The Challenge: All Stars - Season 3 (Spoilers Discussion)

13603 posts / 0 new
Last post

Sylvia is neither a good guy or bad *** honestly 

The way she attacked Madison unprovoked would definitely put her in the bad category. I mean, they could use other incidents but I mean..her attitude alone would place her in that category lol.

I wouldn't say there's a elimination beast on the female side so I really can see any of them getting eliminated. I wouldn't say any woman is a lock to be endgame because this female lineup is good drama but not elite competitors.

Sylvia - 5-1Cynthia- 0-0Jemmye- 2-4Jonna- 2-5Kailah- 4-2KellyAnne- 5-3Kendal- 1-0Melinda- 0-4Nia- 3-1Roni- 0-0Tina- 3-1Veronica- 2-2

a couple of them stand out as elimination beasts but okay.  

No, they don't.  Sylvia won twice with Joss.  Beating Kailah was a nice win but really her only impressive win.   Kailah has two wins over Marie which is like beating a corpse.  Tina has 2 wins with Kenny and we saw exactly what she was made of on Cutthroat.  Nia is probably the closest but she quit about Cara and had Leroy as a partner which was huge especially in the elimination against Wes.   There's no Laurel or Emily on this cast.

okay well if you're comparing everyone to Laurel and Emily then you'll never be happy. 

That's what people mean by "an elimination beast"--someone you expect to beat everyone.

There's literally nothing wrong with that but stat padding still isn't gonna change my mind because fluky elimination wins does not indeed make you a " elimination beast "

When I agree with Kevin you know it's bad.....

It all depends on the elim tbh. If it is physical none of these girls are beating Nia. But if its endurance or a puzzle she could lose to a few of these girls. Kelly anne imo is the most well rounded girl for eliminations.

It all depends on the elim tbh. If it is physical none of these girls are beating Nia. But if its endurance or a puzzle she could lose to a few of these girls. Kelly anne imo is the most well rounded girl for eliminations.

Sylvia could maybe beat nia in something physical

Averey battled Nia for how long?  2 hours?

 

It all depends on the elim tbh. If it is physical none of these girls are beating Nia. But if its endurance or a puzzle she could lose to a few of these girls. Kelly anne imo is the most well rounded girl for eliminations.

Sylvia could maybe beat nia in something physical

Sylvia barely beat Melissa I don't see her doing much of anything against Nia but I guess we'll see

 

It all depends on the elim tbh. If it is physical none of these girls are beating Nia. But if its endurance or a puzzle she could lose to a few of these girls. Kelly anne imo is the most well rounded girl for eliminations.

Sylvia could maybe beat nia in something physical

Sylvia barely beat Melissa I don't see her doing much of anything against Nia but I guess we'll see

Good guys: Cynthia, Jonna, KellyAnne, Kendal, Melinda, Roni, Brad, Darrell, Laterrian, Mark, MJ, Yes

Bad *****: Jemmye, Kailah, Nia, Sylvia, Tina, Veronica, Derrick, Jordan, Nehemiah, Syrus, Tyler, Wes

is that it? It seems clearer for the women than the men but this concept only works best when the personalities are more clear cut or overall crazier aka like the Inferno 2. The teams were much better selected that season than Inferno 3, and I loved how there were some questionable good guys too (mike, Landon, Brad, robin, Julie) lol it seemed like they would base it more on attitude or degree of maliciousness/feistiness than only just craziness 

I'd swap Brad and Syrus. No way Cokehead is labeled a good guy.

Averey battled Nia for how long?  2 hours?

Who do you see beating her in something physical then?

Averey battled Nia for how long?  2 hours?

yeah and IMO Averey lowkey won both her fights her Nia and would’ve done serious damage had her dumbáss Doug looking boyfriend not held her back so much but people don’t wanna hear that. I like em both

Averey battled Nia for how long?  2 hours?

Who do you see beating her in something physical then?

Depending on what it is I think a few could.  Nia literally only has size--she's not "strong"

 

 

It all depends on the elim tbh. If it is physical none of these girls are beating Nia. But if its endurance or a puzzle she could lose to a few of these girls. Kelly anne imo is the most well rounded girl for eliminations.

Sylvia could maybe beat nia in something physical

Sylvia barely beat Melissa I don't see her doing much of anything against Nia but I guess we'll see

Nia lost to a little Cara Maria and struggled with Avery and Theresa. Nia is no powerhouse. 

This is Sylvia's best chance to win and that's just the ******* facts.

Cara, Nia, Theresa, Sylvia, and Averey are all in the Top 20 girls all time on The Challenge in terms of athleticism and strength. Cara and Nia may crack the Top 5. Comparing their abilities when there's people like Jemmye, Jonna, and Melinda on the cast is like a sad joke.

Sylvia aint winning . I can guarantee that.

Cara, Nia, Theresa, Sylvia, and Averey are all in the Top 20 girls all time on The Challenge in terms of athleticism and strength. .

LMAO

I'm trying to get over saying Nia and Cara Maria are top 5 all time in athleticism and strength.   Cara is the first to admit she's not an athlete.

Cara, Nia, Theresa, Sylvia, and Averey are all in the Top 20 girls all time on The Challenge in terms of athleticism and strength. Cara and Nia may crack the Top 5. Comparing their abilities when there's people like Jemmye, Jonna, and Melinda on the cast is like a sad joke.

That must just be your list because Theresa has 1 elimination win (beating a girl who was shorter than her/wanted to go home) out of nearly 8, no final wins, and has only made it to 1 final when production brought her back...

Averey has done absolutely nothing yet to prove she's on that level either...

I mean--they literally said Nia and Cara were top 5 with strength AND athleticism.   I can't.

 

Cara, Nia, Theresa, Sylvia, and Averey are all in the Top 20 girls all time on The Challenge in terms of athleticism and strength. .

LMAO

In terms of having the strength and athleticism in surviving eliminations and who I would want as a partner in a final? Okay, Nia's like 7th.

1. Emily 2. Laurel 3. Jenny 4. Kaycee 5. Cara 6. Evelyn 7. Nia 8. Rachel R. 9. Ninja 10. Jodi 11. Kam 12. Cooke 13. Camila 14. Kellyanne 15. Sarah 16. Theresa 17. Ashley 18. Sylvia 19. Nicole Z. 20. Averey 21. Kendal 22. Tori D. 23. Susie 24. Janelle 25. Jenn 26. Jillian 27. Dee 28. Jenna 29. Tori F. 30. Amber B.

 

Cara, Nia, Theresa, Sylvia, and Averey are all in the Top 20 girls all time on The Challenge in terms of athleticism and strength. .

LMAO

In terms of surviving eliminations and who I would want as a partner in a final? Okay, Nia's like 7th.

1. Emily 2. Laurel 3. Jenny 4. Kaycee 5. Cara 6. Evelyn 7. Nia 8. Rachel R. 9. Ninja 10. Jodi 11. Kam 12. Cooke 13. Camila 14. Kellyanne 15. Sarah 16. Theresa 17. Ashley 18. Sylvia 19. Nicole Z. 20. Averey 21. Kendal 22. Tori D. 23. Susie 24. Janelle 25. Jenn 26. Jillian 27. Dee 28. Jenna 29. Tori F. 30. Amber B.

I can't.  I'll let someone else take this.  

 

Cara, Nia, Theresa, Sylvia, and Averey are all in the Top 20 girls all time on The Challenge in terms of athleticism and strength. Cara and Nia may crack the Top 5. Comparing their abilities when there's people like Jemmye, Jonna, and Melinda on the cast is like a sad joke.

That must just be your list because Theresa has 1 elimination win (beating a girl who was shorter than her/wanted to go home) out of nearly 8, no final wins, and has only made it to 1 final when production brought her back...

Averey has done absolutely nothing yet to prove she's on that level either...

 

 

Cara, Nia, Theresa, Sylvia, and Averey are all in the Top 20 girls all time on The Challenge in terms of athleticism and strength. .

LMAO

In terms of having the strength and athleticism in surviving eliminations and who I would want as a partner in a final? Okay, Nia's like 7th.

1. Emily 2. Laurel 3. Jenny 4. Kaycee 5. Cara 6. Evelyn 7. Nia 8. Rachel R. 9. Ninja 10. Jodi 11. Kam 12. Cooke 13. Camila 14. Kellyanne 15. Sarah 16. Theresa 17. Ashley 18. Sylvia 19. Nicole Z. 20. Averey 21. Kendal 22. Tori D. 23. Susie 24. Janelle 25. Jenn 26. Jillian 27. Dee 28. Jenna 29. Tori F. 30. Amber B.

Where is Sarah Greyson? 

Anyways. 

how long is this sseson filming till? early december? or before thanksgiving? 

In terms of surviving eliminations and who I would want as a partner in a final? Okay, Nia's like 7th.

1. Emily 2. Laurel 3. Jenny 4. Kaycee 5. Cara 6. Evelyn 7. Nia 8. Rachel R. 9. Ninja 10. Jodi 11. Kam 12. Cooke 13. Camila 14. Kellyanne 15. Sarah 16. Theresa 17. Ashley 18. Sylvia 19. Nicole Z. 20. Averey 21. Kendal 22. Tori D. 23. Susie 24. Janelle 25. Jenn 26. Jillian 27. Dee 28. Jenna 29. Tori F. 30. Amber B.

I can't.  I'll let someone else take this.  

Give me your list KVM. 

 

Averey battled Nia for how long?  2 hours?

Who do you see beating her in something physical then?

Depending on what it is I think a few could.  Nia literally only has size--she's not "strong"

Who on this cast is "stronger"

Pages