The Challenge: All Stars (Season 1)- Spoilers Discussion

7437 posts / 0 new
Last post

 

It's so weird to me looking at a cast list and the only two female champs are Katie and Kendal lol

I think KellyAnne and Darrell have probably the best chance to win if it's a straight up individual game. But they'll probably do some weird format per usual.

I didn't realize that KellyAnne has actually done seasons with a few of the other cast members - Derrick (twice -Ruins, The Island), Katie (The Ruins), Darrell (The Ruins), & Aneesa (Bloodlines).  Did she have good relationships with any of them on those seasons?  The Ruins I felt like she was more centered around Wes, Dunbar and Sarah so I don't remember much about how she interacted on the others those four.  

Her and Derrick never seemed to work together (though apparently they hooked up according to KVM lol)

Her and Darrell clashed and actually got into a big fight (Darrell made the "you can't turn a hoe into a housewife" comment about her to Wes)

And Aneesa and her had that drink throwing incident on Bloodlines lol

So no, not the best with any but I think that her and Aneesa are actually friends now

lol forgot about those moments 

I feel like I can't even think of who might win, especially for the women, until we know the format. Cause some of the guys could take any girl to a win, some pairs wouldn't work together, teams would open up opportunities for a lot of winners, and individual could mean that because of the limited amount of people, all it'd take is for one upset win in a challenge and two strong men or friends can be put in together.

Im actually really excited to know the format.

I HIGHLY doubt its pairs until maybe it gets down to 8-10 people.

 

Do you think production really wants to be losing a guy and girl every episode vs. just one person a week in a 1 hour episode knowing we've barely seen any of these people in years? 

I bet each episode is a challenge vote and one guy goes home, next episode same but girl goes home.. then after 10 people go home its a team final (or) they split them into pairs. 

Umm who create the purple poster for this thread bc none of those are on this season unfortunately. Those 6 are who I wanted to see on this.

I HIGHLY doubt its pairs until maybe it gets down to 8-10 people.

 

Do you think production really wants to be losing a guy and girl every episode vs. just one person a week in a 1 hour episode knowing we've barely seen any of these people in years? 

I bet each episode is a challenge vote and one guy goes home, next episode same but girl goes home.. then after 10 people go home its a team final (or) they split them into pairs. 

Its actually a good opportunity to do something I wanted to see years ago. Start as two teams, few people get eliminated, then break into pairs, a few pairs go home, then one or two rounds of individual then the final.

Do you think production really wants to be losing a guy and girl every episode

I mean they only have 2 weeks to film so maybe lol

I feel like I can't even think of who might win, especially for the women, until we know the format. Cause some of the guys could take any girl to a win, some pairs wouldn't work together, teams would open up opportunities for a lot of winners, and individual could mean that because of the limited amount of people, all it'd take is for one upset win in a challenge and two strong men or friends can be put in together.

Im actually really excited to know the format.

oh ya, format is gonna have a huge pull in how these people do. But just speaking on general ability/shape that they'r'e in, I would say KellyAnne is the frontrunner, followed by probably Ruthie, Kendal, Trishelle, Beth, etc.

Umm who create the purple poster for this thread bc none of those are on this season unfortunately. Those 6 are who I wanted to see on this.

Three of those people we see regularly, one is someone who should've been on this but has been playing bullshit games for years, and the other two are Laurel and Jordan who would stick out worse than Jemmye and Cooke (arguably).

 

Do you think production really wants to be losing a guy and girl every episode

I mean they only have 2 weeks to film so maybe lol

And on the main show can't they only do 2 eliminations a week unless they do doubles? Assuming it's the same for this in a 2 week filming period we'd only get 4 total eliminations, which isn't happening

My rankings based on physicality (granted, haven't seen most of these people so my assumptions could be way off), and how well I think they have the potential to do.

1. Kellyanne

2. Ruthie

3. Trishelle

4. Kendal

5. Jonna/Beth (I have no idea what shape Beth is in, but she's always been in good shape and pretty strong. I think the pregnancy weight on Jonna suits her extremely well and it'll make her better overall).

6. Katie

7. Aneesa

8. Jemmye

9. Arissa

10. Jisela

 

1. Derrick

2. Darrell

3. Nehemiah

4. Mark

5. Alton

6. Ace

7. Laterrian

8. Yes

9. Syrus

10. Teck

11. Thats all

Agreed with your rankings except I'd probably switch Derrick and Darrell. Derrick is hungrier for it cause he's a loser that can't move on but Darrell is still overall better imo

 

Do you think production really wants to be losing a guy and girl every episode

I mean they only have 2 weeks to film so maybe lol

No one is going to give a shit about the show unless we get to know about 80% of the contestants vs. 2 random people leaving each week as they stuff in a challenge, strategy, elimination etc in an hour.

 

We barely get any character development on the main challenge at 1.5 hours, if they are smart it will be one person leaving an episode. Who cares if its' a big team final at the end? Those are the most fun anyway. 

 

 

Do you think production really wants to be losing a guy and girl every episode

I mean they only have 2 weeks to film so maybe lol

And on the main show can't they only do 2 eliminations a week unless they do doubles? Assuming it's the same for this in a 2 week filming period we'd only get 4 total eliminations, which isn't happening

I could see them squeezing in 3 eliminations a week, so 6 people go home (3 guys 3 girls) do a purge right before the final (another 2-4 go home) then a final.

 

The Champs Pros final had a purge right before the final and like half the people went home... not my favorite thing but it's not that difficult.

 

How long did Champs v Pros film? That's a pretty good format imo they can just copy.

 

 

Do you think production really wants to be losing a guy and girl every episode

I mean they only have 2 weeks to film so maybe lol

No one is going to give a shit about the show unless we get to know about 80% of the contestants vs. 2 random people leaving each week as they stuff in a challenge, strategy, elimination etc in an hour.

 

We barely get any character development on the main challenge at 1.5 hours, if they are smart it will be one person leaving an episode. Who cares if its' a big team final at the end? Those are the most fun anyway. 

I'm just being realistic. Production of this show takes time and they only have like 2-2.5 weeks for this. I highly doubt they're gonna have time to do 14 challenges and 14 separate girl/guy eliminations as that would literally be a challenge AND elimination every single day lol

My guess is that this is a team challenge and they'll have like 6 challenges and 6 elimination days. Even that is pushing it as it would be day 1: challenge, day 2: elimination, etc. I'm expecting challenges and eliminations to be simple because of the time frame

 

 

 

Do you think production really wants to be losing a guy and girl every episode

I mean they only have 2 weeks to film so maybe lol

No one is going to give a shit about the show unless we get to know about 80% of the contestants vs. 2 random people leaving each week as they stuff in a challenge, strategy, elimination etc in an hour.

 

We barely get any character development on the main challenge at 1.5 hours, if they are smart it will be one person leaving an episode. Who cares if its' a big team final at the end? Those are the most fun anyway. 

I'm just being realistic. Production of this show takes time and they only have like 2-2.5 weeks for this. I highly doubt they're gonna have time to do 14 challenges and 14 separate girl/guy eliminations as that would literally be a challenge AND elimination every single day lol

My guess is that this is a team challenge and they'll have like 6 challenges and 6 elimination days. Even that is pushing it as it would be day 1: challenge, day 2: elimination, etc. I'm expecting challenges and eliminations to be simple because of the time frame

i already said in the next post, 3 eliminations a week (6 in total) . Not 14. And I believe the Champs Pros spinoff ended up doing a challenge/elimination in the same day every episode. 

Agreed. Team Challenge, 6 days each day is a challenge and elimination.. weekends do interviews.  All these people know the drill of these shows anyway so its not like the pros or "stars" who probably had bigger egos than most of the challengers about doing so much every day. 

I just want to see Big Easy's worthless self pop up on that eliminated list asap plz

Jonna and Darrell gettin this easy dub.

Derrick been training 3 years for this so I hope he gets knocked out early

 

 

 

 

Do you think production really wants to be losing a guy and girl every episode

I mean they only have 2 weeks to film so maybe lol

No one is going to give a shit about the show unless we get to know about 80% of the contestants vs. 2 random people leaving each week as they stuff in a challenge, strategy, elimination etc in an hour.

 

We barely get any character development on the main challenge at 1.5 hours, if they are smart it will be one person leaving an episode. Who cares if its' a big team final at the end? Those are the most fun anyway. 

I'm just being realistic. Production of this show takes time and they only have like 2-2.5 weeks for this. I highly doubt they're gonna have time to do 14 challenges and 14 separate girl/guy eliminations as that would literally be a challenge AND elimination every single day lol

My guess is that this is a team challenge and they'll have like 6 challenges and 6 elimination days. Even that is pushing it as it would be day 1: challenge, day 2: elimination, etc. I'm expecting challenges and eliminations to be simple because of the time frame

i already said in the next post, 3 eliminations a week (6 in total) . Not 14. And I believe the Champs Pros spinoff ended up doing a challenge/elimination in the same day every episode. 

Agreed. Team Challenge, 6 days each day is a challenge and elimination.. weekends do interviews.  All these people know the drill of these shows anyway so its not like the pros or "stars" who probably had bigger egos than most of the challengers about doing so much every day. 

yeah misunderstood your first post my bad.

I'm actually looking forward to the simplier missions. Sometimes they really do the most for the production value of the main show that they lose the actual competition aspect (i.e. dropping boxes out of a helicopter for the final leg of the endurance mission on TM)

Jonna and Darrell gettin this easy dub.

Derrick been training 3 years for this so I hope he gets knocked out early

Actually on second thought I would absolutely love to see Derrick's name pop up as an early boot. It's probably not going to happen but it would be hilarious 

Derrick is really going to act like this is the Olympics smh lol

 

 

Do you think production really wants to be losing a guy and girl every episode

I mean they only have 2 weeks to film so maybe lol

And on the main show can't they only do 2 eliminations a week unless they do doubles? Assuming it's the same for this in a 2 week filming period we'd only get 4 total eliminations, which isn't happening

I was looking through old threads and The duel 2 was quick filming October 30- December 4 and the cast was bigger lol

 

 

 

Do you think production really wants to be losing a guy and girl every episode

I mean they only have 2 weeks to film so maybe lol

And on the main show can't they only do 2 eliminations a week unless they do doubles? Assuming it's the same for this in a 2 week filming period we'd only get 4 total eliminations, which isn't happening

I was looking through old threads and The duel 2 was quick filming October 30- December 4 and the cast was bigger lol

I feel like I remember the spoilers for that season, eliminated names popped up left and right.

 

 

 

 

Do you think production really wants to be losing a guy and girl every episode

I mean they only have 2 weeks to film so maybe lol

And on the main show can't they only do 2 eliminations a week unless they do doubles? Assuming it's the same for this in a 2 week filming period we'd only get 4 total eliminations, which isn't happening

I was looking through old threads and The duel 2 was quick filming October 30- December 4 and the cast was bigger lol

I feel like I remember the spoilers for that season, eliminated names popped up left and right.

I wasn't around then lol But I was just looking through old threads seems like filming were way short it got expand during dirty 30

I hope Beth eliminates Jemmye lmaoooooo

Beth vs Jemmye reverse tug of war love to see it 

I hope Jemmye is the first boot 

Would love any boot list similar to this 

1 Jemmye/Eric

2 Jonna/Derrick

3 Jisela/ Ace

4 Arissa/Teck

5 Aneesa/Mark

6 Trishelle/ LT

7 Katie /  Alton

8 Beth / Cyrus

Final

Kendal,Ruthie, Kelly Anne

Darrell, Nehemiah, Yes

Veronica spending her excess time planning beths downfall instead of just accepting and doing it herself 

I hope Beth knows about Jemmyes fear of ketchup and squirts it all over her and in her bed LMAO

 

Derrick K is overrated hit me up when he finally wins one without a team 

Derrick's a great competitor.  He's arguably the dumbest person to be on the show before Cory showed up so he's not going to win an individual season if there's a puzzle.  See XXX but the man doesn't quit.  Ever.

Derrick is great but he's at number 10 for me possibly outside the top 10 ive seen so many lists with him in the top 5 which I think is insane 

Yeah, definitely not top 5 ever (Landon, Alton, Darrell, sadly Jordan are all obvious without getting into JEK and the rest of the golden era)

Im starting to think Darrell is a little overrated, I have been watching so,e old seasons and I think Evan has to be up there since he dominated the challenges, he was just as good as CT on duel 1.

Pages

Topic locked