The Challenge: All Stars (Season 1)- Spoilers Discussion

7437 posts / 0 new
Last post

I wonder when/if names are going to pop up. It'll be harder to tell the order I'm sure with the shortened filming schedule.

 

the best performance in challenge history is darrell AND Aviv's final (aviv deserves a lot of credit for the puzzles). They couldnt even pretend it was close they beat Tina and Kenny by like 3 hours 

Landon FM2 period. Absolutely no debate.

There actually is a debate but I wont spend 5 pages arguing with you about it lol. 

His partner was not as bad as people made her out to be. 

 

 

the best performance in challenge history is darrell AND Aviv's final (aviv deserves a lot of credit for the puzzles). They couldnt even pretend it was close they beat Tina and Kenny by like 3 hours 

Landon FM2 period. Absolutely no debate.

There actually is a debate but I wont spend 5 pages arguing with you about it lol. 

His partner was not as bad as people made her out to be. 

oh please

 

 

the best performance in challenge history is darrell AND Aviv's final (aviv deserves a lot of credit for the puzzles). They couldnt even pretend it was close they beat Tina and Kenny by like 3 hours 

Landon FM2 period. Absolutely no debate.

There actually is a debate but I wont spend 5 pages arguing with you about it lol. 

His partner was not as bad as people made her out to be. 

Give that partner to Darrell on that same final and he wouldn't win a final. Aviv was good at his weakness based on clips I saw.

Carley <3

FM2 final was way tougher. Kenny and Laurel were the best team that entire challenge and Landon literally pushed Carley up a mountain to beat both of them. 

Mt Rushmore: Landon, CT, Johnny (unfortunately 7 wins is just too much to leave out even if he did like 20 plus challenges), Jordan

Landon won 2 team challenges... one of them involving a stuffed burrito and ibis won for them... the first being a sprinting challenge against tina and tonya.... ya'll can stop hyping this man up now.

Landon won 2 team challenges... one of them involving a stuffed burrito and ibis won for them... the first being a sprinting challenge against tina and tonya.... ya'll can stop hyping this man up now.

he also was the best player on the Duel 2 and lost before the final on a technicality. Get your facts straight, otherwise you have no argument. 

The best female competitor of the show Evelyn deserves a spot in the Mount Rushmore imo 

I'm still sad ****** isn't doing this. 

Imagine contacting ******* Jasmine of all people. 

I'd much prefer her over Jonna.  Jasmine was my fav cast member from Cancun lol

Landon won 2 team challenges... one of them involving a stuffed burrito and ibis won for them... the first being a sprinting challenge against tina and tonya.... ya'll can stop hyping this man up now.

lol Landon is one of the best - team wins or not - his Fresh Meat 2 win was super impressive and he was a beast <3  

Landon won 2 team challenges... one of them involving a stuffed burrito and ibis won for them... the first being a sprinting challenge against tina and tonya.... ya'll can stop hyping this man up now.

It's not his fault Tonya and Tina sucked--Landon & Darrell dominated that final regardless.  Even if Ibis doesn't eat half the food they still probably win because Landon's winning the relay race and I can't see Susie/Kina losing the puzzle to Katie in a puzzle/game of memory.  The champs were done even if they won the food part.   Landon & Mark dominated the Duel 2.  Landon's performance in the FM2 final is one of the best things we've ever seen.  Kudos to Carley for hanging in their but Landon beat Kenny/Laurel.  Kenny's an *** but unbelievable in finals.  Laurel's on of the best girls.   Landon only did 4 challenges and was almost perfect.  He's the GOAT

The best female competitor of the show Evelyn deserves a spot in the Mount Rushmore imo 

There would be a women's Mt Rushmore but that's one's more difficult with Coral & Veronica almost getting a spot regardless of anything other than being Coral & Veronica.

 

The best female competitor of the show Evelyn deserves a spot in the Mount Rushmore imo 

There would be a women's Mt Rushmore but that's one's more difficult with Coral & Veronica almost getting a spot regardless of anything other than being Coral & Veronica.

Feel like each era really needs its own Rushmore...Coral, Miz, & Veronica 100% get the golden age spots (Seasons 1 to 12), I don't know who #4 would be, I'd pick Darrell tho

The best female competitor of the show Evelyn deserves a spot in the Mount Rushmore imo 

There would be a women's Mt Rushmore but that's one's more difficult with Coral & Veronica almost getting a spot regardless of anything other than being Coral & Veronica.

Feel like each era really needs its own Rushmore...Coral, Miz, & Veronica 100% get the golden age spots (Seasons 1 to 12), I don't know who #4 would be, I'd pick Darrell tho

Darrell/Theo V/Dan S/Mark--any one of those 4 would work--I'd also say Darrell

Doing some research for pink on a funny LT story, fishing back through Colin's blog and found this great account of Beth. LOVE that she's back and hope she does well, but she sure is disliked by her peers. She certainly has no friend in Ruthie;

"

ON OG BETH:

"Ruthie was waitressing to pay the bills before she left for Jamaica—she wanted to have a few hundred bucks in her pocket when she showed up to the challenge. She needed a ride to one of her last days of work, so she asked Beth if she could provide such a ride. Beth said that she could definitely give her a ride… “I’ll be there at 4:30 to pick you up for your 5:00 shift.” Beth showed up and hour late and cost Ruthie her reputation and a day’s pay. Not the move of a good friend. According to Ruthie, Beth was always down to meet when she thought there was money to be made, but never included Ruthie in her social invitations. Ruthie was never invited to parties or get-togethers that Beth was privy to. Beth even had a “going away to Jamaica” party and didn’t invite Ruthie (refer to point in episode when Beth says, “Hello, we’re friends.”). Not to mention that there were several occasions when Beth left Ruthie stranded in Santa Monica and forced her to take a cab home to the Valley (if you don’t live in L.A… that’s a very, very, expensive cab ride). This, and a few other things, is the history between Ruthie and Beth. Couple all of these things with the fact that Beth just barged in on a nearly incapacitated Ruthie, suffering from incredible pain, who happens to be in the process of trying to squeeze one out, all in the hopes trying to buy herself another day on an MTV challenge… and you have the following equation…

Gladys=really nice person who everyone got along with in Jamaica   Beth=psycho   Beth + challenge=people having a bad time    Beth + mental stabalizers=not a bad idea     Ruthie in the inner circle=Beth packing her bags and going home because she is being voted off of mtv’s battle of the sexes    Well, at least Beth got her wish of not wanting to be the first person voted off of the Battle of the Sexes… second worst isn’t that bad, right? Then again, your teammates chose a pregnant woman over you in a physical competition. That’s gotta sting!"

 

 

Female Rushmore: 

Veronica/Evelyn/Cara Maria (3 wins each)

then out of females with 2 wins it's between Emily S, Ashley M, Rachel R. or Sarah R.

Female Rushmore: 

Veronica/Evelyn/Cara Maria (3 wins each)

then out of females with 2 wins it's between Emily S, Ashley M, Rachel R. or Sarah R.

It's not only about wins--the show isn't what it is today without Coral.  Coral >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Ashley Mitchell.  And that's not enough ">"

 

 

 

the best performance in challenge history is darrell AND Aviv's final (aviv deserves a lot of credit for the puzzles). They couldnt even pretend it was close they beat Tina and Kenny by like 3 hours 

Landon FM2 period. Absolutely no debate.

There actually is a debate but I wont spend 5 pages arguing with you about it lol. 

His partner was not as bad as people made her out to be. 

Give that partner to Darrell on that same final and he wouldn't win a final. Aviv was good at his weakness based on clips I saw.

I disagree, he still wins the FM2 final, Kenny and Laurel did not perform as well on that final as they did all season. But Aviv was a really good partner for him.  

 

 

Surprised Alton isn't getting more love. 

Im not one of them but a lot of people have him on their Challenge mount rushmore 

Alton's Gauntlet 2 performance is potentially the greatest performance in the show's history just in terms of how much he basically carried the team and led them to the win, but outside of that he's been good but I don't see how you'd put him on Mt. Rushmore.  I mean personally Mt. Rushmore (at least for guys) would almost universally have to be Mark, The Miz, CT, and Bananas.  I don't really know who else you'd swap out for that.

You really have THE MIZ over Darrell on your Mount Rushmore??? And Mark Long who quits every other season to split the prize money after??? 

Yes.  Mark Long is basically the George Washington of the show and The Miz is legitimately the biggest star the show ever produced.  He was THE guy on the show for years and always performed well.  He'd probably be the first person I'd put on Mt. Rushmore and the first person I'd cast on this show after Mark.  But he said he couldn't do it.

The females is actually easy. Veronica,Coral,Cara Maria, Evelyn period. You don't have to like all of them but they all have made an impact 

the best performance in challenge history is darrell AND Aviv's final (aviv deserves a lot of credit for the puzzles). They couldnt even pretend it was close they beat Tina and Kenny by like 3 hours 

Landon FM2 period. Absolutely no debate.

There actually is a debate but I wont spend 5 pages arguing with you about it lol. 

His partner was not as bad as people made her out to be. 

Give that partner to Darrell on that same final and he wouldn't win a final. Aviv was good at his weakness based on clips I saw.

I disagree, he still wins the FM2 final, Kenny and Laurel did not perform as well on that final as they did all season. But Aviv was a really good partner for him.  

It's going to be very difficult for Darrell to win that with Carley.  Darrell & Jordan are probably the only other guys that even "could" have but I'm convinced only Landon wins.  Jordan would have been too busy screaming at Carley IMO

The females is actually easy. Veronica,Coral,Cara Maria, Evelyn period. You don't have to like all of them but they all have made an impact 

Cara's the only one I question as a lock but, yeah, you're probably right.  I could see some saying Laurel instead

 

 

 

Surprised Alton isn't getting more love. 

Im not one of them but a lot of people have him on their Challenge mount rushmore 

Alton's Gauntlet 2 performance is potentially the greatest performance in the show's history just in terms of how much he basically carried the team and led them to the win, but outside of that he's been good but I don't see how you'd put him on Mt. Rushmore.  I mean personally Mt. Rushmore (at least for guys) would almost universally have to be Mark, The Miz, CT, and Bananas.  I don't really know who else you'd swap out for that.

You really have THE MIZ over Darrell on your Mount Rushmore??? And Mark Long who quits every other season to split the prize money after??? 

Yes.  Mark Long is basically the George Washington of the show and The Miz is legitimately the biggest star the show ever produced.  He was THE guy on the show for years and always performed well.  He'd probably be the first person I'd put on Mt. Rushmore and the first person I'd cast on this show after Mark.  But he said he couldn't do it.

Why not put jamie Chung and Theo Von then on if it's just who is most successful post show? 

 

 

 

 

the best performance in challenge history is darrell AND Aviv's final (aviv deserves a lot of credit for the puzzles). They couldnt even pretend it was close they beat Tina and Kenny by like 3 hours 

Landon FM2 period. Absolutely no debate.

There actually is a debate but I wont spend 5 pages arguing with you about it lol. 

His partner was not as bad as people made her out to be. 

Give that partner to Darrell on that same final and he wouldn't win a final. Aviv was good at his weakness based on clips I saw.

I disagree, he still wins the FM2 final, Kenny and Laurel did not perform as well on that final as they did all season. But Aviv was a really good partner for him.  

actually i think it was just Laurel that really slowed them down, she gassed out hard. granted had Kenny tried to be motivating like Landon instead of screaming at her they would've won (IMO)

 

 

 

 

Surprised Alton isn't getting more love. 

Im not one of them but a lot of people have him on their Challenge mount rushmore 

Alton's Gauntlet 2 performance is potentially the greatest performance in the show's history just in terms of how much he basically carried the team and led them to the win, but outside of that he's been good but I don't see how you'd put him on Mt. Rushmore.  I mean personally Mt. Rushmore (at least for guys) would almost universally have to be Mark, The Miz, CT, and Bananas.  I don't really know who else you'd swap out for that.

You really have THE MIZ over Darrell on your Mount Rushmore??? And Mark Long who quits every other season to split the prize money after??? 

Yes.  Mark Long is basically the George Washington of the show and The Miz is legitimately the biggest star the show ever produced.  He was THE guy on the show for years and always performed well.  He'd probably be the first person I'd put on Mt. Rushmore and the first person I'd cast on this show after Mark.  But he said he couldn't do it.

Why not put jamie Chung and Theo Von then on if it's just who is most successful post show? 

Cuz neither of those 2 were ever the face of the show and the latter basically despises the fact that he came from MTV.  The Miz doesn't hide or pretend he didn't start there.

Like The Miz in a certain environment could actually have done this show or hosted it or something.  Theo Von would NEVER have done it no matter what they paid him.

 

 

 

 

the best performance in challenge history is darrell AND Aviv's final (aviv deserves a lot of credit for the puzzles). They couldnt even pretend it was close they beat Tina and Kenny by like 3 hours 

Landon FM2 period. Absolutely no debate.

There actually is a debate but I wont spend 5 pages arguing with you about it lol. 

His partner was not as bad as people made her out to be. 

Give that partner to Darrell on that same final and he wouldn't win a final. Aviv was good at his weakness based on clips I saw.

I disagree, he still wins the FM2 final, Kenny and Laurel did not perform as well on that final as they did all season. But Aviv was a really good partner for him.  

Yeah no lol It would have ended the same way it ended with Cara Maria the first time they were partners

Jenny and Tori for My Rushmore!

Pages

Topic locked