The Challenge: Power Rankings

259 posts / 0 new
Last post

Now Free Agents for the guys: 1. Johnny Bananas 2. CT 3. Zach 4. Johnny Reilly 5. Cohutta 6. Preston 7. Leroy 8. Jordan 9. Frank 10. Dustin 11. Brandon 12. Issac 13. Chet 14. Swift

 

lol @ Preston being higher than Frank... And Brandon... And Dustin.... and Jordan.

And Leroy

Yall need to rewatch the season then. Brandon, Frank, and Dustin were out too early which is why i rated them that low. Rankins are based on THIS season alone. And Preston performed better than Jordan and Leroy especially.

Now Free Agents for the guys:
1. Johnny Bananas
2. CT
3. Zach
4. Johnny Reilly
5. Cohutta
6. Preston
7. Leroy
8. Jordan
9. Frank
10. Dustin
11. Brandon
12. Issac
13. Chet
14. Swift

Frank 9? After Leroy and Jordan? Really? He performed very good for someone, who was that ill. I do not think anyone could do it like he did.
He did go home early but was still good. If he would have been fine, I think he could have won that season. Or even being ill he would have made it to finale..

I actually like Preston, but there is no way I'd ever put him ahead of Leroy. Leroy had a dominant elimination win over the guy who sent Preston home. His elimination against CT was also pretty close

Yall need to rewatch the season then. Brandon, Frank, and Dustin were out too early which is why i rated them that low. Rankins are based on THIS season alone. And Preston performed better than Jordan and Leroy especially.

I'm aware. I saw Free Agents too, but I hate Frank and he was actually better than Preston for how long he was there for. Brandon and Dustin are fine, I guess, but I still see Preston losing to both of them.

Battle of the Seasons 2 Males: 1) Frank 2) Zach 3) Dustin 4) CJ 5) Chet 6) Derek 7) Alton Dirol JD 9) Robb 10) Trey 11) Knight 12) Brandon 13) Big Easy 14) Wes 15) Preston 16) Danny Females: 1) Sarah 2) Ashley K. 3) Nany 4) Jonna 5) Trashelle 6) Marie 7) Laura Dirol McKenzie 9) Camila 10) Jemmye 11) Cara Maria 12) Jazmin 13) Melinda 14) Devyn 15) Sam 16) Lacey

 

Can I ask as to why Ashley K. was ranked so high? I believe Nany deserves a higher rank and possibly Jonna and Marie as well. I feel as though Ashley was a decent competitor in a great team, but that's just my opinon. I was just curious as to why that decision. 

im of the opinon that ashley k hasnt shown herself to be that good yet either.  other then running what else can she do? she hasnt shown that she's aggressive, physical,puzzle- savy, the best climber, etc.. even her ability fo finish a final was only minimally tested in one of the easiest finals to date. nobody really knows if she can actually finish a final faster or as fast as people like paula, cara maria, camila, nany, etc. i'll throw theresa in there too because she made a good case for hserlf on free agents.

out of the girls that  came to play on BOTseasons, marie, nany, jonna all impressed me more. sarah, camila and maybe even cara would of course be selected before ashley k as well.

Battle of the Seasons 2 Males: 1) Frank 2) Zach 3) Dustin 4) CJ 5) Chet 6) Derek 7) Alton Dirol JD 9) Robb 10) Trey 11) Knight 12) Brandon 13) Big Easy 14) Wes 15) Preston 16) Danny Females: 1) Sarah 2) Ashley K. 3) Nany 4) Jonna 5) Trashelle 6) Marie 7) Laura Dirol McKenzie 9) Camila 10) Jemmye 11) Cara Maria 12) Jazmin 13) Melinda 14) Devyn 15) Sam 16) Lacey

 

Can I ask as to why Ashley K. was ranked so high? I believe Nany deserves a higher rank and possibly Jonna and Marie as well. I feel as though Ashley was a decent competitor in a great team, but that's just my opinon. I was just curious as to why that decision. 

Ashley K was definitely the second best girl there IMO.  Ashley K is just quiet so people forget about her.  I might pick Ashley to be my partner in a challenge over anyone that has every appeared on these shows.  She's not going to hurt your political game, she's an endurance beast and she performs without complaining.

She's not Emily, Laurel, Evelyn, Rachel or even Cooke as an athlete but she's the perfect partner/teammate

Battle of the Seasons 2 Males: 1) Frank 2) Zach 3) Dustin 4) CJ 5) Chet 6) Derek 7) Alton Dirol JD 9) Robb 10) Trey 11) Knight 12) Brandon 13) Big Easy 14) Wes 15) Preston 16) Danny Females: 1) Sarah 2) Ashley K. 3) Nany 4) Jonna 5) Trashelle 6) Marie 7) Laura Dirol McKenzie 9) Camila 10) Jemmye 11) Cara Maria 12) Jazmin 13) Melinda 14) Devyn 15) Sam 16) Lacey

 

Can I ask as to why Ashley K. was ranked so high? I believe Nany deserves a higher rank and possibly Jonna and Marie as well. I feel as though Ashley was a decent competitor in a great team, but that's just my opinon. I was just curious as to why that decision. 

Ashley K was definitely the second best girl there IMO.  Ashley K is just quiet so people forget about her.  I might pick Ashley to be my partner in a challenge over anyone that has every appeared on these shows.  She's not going to hurt your political game, she's an endurance beast and she performs without complaining.

She's not Emily, Laurel, Evelyn, Rachel or even Cooke as an athlete but she's the perfect partner/teammate

Yeah she's solid, but I can think of a bunch of girls I'd rather work with. Endurance beast is definitely overrating her abilities.

Now Free Agents for the guys: 1. Johnny Bananas 2. CT 3. Zach 4. Johnny Reilly 5. Cohutta 6. Preston 7. Leroy 8. Jordan 9. Frank 10. Dustin 11. Brandon 12. Issac 13. Chet 14. Swift
Frank 9? After Leroy and Jordan? Really? He performed very good for someone, who was that ill. I do not think anyone could do it like he did. He did go home early but was still good. If he would have been fine, I think he could have won that season. Or even being ill he would have made it to finale..

Frank was still out too early. His eliminations were impressive yes. But his two challenge performances weren't superb. him running up the stairs was solid, but he and Nia were probbably the 3rd or 4th worst team on the bike challenge.  so he still gets his low ranking.

Yall need to rewatch the season then. Brandon, Frank, and Dustin were out too early which is why i rated them that low. Rankins are based on THIS season alone. And Preston performed better than Jordan and Leroy especially.

I'm aware. I saw Free Agents too, but I hate Frank and he was actually better than Preston for how long he was there for. Brandon and Dustin are fine, I guess, but I still see Preston losing to both of them.

of course preston would lose to them, but they wre out early so it doens't matter. preston did better than Frank on the bike challenge. in fact Frank and Nia were either the 3rd or 4th worst team on that challenge, and i estimate Preston and Camila were the 3rd best team on that challenge. Cohutta who WON that challenge said himself Preston came out of the woodworks and he was concerned more about his time than anyone else's at that point.

Frank only did impressive performances on eliminations.the first mission he did solid, and the second one he did terrible.

I actually like Preston, but there is no way I'd ever put him ahead of Leroy. Leroy had a dominant elimination win over the guy who sent Preston home. His elimination against CT was also pretty close

Preston outperformed or was tied with Leory on EVERY mission except for Auto Body Rally and Hold that Pose. Preston deserves to beranked hiher than Leroy, he does.  didn't CT murder Leroy?

Battle of the Seasons 2 Males: 1) Frank 2) Zach 3) Dustin 4) CJ 5) Chet 6) Derek 7) Alton Dirol JD 9) Robb 10) Trey 11) Knight 12) Brandon 13) Big Easy 14) Wes 15) Preston 16) Danny Females: 1) Sarah 2) Ashley K. 3) Nany 4) Jonna 5) Trashelle 6) Marie 7) Laura Dirol McKenzie 9) Camila 10) Jemmye 11) Cara Maria 12) Jazmin 13) Melinda 14) Devyn 15) Sam 16) Lacey

 

Can I ask as to why Ashley K. was ranked so high? I believe Nany deserves a higher rank and possibly Jonna and Marie as well. I feel as though Ashley was a decent competitor in a great team, but that's just my opinon. I was just curious as to why that decision. 

Ashley K was definitely the second best girl there IMO.  Ashley K is just quiet so people forget about her.  I might pick Ashley to be my partner in a challenge over anyone that has every appeared on these shows.  She's not going to hurt your political game, she's an endurance beast and she performs without complaining.

She's not Emily, Laurel, Evelyn, Rachel or even Cooke as an athlete but she's the perfect partner/teammate

Yeah she's solid, but I can think of a bunch of girls I'd rather work with. Endurance beast is definitely overrating her abilities.

very much so, nobody even knows if she can do a final better than any of the other girls that have finished finals. the BOTseasons finale was a joke compared to cutthroat, rivals, fresh meat 2, botexes, etc.

I made sure to rewatch it right before I posted. Leroy did say he got murdered, but it was very close, just a way he copes with defeat. I've seen it plenty of times. The drywall told the story though and one more hole would have been more then enough for him to smack the bell. He did really well. It wasn't as close as Dustin/Frank but still close. After seeing the six guys compete in that elimination I would say he was faster then Dustin, Frank, Jordan, and Bananas. Unfortunately for him, he was just up against a beast. 

 

Although none of this should really matter. The fact alone that he made the guy who sent Preston home look like a child in their elimination should be enough to rank him over Preston. I love Cohutta, but size differnce or no, he got manhandled.

I made sure to rewatch it right before I posted. Leroy did say he got murdered, but it was very close, just a way he copes with defeat. I've seen it plenty of times. The drywall told the story though and one more hole would have been more then enough for him to smack the bell. He did really well. It wasn't as close as Dustin/Frank but still close. After seeing the six guys compete in that elimination I would say he was faster then Dustin, Frank, Jordan, and Bananas. Unfortunately for him, he was just up against a beast. 

 

Although none of this should really matter. The fact alone that he made the guy who sent Preston home look like a child in their elimination should be enough to rank him over Preston. I love Cohutta, but size differnce or no, he got manhandled.


I so Leroy is a better competitor because he is stronger than Preston? Lol

Yall need to rewatch the season then. Brandon, Frank, and Dustin were out too early which is why i rated them that low. Rankins are based on THIS season alone. And Preston performed better than Jordan and Leroy especially.

I'm aware. I saw Free Agents too, but I hate Frank and he was actually better than Preston for how long he was there for. Brandon and Dustin are fine, I guess, but I still see Preston losing to both of them.

of course preston would lose to them, but they wre out early so it doens't matter. preston did better than Frank on the bike challenge. in fact Frank and Nia were either the 3rd or 4th worst team on that challenge, and i estimate Preston and Camila were the 3rd best team on that challenge. Cohutta who WON that challenge said himself Preston came out of the woodworks and he was concerned more about his time than anyone else's at that point.

Frank only did impressive performances on eliminations.the first mission he did solid, and the second one he did terrible.

So he did well on one or two challenges, so he deserves to be ranked over the others?.. Alright.

Yall need to rewatch the season then. Brandon, Frank, and Dustin were out too early which is why i rated them that low. Rankins are based on THIS season alone. And Preston performed better than Jordan and Leroy especially.

I'm aware. I saw Free Agents too, but I hate Frank and he was actually better than Preston for how long he was there for. Brandon and Dustin are fine, I guess, but I still see Preston losing to both of them.

of course preston would lose to them, but they wre out early so it doens't matter. preston did better than Frank on the bike challenge. in fact Frank and Nia were either the 3rd or 4th worst team on that challenge, and i estimate Preston and Camila were the 3rd best team on that challenge. Cohutta who WON that challenge said himself Preston came out of the woodworks and he was concerned more about his time than anyone else's at that point.

Frank only did impressive performances on eliminations.the first mission he did solid, and the second one he did terrible.

So he did well on one or two challenges, so he deserves to be ranked over the others?.. Alright.


Are you talking about Preston? He did well on almost every challenge lmbo.

Imagine if Camila and Frank stayed in the game longer. I definitly don't think Bananas would have won the final

I guess it depends how you base these power rankings. Usually it's by individual performance without including any past challenge experience (for less bias). The whole "this person can beat this person in a physical elimination" really only matters if they even went against each other if you want to include that in rankings. IMO It matters most who performed the best, who fought the hardest, and overall played a better game politically in that challenge only.

IMO I thought that Zach, aside from the final, had the best & most consistent performance on Free Agents. Then I guess I would have Bananas, Cohutta, CT, and Johnny R after.

Imagine if Camila and Frank stayed in the game longer. I definitly don't think Bananas would have won the final

Yeah, Frank would have won had he stayed and was healthy. Unless he somehow went up against Zach or CT (which knowing his luck in the draw, maybe).

Camila... had this challenge been at a different time and she was focused on the game, I think would have made it to the end. Would she win? Well, I'd still put money on Laurel.

Yall need to rewatch the season then. Brandon, Frank, and Dustin were out too early which is why i rated them that low. Rankins are based on THIS season alone. And Preston performed better than Jordan and Leroy especially.

I'm aware. I saw Free Agents too, but I hate Frank and he was actually better than Preston for how long he was there for. Brandon and Dustin are fine, I guess, but I still see Preston losing to both of them.

of course preston would lose to them, but they wre out early so it doens't matter. preston did better than Frank on the bike challenge. in fact Frank and Nia were either the 3rd or 4th worst team on that challenge, and i estimate Preston and Camila were the 3rd best team on that challenge. Cohutta who WON that challenge said himself Preston came out of the woodworks and he was concerned more about his time than anyone else's at that point.

Frank only did impressive performances on eliminations.the first mission he did solid, and the second one he did terrible.

So he did well on one or two challenges, so he deserves to be ranked over the others?.. Alright.

Are you talking about Preston? He did well on almost every challenge lmbo.

Yes, Preston.

He was safe most of the time, I don't know what you consider "well", but he only won Bounce Out and Out on a Ledge. I only saw him doing well with Bounce Out when most of them complimented Preston on his performance. Otherwise, Preston skated through as usual.

Yall need to rewatch the season then. Brandon, Frank, and Dustin were out too early which is why i rated them that low. Rankins are based on THIS season alone. And Preston performed better than Jordan and Leroy especially.

I'm aware. I saw Free Agents too, but I hate Frank and he was actually better than Preston for how long he was there for. Brandon and Dustin are fine, I guess, but I still see Preston losing to both of them.

of course preston would lose to them, but they wre out early so it doens't matter. preston did better than Frank on the bike challenge. in fact Frank and Nia were either the 3rd or 4th worst team on that challenge, and i estimate Preston and Camila were the 3rd best team on that challenge. Cohutta who WON that challenge said himself Preston came out of the woodworks and he was concerned more about his time than anyone else's at that point.

Frank only did impressive performances on eliminations.the first mission he did solid, and the second one he did terrible.

So he did well on one or two challenges, so he deserves to be ranked over the others?.. Alright.


Are you talking about Preston? He did well on almost every challenge lmbo.

Preston did average on free agents, people overate his performance. He only did good in 2 or 3 missions out of 8.
1st mission alright
2nd mission did good
3rd mission did absolutely nothing besides hang on to Nany
4th mission came in at the last second after Jordan was in a stalemate with Leroy.
5th mission DQed
6th mission can't even remember how he did
7th mission did absolutely awful
8th mission did nothing .

Yall need to rewatch the season then. Brandon, Frank, and Dustin were out too early which is why i rated them that low. Rankins are based on THIS season alone. And Preston performed better than Jordan and Leroy especially.

I'm aware. I saw Free Agents too, but I hate Frank and he was actually better than Preston for how long he was there for. Brandon and Dustin are fine, I guess, but I still see Preston losing to both of them.

of course preston would lose to them, but they wre out early so it doens't matter. preston did better than Frank on the bike challenge. in fact Frank and Nia were either the 3rd or 4th worst team on that challenge, and i estimate Preston and Camila were the 3rd best team on that challenge. Cohutta who WON that challenge said himself Preston came out of the woodworks and he was concerned more about his time than anyone else's at that point.

Frank only did impressive performances on eliminations.the first mission he did solid, and the second one he did terrible.

So he did well on one or two challenges, so he deserves to be ranked over the others?.. Alright.

Are you talking about Preston? He did well on almost every challenge lmbo.
Preston did average on free agents, people overate his performance. He only did good in 2 or 3 missions out of 8. 1st mission alright 2nd mission did good 3rd mission did absolutely nothing besides hang on to Nany 4th mission came in at the last second after Jordan was in a stalemate with Leroy. 5th mission DQed 6th mission can't even remember how he did 7th mission did absolutely awful 8th mission did nothing .

well thats better than Leroy,

1st mission: alright

2nd mission: did good, got second place

3rd mission: did absoultley nothing except for hang on to Issac

4th mission: should have been able to take on Jordan and Preston but couldn't.

5th mission: made it across like Preston did.

6th mission: was the first person out before Preston.

7th mission: did the absolute worst.

8th mission: did good but he didn't really contribute. just did what CT and Zach told him to do.

9th mission: did good and took a hit from CT pretty well.

10th mission: did terrible and held back Laurel

So yeah Preston had a better performance overall than Leroy

Free Agents Rankings: 
 
1. Bananas
2. Zach
3. Johnny R. 
4. CT
5. Cohutta
6. Frank
7. Preston
8. Leroy
9. Jordan
10. Brandon
11. Dustin
12. Isaac
13. Swift
14. Chet
 
1. Laurel
2. Cara Maria
3. Nany
4. Theresa
5. Jessica
6. Camila
7. Jonna
8. Aneesa
9. LaToya
10. Nia
11. Devyn
12. Jemmye
13. Jasmine
14. Emilee

I so Leroy is a better competitor because he is stronger than Preston? Lol

Balls in is more then just strength. Otherwise Bananas vs Isaac wouldnt have been such a blowout. Leroy is a better competitor then Preton because he's bigger, stronger, faster, more agile, more durable, and just a much better athelete. Definitely needs to work on that swimming though.

I so Leroy is a better competitor because he is stronger than Preston? Lol

Balls in is more then just strength. Otherwise Bananas vs Isaac wouldnt have been such a blowout. Leroy is a better competitor then Preton because he's bigger, stronger, faster, more agile, more durable, and just a much better athelete. Definitely needs to work on that swimming though.


I can't even see how anyone would think Preston is better. Maybe if they only watched free agents and not rivals 2 when Preston DQed/placed last in almost every mission.

Imagine if Camila and Frank stayed in the game longer. I definitly don't think Bananas would have won the final

Yeah, Frank would have won had he stayed and was healthy. Unless he somehow went up against Zach or CT (which knowing his luck in the draw, maybe).

Camila... had this challenge been at a different time and she was focused on the game, I think would have made it to the end. Would she win? Well, I'd still put money on Laurel.


Eh Bananas killed that final and has killrf many others. Frank did well in a watered down final in Seasons. I think it's exaggerating his abilities to think he'd automatically win. Yeah I agree Camila probably would have made the final unless eh had to face a bigger girl in an elimination round with how physical those were.

Imagine if Camila and Frank stayed in the game longer. I definitly don't think Bananas would have won the final

Yeah, Frank would have won had he stayed and was healthy. Unless he somehow went up against Zach or CT (which knowing his luck in the draw, maybe).

Camila... had this challenge been at a different time and she was focused on the game, I think would have made it to the end. Would she win? Well, I'd still put money on Laurel.

Eh Bananas killed that final and has killrf many others. Frank did well in a watered down final in Seasons. I think it's exaggerating his abilities to think he'd automatically win. Yeah I agree Camila probably would have made the final unless eh had to face a bigger girl in an elimination round with how physical those were.

Now that I think about it, Bananas did kill that final. I guess I was just so hung up about Rivals 2 when Bananas kept gassing out and Frank was outperforming him. But Bananas did train like a **** for Free Agents, so who knows. I think had Frank replaced Johnny R in the final, he would have done about the same. Perform well at first, get stuck with Devyn on the hardest leg, do well in the bicycle part, and absolutely kill the mountain leg. Unless he somehow knew all those countries in the geography puzzle, I think Bananas would win still.

Then again, FA's final for the guys was pretty much who got Devyn in the least strenuous leg.

I so Leroy is a better competitor because he is stronger than Preston? Lol

Balls in is more then just strength. Otherwise Bananas vs Isaac wouldnt have been such a blowout. Leroy is a better competitor then Preton because he's bigger, stronger, faster, more agile, more durable, and just a much better athelete. Definitely needs to work on that swimming though.

I can't even see how anyone would think Preston is better. Maybe if they only watched free agents and not rivals 2 when Preston DQed/placed last in almost every mission.

That is exactly what i stated EARLIER!!!!

My Free Agents ranking was based on that season's performances and that season's performances alone. Leroy didn't really use any agility in defeating Cohutta, if you notice. ts debatable whther Leroy is faster than Preston. you have to admit Leroy perfromance on Free Agents didn't stand out.

Pages