The Challenge: Generic Thread

69913 posts / 0 new
Last post

rwportland2 wrote:

Who are you top 10 favorite challengers? (guy/girl)Darrell, Wes, Landon, Ace, Timmy, Mike the Miz, Abram, Frank R, Nehemiah, Antoine Coral, Katie, Beth, Ashley M, Nia, Kendal, Jillian, Marie, KellyAnne, Veronica

I forgot to answer this. Top 10 Males(In No Order)1.Abram 2.Ace 3.Nelson 4.Jordan 5.Dustin 6.Brad 7.Antoine 8.Landon 9.Cory 10.WesHonorable Mentions: Tony/Devin/Dan(Viewer's Revenge)/Cohutta/Hunter/Isaac/Yes/Joss/Mike(Back To New York)/Thomas/Jamie(Bloodlines)/Mike(Bloodlines)/Mitch/Darrell/CJTop 10 Women(In No Order)1.Jullie(New Orleans 1) 2.Jonna 3.Nany 4.Devyn 5.Katie 6.Beth 7.Piggy 8.Belou 9.Kam 10.Ashley MHonerable Mentions Kayleigh/Kellyanne/Nia/Jemmye/Robin/Aneesa/Marie/Sylvia/Melissa

1. Wes 2. Nelly 3. Hunter 4. Devin 5. Nehemiah 6. Danny 7. Frank Roessler 8. Alton 9. Timmy B 10. Marlon 1. Laurel 2. Evelyn 3. Amanda 4. Melinda 5. Britni 6. Cheyenne 7. Johanna 8. Cara Z  9. Smashley 10. Brittini (duel 2)

No Order:

Brad (Pre Vendettas)

Alton

Theo Von

Timmy

Alton

Derrick

Wes

Landon

Kenny

CT

 

Svetlana

Elka

Laurel

Katie

Sarah Greyson

Susie

Rachel

Veronica

Tori Hall

Cara Z

Landon, Darrell, Theo V, Dan S, Abram, Ace, CJ, Frank S (if I pretend Seasons didn't happen), Hunter (if I ignore the alliance) & Timmy

Susie, Coral, Mallory, Jonna, Veronica, Elka, Genesis, , Jenn, Holly Shand & Kimberly

TylerLovesTyler3 wrote:

Is it just me or has anyone else found the cast annoying over the years?. I started watching the show when I was 16 and loved the show. Now that I'm older im annoyed more easily by most of the cast. Like I don't even have anyone in specific anymore that I would like to win. I just watch the show out of habit these days. 

I agree for the most part. The only thing I don't really connect with is only watching the show out of habit, I just can't do that. I enjoy the show, I just know it's not the same and I don't have anyone I'm thoroughly rotting for.

I dont have anyone I'm rooting for anymore too. Because they are all the same nowadays. 

1- start off as a rookie (usually arrogant/self-centered) and trying to go against the sheeps.

2- Realise you can't change it by yourself.

3- Become a sheep

4- Lose all the personality and traits and follow John or whoever has the majority in the house. 

5- Do challenges over and over again (without taking breaks or bringing anything new).

Most of the guys and girls from the challenge nowadays fit in this model. If they are **** bent on making so many challenges honestly they should rotate their casts way more, having the same core challengers is hurting the show and the newcomers.

I'd go with something like:Abram, Wes, CT, Darrell,  Landon,  Hunter, Derrick, Alton, Timmy, DevinSarah, Cara Maria, Laurel, Jenna, Ev, Kellyanne, Coral, Emily, Nia and I hate to say it, but I always liked Ibis. Edit: I'm at least going to give Holly S. an HM. I also replaced Lori with Emily since I don't want to put people that only did one season. 

Wes followed by a big gap. Then Frank R, Landon, Jordan, Tony, Devin kinda have a soft spot for Dario too lol

Nany followed by an even bigger gap. Laurel, Amanda, Jillian, Kailah, Ashley M, Svetlana, Cooke

Based on the challenges only

Miz, Frank (Vegas), Brad, Landon, Wes, Jordan, Darrell, Abe, Derrick, Shane

Coral, Jonna, Nany, Marie, Veronica, Katie, Tina, Jillian, Ashley M., Theresa 

Honorable Mentions - Knight, Cohutta, Isaac, Holly Shand, Elka, Kellyanne

Honorable One Hit Wonder Mentions  - Queen Kendal, Averey (**** Leroy for Rivals 3), Mallory, Cooke & Svetlana

 

https://www.reddit.com/r/MtvChallenge/comments/807srk/request_dont_go_to_vevmo_because_that_website_is/So Bacchus & all the mods, you now have the confirmation you need. Make the upcoming Challenge 32 cast/elimination spoiler pages private and members-only from now on since not only are they trash, but ungrateful trash at that. Smile

Lmaoooooooooo tho

"its okay. you hating **********. all fraudulent."

Top 10 all time in no particular order based on challenges only:

Aneesa (all time fave), Cara Maria, Ashley M, Coral, Veronica, Rachel R, Tina, Theresa, Katie, Jillian Z

Wes (all time fave), Devin, Landon, Darrell, Abram, Shane, Frank R, CT, Derrick, Brandon N

Honorable mentions: Kam, Averey, Kendal, KellyAnne, Cohutta, Brad, Isaac

Challenge13 has a list that is very nearly perfection.

Are these Top 10's based on preference or performance? like best competitors or favorite cast members?

Are these Top 10's based on preference or performance? like best competitors or favorite cast members?

I made mine based on people I get excited to see on a cast list. They’re the people who always bring something to me that makes them likeable. If it was based on performance i think everyone would have Ev, Laurel, Rachel R, and Emily 

richjoe92 wrote:

Are these Top 10's based on preference or performance? like best competitors or favorite cast members?

I made mine based on people I get excited to see on a cast list. They’re the people who always bring something to me that makes them likeable. If it was based on performance i think everyone would have Ev, Laurel, Rachel R, and Emily 

That's why I was confused. Thank you for the clarification.

Challenge13 has a list that is very nearly perfection.

everyone except brad . Well at least brad before duel 2 is good

Are these Top 10's based on preference or performance? like best competitors or favorite cast members?

I have danny ****** jamison on mine. Clearly mine is just who is my favorite! ****.

Lmaoooooooooo tho"its okay. you hating **********. all fraudulent."

Are these Top 10's based on preference or performance? like best competitors or favorite cast members?

Mine is favorite castmembers period. Dunno about anyone else(Save for the two that answered you ****).

Based on Challenges only, some of my******* were icons on RW but nothing on challenges :/

Marie (always), Nia, Ashley M, Svetlana, Katie <3, Julie, Veronica, Coral, Tina, Sylvia. 

Wes, Shane Landrum, Landon, Darrell, Abe, Thomas, Marlon, Tony, Frank, Brad (was top 5 until this season)

Based on the challenges onlyMiz, Frank (Vegas), Brad, Landon, Wes, Jordan, Darrell, Abe, Derrick, ShaneCoral, Jonna, Nany, Marie, Veronica, Katie, Tina, Jillian, Ashley M., Theresa Honorable Mentions - Knight, Cohutta, Isaac, Holly Shand, Elka, KellyanneHonorable One Hit Wonder Mentions  - Queen Kendal, Averey (**** Leroy for Rivals 3), Mallory, Cooke & Svetlana 

If you take out Marie & Jordan this is an elite list

Based on the challenges onlyMiz, Frank (Vegas), Brad, Landon, Wes, Jordan, Darrell, Abe, Derrick, ShaneCoral, Jonna, Nany, Marie, Veronica, Katie, Tina, Jillian, Ashley M., Theresa Honorable Mentions - Knight, Cohutta, Isaac, Holly Shand, Elka, KellyanneHonorable One Hit Wonder Mentions  - Queen Kendal, Averey (**** Leroy for Rivals 3), Mallory, Cooke & Svetlana 

If you take out Marie & Jordan this is an elite list

triple post

 

Marie >>>

that’s my list 

richjoe92 wrote:

Are these Top 10's based on preference or performance? like best competitors or favorite cast members?

I have danny ****** jamison on mine. Clearly mine is just who is my favorite! ****.

I must have missed that name or else it would've been telling. ****. whoops.

This probably belongs in the "unpopular opinion" category but while Danny Jamieson isn't one of the best ever (obviously) I don't think he's one of the worst ever either.  He's slow which killed him against Davis & Adam King.  Losing to Darrell in an elimination based on strength is hardly shameful.   Wes & Casey had a better strategy than him & Evelyn + less weight.  He actually impressed with with Sandy on FM2...he was encouraging and showed stamina.  Then he had the dumbest "endurance" elimination of all time on Seasons.  0-6 is hard to ignore but I don't think he's as bad as she's shown over the years.  I would have loved to have seen him on a Duel or Cutthroat

This probably belongs in the "unpopular opinion" category but while Danny Jamieson isn't one of the best ever (obviously) I don't think he's one of the worst ever either.  He's slow which killed him against Davis & Adam King.  Losing to Darrell in an elimination based on strength is hardly shameful.   Wes & Casey had a better strategy than him & Evelyn + less weight.  He actually impressed with with Sandy on FM2...he was encouraging and showed stamina.  Then he had the dumbest "endurance" elimination of all time on Seasons.  0-6 is hard to ignore but I don't think he's as bad as she's shown over the years.  I would have loved to have seen him on a Duel or Cutthroat

 

Danny actually did well on Ruins. He was always encouraging and him and Brad were the heart and brawn of their team. He also beat Darrell in the one leg of their elimination. 

 

He would possibly do better if he were faster. 

MEN: Darrell, Theo Von,  Marlon, Brad (gone down a bit after this season but I loved him so much before his return I have to include him), Wes, Brandon Nelson, Devin, Frank S., Miz, Alton

WOMEN: Laurel, Cooke, Marie, Nia, Nany, Coral, Katie, Sylvia, Ruthie & Melissa

dp

This probably belongs in the "unpopular opinion" category but while Danny Jamieson isn't one of the best ever (obviously) I don't think he's one of the worst ever either.  He's slow which killed him against Davis & Adam King.  Losing to Darrell in an elimination based on strength is hardly shameful.   Wes & Casey had a better strategy than him & Evelyn + less weight.  He actually impressed with with Sandy on FM2...he was encouraging and showed stamina.  Then he had the dumbest "endurance" elimination of all time on Seasons.  0-6 is hard to ignore but I don't think he's as bad as she's shown over the years.  I would have loved to have seen him on a Duel or Cutthroat

He was never bad or an anchor and I wouldn't have been surprised if he made the G3 final if he avoided that elimination. Same with Dunbar who people seem to think is terrible. 

kvm1977 wrote:

This probably belongs in the "unpopular opinion" category but while Danny Jamieson isn't one of the best ever (obviously) I don't think he's one of the worst ever either.  He's slow which killed him against Davis & Adam King.  Losing to Darrell in an elimination based on strength is hardly shameful.   Wes & Casey had a better strategy than him & Evelyn + less weight.  He actually impressed with with Sandy on FM2...he was encouraging and showed stamina.  Then he had the dumbest "endurance" elimination of all time on Seasons.  0-6 is hard to ignore but I don't think he's as bad as she's shown over the years.  I would have loved to have seen him on a Duel or Cutthroat

He was never bad or an anchor and I wouldn't have been surprised if he made the G3 final if he avoided that elimination. Same with Dunbar who people seem to think is terrible. 

Dunbar sucks the life out of everyone, but he isn't Big Easy or Nathan (San Diego 2). He pulled his own weight on Cutthroat. 

Pages