The Challenge: All Stars (Season 1)- Spoilers Discussion

I think Sophia would do well on the actual show. 

she would not i am so sorry to say it

 

Just realized Cooke is probably going to dominate this unless it's carnival games looking at the girls side.. 

Exactly **** I do see them giving her a second shot on the main show especially since she is back on their radar

This or having vote outs instead of eliminations but a lot of the entertaining people are disliked by most of the cast. 

I think Sophia would do well on the actual show. 

***** shut up lol

if the daily is like reading out of the hippie bible she wil do well yeah.

I love Ayanna and Piggy but there's no way they would be contacted for another show.

why is jay on twitter trashing the og show when it HASNT EVEN STARTED YET

 

Because he clearly is a newer/ish fan and doesn't know the legends that are on this. When Cooke is your fav female listed you know this show isn't meant for you.. it's people like that, that will ruin this show. They think people like Ashley Mitchell is an OG... 

pinkrose do you agree with jay that this will be a snoozefest

see that's why i don't like Derrick on here, i don't actually want anybody on here to play with the intention of "showing out" to producers because they desperately want to get on the main show.

like i'll be able to smell that desperate energy a mile a way. everything doesn't have to be a stepping stone just play. they're not gonna pick you anyway 

ugh throwback to him acting up on the vendettas reunion <<< 

Still dead at Nelson popping him and getting a call back every season after 

Just realized Cooke is probably going to dominate this unless it's carnival games looking at the girls side.. 

this is the main reason I don't want her on. Aneesa, Beth, Kendal, Kellyanne, Trishelle, Ruthie and Jonna are all on the same level. Katie, Jemmye, Sophia, Arissa right below them. Idk what Casey is like now that she's older but Jisela is definitely the weakest 

Whose idea was it to contact Emily Schromm and Cooke for this? 

 

Just realized Cooke is probably going to dominate this unless it's carnival games looking at the girls side.. 

this is the main reason I don't want her on. Aneesa, Beth, Kendal, Kellyanne, Trishelle, Ruthie and Jonna are all on the same level. Katie, Jemmye, Sophia, Arissa right below them. Idk what Casey is like now that she's older but Jisela is definitely the weakest 

Yeah besides her the female side is a toss up. I'd put it as:

Cooke

KellyAnne, Ruthie

Jonna, Aneesa, Kendal, Trishelle, Katie, Beth (just cause she's the oldest here I don't see her performing like she used to, maybe I'm wrong)

Sophia, Arissa, Jemmye, Casey, Jisela

Basically anyone has a shot to win except those last 5 imo if they get Cooke out

 

 

 

Just realized Cooke is probably going to dominate this unless it's carnival games looking at the girls side.. 

this is the main reason I don't want her on. Aneesa, Beth, Kendal, Kellyanne, Trishelle, Ruthie and Jonna are all on the same level. Katie, Jemmye, Sophia, Arissa right below them. Idk what Casey is like now that she's older but Jisela is definitely the weakest 

Yeah besides her the female side is a toss up. I'd put it as:

Cooke

KellyAnne, Ruthie

Jonna, Aneesa, Kendal, Trishelle, Katie, Beth (just cause she's the oldest here I don't see her performing like she used to, maybe I'm wrong)

Sophia, Arissa, Jemmye, Casey, Jisela

Basically anyone has a shot to win except those last 5 imo if they get Cooke out

 

Ruthie was good back in the day? Because on the Duel 2 she was a flop. Kim is tiny and send her *** home.

She was a top performer on some seasons. But in anything physical she's probably going home 

 

pinkrose do you agree with jay that this will be a snoozefest

I don't like stating assumptions as facts especially on something that hasn't even film. On paper it may not sound the most exciting but maybe these people bring their A games.

feels like jay has some type of agenda for why they're already trashing it and people dont even realize it hasnt started. like they want to see it flop. 

or just a casual idk. I hope it turns out good, its great to see a lot of these people back 

Ruthie ran BOTS from what I remember. Had the guys not cheated on the puzzle in the final the woman would have won BOTS 1. 

if this is individual i think she'll be a lock for the finals. smart as **** 

Ruthie was good back in the day? Because on the Duel 2 she was a flop. Kim is tiny and send her *** home.

On Sexes Ruthie was easily the best female and better than most of the men.   She was very solid on Sexes 2 and Gauntlet 2 as well.   Beth just destroyed her in Reverse Tug O war because, well, Beth ways a lot more.   Ruthie did win a mission on Duel 2--Kim was way smarter than Ruthie to the point they had to change the rules of the elimination after Kim won  lol

Ruthie will lose a physical elimination to a bigger girl but she does well in daily challenges.

Ruthie will lose a physical elimination to a bigger girl but she does well in daily challenges.

depending on the format i dont even see her getting thrown into an elimination unless they continue that dumb skull twist

The girls team kept Sophia in the game because she was good at puzzles. 

 

Just realized Cooke is probably going to dominate this unless it's carnival games looking at the girls side.. 

Exactly **** I do see them giving her a second shot on the main show especially since she is back on their radar

but is she open to do the main show?

Pink/Challenge 13, do you think it's going to be 4 alts per gender then? 

They really should tell them ahead of time if they're an alt or not. Getting them to go with the hope they're on the season only to send them home is kinda cruel imo lol

 

 

Just realized Cooke is probably going to dominate this unless it's carnival games looking at the girls side.. 

this is the main reason I don't want her on. Aneesa, Beth, Kendal, Kellyanne, Trishelle, Ruthie and Jonna are all on the same level. Katie, Jemmye, Sophia, Arissa right below them. Idk what Casey is like now that she's older but Jisela is definitely the weakest 

Yeah besides her the female side is a toss up. I'd put it as:

Cooke

KellyAnne, Ruthie

Jonna, Aneesa, Kendal, Trishelle, Katie, Beth (just cause she's the oldest here I don't see her performing like she used to, maybe I'm wrong)

Sophia, Arissa, Jemmye, Casey, Jisela

Basically anyone has a shot to win except those last 5 imo if they get Cooke out

 

.....why do you have Sophia with Jemmye, Casey and them lol

 

 

 

Just realized Cooke is probably going to dominate this unless it's carnival games looking at the girls side.. 

this is the main reason I don't want her on. Aneesa, Beth, Kendal, Kellyanne, Trishelle, Ruthie and Jonna are all on the same level. Katie, Jemmye, Sophia, Arissa right below them. Idk what Casey is like now that she's older but Jisela is definitely the weakest 

Yeah besides her the female side is a toss up. I'd put it as:

Cooke

KellyAnne, Ruthie

Jonna, Aneesa, Kendal, Trishelle, Katie, Beth (just cause she's the oldest here I don't see her performing like she used to, maybe I'm wrong)

Sophia, Arissa, Jemmye, Casey, Jisela

Basically anyone has a shot to win except those last 5 imo if they get Cooke out

 

.....why do you have Sophia with Jemmye, Casey and them lol

 

.....why do you have Sophia with Jemmye, Casey and them lol

I would probably have put her a tier above back in the day but I don't really see her doing much with how much time has passed. Similar to how I would probably have ranked Beth higher.

wait i just realized something:

Arissa, Sophia and Ruthie all made F4 in Battle of Sexes 2.. which was a game built on pregame alliances, loyalty never changed

Umm.. if they are all on the final cast they can easily run the whole game. just saying. 

wait i just realized something:

Arissa, Sophia and Ruthie all made F4 in Battle of Sexes 2.. which was a game built on pregame alliances, loyalty never changed

 

Umm.. if they are all on the final cast they can easily run the whole game. just saying. 

3 people isn't "running the whole game" lol

Obviously Derrick and Mark are going to work together and probably did a whole lot of pregame scheming 

As for the girls, no one seems really tied to each other with the exception of those 3, but KA has Nehemiah, Cohutta, and then Ace/Abram by proxy. 

 

 

.....why do you have Sophia with Jemmye, Casey and them lol

I would probably have put her a tier above back in the day but I don't really see her doing much with how much time has passed. Similar to how I would probably have ranked Beth higher.

Understandable, I personally wouldn't rank her bottom tier but who knows how any of these people perform now