The Challenge: Power Rankings

259 posts / 0 new
Last post
The Challenge: Power Rankings

So I was reading a blogpost the other day poweranking the remaining contestants of Free Agents and I thought it would be fun to do for past seasons as a post-season thing. I think I'll start with the season I last watched in full, Fresh Meat 2:

1. Kenny & Laurel - They finished first or second (?) in every single challenge. Simples. It can be debated if that's just because Laurel was in another class to the other girls or if they both performed stellar, but I believe both had a part to play in their success all season.

2. Landon & Carley - Bar Carley's freakout in the nighttime exile they were close behind Kenny and Laurel all season and obviously work very well together as proof of their couple of challenge wins and their win overall in the final

3. Jillian & Pete - Pete proved himself to be a strong competitor throughout the season and Jillian kept up for the most part, they proved they deserved their 3rd place by winning two exiles and by finishing 3rd in the final challenge obstacle course. They were #Team Kenny from the start and that payed off towards the end being seen as the only other teammates definitely safe from exile in the closing weeks.

4. Jenn & Noor - Only 4 couples ever won challenges and Jenn and Noor close them out. They both proved their small statures mean nothing with both showing strength and Noor showing great speed. They gave up in the final, accepting 4th place, but they definitely deserved to see the final.

5. Evelyn & Luke - Just like only 4 couples won a challenge, only 5 won a single exile and they round up this list as well. Obviously if this was just down to sportmanship Evelyn would be dead last. Although she is also by far the strongest overall of the alumni women and her and Luke powered through two exiles before being edged out by the eventual winners by a mistake in judgement on Evelyn's part. Granted even had they won they would have been sent in every week thereafter. The reason they are not higher (besides not winning a challenge) is Luke just isn't as strong as the other guys present physically, although he proved his endurance in the exiles.

6. CJ & Sydney - This may be a bit controversial, but I think had they not completely ****ed up the puzzle they would have given Landon and Carley a run for their money in the exile. Both proved they can hang with their respective gender fields in this challenge and had they seen the exile against Kaitlynn and Brandon the game may have changed quite some way

7. Wes & Mandi - This ranking is purely based on Wes managing to "mastermind" the game for the first half of the competition even if it was a way that caused the plan to completely fall apart in the second half. If Kenny and Laurel hadn't saved themselves by winning nearly every week, Wes (and Evelyn) would probably have both seen the final.

8. Ryan & Theresa - This team's weakness showed when Ryan failed to get past Kenny in the obstacle course. Despite putting up a surprising showing in the log push, Ryan, like Luke, just couldn't hang with the bigger guys and Theresa wasn't strong enough, or as strong as Evelyn/Laurel to compensate.

9. Darrell & CaraMaria - Were it not for them (rightfully imo) being pegged as strong competitiors and targeted off the bat I think they could have challenged their way a large chunk of the competition. But they didn't get the chance to really show how their chemistry would show as a competitive partnership From here on it's much of a muchness so I really can't be bothered with as long comments.

10. Sarah & Vinny - Both should have done better than they did

11. Paula & Jeff - Jeff really let Paula down in their exile.

12. Danny & Sandy - Don't care

13. Kaitlynn & Brandon - Poor Brandon Yeah so I'd love to see people's rankings of seasons. Even week by week rankings for team challenges i.e. how losing certain compeitiors helped/hindered each team's chances!

Free Agents: Females: 1. Laurel 2. Cara Maria 3. Theresa 4. Nany 5. Camila 6. Jessica 7. Aneesa 8. LaToya 9. Nia 10. Jonna 11. Jemmye 12. Devyn 13. Jasmine 14. Emilee Males: 1. Johnny Bananas 2. Zach 3. CT 4. Frank - he only lasted 3 episodes, but he beat 2 good competitor with a lung infection and performed well on the challenges, and that says a lot. 5. Cohutta 6. Johnny 7. Dustin 8. Preston 9. Leroy 10. Brandon 11. Jordan 12. Swift 13. Chet 14. Isaac
I am looking at the missions performance 1. Cara Maria 2. Laurel 3. Nany 4. Theresa 5. Camila 6. Jonna 7. Jessica 8. Aneesa (she is not that great at missions) 9. Nia (Nothing impressive was just there disappointment for me) 10. LaToya (Over rate) 11. Jasmine 12. Jemmye 13. Devyn 14. Emilee 1. Zach 2. Bananas 3. CT 4. Cohutta 5. Frank 6. Johnny R 7. Dustin 8. Preston 9. Leroy 10. Jordan 11. Brandon 12. Swift 13. Chet 14. Isaac
Battle of the Exes: Johnny/Camila Ty/Emly CT/Diem Dunbar/Paula Mark/Robin Abram/Cara Maria Aneesa/Rachel Sarah/Vinny Dustin/Heather Wes/Mandi Tryie/Jasmine Leroy/Naomi Nate/Priscilla
[QUOTE=PinkRose;424382]I am looking at the missions performance 1. Cara Maria 2. Laurel 3. Nany 4. Theresa 5. Camila 6. Jonna 7. Jessica 8. Aneesa (she is not that great at missions) 9. Nia (Nothing impressive was just there disappointment for me) 10. LaToya (Over rate) 11. Jasmine 12. Jemmye 13. Devyn 14. Emilee [/QUOTE] I find your girls side pretty interesting...Cara won 2 missions and they were big team ones. She also did well in the Sausage one, but other than that I can't pick out a standout performance. I have (for girls, based only on day challenges) 1. Laurel 2. Nany 3. Theresa 4. Cara Maria 5. Camila 6. Jonna 7. Aneesa 8. Jessica 9. Devyn (was on a few winning teams, won an individual challenge, didn't bring team down in hold that pose) 10. Nia 11. Latoya 12. Jasmine 13. Emilee (did well on the puzzle on the first one) 14. Jemmye (only did one challenge, which she DQed on)
Free Agents: Girls: 1. Laurel 2. Theresa 3. Cara Maria 4. Nany 5. Aneesa 6. Camila 7. Jessica 8. Jonna 9. Devyn 10. Nia 11. LaToya 12. Emilee 13. Jasmine 14. Jemmye Guys: 1. Zach 2. CT 3. Bananas 4. Johnny 5. Leroy 6. Cohutta 7. Frank 8. Brandon 9. Preston 10. Jordan 11. Swift 12. Isaac 13. Dustin 14. Chet
Im throwing a classic at you guys. The inferno 1 The Real World: CT Syrus Mike David Ace Mallory Trishelle Coral Julie Leah Road Rules Darrell Shane Abram Timmy Jeremy *honestly most of the road rules boys performed about the same.* Holly Veronica Christina Kendal Katie
Inferno 2: GOOD Guys: Landon Brad Mike Darrell Jon Jodi Julie Robin Jamie Shavonda The bad *****: CT Derrick Abram Dan Karamo Rachel Tina Tonya Veronica Beth Inferno 3 GOOD GUYS: Johnny Alton Timmy Davis Ace Paula Rachel Susie Cara Colie The bad *****: Abram Derrick Kenny Danny Tyrie Ev Tonya Janelle Jenn Aneesa
FREE AGENTS Males: 1) Bananas 2) CT 3) Zach 4) Cohutta 5) Frank 6) Riley 7) Preston 8) Leroy 9) Swift 10)Jordan 11) Isaac 12) Brandon 13) Dustin 14) Chet Females: 1) Laurel 2) Theresa 3) Cara Maria 4) Nany 5) Jessica 6) Devyn 7) Aneesa 8) Camila 9) Jonna 10)Latoya 11)Nia 12)Emilee 13)Jazmin 14)Jemmye
[QUOTE=JayTee;424419]FREE AGENTS Males: 1) Bananas 2) CT 3) Zach 4) Cohutta 5) Frank 6) Riley 7) Preston 8) Leroy 9) Swift 10)Jordan 11) Isaac 12) Brandon 13) Dustin 14) Chet Females: 1) Laurel 2) Theresa 3) Cara Maria 4) Nany 5) Jessica 6) Devyn 7) Aneesa 8) Camila 9) Jonna 10)Latoya 11)Nia 12)Emilee 13)Jazmin 14)Jemmye[/QUOTE] Why are Jessica and Devyn even that high?
[QUOTE=Fresh Meat;424426]Why are Jessica and Devyn even that high?[/QUOTE] Jessica won more missions than people like Aneesa and Camila. All Aneesa has done is beat Jonna. Devyn has won more missions than people like Aneesa and Camila. Although an argument could be made to put Aneesa higher than Devyn. But I would still put Jessica higher on this list than Aneesa. Jessica has been a sleeper.
Rivals 1: Johnny/Tyler CT/Adam *substantial gap* Kenny/Wes Evan/Nehemiah Mike/Leroy Brandon/Ty Tyrie/Davis Ev/Paula Laurel/CM Jenn/Mandi Camila/Theresa Jasmine/Jonna Sarah/Katelynn Aneesa/Robin
[QUOTE=JayTee;424429]Jessica won more missions than people like Aneesa and Camila. All Aneesa has done is beat Jonna. Devyn has won more missions than people like Aneesa and Camila. Although an argument could be made to put Aneesa higher than Devyn. But I would still put Jessica higher on this list than Aneesa. Jessica has been a sleeper.[/QUOTE] Aneesa proved her worth in eliminations at least and just off the top of my head in the first mission Camila did her portion in 20 seconds, while Jess took 3 minutes. Winning missions with this format doesn't mean much unless she had a good hand in the win.
Rivals 1: 1) Johnny/Tyler 2) CT/Adam 3) Kenny/Wes 4) Mike and Leroy 5) Evan and Nehemiah 6) Brandon/Ty 7) Tyrie/Davis Females: 1) Ev/Paula 2) Laurel/CM 3) Camila/Theresa 4) Jenn/Mandi 5) Jasmine/Jonna 6) Sarah/Katelynn 7) Aneesa/Robin I feel like pair challenges don't give us a good variety on ranking people. It's always 2 or 3 good teams, 2 or so decent teams and everyone else is trash.
Can someone do a Cutthroat ranking? I only recall about half of the cast's performance and would be interested in seeing a full ranking.
[QUOTE=JayTee;424436]Rivals 1: 1) Johnny/Tyler 2) CT/Adam 3) Kenny/Wes 4) Mike and Leroy 5) Evan and Nehemiah 6) Brandon/Ty 7) Tyrie/Davis Females: 1) Ev/Paula 2) Laurel/CM 3) Camila/Theresa 4) Jenn/Mandi 5) Jasmine/Jonna 6) Sarah/Katelynn 7) Aneesa/Robin I feel like pair challenges don't give us a good variety on ranking people. It's always 2 or 3 good teams, 2 or so decent teams and everyone else is trash.[/QUOTE] I think that is more on casting, rather than pairs challenges, but I agree...
[QUOTE=Fresh Meat;424433]Aneesa proved her worth in eliminations at least and just off the top of my head in the first mission Camila did her portion in 20 seconds, while Jess took 3 minutes. Winning missions with this format doesn't mean much unless she had a good hand in the win.[/QUOTE] 1 elimination. Laurel beat her on her own turf. However, I guess you can give credit to Aneesa in Oppenheimer but then you would also have to give credit to Jessica in Balls In because she did pretty good. And yes Camila did faster than Jess, but she got eliminated too quickly to really compare the amount of work she put in. Jessica has always performed well on missions. Meanwhile you have Aneesa, a VETERAN with a loud mouth, who can't even remotely change her teams strategy to win (the colored bands mission).
[QUOTE=Fresh Meat;424433]Aneesa proved her worth in eliminations at least and just off the top of my head in the first mission Camila did her portion in 20 seconds, while Jess took 3 minutes. Winning missions with this format doesn't mean much unless she had a good hand in the win.[/QUOTE] But then Jessica was top 2 in the bike mission and top 3 in the wrap mission. It is hard to judge though... especially since Camila wasn't around long enough.
Now that I think about it, it is more difficult to judge someone who stayed for more time and we got to see compete individually over someone who left earlier. Still though, Devyn should be nearing the bottom and I am a Devyn fan.
[QUOTE=Fresh Meat;424439]Can someone do a Cutthroat ranking? I only recall about half of the cast's performance and would be interested in seeing a full ranking.[/QUOTE] Cutthroat's tough. There's a LOT of room for disagreement. But based solely on day challenges I'd say: MEN: Abram Derrick Bananas Luke (not a standout but solid the whole time) Tyler (best on his team but a few subpar performances) Dan Brad* Dunbar* Brandon Chet Big Easy Ty Vinny Derek JD *Brad and Dunbar were pretty bad all season. I barely wanted them that high. WOMEN Laurel Jenn Camila Emily Theresa* Sarah* Cara Maria* Tori Paula Katie Ayiiia Melinda Mandi Emilee Shauvon *These three are interchangeable to me.
Didn't Sarah perform fairly well that season? I originally thought she was the second best. Also, unless aside from a few, the girls were subpar, I remember Emily being just decent and even holding Jenn back at times? Feel free to correct me though.
[QUOTE=Fresh Meat;424450]Didn't Sarah perform fairly well that season? I originally thought she was the second best. Also, unless aside from a few, the girls were subpar, I remember Emily being just decent and even holding Jenn back at times? Feel free to correct me though.[/QUOTE] Yeah. Emily Sarah Theresa and Cara can probably be switched around within that group. Emily and Sarah were probably the better two in some order.
Free Agents This is not in terms of their performance on Free Agents, but my ranking of them as a competitor as a whole. Guys: 1. CT 2. Bananas 3. Zach 4. Frank 5. Jordan 6. Leroy 7. Dustin 8. Johnny 9. Cohutta 10. Chet 11. Swift 12. Brandon 13. Preston 14. Isaac Girls: 1. Laurel 2. Cara Maria 3. Theresa 4. Camila 5. Nany 6. Aneesa 7. Jemmye 8. Jonna 9. Jessica 10. Nia 11. Jasmine 12. Emilee 13. Devyn 14. LaToya
That's a fairly accurate ranking for Cutthroat. I'd probably rank Sarah higher than Theresa based off my memory of her performance (other than the final). Abram was definitely MVP that season, it's just unbelievable how he lost to Ty on Exes.
Rivals Guys Rankings 1. Johnny & Tyler 2. CT & Adam 3. Kenny & Wes 4. Evan & Nehemiah 5. Leroy & Michael 6. Brandon & Ty 7. Tyrie & Davis Girls Rankings: 1. Paula & Evelyn 2. Laurel & Cara Maria 3. Camila & Theresa 4. Jenn & Mandi 5. Jasmine & Jonna 6. Aneesa & Robin 7. Katelynn & Sarah
[QUOTE=El Scorcho;424452]Free Agents This is not in terms of their performance on Free Agents, but my ranking of them as a competitor as a whole. Guys: 1. CT 2. Bananas 3. Zach 4. Frank 5. Jordan 6. Leroy 7. Dustin 8. Johnny 9. Cohutta 10. Chet 11. Swift 12. Brandon 13. Preston 14. Isaac Girls: 1. Laurel 2. Cara Maria 3. Theresa 4. Camila 5. Nany 6. Aneesa 7. Jemmye 8. Jonna 9. Jessica 10. Nia 11. Jasmine 12. Emilee 13. Devyn 14. LaToya[/QUOTE] Why is LaToya the lowest, even worse than Emilee, Devyn, Jasmine, and Jemmye? And why is Jordan so high and Cohutta so low?
[QUOTE=Youssarian;424457]Why is LaToya the lowest, even worse than Emilee, Devyn, Jasmine, and Jemmye? And why is Jordan so high and Cohutta so low?[/QUOTE] Because I think LaToya is a pathetic excuse for a competitor. She may do good at physical things which is good but has no gas (watch the first challenge of Free Agents). Maybe switch around Devyn and Emilee. Sure she beat Jemmye but I feel like Jemmye is good at more things than LaToya is. Jemmye may not be very good at physical contact stuff but that is fine, she has gas, endurance, stamina, and has seen the end of one of these things and worked hard to get there beating some of the best key female players in recent years. When LaToya has done that let me know. And like I said, I am ranking these players from an overall perspective, not just their performance on Free Agents. I feel Jordan would beat Cohutta in any of those elimination games on Free Agents, the only exception being Oppenheimer which would be a toss up because both Cohutta and Jordan are pretty quick.
[QUOTE=El Scorcho;424461]Because I think LaToya is a pathetic excuse for a competitor. She may do good at physical things which is good but has no gas (watch the first challenge of Free Agents). Maybe switch around Devyn and Emilee. Sure she beat Jemmye but I feel like Jemmye is good at more things than LaToya is. Jemmye may not be very good at physical contact stuff but that is fine, she has gas, endurance, stamina, and has seen the end of one of these things and worked hard to get there beating some of the best key female players in recent years. When LaToya has done that let me know. And like I said, I am ranking these players from an overall perspective, not just their performance on Free Agents. I feel Jordan would beat Cohutta in any of those elimination games on Free Agents, the only exception being Oppenheimer which would be a toss up because both Cohutta and Jordan are pretty quick.[/QUOTE] Wasn't she dehydrated? If you have her beating someone who is number 7 on your list of best competitors, I do not believe she should be last place. Also, I'm just curious on why Jordan is ranked so high above Cohutta. Cohutta has been solid on all the Challenges he's done, whereas Jordan was good on Rivals 2 but not good on Free Agents.
[B][U]Cuthroat [/U][/B] [U]Males:[/U] 1) Abram 2) Tyler 3) Derrick 4) Bananas 5) Brad 6) Brandon 7) Luke 8) Dan 9) Dunbar 10) Vinny 11) Chet 12) Ty 13) Derek 14) Big Easy 15) JD [U]Females:[/U] 1) Laurel 2) Sarah 3) Jenn 4) Emily 5) Cara Maria 6) Camila 7) Theresa 8) Tori 9) Paula 10) Melinda 11) Ayiia 12) Katie 13) Mandi 14) Emilee 15) Shauvon
Does Jemmye even have stamina/endurance? Wasn't she holding Camila back in the mile run where they had to run then solve a puzzle?
[QUOTE=JayTee;424466][B][U]Cuthroat [/U][/B] [U]Males:[/U] 1) Abram 2) Tyler 3) Derrick 4) Bananas 5) Brad 6) Brandon 7) Luke 8) Dan 9) Dunbar 10) Vinny 11) Chet 12) Ty 13) Derek 14) Big Easy 15) JD [U]Females:[/U] 1) Laurel 2) Sarah 3) Jenn 4) Emily 5) Cara Maria 6) Camila 7) Theresa 8) Tori 9) Paula 10) Melinda 11) Ayiia 12) Katie 13) Mandi 14) Emilee 15) Shauvon[/QUOTE] Luke while not amazing, was consistently solid this season and should be a bit higher. I'd swap Camila and Emily, as well. No way Cara ranks higher than either girl though.

Pages