Yeah KA has shown a lot, but she also was just flatout demolished by Evelyn. It wasn't even close at all and was hard to watch how much KA was trying to make Evelyn budge and Everything was standing there looking bored. Evelyn is a beast and the best female competitor to date, but it's still fair to point out imo. I would say Camila has a pretty good mental state tho. Despite her meltdowns, she can almost always keep it together (only exception being FA). She can be the outsider and still fight in elimination rounds like Cutthroat and Seasons 2.
Getting demolished by Evelyn doesn't really take away your ability or lessen you as a competitor lol considering Evelyn is basically a dude and Alton couldn't even reel her in when he was in his prime...
That's true which is why I mentioned how great Evelyn is, but if we're gonna technically count that as a win, let's remember what also happened in that elimination round.
I agree with that and that's why I said "technically". I know KA would have lost if Ev tried. The only person who can beat Ev if they were on the same season is Emily. The point I was trying to make is that KA was feared by everyone and none of the girls wanted to go up against her. KA is a beast and is elite in my eyes. I really hope she's on this next challenge.
Yeah KA has shown a lot, but she also was just flatout demolished by Evelyn. It wasn't even close at all and was hard to watch how much KA was trying to make Evelyn budge and Everything was standing there looking bored. Evelyn is a beast and the best female competitor to date, but it's still fair to point out imo. I would say Camila has a pretty good mental state tho. Despite her meltdowns, she can almost always keep it together (only exception being FA). She can be the outsider and still fight in elimination rounds like Cutthroat and Seasons 2.
Getting demolished by Evelyn doesn't really take away your ability or lessen you as a competitor lol considering Evelyn is basically a dude and Alton couldn't even reel her in when he was in his prime...
That's true which is why I mentioned how great Evelyn is, but if we're gonna technically count that as a win, let's remember what also happened in that elimination round.
I wouldn't even count that as a win considering Evelyn let KellyAnne win.
Yeah KA has shown a lot, but she also was just flatout demolished by Evelyn. It wasn't even close at all and was hard to watch how much KA was trying to make Evelyn budge and Everything was standing there looking bored. Evelyn is a beast and the best female competitor to date, but it's still fair to point out imo. I would say Camila has a pretty good mental state tho. Despite her meltdowns, she can almost always keep it together (only exception being FA). She can be the outsider and still fight in elimination rounds like Cutthroat and Seasons 2.
Getting demolished by Evelyn doesn't really take away your ability or lessen you as a competitor lol considering Evelyn is basically a dude and Alton couldn't even reel her in when he was in his prime...
That's true which is why I mentioned how great Evelyn is, but if we're gonna technically count that as a win, let's remember what also happened in that elimination round.
I wouldn't even count that as a win considering Evelyn let KellyAnne win.
I love KellyAnne but I agree.
I can't believe I'm agreeing with Kenny since I can't stand him but he was so on point when he said "What's the point of hurting your friend when you're just gonna let her win anyway? It makes no sense." lol if Evelyn was sick of everyone and wanted to quit, she should've just done that instead of torturing KellyAnne in that elimination.
Yeah KA has shown a lot, but she also was just flatout demolished by Evelyn. It wasn't even close at all and was hard to watch how much KA was trying to make Evelyn budge and Everything was standing there looking bored. Evelyn is a beast and the best female competitor to date, but it's still fair to point out imo. I would say Camila has a pretty good mental state tho. Despite her meltdowns, she can almost always keep it together (only exception being FA). She can be the outsider and still fight in elimination rounds like Cutthroat and Seasons 2.
Getting demolished by Evelyn doesn't really take away your ability or lessen you as a competitor lol considering Evelyn is basically a dude and Alton couldn't even reel her in when he was in his prime...
That's true which is why I mentioned how great Evelyn is, but if we're gonna technically count that as a win, let's remember what also happened in that elimination round.
I agree with that and that's why I said "technically". I know KA would have lost if Ev tried. The only person who can beat Ev if they were on the same season is Emily. The point I was trying to make is that KA was feared by everyone and none of the girls wanted to go up against her. KA is a beast and is elite in my eyes. I really hope she's on this next challenge.
She may have been feared but she slowed Sarah down during that final. I love KellyAnne but she is not on the same level as Ev, Laurel, Emily etc.
Yeah KA has shown a lot, but she also was just flatout demolished by Evelyn. It wasn't even close at all and was hard to watch how much KA was trying to make Evelyn budge and Everything was standing there looking bored. Evelyn is a beast and the best female competitor to date, but it's still fair to point out imo. I would say Camila has a pretty good mental state tho. Despite her meltdowns, she can almost always keep it together (only exception being FA). She can be the outsider and still fight in elimination rounds like Cutthroat and Seasons 2.
Getting demolished by Evelyn doesn't really take away your ability or lessen you as a competitor lol considering Evelyn is basically a dude and Alton couldn't even reel her in when he was in his prime...
That's true which is why I mentioned how great Evelyn is, but if we're gonna technically count that as a win, let's remember what also happened in that elimination round.
I wouldn't even count that as a win considering Evelyn let KellyAnne win.
I love KellyAnne but I agree.
I can't believe I'm agreeing with Kenny since I can't stand him but he was so on point when he said "What's the point of hurting your friend when you're just gonna let her win anyway? It makes no sense." lol if Evelyn was sick of everyone and wanted to quit, she should've just done that instead of torturing KellyAnne in that elimination.
It's because Evelyn was very far up her own *** & she just had to let everybody know she could've won if she wanted to, lest she seemed "weak".
Yeah KA has shown a lot, but she also was just flatout demolished by Evelyn. It wasn't even close at all and was hard to watch how much KA was trying to make Evelyn budge and Everything was standing there looking bored. Evelyn is a beast and the best female competitor to date, but it's still fair to point out imo. I would say Camila has a pretty good mental state tho. Despite her meltdowns, she can almost always keep it together (only exception being FA). She can be the outsider and still fight in elimination rounds like Cutthroat and Seasons 2.
Getting demolished by Evelyn doesn't really take away your ability or lessen you as a competitor lol considering Evelyn is basically a dude and Alton couldn't even reel her in when he was in his prime...
That's true which is why I mentioned how great Evelyn is, but if we're gonna technically count that as a win, let's remember what also happened in that elimination round.
I agree with that and that's why I said "technically". I know KA would have lost if Ev tried. The only person who can beat Ev if they were on the same season is Emily. The point I was trying to make is that KA was feared by everyone and none of the girls wanted to go up against her. KA is a beast and is elite in my eyes. I really hope she's on this next challenge.
She may have been feared but she slowed Sarah down during that final. I love KellyAnne but she is not on the same level as Ev, Laurel, Emily etc.
Emily isn't on that level either. She did average on Cutthroat, decent to good on Exes 1, and had a great showing on Rivals 2. She can't even compare to Laurel who has been the best female on all but one of her seasons and doesn't need to get a fitness guru to do it or the other girls like Rachel, Jodi, Holly S, etc. Even Camila has better stats with great showings on Cutthroat and Exes 1 and doing as well as she could have on Rivals 1/Seasons 2/Rivals 2 given the card she was dealt (bad partners or targeted early).
Yeah KA has shown a lot, but she also was just flatout demolished by Evelyn. It wasn't even close at all and was hard to watch how much KA was trying to make Evelyn budge and Everything was standing there looking bored. Evelyn is a beast and the best female competitor to date, but it's still fair to point out imo. I would say Camila has a pretty good mental state tho. Despite her meltdowns, she can almost always keep it together (only exception being FA). She can be the outsider and still fight in elimination rounds like Cutthroat and Seasons 2.
Getting demolished by Evelyn doesn't really take away your ability or lessen you as a competitor lol considering Evelyn is basically a dude and Alton couldn't even reel her in when he was in his prime...
That's true which is why I mentioned how great Evelyn is, but if we're gonna technically count that as a win, let's remember what also happened in that elimination round.
I agree with that and that's why I said "technically". I know KA would have lost if Ev tried. The only person who can beat Ev if they were on the same season is Emily. The point I was trying to make is that KA was feared by everyone and none of the girls wanted to go up against her. KA is a beast and is elite in my eyes. I really hope she's on this next challenge.
She may have been feared but she slowed Sarah down during that final. I love KellyAnne but she is not on the same level as Ev, Laurel, Emily etc.
Emily isn't on that level either. She did average on Cutthroat, decent to good on Exes 1, and had a great showing on Rivals 2. She can't even compare to Laurel who has been the best female on all but one of her seasons and doesn't need to get a fitness guru to do it or the other girls like Rachel, Jodi, Holly S, etc. Even Camila has better stats with great showings on Cutthroat and Exes 1 and doing as well as she could have on Rivals 1/Seasons 2/Rivals 2 given the card she was dealt (bad partners or targeted early).
But look at Emily from Cutthroat to Rivals 2. She is obviously much different that she was on her first challenge. Nothing wrong with working out a lot and getting into the elite level eventually. I still think Laurel and Ev are better than her.
Yeah but unlike many of the girls you named . Emily has never been eliminated and made it to every seasons final shes been on . Name one other girl besides laurel that does that.
Yeah KA has shown a lot, but she also was just flatout demolished by Evelyn. It wasn't even close at all and was hard to watch how much KA was trying to make Evelyn budge and Everything was standing there looking bored. Evelyn is a beast and the best female competitor to date, but it's still fair to point out imo. I would say Camila has a pretty good mental state tho. Despite her meltdowns, she can almost always keep it together (only exception being FA). She can be the outsider and still fight in elimination rounds like Cutthroat and Seasons 2.
Getting demolished by Evelyn doesn't really take away your ability or lessen you as a competitor lol considering Evelyn is basically a dude and Alton couldn't even reel her in when he was in his prime...
That's true which is why I mentioned how great Evelyn is, but if we're gonna technically count that as a win, let's remember what also happened in that elimination round.
I agree with that and that's why I said "technically". I know KA would have lost if Ev tried. The only person who can beat Ev if they were on the same season is Emily. The point I was trying to make is that KA was feared by everyone and none of the girls wanted to go up against her. KA is a beast and is elite in my eyes. I really hope she's on this next challenge.
She may have been feared but she slowed Sarah down during that final. I love KellyAnne but she is not on the same level as Ev, Laurel, Emily etc.
Emily isn't on that level either. She did average on Cutthroat, decent to good on Exes 1, and had a great showing on Rivals 2. She can't even compare to Laurel who has been the best female on all but one of her seasons and doesn't need to get a fitness guru to do it or the other girls like Rachel, Jodi, Holly S, etc. Even Camila has better stats with great showings on Cutthroat and Exes 1 and doing as well as she could have on Rivals 1/Seasons 2/Rivals 2 given the card she was dealt (bad partners or targeted early).
But look at Emily from Cutthroat to Rivals 2. She is obviously much different that she was on her first challenge. Nothing wrong with working out a lot and getting into the elite level eventually. I still think Laurel and Ev are better than her.
Right, but that's one season out of 3 that she's really shown up and even then all the good females were straddled with girls like Jasmine or Jemmye. She's very good, but I would say every other elite female is better than her.
Yeah KA has shown a lot, but she also was just flatout demolished by Evelyn. It wasn't even close at all and was hard to watch how much KA was trying to make Evelyn budge and Everything was standing there looking bored. Evelyn is a beast and the best female competitor to date, but it's still fair to point out imo. I would say Camila has a pretty good mental state tho. Despite her meltdowns, she can almost always keep it together (only exception being FA). She can be the outsider and still fight in elimination rounds like Cutthroat and Seasons 2.
Getting demolished by Evelyn doesn't really take away your ability or lessen you as a competitor lol considering Evelyn is basically a dude and Alton couldn't even reel her in when he was in his prime...
That's true which is why I mentioned how great Evelyn is, but if we're gonna technically count that as a win, let's remember what also happened in that elimination round.
I wouldn't even count that as a win considering Evelyn let KellyAnne win.
I love KellyAnne but I agree.
I can't believe I'm agreeing with Kenny since I can't stand him but he was so on point when he said "What's the point of hurting your friend when you're just gonna let her win anyway? It makes no sense." lol if Evelyn was sick of everyone and wanted to quit, she should've just done that instead of torturing KellyAnne in that elimination.
It's because Evelyn was very far up her own *** & she just had to let everybody know she could've won if she wanted to, lest she seemed "weak".
This is so true because right after Evelyn lost, she announced this to everybody that she could have stayed if she wanted to.
Speaking of The Ruins, I think Susie is a great player but it annoyed me when Brianna chose her for the elimination round and Susie talked about how she was "undefeated" in eliminations. Before facing Brianna, Susie had only won ONE elimination at that point so I don't understand why she was bragging lol she did good on that season by taking out Brianna, Kimberly and Casey (who anyone could have taken out). However, I just feel that Susie is overrated and I always wanted someone to take her out in an elimination so they can deflate her ego. She is good at politics though so I'll give her credit for that. I just feel like a lot of the girls from the new generation would be able to take her out in a one-on-one battle.
Yeah but unlike many of the girls you named . Emily has never been eliminated and made it to every seasons final shes been on . Name one other girl besides laurel that does that.
So she's good at elimination rounds? I mean she's faced Naomi, Paula, Melinda, and Cara in eliminations and most of which were physical...
This is so true because right after Evelyn lost, she announced this to everybody that she could have stayed if she wanted to.
Speaking of The Ruins, I think Susie is a great player but it annoyed me when Brianna chose her for the elimination round and Susie talked about how she was "undefeated" in eliminations. Before facing Brianna, Susie had only won ONE elimination at that point so I don't understand why she was bragging lol she did good on that season by taking out Brianna, Kimberly and Casey (who anyone could have taken out). However, I just feel that Susie is overrated and I always wanted someone to take her out in an elimination so they can deflate her ego. She is good at politics though so I'll give her credit for that. I just feel like a lot of the girls from the new generation would be able to take her out in a one-on-one battle.
Yeah but unlike many of the girls you named . Emily has never been eliminated and made it to every seasons final shes been on . Name one other girl besides laurel that does that.
Yeah but unlike many of the girls you named . Emily has never been eliminated and made it to every seasons final shes been on . Name one other girl besides laurel that does that.
This is so true because right after Evelyn lost, she announced this to everybody that she could have stayed if she wanted to.
Speaking of The Ruins, I think Susie is a great player but it annoyed me when Brianna chose her for the elimination round and Susie talked about how she was "undefeated" in eliminations. Before facing Brianna, Susie had only won ONE elimination at that point so I don't understand why she was bragging lol she did good on that season by taking out Brianna, Kimberly and Casey (who anyone could have taken out). However, I just feel that Susie is overrated and I always wanted someone to take her out in an elimination so they can deflate her ego. She is good at politics though so I'll give her credit for that. I just feel like a lot of the girls from the new generation would be able to take her out in a one-on-one battle.
[/quote]
This. This so much!
[/quote]
I wish her and Bri got a different elimination, watching them compete in the one they had wasn't really exciting. I think Bri has so much potential and could have taken Susie out if they competed in a physical elimination like Rag Doll. Bri whooped that guys *** in the Hollywood finale and could have done that to Susie lol it would have been a tough fight.
Yeah but unlike many of the girls you named . Emily has never been eliminated and made it to every seasons final shes been on . Name one other girl besides laurel that does that.
Yeah but unlike many of the girls you named . Emily has never been eliminated and made it to every seasons final shes been on . Name one other girl besides laurel that does that.
Jenna and Cooke being the most recent ones
ashley from san diego 2
jamie san diego
aviv
christena south pacific
devyn
carley
ellen
lori
kendall
sam
roni
susie
sarah g
susie, roni and devyn being the only ones doing it on more than one occasion
Yeah but unlike many of the girls you named . Emily has never been eliminated and made it to every seasons final shes been on . Name one other girl besides laurel that does that.
I didn't want to reply to everything so I'll just list you guys with my reply
JamieFire = KA is a reach but based on her two challenges, she's definitely top tier. Especially when all of the girls feared going up against KA in The Ruins. Also, the guys wanted to get rid of her mostly because she's a threat. That's why they screwed Ev to try and get KA out. Also, she beat Rachel in an endurance challenge and "technically" has a win under her belt against Ev. Also, her and Sarah gave the guys a run for their money in the Ruins Final. I think she's earned her spot as a top tier female competitor. I think Camila is borderline top tier and 2nd tier. I'll put her more in the 2nd tier but I think after the next challenge, I guarantee she'll move up to one. She's shown some amazing strength and feat for her size but her mental state is not up there yet.
FreeAgent3 = I agree with CM and I honestly wish she didn't get injured. I think she would have won FA IMO. Your explanation of Theresa is the main reason why I didn't put her in the top tier. She sucks at eliminations. Has the ability but something always flusters her. I can see why you would put Tori in the 3rd tier but Tonya and Paula are definitely 2nd tier. Tonya was a force on Inferno 3. That was Tonya in her best shape and form. She was by far the 3rd best female that season (not far behind from Ev and Susie). She could have made it far in The Ruins but she wasn't in the mental state to compete. I always have a soft spot for Tonya and I think she's improved every challenge. I hate Paula haha! She's my 2nd worst person on the challenge (Tori is #1) but Paula is a final BEAST!!! Yes she's had great partners but in the finals, her partners were keeping up with her. From Duel 1-Cutthroat, she would have been tier 3. Rivals 1 on, she's tier 2. Plus she technically beat Rachel R. in Exes 1 by getting to the bar first in the Banded Together elimination.
Thanks El Scorcho & justintime
Nice list El Scorcho but I would put Tyler in the top tier. Cutthroat and Rivals 1 definitely put him in that spot. He put up a fight with CT on Cutthroat for 40 minutes and beat Derrick. He was also the man to solve the final puzzle on Cutthroat (Sign Language). Also, on Rivals, he finished and won the final with a stomach bug and dehydration. Rivals was hands down the 2nd toughest final ever IMO (Exes 1 was the toughest). Tyler is definitely elite and I wished he was on Free Agents. He would have crushed the competition.
I just can't shake the fact that Tyler was god awful on his first 2 challenges which bumps him down to the 2nd tier category.
I agree with that and that's why I said "technically". I know KA would have lost if Ev tried. The only person who can beat Ev if they were on the same season is Emily. The point I was trying to make is that KA was feared by everyone and none of the girls wanted to go up against her. KA is a beast and is elite in my eyes. I really hope she's on this next challenge.
Unpopular opinion: I hated Cara Maria's storyline on Free Agents and was annoyed by it
I love KellyAnne but I agree.
I can't believe I'm agreeing with Kenny since I can't stand him but he was so on point when he said "What's the point of hurting your friend when you're just gonna let her win anyway? It makes no sense." lol if Evelyn was sick of everyone and wanted to quit, she should've just done that instead of torturing KellyAnne in that elimination.
She may have been feared but she slowed Sarah down during that final. I love KellyAnne but she is not on the same level as Ev, Laurel, Emily etc.
It's because Evelyn was very far up her own *** & she just had to let everybody know she could've won if she wanted to, lest she seemed "weak".
Emily isn't on that level either. She did average on Cutthroat, decent to good on Exes 1, and had a great showing on Rivals 2. She can't even compare to Laurel who has been the best female on all but one of her seasons and doesn't need to get a fitness guru to do it or the other girls like Rachel, Jodi, Holly S, etc. Even Camila has better stats with great showings on Cutthroat and Exes 1 and doing as well as she could have on Rivals 1/Seasons 2/Rivals 2 given the card she was dealt (bad partners or targeted early).
But look at Emily from Cutthroat to Rivals 2. She is obviously much different that she was on her first challenge. Nothing wrong with working out a lot and getting into the elite level eventually. I still think Laurel and Ev are better than her.
Yeah but unlike many of the girls you named . Emily has never been eliminated and made it to every seasons final shes been on . Name one other girl besides laurel that does that.
Right, but that's one season out of 3 that she's really shown up and even then all the good females were straddled with girls like Jasmine or Jemmye. She's very good, but I would say every other elite female is better than her.
This is so true because right after Evelyn lost, she announced this to everybody that she could have stayed if she wanted to.
Speaking of The Ruins, I think Susie is a great player but it annoyed me when Brianna chose her for the elimination round and Susie talked about how she was "undefeated" in eliminations. Before facing Brianna, Susie had only won ONE elimination at that point so I don't understand why she was bragging lol she did good on that season by taking out Brianna, Kimberly and Casey (who anyone could have taken out). However, I just feel that Susie is overrated and I always wanted someone to take her out in an elimination so they can deflate her ego. She is good at politics though so I'll give her credit for that. I just feel like a lot of the girls from the new generation would be able to take her out in a one-on-one battle.
So she's good at elimination rounds? I mean she's faced Naomi, Paula, Melinda, and Cara in eliminations and most of which were physical...
[/quote]
This is so true because right after Evelyn lost, she announced this to everybody that she could have stayed if she wanted to.
Speaking of The Ruins, I think Susie is a great player but it annoyed me when Brianna chose her for the elimination round and Susie talked about how she was "undefeated" in eliminations. Before facing Brianna, Susie had only won ONE elimination at that point so I don't understand why she was bragging lol she did good on that season by taking out Brianna, Kimberly and Casey (who anyone could have taken out). However, I just feel that Susie is overrated and I always wanted someone to take her out in an elimination so they can deflate her ego. She is good at politics though so I'll give her credit for that. I just feel like a lot of the girls from the new generation would be able to take her out in a one-on-one battle.
[/quote]
This. This so much!
Ok and laurels done the same shes faced jamine , johnna , cara (with a broken hand , not fair )thersa and camilla
Devyn haha
So i would say laurel and emily are about the same . Not only that i truly believe that if there was a physical elimination she could beat laurel too
She's faced Camila/Theresa, Camila, Aneesa, and Sarah so yeah she's faced better competitors.
I want to see her get eliminated one day lmao
Emily has strength over Laurel, but Laurel is better at pretty much anything else.
This is so true because right after Evelyn lost, she announced this to everybody that she could have stayed if she wanted to.
Speaking of The Ruins, I think Susie is a great player but it annoyed me when Brianna chose her for the elimination round and Susie talked about how she was "undefeated" in eliminations. Before facing Brianna, Susie had only won ONE elimination at that point so I don't understand why she was bragging lol she did good on that season by taking out Brianna, Kimberly and Casey (who anyone could have taken out). However, I just feel that Susie is overrated and I always wanted someone to take her out in an elimination so they can deflate her ego. She is good at politics though so I'll give her credit for that. I just feel like a lot of the girls from the new generation would be able to take her out in a one-on-one battle.
[/quote]
This. This so much!
[/quote]
I wish her and Bri got a different elimination, watching them compete in the one they had wasn't really exciting. I think Bri has so much potential and could have taken Susie out if they competed in a physical elimination like Rag Doll. Bri whooped that guys *** in the Hollywood finale and could have done that to Susie lol it would have been a tough fight.
Jenna and Cooke being the most recent ones
susie, roni and devyn being the only ones doing it on more than one occasion
Queen Devyn.
Please . If you going by devyns looks yeah. But as a competitor shes far from a queen
Exactly many of those names have only did One challenge . thats like you saying sam from san diego 2 is on emilys level
I just can't shake the fact that Tyler was god awful on his first 2 challenges which bumps him down to the 2nd tier category.
Out of all the Gauntlet Seasons the second one is the best.
Cast wise, yes
Overall, 1 holds dear to my heart. It just looked fun and the cast was mostly likeable
i loved the first gauntlet. it would have been better if the eliminations they separated male and female eliminations.
Guarentee Emily has better endurance.
Pages