The Challenge: What Ifs

2827 posts / 0 new
Last post

As good and physical as Aneesa is, I still can't see her beating Laurel in Balls In. Laurel's height advantage just is too much to overcome I think. Would she had her hands full? Yes. But I think Aneesa would have trouble getting the balls in the basket.

I would've loved that elimination though, guaranteed to be one of the top in history.


I agree it would be a great battle. I think Laurel would use speed and her long arms to win.

As good and physical as Aneesa is, I still can't see her beating Laurel in Balls In. Laurel's height advantage just is too much to overcome I think. Would she had her hands full? Yes. But I think Aneesa would have trouble getting the balls in the basket.

I would've loved that elimination though, guaranteed to be one of the top in history.

i wonder why everyone thinks Aneesa woul have a guaranteed win against Laurel in that elimination?

Laurel proved she can take a hit from Aneesa pretty well in Oppenheimer.  i think it would be a 3-2 elimination in favor of Laurel.

The only thing about Laurel vs. Aneesa, and it showed in Oppenheimer, is that Aneesa has the aggression that Laurel doesn't. Aneesa is more in your face, I'll take cheap shots, do what I have to do to win. Laurel is just a bigger girl who doesn't need that extra switch to dominate an elimination. I think that could've worked in Aneesa's favor because she would've had more room to move around in Balls In, but I still think Laurel takes it.

As good and physical as Aneesa is, I still can't see her beating Laurel in Balls In. Laurel's height advantage just is too much to overcome I think. Would she had her hands full? Yes. But I think Aneesa would have trouble getting the balls in the basket.

I would've loved that elimination though, guaranteed to be one of the top in history.

i wonder why everyone thinks Aneesa woul have a guaranteed win against Laurel in that elimination?

Laurel proved she can take a hit from Aneesa pretty well in Oppenheimer.  i think it would be a 3-2 elimination in favor of Laurel.

Aneesa is a real cast member and Laurel isn't..that's why Aneesa will win.

Lol sorry. Old debut came out.

What do you guys think would happen if these four pairs were teams on Battle of the Exes 2? 

Alton/Sarah

Jordan/Nia

Leroy/Theresa

Wes/KellyAnne

I remember these were supposed to be the original teams for that season but Alton and KellyAnne declined. If only they accepted, I think these four teams would be way more interesting. 

What if Jasmine didn't pulled the kill card on Free Agents? That means Anessa had to go against Laurel in "Ball In"... (Anessa & Jazzy were last 2 girls standing during the draw)

Man that would have been awesome!! Aneesa vs Laurel in Balls in would have been epic. I would put my money in Aneesa based on her aggresiveness and will to win that she shows in her eliminations, but it could go either way. It would have been a great match-up.

What do you guys think would happen if these four pairs were teams on Battle of the Exes 2? 

Alton/Sarah

Jordan/Nia

Leroy/Theresa

Wes/KellyAnne

I remember these were supposed to be the original teams for that season but Alton and KellyAnne declined. If only they accepted, I think these four teams would be way more interesting. 

Wes & KellyAnne win, Alton & Sarah in 2nd, Leroy & Theresa in 3rd

What if Tori and Theresa & Bananas and Tyler had to face each other in Back Off Of Me on Cutthroat instead of bringing CT and Tina?

Tina was cheating lol so I say Theresa andTyler win

What if Jasmine didn't pulled the kill card on Free Agents? That means Anessa had to go against Laurel in "Ball In"... (Anessa & Jazzy were last 2 girls standing during the draw)

Man that would have been awesome!! Aneesa vs Laurel in Balls in would have been epic. I would put my money in Aneesa based on her aggresiveness and will to win that she shows in her eliminations, but it could go either way. It would have been a great match-up.

Idk. If Aneesa somewhat struggeled with Shauvon, I think Laurel would plow her tbh. Aneesas best bet for en elimination round against Laurel would be Wrecking Wall.

Laurel would take aneesa

What if Jordan/Sarah voted in Bananas/Nany to face Wes/Theresa in Hall Brawl? That would've been such an epic match because both teams despised each other. It's crazy to know that Bananas and Wes have one of the longest rivalries in Challenge history but they still have never faced each other in an elimination round. 

What if Jordan/Sarah voted in Bananas/Nany to face Wes/Theresa in Hall Brawl? That would've been such an epic match because both teams despised each other. It's crazy to know that Bananas and Wes have one of the longest rivalries in Challenge history but they still have never faced each other in an elimination round. 

I think Wes/Theresa would've taken it. Would've been epic.

What if Jemmye didn't pulled the kill card on Free Agents? That means Camilla has to go against Latoya in "Balls In"? How well Toya would do? (Jemmye and Camilla was the last 2 girls standing in The Draw)

Camila would kill her. Toya is no punk tho!!

Camila actually done that elimination on SBC and she played good as defender, but wasn't so good at offense. It would've been kind of closer than Jemmye vs Toya.

I didn't watch that elimination on SBC, but I find that hard to believe (that it'd be close). Camila turns up in elimination and goes insane, I think someone here posted about how intense she got against Emilee by scratching, biting, etc.

What if Jemmye didn't pulled the kill card on Free Agents? That means Camilla has to go against Latoya in "Balls In"? How well Toya would do? (Jemmye and Camilla was the last 2 girls standing in The Draw)

Camila would kill her. Toya is no punk tho!!

Camila actually done that elimination on SBC and she played good as defender, but wasn't so good at offense. It would've been kind of closer than Jemmye vs Toya.

I see what you're saying. But SBC was a while ago before she religiously worked out for the shows. Idk I love  them both

What if Jemmye didn't pulled the kill card on Free Agents? That means Camilla has to go against Latoya in "Balls In"? How well Toya would do? (Jemmye and Camilla was the last 2 girls standing in The Draw)

Camila would kill her. Toya is no punk tho!!

Camila actually done that elimination on SBC and she played good as defender, but wasn't so good at offense. It would've been kind of closer than Jemmye vs Toya.

I see what you're saying. But SBC was a while ago before she religiously worked out for the shows. Idk I love  them both


Does she religiously work out? Lol all I see is she does some working out before doing challenges, but even when she did Cutthroat she wasn't someone who looked they worked out that much tbh

What if Jemmye didn't pulled the kill card on Free Agents? That means Camilla has to go against Latoya in "Balls In"? How well Toya would do? (Jemmye and Camilla was the last 2 girls standing in The Draw)

Camila would kill her. Toya is no punk tho!!

Camila actually done that elimination on SBC and she played good as defender, but wasn't so good at offense. It would've been kind of closer than Jemmye vs Toya.

I see what you're saying. But SBC was a while ago before she religiously worked out for the shows. Idk I love  them both

Does she religiously work out? Lol all I see is she does some working out before doing challenges, but even when she did Cutthroat she wasn't someone who looked they worked out that much tbh

Im comparing it to right now but yeah I exaggerated the religiously but I mean she does work out everyday, and a good amount compared to the other females on the show especially LaToya. My point was that I think Camila would destroy LaToya in a physical elimination but that's just my opinion.

idkkk, I think bananas and nany might have beaten Wes and Theresa. Theresa beat nany in x battle but that's mostly about leverage. Nany was so mad that she probably would have mowed Theresa down. and bananas would have gotten Wes for sure because Wes really sucked on that elimination 

While I think Wes/Theresa vs Bananas/Nany might have been close, I think it would have come down to Theresa vs Nany battling somewhat close to the middle and I think Theresa would have pulled Nany backwards more and ultimately beat her and ring the bell first, getting Wes/Theresa the win. But it would have been a great close match.

If Theresa could drag a 6'0 girl I'm pretty sure she could beat Nany. Plus Theresa's are just...****

If Theresa could drag a 6'0 girl I'm pretty sure she could beat Nany. Plus Theresa's are just...****

If Theresa could drag a 6'0 girl I'm pretty sure she could beat Nany. Plus Theresa's are just...****

What if they got Brooklyn team: Katellyn/Scott/Devyn/JD for Seasons 2?

What if they got Brooklyn team: Katellyn/Scott/Devyn/JD for Seasons 2?

Theyd get sent home by Fresh Meat.

I like Laurel but seeing Aneesa take her out would have been amazing just because Laurel has never lost before and it would have actually been an even playing field for the girls.

What if they got Brooklyn team: Katellyn/Scott/Devyn/JD for Seasons 2?

Theyd get sent home by Fresh Meat.

Not necessarily. Assuming Eric still does what he did in that elimination and San Diego does what they do at the end I think they make it to the end.

What if they got Brooklyn team: Katellyn/Scott/Devyn/JD for Seasons 2?

how sad

What if they got Brooklyn team: Katellyn/Scott/Devyn/JD for Seasons 2?

They would have been doomed from the start. As much as I can't stand Sarah, she is the reason Brooklyn made the finals. She ran that team and did a **** of a job.

What if they got Brooklyn team: Katellyn/Scott/Devyn/JD for Seasons 2?

Theyd get sent home by Fresh Meat.

Not necessarily. Assuming Eric still does what he did in that elimination and San Diego does what they do at the end I think they make it to the end.


But at the same time, Brooklyn also won two missions after that and can they do that with two people dragging their team down?

What if they got Brooklyn team: Katellyn/Scott/Devyn/JD for Seasons 2?

All I have to say is poor Scott.

Pages