The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

16669 posts / 0 new
Last post

I don't mind having a "weak" cast as long as they're entertaining. I would rather have someone like Anastasia who isn't that strong but is entertaining than someone like Emily who is elite but is a bore to watch. 

I agree. I'm not going to care if someone is strong or a good competitor if that person is boring or a terrible piece of shit.

I don't mind having a "weak" cast as long as they're entertaining. I would rather have someone like Anastasia who isn't that strong but is entertaining than someone like Emily who is elite but is a bore to watch. 

I agree. I'm not going to care if someone is strong or a good competitor if that person is boring or a terrible piece of shit.

i loved that cast actually lol 

Thanks for the love guys haha

Battle of the Seasons 3 Las Vegas 2-Leroy/Cooke/Nany/Dustin San Diego 1-Brad/Cameron/Robin/Randy Portland-Marlon/Nia/Avery/Johnny Las Vegas 1-Frank/Trishelle/Arissa/Alton Ex-plosion-Cory/Jamie/Arielle/Brian Road Rules-Abram/Katie/Susie/Derrick Skeletons-Tony/Sylvia/Violetta/Jason Sydney-Cohutta/Kellyanne/Trisha/Issac

Battle of the Seasons 3 Las Vegas 2-Leroy/Cooke/Nany/Dustin San Diego 1-Brad/Cameron/Robin/Randy Portland-Marlon/Nia/Avery/Johnny Las Vegas 1-Frank/Trishelle/Arissa/Alton Ex-plosion-Cory/Jamie/Arielle/Brian Road Rules-Abram/Katie/Susie/Derrick Skeletons-Tony/Sylvia/Violetta/Jason Sydney-Cohutta/Kellyanne/Trisha/Issac

This would be awesome! 

The Challenge: The Duel 3

Males

Abram Boise (South Pacific)

Scott Herman (Brooklyn)

CJ Koegel (Cancun)

Leroy Garett (Las Vegas 2)

Frank Sweeney (San Diego 2)

Robb Shrieber (St.Thomas)

Trey Weatherholtz (St.Thomas)

Marlon Williams (Portland)

Cory Wharton (Ex-Plosion)

Brian Williams Jr (Ex-Plosion)

Adam Kuhn (AYTO?)

Tony Raines (Skeletons)

Shane Raines (Bloodlines)

Tyler Pratt (AYTO?2)

 

Females 

Cara Maria Sorbello (Fresh Meat 2)

Camila Nakagawa (Spring Break Challenge)

Nany Gonzalez (Las Vegas 2)

Marie Roda (St.Thomas)

LaToya Jackson (St.Thomas)

Nia Moore (Portland)

Averey Tressler (Portland)

Jenna Compono (Ex-Plosion)

Ashley Mitchell (Ex-Plosion)

Shanley McIntee (AYTO?)

Sylvia Elsrode (Skeletons)

Violetta Milerman (Skeletons)

Paris Eike (AYTO?2)

Rianna Valentine (Bloodlines)

I like it. Averey, LaToya, Marie, Nany, Nia, Sylvia and Violetta together would be amazing. 

The Challenge: The Duel 3

Males

Abram Boise (South Pacific)

Scott Herman (Brooklyn)

CJ Koegel (Cancun)

Leroy Garett (Las Vegas 2)

Frank Sweeney (San Diego 2)

Robb Shrieber (St.Thomas)

Trey Weatherholtz (St.Thomas)

Marlon Williams (Portland)

Cory Wharton (Ex-Plosion)

Brian Williams Jr (Ex-Plosion)

Adam Kuhn (AYTO?)

Tony Raines (Skeletons)

Shane Raines (Bloodlines)

Tyler Pratt (AYTO?2)

 

Females 

Cara Maria Sorbello (Fresh Meat 2)

Camila Nakagawa (Spring Break Challenge)

Nany Gonzalez (Las Vegas 2)

Marie Roda (St.Thomas)

LaToya Jackson (St.Thomas)

Nia Moore (Portland)

Averey Tressler (Portland)

Jenna Compono (Ex-Plosion)

Ashley Mitchell (Ex-Plosion)

Shanley McIntee (AYTO?)

Sylvia Elsrode (Skeletons)

Violetta Milerman (Skeletons)

Paris Eike (AYTO?2)

Rianna Valentine (Bloodlines)

Great Cast!

I don't mind having a "weak" cast as long as they're entertaining. I would rather have someone like Anastasia who isn't that strong but is entertaining than someone like Emily who is elite but is a bore to watch. 


Losers Anastasia aren't going to make it past episode 1 she only did because it was a guys day.
This is a duel the reason people want a duel 3 is to see great competitors battle it out individual for once

Abe, CJ, Frank, Leroy, Marlon are weak cast?
Cara Maria, Camilla, Nia, Nany, Averey, Marie are weak?

I didn't think it was bad either.

A Duel doesn't have to be "best of the best."


It should be especially now with all the damn partner challenges.
There are what three old school people which makes it a hell of a lot worse.

Abe, CJ, Frank, Leroy, Marlon are weak cast? Cara Maria, Camilla, Nia, Nany, Averey, Marie are weak?
I didn't think it was bad either. A Duel doesn't have to be "best of the best."
It should be especially now with all the damn partner challenges. There are what three old school people which makes it a hell of a lot worse.

How does it make it worse? I mean there's not going to be alot of old-schoolers there anyways.

Abe, CJ, Frank, Leroy, Marlon are weak cast? Cara Maria, Camilla, Nia, Nany, Averey, Marie are weak?
I didn't think it was bad either. A Duel doesn't have to be "best of the best."
It should be especially now with all the damn partner challenges. There are what three old school people which makes it a hell of a lot worse.

How does it make it worse? I mean there's not going to be alot of old-schoolers there anyways.


There's literally 3 people pre 2010.... that's pathetic.

Abe, CJ, Frank, Leroy, Marlon are weak cast? Cara Maria, Camilla, Nia, Nany, Averey, Marie are weak?
I didn't think it was bad either. A Duel doesn't have to be "best of the best."
It should be especially now with all the damn partner challenges. There are what three old school people which makes it a hell of a lot worse.

How does it make it worse? I mean there's not going to be alot of old-schoolers there anyways.

There's literally 3 people pre 2010.... that's pathetic.

But...Why? It's not a requirment for veterans/old-schoolers to be there.

Abe, CJ, Frank, Leroy, Marlon are weak cast? Cara Maria, Camilla, Nia, Nany, Averey, Marie are weak?
I didn't think it was bad either. A Duel doesn't have to be "best of the best."
It should be especially now with all the damn partner challenges. There are what three old school people which makes it a hell of a lot worse.

How does it make it worse? I mean there's not going to be alot of old-schoolers there anyways.

There's literally 3 people pre 2010.... that's pathetic.

But...Why? It's not a requirment for veterans/old-schoolers to be there.


They should be especially on something like a duel. The format most old schools want. I'm shocked you like that cast with all the non cast members ayto losers and bloodlines.

Abe, CJ, Frank, Leroy, Marlon are weak cast? Cara Maria, Camilla, Nia, Nany, Averey, Marie are weak?
I didn't think it was bad either. A Duel doesn't have to be "best of the best."
It should be especially now with all the damn partner challenges. There are what three old school people which makes it a hell of a lot worse.

How does it make it worse? I mean there's not going to be alot of old-schoolers there anyways.

There's literally 3 people pre 2010.... that's pathetic.

But...Why? It's not a requirment for veterans/old-schoolers to be there.

They should be especially on something like a duel. The format most old schools want. I'm shocked you like that cast with all the non cast members ayto losers and bloodlines.

They aren't THAT many of them. It's mostly Rw'ers so it's good.

And it really doesn't matter if old-schoolers want a duel. That doesn't automatically mean they should be on it. Besides those old-schoolers probably already were on the first two seasons anyways and if not they were able to show what they were made of in another challenge. Honestly  I think it would be really nice to see the current crop of challengers be on their own completly for once. That's more interesting to me than seeing tired *** old-schoolers compete for the umptenth time.

The Challenge: The Duel 3

Males

Abram Boise (South Pacific)

Scott Herman (Brooklyn)

CJ Koegel (Cancun)

Leroy Garett (Las Vegas 2)

Frank Sweeney (San Diego 2)

Robb Shrieber (St.Thomas)

Trey Weatherholtz (St.Thomas)

Marlon Williams (Portland)

Cory Wharton (Ex-Plosion)

Brian Williams Jr (Ex-Plosion)

Adam Kuhn (AYTO?)

Tony Raines (Skeletons)

Shane Raines (Bloodlines)

Tyler Pratt (AYTO?2)

 

Females 

Cara Maria Sorbello (Fresh Meat 2)

Camila Nakagawa (Spring Break Challenge)

Nany Gonzalez (Las Vegas 2)

Marie Roda (St.Thomas)

LaToya Jackson (St.Thomas)

Nia Moore (Portland)

Averey Tressler (Portland)

Jenna Compono (Ex-Plosion)

Ashley Mitchell (Ex-Plosion)

Shanley McIntee (AYTO?)

Sylvia Elsrode (Skeletons)

Violetta Milerman (Skeletons)

Paris Eike (AYTO?2)

Rianna Valentine (Bloodlines)

Great Cast!

Thanks!

The Challenge: Cutthroat 2

Four Teams of 8

Team Black

Abram (RR: South Pacific)

Cory (RW: Ex-Plosion)

Derrick (RR: X-Treme)

Frank S. (RW: Back to San Diego)

Averey (RW: Portland)

Beth (RW: Los Angeles)

Coral (RW: Back to New York)

Nany (RW: Back to Las Vegas)

Team Blue

Bruno (RW: Skeletons)

Darrell (RR: Campus Crawl)

Dustin (RW: Back to Las Vegas)

Zach (RW: Back to San Diego)

Ashley K. (RW: Back to San Diego)

Heather M. (RW: Back to Las Vegas)

Sylvia (RW: Skeletons)

Rachel R. (RR: Campus Crawl)

Team Grey

Brian (RW: Ex-Plosion)

Frank R. (RW: Las Vegas)

Ryan C. (RW: Brooklyn)

Wes (RW: Austin)

Brittini (RW: Hollywood)

KellyAnne (RW: Sydney)

LaToya (RW: St. Thomas)

Ruthie (RW: Hawaii)

Team Red

CJ (RW: Cancun)

Jordan (RW: Portland)

Robb (RW: St. Thomas)

Scott (RW: Brooklyn)

Cooke (RW: Back to Las Vegas)

Marie (RW: St. Thomas) 

Nia (RW: Portland)

Violetta (RW: Skeletons)

Abe, CJ, Frank, Leroy, Marlon are weak cast? Cara Maria, Camilla, Nia, Nany, Averey, Marie are weak?
I didn't think it was bad either. A Duel doesn't have to be "best of the best."
It should be especially now with all the damn partner challenges. There are what three old school people which makes it a hell of a lot worse.

How does it make it worse? I mean there's not going to be alot of old-schoolers there anyways.

There's literally 3 people pre 2010.... that's pathetic.

But...Why? It's not a requirment for veterans/old-schoolers to be there.

They should be especially on something like a duel. The format most old schools want. I'm shocked you like that cast with all the non cast members ayto losers and bloodlines.

They aren't THAT many of them. It's mostly Rw'ers so it's good.

And it really doesn't matter if old-schoolers want a duel. That doesn't automatically mean they should be on it. Besides those old-schoolers probably already were on the first two seasons anyways and if not they were able to show what they were made of in another challenge. Honestly  I think it would be really nice to see the current crop of challengers be on their own completly for once. That's more interesting to me than seeing tired *** old-schoolers compete for the umptenth time.


Old school doesn't have to mean that....
There are plenty of people who aren't "tired" replace the ayto losers with Kelly Anne Beth Cohutta and Derrick And its much better.

I didn't put Beth because cmon, the girls existence on reality is long gone. Derrick has his crazy wife so it's unrealistic for him to be on. Kelly Anne is close to elite so I decided to not include her. And Cohutta wouldn't do well in a duel format so why put him. I wanted a fresh cast so new alliances could be formed and new winners.

Abe, CJ, Frank, Leroy, Marlon are weak cast? Cara Maria, Camilla, Nia, Nany, Averey, Marie are weak?
I didn't think it was bad either. A Duel doesn't have to be "best of the best."
It should be especially now with all the damn partner challenges. There are what three old school people which makes it a hell of a lot worse.

How does it make it worse? I mean there's not going to be alot of old-schoolers there anyways.

There's literally 3 people pre 2010.... that's pathetic.

But...Why? It's not a requirment for veterans/old-schoolers to be there.

They should be especially on something like a duel. The format most old schools want. I'm shocked you like that cast with all the non cast members ayto losers and bloodlines.

They aren't THAT many of them. It's mostly Rw'ers so it's good.

And it really doesn't matter if old-schoolers want a duel. That doesn't automatically mean they should be on it. Besides those old-schoolers probably already were on the first two seasons anyways and if not they were able to show what they were made of in another challenge. Honestly  I think it would be really nice to see the current crop of challengers be on their own completly for once. That's more interesting to me than seeing tired *** old-schoolers compete for the umptenth time.

Old school doesn't have to mean that.... There are plenty of people who aren't "tired" replace the ayto losers with Kelly Anne Beth Cohutta and Derrick And its much better.

I don't even consider Cohutta and Kellyanne Old-school. I love Beth but she is tired and doesn't need to come on anymore. Same with Derrick. The guy has done 9 challenges and has done about all he is going to do on this show. No need for him to be on.

 

Abe, CJ, Frank, Leroy, Marlon are weak cast? Cara Maria, Camilla, Nia, Nany, Averey, Marie are weak?
I didn't think it was bad either. A Duel doesn't have to be "best of the best."
It should be especially now with all the damn partner challenges. There are what three old school people which makes it a hell of a lot worse.

How does it make it worse? I mean there's not going to be alot of old-schoolers there anyways.

There's literally 3 people pre 2010.... that's pathetic.

But...Why? It's not a requirment for veterans/old-schoolers to be there.

They should be especially on something like a duel. The format most old schools want. I'm shocked you like that cast with all the non cast members ayto losers and bloodlines.

They aren't THAT many of them. It's mostly Rw'ers so it's good.

And it really doesn't matter if old-schoolers want a duel. That doesn't automatically mean they should be on it. Besides those old-schoolers probably already were on the first two seasons anyways and if not they were able to show what they were made of in another challenge. Honestly  I think it would be really nice to see the current crop of challengers be on their own completly for once. That's more interesting to me than seeing tired *** old-schoolers compete for the umptenth time.

Old school doesn't have to mean that.... There are plenty of people who aren't "tired" replace the ayto losers with Kelly Anne Beth Cohutta and Derrick And its much better.

I don't even consider Cohutta and Kellyanne Old-school. I love Beth but she is tired and doesn't need to come on anymore. Same with Derrick. The guy has done 9 challenges and has done about all he is going to do on this show. No need for him to be on.

 


Compared to this cast they are old school.
Fine replace Derrick with Darrell and he destroys this cast

I didn't put Beth because cmon, the girls existence on reality is long gone. Derrick has his crazy wife so it's unrealistic for him to be on. Kelly Anne is close to elite so I decided to not include her. And Cohutta wouldn't do well in a duel format so why put him. I wanted a fresh cast so new alliances could be formed and new winners.


Winning a season like this isn't impressive at all. Winning over a bunch of scrubs isn't anything to brag about.
Realty went out the window when Jenna beat Averey IMO.

I didn't put Beth because cmon, the girls existence on reality is long gone. Derrick has his crazy wife so it's unrealistic for him to be on. Kelly Anne is close to elite so I decided to not include her. And Cohutta wouldn't do well in a duel format so why put him. I wanted a fresh cast so new alliances could be formed and new winners.

And In addition to that he's done 9 challenges already and done all that he's going to do on this show. What is the point of him coming back?

Kellyanne? ehhh I wouldn't even say she is close to elite. I'd say she's slightly above average.

COHUTTA WILL SAY ALL OF THEM!!!!!!!! just kidding lol. I think he would do alright in a duel though.

But I like your thinking..Fresh cast is the way to go!

 

I didn't put Beth because cmon, the girls existence on reality is long gone. Derrick has his crazy wife so it's unrealistic for him to be on. Kelly Anne is close to elite so I decided to not include her. And Cohutta wouldn't do well in a duel format so why put him. I wanted a fresh cast so new alliances could be formed and new winners.

Winning a season like this isn't impressive at all. Winning over a bunch of scrubs isn't anything to brag about. Realty went out the window when Jenna beat Averey IMO.

So bascially you think they're all weak? That explains it.

Frank wins this season without competition.
Marlon & Leroy can't swim, CJ is unproven in finals and last tine he was on Abram was out of shape. The other guys are unproven

Abe, CJ, Frank, Leroy, Marlon are weak cast? Cara Maria, Camilla, Nia, Nany, Averey, Marie are weak?
I didn't think it was bad either. A Duel doesn't have to be "best of the best."
It should be especially now with all the damn partner challenges. There are what three old school people which makes it a hell of a lot worse.

How does it make it worse? I mean there's not going to be alot of old-schoolers there anyways.

There's literally 3 people pre 2010.... that's pathetic.

But...Why? It's not a requirment for veterans/old-schoolers to be there.

They should be especially on something like a duel. The format most old schools want. I'm shocked you like that cast with all the non cast members ayto losers and bloodlines.

They aren't THAT many of them. It's mostly Rw'ers so it's good.

And it really doesn't matter if old-schoolers want a duel. That doesn't automatically mean they should be on it. Besides those old-schoolers probably already were on the first two seasons anyways and if not they were able to show what they were made of in another challenge. Honestly  I think it would be really nice to see the current crop of challengers be on their own completly for once. That's more interesting to me than seeing tired *** old-schoolers compete for the umptenth time.

Old school doesn't have to mean that.... There are plenty of people who aren't "tired" replace the ayto losers with Kelly Anne Beth Cohutta and Derrick And its much better.

I don't even consider Cohutta and Kellyanne Old-school. I love Beth but she is tired and doesn't need to come on anymore. Same with Derrick. The guy has done 9 challenges and has done about all he is going to do on this show. No need for him to be on.

 

Compared to this cast they are old school. Fine replace Derrick with Darrell and he destroys this cast

I guess but I still wouldn't say they're old-school. I consider them mid-school(if that makes sense).

Ehhh. I do want Darrell to return but not on this type of cast.

I didn't put Beth because cmon, the girls existence on reality is long gone. Derrick has his crazy wife so it's unrealistic for him to be on. Kelly Anne is close to elite so I decided to not include her. And Cohutta wouldn't do well in a duel format so why put him. I wanted a fresh cast so new alliances could be formed and new winners.

Winning a season like this isn't impressive at all. Winning over a bunch of scrubs isn't anything to brag about. Realty went out the window when Jenna beat Averey IMO.

I don't know how Jenna would do in an elimination but she is big and she is somewhat athletic. I'd say she performed better than Averey on Exes so I just went off of that.

Frank wins this season without competition. Marlon & Leroy can't swim, CJ is unproven in finals and last tine he was on Abram was out of shape. The other guys are unproven

The challenge isn't all about swimming though. And yes CJ hasn't been a final but you can't just assume he'll suck in one and for all you know Abram is back in shape.

And with the others..well you can't assume they'll all be weak.

I didn't put Beth because cmon, the girls existence on reality is long gone. Derrick has his crazy wife so it's unrealistic for him to be on. Kelly Anne is close to elite so I decided to not include her. And Cohutta wouldn't do well in a duel format so why put him. I wanted a fresh cast so new alliances could be formed and new winners.

Winning a season like this isn't impressive at all. Winning over a bunch of scrubs isn't anything to brag about. Realty went out the window when Jenna beat Averey IMO.

So bascially you think they're all weak? That explains it.


Not all but most of them. Especially girls, Nia sucks at anything high, cara can't swim, Marie is good Averey is good Nany is good Jenna is a quitter. Camila is good. The rest are losers (atyo) or rookies I can't see doing well (violetta)

Abe, CJ, Frank, Leroy, Marlon are weak cast? Cara Maria, Camilla, Nia, Nany, Averey, Marie are weak?
I didn't think it was bad either. A Duel doesn't have to be "best of the best."
It should be especially now with all the damn partner challenges. There are what three old school people which makes it a hell of a lot worse.

How does it make it worse? I mean there's not going to be alot of old-schoolers there anyways.

There's literally 3 people pre 2010.... that's pathetic.

But...Why? It's not a requirment for veterans/old-schoolers to be there.

They should be especially on something like a duel. The format most old schools want. I'm shocked you like that cast with all the non cast members ayto losers and bloodlines.

They aren't THAT many of them. It's mostly Rw'ers so it's good.

And it really doesn't matter if old-schoolers want a duel. That doesn't automatically mean they should be on it. Besides those old-schoolers probably already were on the first two seasons anyways and if not they were able to show what they were made of in another challenge. Honestly  I think it would be really nice to see the current crop of challengers be on their own completly for once. That's more interesting to me than seeing tired *** old-schoolers compete for the umptenth time.

Old school doesn't have to mean that.... There are plenty of people who aren't "tired" replace the ayto losers with Kelly Anne Beth Cohutta and Derrick And its much better.

I don't even consider Cohutta and Kellyanne Old-school. I love Beth but she is tired and doesn't need to come on anymore. Same with Derrick. The guy has done 9 challenges and has done about all he is going to do on this show. No need for him to be on.

 

Compared to this cast they are old school. Fine replace Derrick with Darrell and he destroys this cast

I guess but I still wouldn't say they're old-school. I consider them mid-school(if that makes sense).

Ehhh. I do want Darrell to return but not on this type of cast.


You don't want Darrell because he'd destroy all but Leroy

Frank wins this season without competition. Marlon & Leroy can't swim, CJ is unproven in finals and last tine he was on Abram was out of shape. The other guys are unproven

The challenge isn't all about swimming though. And yes CJ hasn't been a final but you can't just assume he'll suck in one and for all you know Abram is back in shape.

And with the others..well you can't assume they'll all be weak.


I didn't say he would suck, I meant you can't tell if he will be good. Frank us the only one proven in finals.

Pages