The Challenge: All Stars (Season 1)- Spoilers Discussion

7437 posts / 0 new
Last post

 

Its the potential ratio of season 1 people to new OGs on season 2 that worries me. I think repeating majority of the cast and not rotating them ruined the main show.

True but most of these people know each other even those not on season 1

its not that they all know each other, its that it becomes too predictable when the majority of the same cast is used repeatedly. Its interesting to see the dynamics when they bring majority of people they havent seen in 10/20 years, vs having the majority being people who were on the first season.  

dont get me wrong, Id love to see alot of season 1 people back. But only a few for each season, not an overwhelming amount. I think rotation is key

its not that they all know each other, its that it becomes too predictable when the majority of the same cast is used repeatedly. Its interesting to see the dynamics when they bring majority of people they havent seen in 10/20 years, vs having the majority being people who were on the first season.  

dont get me wrong, Id love to see alot of season 1 people back. But only a few for each season, not an overwhelming amount. I think rotation is key

All of this

 

its not that they all know each other, its that it becomes too predictable when the majority of the same cast is used repeatedly. Its interesting to see the dynamics when they bring majority of people they havent seen in 10/20 years, vs having the majority being people who were on the first season.  

dont get me wrong, Id love to see alot of season 1 people back. But only a few for each season, not an overwhelming amount. I think rotation is key

All of this

Yeah I'm all for this too. I just don't think its realistic for season 2.  After S2 we might see more of a rotation.  Though do we really think they wouldn't keep inviting back people that make their lives easier or minority cast members that they have a limited pool of?

Like Mark will probably be on any season he wants to be. Jemmye is likely cheap and narrates for them. Beth is Beth so if she's willing she's on. 

As long as it stays with RW/RR/FM I'm fine with repeats. It's better than the alternative IMO

12 of the same ******* people??? 

Season 2 should be The Challenge Allstars: Real World vs Road Rules. new and improved Blue and Red Jerseys. An actual Team Challenge from Beginning to End. 

Simple yet exactly what should happen 

yessssss

We're obviously going to see Mark and Beth but 12 is quite a bit. I'd even be ok if they did returnees vs newbies (aka people from season 1 vs all new crop of season 2)

Will all of these returnees even be able to get time off from work again? I thought a big part of this was the limited filming schedule so people could use their vacation time to go.  How many who have jobs can realistically take another 2-3 weeks off in the same year?

I honestly don't want to see more than 5-6 people come back. If they have over 100+ people willing to do it in sure they can get a lot on that weren't on season one. Mainly people who could've been on

Will all of these returnees even be able to get time off from work again? I thought a big part of this was the limited filming schedule so people could use their vacation time to go.  How many who have jobs can realistically take another 2-3 weeks off in the same year?

Most people with real jobs get 3+ weeks vacation and with most companies you can take an unpaid leave.  This isn't even including carrying over vacation time. Given the app fee I dony see much of a problem 

Will all of these returnees even be able to get time off from work again? I thought a big part of this was the limited filming schedule so people could use their vacation time to go.  How many who have jobs can realistically take another 2-3 weeks off in the same year?

some jobs you're able to take multiple vacations a year, so certain people may be able to go again

Then again we don't know what these people's job is or even if they have a job. Kendal is someone who can be iffy since she works in the medical field 

And lets be real a lot of them really dont have real jobs lol

from this season only ones i can think of are Katie, and Kendal on the girls side of things

guys not as so sure about

And lets be real a lot of them really dont have real jobs lol

from this season only ones i can think of are Katie, and Kendal on the girls side of things

guys not as so sure about

I think Yes does but maybe he's an independent contractor but you're correct most don't have what most people consider real jobs

And lets be real a lot of them really dont have real jobs lol

from this season only ones i can think of are Katie, and Kendal on the girls side of things

guys not as so sure about

what job Katie have?

 

And lets be real a lot of them really dont have real jobs lol

from this season only ones i can think of are Katie, and Kendal on the girls side of things

guys not as so sure about

what job Katie have?

i think she's an interior designer?

 

 

And lets be real a lot of them really dont have real jobs lol

from this season only ones i can think of are Katie, and Kendal on the girls side of things

guys not as so sure about

what job Katie have?

i think she's an interior designer?

then she probably got plenty of time to go do another Challenge... this was her favorite one

Katie actually worked from quarantine because she didnt have enough time off available.

i know Yes is a lecturer at Berkley as well as the architecture he does, but I'm not sure if that's a fulltime gig or if that will even come into play if school isnt in session yet. 

i could be wrong but I think mostly everyone other than the ones previously mentioned can do it freely because they work for themselves, but they may not want to leave their families for that long in the same year again, especially if it overlaps with the start of the school year. 

I think where they film may play a huge part in it as well, if they have to quarantine for x amount of days. 

 

 

And lets be real a lot of them really dont have real jobs lol

from this season only ones i can think of are Katie, and Kendal on the girls side of things

guys not as so sure about

what job Katie have?

i think she's an interior designer?

i think thats a side hustle/passion project, i wanna say she works in finance at like a media company or something maybe

 

And lets be real a lot of them really dont have real jobs lol

from this season only ones i can think of are Katie, and Kendal on the girls side of things

guys not as so sure about

I think Yes does but maybe he's an independent contractor but you're correct most don't have what most people consider real jobs

yup youre right with yes totally slipped my mind, i think he owns his own practice and then also is an adjunct prof at berkely 

i could be wrong but I think mostly everyone other than the ones previously mentioned can do it freely because they work for themselves, but they may not want to leave their families for that long in the same year again, especially if it overlaps with the start of the school year. 

Honestly, depending on the cash I think most would be willing to leave for another 2-3 weeks.  A lot of parents travel constantly for their jobs or they're at work all day and only get to see their kids for a few hours in the evening/on the weekends.  These people are probably going to be able to make as much in 6-8 weeks than they do typically in a year even if they don't win.

 

i could be wrong but I think mostly everyone other than the ones previously mentioned can do it freely because they work for themselves, but they may not want to leave their families for that long in the same year again, especially if it overlaps with the start of the school year. 

Honestly, depending on the cash I think most would be willing to leave for another 2-3 weeks.  A lot of parents travel constantly for their jobs or they're at work all day and only get to see their kids for a few hours in the evening/on the weekends.  These people are probably going to be able to make as much in 6-8 weeks than they do typically in a year even if they don't win.

exactly, a lot of people who work for themselves or have jobs that would let them would be willing to go. Like Jonna who I think is a stay at home mom, she said she'll do it if she gets her family to watch them. Filming is like 3-4 weeks, not that long at all

i could be wrong but I think mostly everyone other than the ones previously mentioned can do it freely because they work for themselves, but they may not want to leave their families for that long in the same year again, especially if it overlaps with the start of the school year. 

Honestly, depending on the cash I think most would be willing to leave for another 2-3 weeks.  A lot of parents travel constantly for their jobs or they're at work all day and only get to see their kids for a few hours in the evening/on the weekends.  These people are probably going to be able to make as much in 6-8 weeks than they do typically in a year even if they don't win.

exactly, a lot of people who work for themselves or have jobs that would let them would be willing to go. Like Jonna who I think is a stay at home mom, she said she'll do it if she gets her family to watch them. Filming is like 3-4 weeks, not that long at all

And especially for someone like Jonna that's going to give her the opportunity to spend more time with her kids while they're young.  If she can give up 6-8 weeks a year of seeing them it gives her 44 or so weeks to spend every waking seconds with them.

unless we're getting people like evelyn, bananas, etc level players for season 2, they can just have most of the S1 people come back. dont need to be adding all these new people just for the sake of adding new people.

If they did a battle of the seasons what would be your fantasy cast?

If they did a battle of the seasons what would be your fantasy cast?

Omg, I'd love a BOTSeasons...

If they did a battle of the seasons what would be your fantasy cast?

teams or 4 or pairs?

Teams of 4 is easy for me Campus Crawl (Rachel/Kendal/Shane/Darrell), Boston (Sean/Syrus/Genesis/Montana or Elka), Vegas (Alton/Frank/Irulan/Arissa or Trishelle), Viewers Revenge (Abram/Derek/Susie/Veronica) Paris (Adam or CT/Ace/Mallory/Leah)  Xtreme (Derrick/Nick/Ibis/Jillian), The Quest (Adam/Blair/Katie/Ellen or Sophia) Cancun (same as Seasons) and Key West (John/Tyler/Paula/Janelle)--trying to be somewhat realistic 

If they did a battle of the seasons what would be your fantasy cast?

Las Vegas: Arissa, Irulan, Alton, Frank

Key West: Svetlana, Paula, Bananas, Tyler

Cancun: Jonna, Ayiia, CJ, Derek

San Diego: Cameron, Jamie, Brad, Randy

Campus Crawl: Kendal, Rachel, Shane, Darrell

The Quest: Katie, Ellen, Adam, Blair

Viewers Revenge: Susie, Veronica, Derek, Abram

Sydney: Shavuon, KellyAnne, Dunbar, Cohutta

Xtreme: Derrick, Nick, Ibis, Jillian

Seasons would be iconic, I hope it happens

A battle of the seasons would be cool but I would fear that certain people wouldn't be able to get on due to having no willing partners. Like I would love to see Laterrian come back but his only option would be Holly B. And I can't see her doing this.

A battle of the seasons would be cool but I would fear that certain people wouldn't be able to get on due to having no willing partners. Like I would love to see Laterrian come back but his only option would be Holly B. And I can't see her doing this.

Who is Holly B?

 

A battle of the seasons would be cool but I would fear that certain people wouldn't be able to get on due to having no willing partners. Like I would love to see Laterrian come back but his only option would be Holly B. And I can't see her doing this.

Who is Holly B?

Chadwick's wife. Holly Brentson Pelletier. RR Max Velocity Tour 

Pages

Topic locked