531]I just noticed that last week they scheduled a Challenge marathon for today, but now it's just Ridiculousness and a Jersey Shore marathon.... boooooo MTV![/QUOTE] They should be grateful that Free Agents is doing as "good" as it is. They never repeat it, NEVER, but they repeat the heck out of Ridiculousness.

[QUOTE=Challenge20;426429]I was reading something in the speculation thread for next season and seen this thing about CT being into guys or whatever, but I'm guessing by a few posts it a long story, so could someone PM me the whole story?[/QUOTE] CT said something too Tyler about 'getting lucky' and that he said Shane would know what he was talking about. Evan also made a remark about some of the Challenge men swinging both ways, 'one of them being named; Chris'

[QUOTE=JoeRealWorld;426590]CT said something too Tyler about 'getting lucky' and that he said Shane would know what he was talking about. Evan also made a remark about some of the Challenge men swinging both ways, 'one of them being named; Chris'[/QUOTE] I wouldn't be surprised if it happen, but it really doesn't matter. It's their life and they can do what they want. That's isn't gonna change how I view him as a person.

Hey. I just watched Rivals and I am curious if Adam R is planning to return?

[QUOTE=kollanekoer;426685]Hey. I just watched Rivals and I am curious if Adam R is planning to return?[/QUOTE] He may want to return, but he is currently banned from MTV

Why? I am sorry if this topic is already talked about

[QUOTE=kollanekoer;426844]Why? I am sorry if this topic is already talked about[/QUOTE] Damaging the relationship between MTV and the Hard Rock, as well as allegedly failing a psych evaluation. The latter reason is unlikely IMO, due to the fact that when BMP submitted the final BOTExes cast list to MTV Adam was on it and MTV ordered him to be removed. Had he failed the psych exam, why would he have been on the final list in the first place?

I didn't saw much of him at Rivals but I think he was one of the few good looking guys there, easy for the eyes. I am not that into beasts like CT or Zack :D I really would like to see more of him. I feel like I am losing all of my fave males. Landon, Kenny, Derrick, Frank... ughh

My personal favorite Dunbar moment may be them reading his letters to his girlfriend after he was eliminated on Battle of the Exes. Other than that, I thoroughly DIDN'T enjoy Dunbar.

[QUOTE=LurkerNoMore;426845][B]Damaging the relationship between MTV and the Hard Rock[/B], as well as allegedly failing a psych evaluation. The latter reason is unlikely IMO, due to the fact that when BMP submitted the final BOTExes cast list to MTV Adam was on it and MTV ordered him to be removed. Had he failed the psych exam, why would he have been on the final list in the first place?[/QUOTE] There is one part of that theory that still confuses me to this day. Why did they allow him to do Rivals if damaging MTV's relationship was the primary reason for him getting banned? It would seem like that damage was already done and out there well before the filming of Rivals began.

[QUOTE=Meelz;426854]My personal favorite Dunbar moment may be them reading his letters to his girlfriend after he was eliminated on Battle of the Exes. Other than that, I thoroughly DIDN'T enjoy Dunbar.[/QUOTE] That was absolutely hilarious. Dunbar is by far the easiest person to make fun of.

[QUOTE=CHIblackhawk;426855]There is one part of that theory that still confuses me to this day. Why did they allow him to do Rivals if damaging MTV's relationship was the primary reason for him getting banned? It would seem like that damage was already done and out there well before the filming of Rivals began.[/QUOTE] I've wondered that as well, maybe because the show hadn't aired at that point? I have no idea.