The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

[QUOTE=LHarkins;416984]Did women not win more than men in male v. female eliminations when they used to do it? And I can think of a few reasons why... - If you were against say two agile contestants in Knots So Fast you might want to put in two physical strong men in the hopes that if you can't out pace them you can at least maneuver the rope around easier than them etc... I just think it would be a fun twist on the format[/QUOTE] But you're ignoring the fact that its idiotic to send both guys into a elimination at all.....

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;416986]But you're ignoring the fact that its idiotic to send both guys into a elimination at all.....[/QUOTE] Not really. You could do it and force the other team into sending in their two guys to try and compensate (a power move). And with the rule that teams of two have the power to decide who goes into elimination they might not have a choice. But just because you don't see it doesn't mean it wouldn't happen. I could just as easily say it's idiotic to send a guy and a girl in. It's like when Team Cancun went into elimination against San Diego. They knew that CJ was the only one who stood a chance against Frank or Zach so it was sacrifice Derek and keep CJ in the game or try and have a fighting chance. There's two ways to think about it.

[QUOTE=LHarkins;416989]Not really. You could do it and force the other team into sending in their two guys to try and compensate (a power move). And with the rule that teams of two have the power to decide who goes into elimination they might not have a choice. But just because you don't see it doesn't mean it wouldn't happen. I could just as easily say it's idiotic to send a guy and a girl in. It's like when Team Cancun went into elimination against San Diego. They knew that CJ was the only one who stood a chance against Frank or Zach so it was sacrifice Derek and keep CJ in the game or try and have a fighting chance. There's two ways to think about it.[/QUOTE] If there are teams of two then no doubt they would be a team of two guys..... because who in there right mind would send in both guys and keep both girls? The less girls at the end is better just look at the ruins and the trim the fat for the gauntlet 3

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;416992]If there are teams of two then no doubt they would be a team of two guys..... because who in there right mind would send in both guys and keep both girls? The less girls at the end is better just look at the ruins and the trim the fat for the gauntlet 3[/QUOTE] Maybe they'd send in both guys to try and win the elimination round and take out competitors on the other person's team... It's really not that unrealistic. I wouldn't think it would be the prevailing strategy, but I could easily see it happening a couple times.

[QUOTE=Youssarian;417004]Maybe they'd send in both guys to try and win the elimination round and take out competitors on the other person's team... It's really not that unrealistic. I wouldn't think it would be the prevailing strategy, but I could easily see it happening a couple times.[/QUOTE] True, I just dislike gender neutral eliminations because I love physical eliminations/ missions

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;416959]That's why I said for the most part.......[/QUOTE] My fault. I didn't read that part.

[QUOTE=El Scorcho;417040]My fault. I didn't read that part.[/QUOTE] That's alright, do you at least like the cast

Free Agents 2: Location: Johannesburg, South Africa Same rules as the first season, except that everyone that didn't win has to take part on the Draw. 01. Zach Nichols 02. Rachel Robinson 03. Brian Williams 04. KellyAnne Judd 05. Darrell Taylor 06. Ashlee Feldmann 07. Leroy Garrett 08. Sarah Rice 09. Johnny Reilly 10. Theresa Gonzalez 11. Cory Wharton 12. Laurel Stucky 13. Frank Sweeney 14. Susie Meister 15. Jordan Wiseley 16. Ruthie Alcaide 17. Mark Long 18. Jenny Delich 19. Brad Fiorenza 20. Heather Cooke 21. CT Tamburello 22. Emily Schromm 23. Frank Roessler 24. Arielle Scott 25. Johnny Bananas 26. Camila Nakagawa 27. Derrick Kosinski 28. Marie Roda 29. Abram Boise 30. Averey Tressler Who do you think will make the final?

[QUOTE=nevidcm;417071]Free Agents 2: Location: Johannesburg, South Africa Same rules as the first season, except that everyone that didn't win has to take part on the Draw. 01. Zach Nichols 02. Rachel Robinson 03. Brian Williams 04. KellyAnne Judd 05. Darrell Taylor 06. Ashlee Feldmann 07. Leroy Garrett 08. Sarah Rice 09. Johnny Reilly 10. Theresa Gonzalez 11. Cory Wharton 12. Laurel Stucky 13. Frank Sweeney 14. Susie Meister 15. Jordan Wiseley 16. Ruthie Alcaide 17. Mark Long 18. Jenny Delich 19. Brad Fiorenza 20. Heather Cooke 21. CT Tamburello 22. Emily Schromm 23. Frank Roessler 24. Arielle Scott 25. Johnny Bananas 26. Camila Nakagawa 27. Derrick Kosinski 28. Marie Roda 29. Abram Boise 30. Averey Tressler Who do you think will make the final?[/QUOTE] If it's the same eliminations: Zach, Darrell, and CT. Emily, Rachel, and Laurel. I also think Cooke could make it but her and Laurel seem to have a similar political game (which is none at all). But since it's her 2nd one, I can't put her in over Laurel. And with strategist like Susie, Bananas, and Mark... they could make it to the end as well. I wouldn't overlook Arielle(politically), Ashlee(physically), and Brian(physically). They could make some waves as first time rooks. And of course the smaller beasts Derrick, Camila, and Abram could squeak in there but a couple of the big guys would have to take one another out for those guys to have a shot. Again, this is just if it's the same eliminations as the first one. If they added puzzles, strategy, and endurance elimination games, then things could definitely change.

[QUOTE=TeamLandon;417074]If it's the same eliminations: Zach, Darrell, and CT. Emily, Rachel, and Laurel. I also think Cooke could make it but her and Laurel seem to have a similar political game (which is none at all). But since it's her 2nd one, I can't put her in over Laurel. And with strategist like Susie, Bananas, and Mark... they could make it to the end as well. I wouldn't overlook Arielle(politically), Ashlee(physically), and Brian(physically). They could make some waves as first time rooks. And of course the smaller beasts Derrick, Camila, and Abram could squeak in there but a couple of the big guys would have to take one another out for those guys to have a shot. Again, this is just if it's the same eliminations as the first one, and maybe Oppenheimer too. If they added puzzles, strategy, and endurance elimination games, then things could definitely change.[/QUOTE] I think they should ditch Wrecking Wall and Looper, because it favors the bigger guy. The eliminations should be Balls In, Knot So Fast, something like Name that Coconut and Handcuffs. I think Arielle could do great. She seemed like she got along great with everyone on Ex-Plosion and she used to run track, plus she threw Cory to the floor easily, so she is definitely strong. She is definitely a threat and I would love to see her compete, but I doubt we will.

The Challenge: The Duel 3 Guys: [COLOR="#FF0000"]Brian Williams[/COLOR] Cory Wharton [COLOR="#008000"]CT Tamburello[/COLOR] [COLOR="#FFFF00"]Dunbar Flinn[/COLOR] [COLOR="#00FF00"]Johnny Devenanzio[/COLOR] [COLOR="#A9A9A9"]Jordan Wiseley[/COLOR] [COLOR="#800080"]Leroy Garrett[/COLOR] [COLOR="#00FF00"]Marlon Wiliams[/COLOR] [COLOR="#00FFFF"]Robb Schrieber[/COLOR] [COLOR="#FFFF00"]Ryan Knight[/COLOR] [COLOR="#A9A9A9"]Trey Weatherholtz[/COLOR] [COLOR="#0000FF"]Tyler Duckworth[/COLOR] [COLOR="#00FFFF"]Wes Bergmann[/COLOR] [COLOR="#FF0000"]Zach Nichols[/COLOR] Girls: [COLOR="#A9A9A9"]Ashley Kelsey[/COLOR] [COLOR="#FF0000"]Averey Tressler[/COLOR] [COLOR="#008000"]Cara Maria Sorbello[/COLOR] Emily Schromm [COLOR="#008000"]Jamie Larson[/COLOR] [COLOR="#00FFFF"]Jenny Delich[/COLOR] [COLOR="#A9A9A9"]Jonna Mannion[/COLOR] [COLOR="#00FF00"]KellyAnne Judd[/COLOR] [COLOR="#FFFF00"]Laurel Stuckey Nany Gonzalez[/COLOR] [COLOR="#0000FF"]Nia Moore[/COLOR] [COLOR="#800080"]Sam McGinn[/COLOR] [COLOR="#FF0000"]Sarah Rice[/COLOR] [COLOR="#800080"]Theresa Gonzalez[/COLOR] 3 guys/3 girls in the final challenge. Who gets there?

[QUOTE=El Scorcho;417146]The Challenge: The Duel 3 3 guys/3 girls in the final challenge. Who gets there?[/QUOTE] Girls: Emily Schromm, Laurel, Cara Guys:Johnny, CT, Zach

[QUOTE=auldx;417147]Girls: Emily Schromm, Laurel, Cara Guys:Johnny, CT, Zach[/QUOTE] And CM gets revenge on both Emily and Laurel, slaughtering them in the final. Best challenge. Ever.

[QUOTE=nevidcm;417071]Free Agents 2: Location: Johannesburg, South Africa Same rules as the first season, except that everyone that didn't win has to take part on the Draw. 01. Zach Nichols 02. Rachel Robinson 03. Brian Williams 04. KellyAnne Judd 05. Darrell Taylor 06. Ashlee Feldmann 07. Leroy Garrett 08. Sarah Rice 09. Johnny Reilly 10. Theresa Gonzalez 11. Cory Wharton 12. Laurel Stucky 13. Frank Sweeney 14. Susie Meister 15. Jordan Wiseley 16. Ruthie Alcaide 17. Mark Long 18. Jenny Delich 19. Brad Fiorenza 20. Heather Cooke 21. CT Tamburello 22. Emily Schromm 23. Frank Roessler 24. Arielle Scott 25. Johnny Bananas 26. Camila Nakagawa 27. Derrick Kosinski 28. Marie Roda 29. Abram Boise 30. Averey Tressler Who do you think will make the final?[/QUOTE] You should do a season summary

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;417154]You should do a season summary[/QUOTE] Episode 1: Mission: Bottleneck Stampede (two teams) Team Sarah: CT, Laurel, Zach, Kellyanne, Darrell, Camila, Bananas, Ruthie, Leroy., Marie, Brian, Arielle, Johnny R., Jenny Team Brad: Rachel, Mark, Emily, Derrick, Susie, Abram, Theresa, Frank R., Cooke, Jordan, Ashlee, Frank S., Averey, Cory Winning team: Team Brad Picked for elimination: Brian and Marie Draw victims: Johnny R. and Ruthie Elimination: Balls In Eliminated: Johnny R. and Ruthie Episode 2: Mission: Oil Change (teams of 4) Team Susie: CT, Sarah, Frank S. Team Brian: Emily, Brad, Jenny Team Cooke: Mark, Camila, Leroy Team Darrell: Rachel, Derrick, Marie Team Theresa: Zach, Kellyanne, Frank R. Team Bananas: Laurel, Abram, Averey Team Arielle: Cory, Ashlee, Jordan Winning team: Team Darrell Picked for elimination: Frank S. and Camila Draw victims: Zach and Susie Elimination: Handcuffs Eliminated: Frank S. and Susie Episode 3: Mission: Vertical Limit (individual) Winners: CT and Emily Picked for elimination: Cory and Theresa Draw victims: Abram and Camila Elimination: Knot So Fast Eliminated: Cory and Camila Episode 4: Mission: Block Party (two teams) Team Jenny: Zach, Laurel, Mark, Arielle, Derrick, Theresa, Bananas, Ashlee, Frank R., Marie, Jordan Team Abram: Emily, CT, Rachel, Darrell, Cooke, Brad, Kellyanne, Brian, Sarah, Leroy, Averey Winning team: Team Averey Picked for elimination: Jordan and Arielle Draw victims: Mark and Ashlee Elimination: Name that Coconut Eliminated: Jordan and Ashlee Episode 5: Mission: Roller Derby (individual) Winners: Zach and Rachel Picked for elimination: Bananas and Kellyanne Draw victims: Derrick and Sarah Elimination: Balls In Eliminated: Bananas and Sarah Episode 6: Mission: Riot Act (teams of 4) Team Cooke: Zach, Arielle, Abram, Team Leroy: Laurel, Brad, Marie Team Averey: CT, Theresa, Frank R. Team Darrell: Emily, Derrick, Jenny Team Rachel: Mark, Kellyanne, Brian Winning team: Team Rachel Picked for elimination: Frank R. and Averey Draw victims: CT and Arielle Elimination: Handcuffs Eliminated: Frank R. and Averey Episode 7: Mission: Stairway to Heaven (two teams) Team Marie: Darrell, Rachel, Derrick, Theresa, Mark, Cooke, Leroy, Jenny Team CT: Laurel, Zach, Emily, Abram, Kellyanne, Brian, Arielle, Brad Winning team: Team CT Picked for elimination: Leroy and Jenny Draw victims: Darrell and Cooke Elimination: Knot So Fast Eliminated: Leroy and Jenny Episode 8: Mission: Flying Leap (individual) Winners: Zach and Theresa Picked for elimination: Brad and Laurel Draw victims: Darrell and Emily Elimination: Name that Coconut Eliminated: Brad and Emily Episode 9: Mission: Hang On (co-ed partners) Team Kellyanne: CT Team Abram: Arielle Team Theresa: Zach Team Darrell: Rachel Team Cooke: Mark Team Derrick: Marie Team Laurel: Brian Winning team: CT and Kellyanne Picked for elimination: Brian and Cooke Draw victims: Abram and Marie Elimination: Balls In Eliminated: Abram and Marie Episode 10: Mission: Logged Out (teams of 4) Team Derrick: Laurel, CT, Theresa Team Arielle: Darrell, Cooke, Mark Team Brian: Rachel, Zach, Kellyanne Winning team: Team Arielle Picked for elimination: Brian and Kellyanne Draw victims: Zach and Rachel Elimination: Handcuffs Eliminated: Brian and Kellyanne Episode 11: Mission: Dodge Yer Balls (two teams) Team Rachel: Darrell, Laurel, Mark, Arielle, Team Zach: Theresa, CT, Cooke, Derrick Winning team: Team Zach Picked for elimination: Darrell and Laurel Draw victims: Mark and Rachel Elimination: Knot So Fast Eliminated: Mark and Laurel Episode 12: (Finals) 4th place: Derrick and Theresa 3rd place: Zach and Rachel Runner-up: CT and Arielle Winners: Darrell and Cooke

[QUOTE=nevidcm;417175]Episode 1: Mission: Bottleneck Stampede (two teams) Team Sarah: CT, Laurel, Zach, Kellyanne, Darrell, Camila, Bananas, Ruthie, Leroy., Marie, Brian, Arielle, Johnny R., Jenny Team Brad: Rachel, Mark, Emily, Derrick, Susie, Abram, Theresa, Frank R., Cooke, Jordan, Ashlee, Frank S., Averey, Cory Winning team: Team Brad Picked for elimination: Brian and Marie Draw victims: Johnny R. and Ruthie Elimination: Balls In Eliminated: Johnny R. and Ruthie Episode 2: Mission: Oil Change (teams of 4) Team Susie: CT, Sarah, Frank S. Team Brian: Emily, Brad, Jenny Team Cooke: Mark, Camila, Leroy Team Darrell: Rachel, Derrick, Marie Team Theresa: Zach, Kellyanne, Frank R. Team Bananas: Laurel, Abram, Averey Team Arielle: Cory, Ashlee, Jordan Winning team: Team Darrell Picked for elimination: Frank S. and Camila Draw victims: Zach and Susie Elimination: Handcuffs Eliminated: Frank S. and Susie Episode 3: Mission: Vertical Limit (individual) Winners: CT and Emily Picked for elimination: Cory and Theresa Draw victims: Abram and Camila Elimination: Knot So Fast Eliminated: Cory and Camila Episode 4: Mission: Block Party (two teams) Team Jenny: Zach, Laurel, Mark, Arielle, Derrick, Theresa, Bananas, Ashlee, Frank R., Marie, Jordan Team Abram: Emily, CT, Rachel, Darrell, Cooke, Brad, Kellyanne, Brian, Sarah, Leroy, Averey Winning team: Team Averey Picked for elimination: Jordan and Arielle Draw victims: Mark and Ashlee Elimination: Name that Coconut Eliminated: Jordan and Ashlee Episode 5: Mission: Roller Derby (individual) Winners: Zach and Rachel Picked for elimination: Bananas and Kellyanne Draw victims: Derrick and Sarah Elimination: Balls In Eliminated: Bananas and Sarah Episode 6: Mission: Riot Act (teams of 4) Team Cooke: Zach, Arielle, Abram, Team Leroy: Laurel, Brad, Marie Team Averey: CT, Theresa, Frank R. Team Darrell: Emily, Derrick, Jenny Team Rachel: Mark, Kellyanne, Brian Winning team: Team Rachel Picked for elimination: Frank R. and Averey Draw victims: CT and Arielle Elimination: Handcuffs Eliminated: Frank R. and Averey Episode 7: Mission: Stairway to Heaven (two teams) Team Marie: Darrell, Rachel, Derrick, Theresa, Mark, Cooke, Leroy, Jenny Team CT: Laurel, Zach, Emily, Abram, Kellyanne, Brian, Arielle, Brad Winning team: Team CT Picked for elimination: Leroy and Jenny Draw victims: Darrell and Cooke Elimination: Knot So Fast Eliminated: Leroy and Jenny Episode 8: Mission: Flying Leap (individual) Winners: Zach and Theresa Picked for elimination: Brad and Laurel Draw victims: Darrell and Emily Elimination: Name that Coconut Eliminated: Brad and Emily Episode 9: Mission: Hang On (co-ed partners) Team Kellyanne: CT Team Abram: Arielle Team Theresa: Zach Team Darrell: Rachel Team Cooke: Mark Team Derrick: Marie Team Laurel: Brian Winning team: CT and Kellyanne Picked for elimination: Brian and Cooke Draw victims: Abram and Marie Elimination: Balls In Eliminated: Abram and Marie Episode 10: Mission: Logged Out (teams of 4) Team Derrick: Laurel, CT, Theresa Team Arielle: Darrell, Cooke, Mark Team Brian: Rachel, Zach, Kellyanne Winning team: Team Arielle Picked for elimination: Brian and Kellyanne Draw victims: Zach and Rachel Elimination: Handcuffs Eliminated: Brian and Kellyanne Episode 11: Mission: Dodge Yer Balls (two teams) Team Rachel: Darrell, Laurel, Mark, Arielle, Team Zach: Theresa, CT, Cooke, Derrick Winning team: Team Zach Picked for elimination: Darrell and Laurel Draw victims: Mark and Rachel Elimination: Knot So Fast Eliminated: Mark and Laurel Episode 12: (Finals) 4th place: Derrick and Theresa 3rd place: Zach and Rachel Runner-up: CT and Arielle Winners: Darrell and Cooke[/QUOTE] OMG I loved your season summary more than the actually show LOL. I wanna make one now and I don't even like Free Agents.

[QUOTE=nevidcm;417175]Episode 1: Mission: Bottleneck Stampede (two teams) Team Sarah: CT, Laurel, Zach, Kellyanne, Darrell, Camila, Bananas, Ruthie, Leroy., Marie, Brian, Arielle, Johnny R., Jenny Team Brad: Rachel, Mark, Emily, Derrick, Susie, Abram, Theresa, Frank R., Cooke, Jordan, Ashlee, Frank S., Averey, Cory Winning team: Team Brad Picked for elimination: Brian and Marie Draw victims: Johnny R. and Ruthie Elimination: Balls In Eliminated: Johnny R. and Ruthie Episode 2: Mission: Oil Change (teams of 4) Team Susie: CT, Sarah, Frank S. Team Brian: Emily, Brad, Jenny Team Cooke: Mark, Camila, Leroy Team Darrell: Rachel, Derrick, Marie Team Theresa: Zach, Kellyanne, Frank R. Team Bananas: Laurel, Abram, Averey Team Arielle: Cory, Ashlee, Jordan Winning team: Team Darrell Picked for elimination: Frank S. and Camila Draw victims: Zach and Susie Elimination: Handcuffs Eliminated: Frank S. and Susie Episode 3: Mission: Vertical Limit (individual) Winners: CT and Emily Picked for elimination: Cory and Theresa Draw victims: Abram and Camila Elimination: Knot So Fast Eliminated: Cory and Camila Episode 4: Mission: Block Party (two teams) Team Jenny: Zach, Laurel, Mark, Arielle, Derrick, Theresa, Bananas, Ashlee, Frank R., Marie, Jordan Team Abram: Emily, CT, Rachel, Darrell, Cooke, Brad, Kellyanne, Brian, Sarah, Leroy, Averey Winning team: Team Averey Picked for elimination: Jordan and Arielle Draw victims: Mark and Ashlee Elimination: Name that Coconut Eliminated: Jordan and Ashlee Episode 5: Mission: Roller Derby (individual) Winners: Zach and Rachel Picked for elimination: Bananas and Kellyanne Draw victims: Derrick and Sarah Elimination: Balls In Eliminated: Bananas and Sarah Episode 6: Mission: Riot Act (teams of 4) Team Cooke: Zach, Arielle, Abram, Team Leroy: Laurel, Brad, Marie Team Averey: CT, Theresa, Frank R. Team Darrell: Emily, Derrick, Jenny Team Rachel: Mark, Kellyanne, Brian Winning team: Team Rachel Picked for elimination: Frank R. and Averey Draw victims: CT and Arielle Elimination: Handcuffs Eliminated: Frank R. and Averey Episode 7: Mission: Stairway to Heaven (two teams) Team Marie: Darrell, Rachel, Derrick, Theresa, Mark, Cooke, Leroy, Jenny Team CT: Laurel, Zach, Emily, Abram, Kellyanne, Brian, Arielle, Brad Winning team: Team CT Picked for elimination: Leroy and Jenny Draw victims: Darrell and Cooke Elimination: Knot So Fast Eliminated: Leroy and Jenny Episode 8: Mission: Flying Leap (individual) Winners: Zach and Theresa Picked for elimination: Brad and Laurel Draw victims: Darrell and Emily Elimination: Name that Coconut Eliminated: Brad and Emily Episode 9: Mission: Hang On (co-ed partners) Team Kellyanne: CT Team Abram: Arielle Team Theresa: Zach Team Darrell: Rachel Team Cooke: Mark Team Derrick: Marie Team Laurel: Brian Winning team: CT and Kellyanne Picked for elimination: Brian and Cooke Draw victims: Abram and Marie Elimination: Balls In Eliminated: Abram and Marie Episode 10: Mission: Logged Out (teams of 4) Team Derrick: Laurel, CT, Theresa Team Arielle: Darrell, Cooke, Mark Team Brian: Rachel, Zach, Kellyanne Winning team: Team Arielle Picked for elimination: Brian and Kellyanne Draw victims: Zach and Rachel Elimination: Handcuffs Eliminated: Brian and Kellyanne Episode 11: Mission: Dodge Yer Balls (two teams) Team Rachel: Darrell, Laurel, Mark, Arielle, Team Zach: Theresa, CT, Cooke, Derrick Winning team: Team Zach Picked for elimination: Darrell and Laurel Draw victims: Mark and Rachel Elimination: Knot So Fast Eliminated: Mark and Laurel Episode 12: (Finals) 4th place: Derrick and Theresa 3rd place: Zach and Rachel Runner-up: CT and Arielle Winners: Darrell and Cooke[/QUOTE] What is vertical limit from?

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;417220]What is vertical limit from?[/QUOTE] Original Battle of the Seasons - the player must climb up a rope with a buoys on it, and however many buoys they pass, they gain the same number of points.

[QUOTE=Youssarian;417224]Original Battle of the Seasons - the player must climb up a rope with a buoys on it, and however many buoys they pass, they gain the same number of points.[/QUOTE] Ah thanks, I'm bad with names

Free Agents 2 Scott(Brooklyn) Eric(New Orleans 2) Ace(Paris) Dan(Viewer's Revenge) Steven(Las Vegas 1) Cory(Ex-plosion) Marlon(Portland) Jay(Ex-plosion) Davis(Denver) Will(Hollywood) Brian(Ex-plosion) Ty(DC) Adam(Las vegas 2) Cj(Cancun) Cohutta(Sydney) Trey(St Thomas) Jenny(Ex-plosion) Beth(Los Angeles) Ayiiia(Cancun) Ruthie(Hawaii) Kellyanne(Sydney) Ashley(DC) Arielle(Ex-plosion) Tina(South Pacific) Cooke(Las Vegas 2) Avery(Portland) Ashlee(New Orleans 2) Ashley(San Diego 2) Jamie(Ex-plosion) Trishelle(Las Vegas 1) Laura(St Thomas) Janelle(Key West)

[QUOTE=Debut Album;417245]Free Agents 2 Scott(Brooklyn) Eric(New Orleans 2) Ace(Paris) Dan(Viewer's Revenge) Steven(Las Vegas 1) Cory(Ex-plosion) Marlon(Portland) Jay(Ex-plosion) Davis(Denver) Will(Hollywood) Brian(Ex-plosion) Ty(DC) Adam(Las vegas 2) Cj(Cancun) Cohutta(Sydney) Trey(St Thomas) Jenny(Ex-plosion) Beth(Los Angeles) Ayiiia(Cancun) Ruthie(Hawaii) Kellyanne(Sydney) Ashley(DC) Arielle(Ex-plosion) Tina(South Pacific) Cooke(Las Vegas 2) Avery(Portland) Ashlee(New Orleans 2) Ashley(San Diego 2) Jamie(Ex-plosion) Trishelle(Las Vegas 1) Laura(St Thomas) Janelle(Key West)[/QUOTE] On the plus side...there's no chance of anything like this happening

[QUOTE=kvm1977;417248]On the plus side...there's no chance of anything like this happening[/QUOTE] Well yeah that's why it's a FANTASY cast. But actually I wish a cast like that could happen. It would be cool.

[QUOTE=Debut Album;417254]Well yeah that's why it's a FANTASY cast. But actually I wish a cast like that could happen. It would be cool.[/QUOTE] Why, Cooke & CJ would just dominate the whole time

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;417256]Why, Cooke & CJ would just dominate the whole time[/QUOTE] I don't think so. they're strong, But I don't think they are strong enough to dominate. And even if they did. It'd be better than watching Backpack walk to the end unscathed for the umpteenth time or some Non-castmember controlling everything.

[QUOTE=Debut Album;417259]I don't think so. they're strong, But I don't think they are strong enough to dominate. And even if they did. It'd be better than watching Backpack walk to the end unscathed for the umpteenth time or some Non-castmember controlling everything.[/QUOTE] No, he's right...it would be the Cooke/CJ show

[QUOTE=kvm1977;417266]No, he's right...it would be the Cooke/CJ show[/QUOTE] I disagree but whatever it's just a fantasy list.

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;417256]Why, Cooke & CJ would just dominate the whole time[/QUOTE] We only saw CJ do good in 1 challenge. I don't think that's enough to claim he'll dominate anything. He's not a good strategist or politician and can easily be eliminated in a puzzle or strategy elimination. Same for Cooke.

[QUOTE=TeamLandon;417316]We only saw CJ do good in 1 challenge. I don't think that's enough to claim he'll dominate anything. He's not a good strategist or politician and can easily be eliminated in a puzzle or strategy elimination. Same for Cooke.[/QUOTE] I don't think there's even intelligent people in the rest of those casts CJ & Cooke might even win a puzzle if there was a puzzle...and, yes, I remember FM2 but CJ threw that Ashlee could be a huge threat to Cooke but the guys side is actually worse than the female side this season

[QUOTE=kvm1977;417317]I don't think there's even intelligent people in the rest of those casts CJ & Cooke might even win a puzzle if there was a puzzle...and, yes, I remember FM2 but CJ threw that Ashlee could be a huge threat to Cooke but the guys side is actually worse than the female side this season[/QUOTE] I disagree. First, thoughts on the cast. I love rookies and I would like to see, in fact, a LOT of those people back on a Challenge... but not all together. It's just not a captivating enough group for me. That said, it is your fantasy cast so I respect your decision. I think that the competition would not be as clear-cut as previous posters make it seem to be. Threats for CJ could include Scott, Cory, Marlon, Brian, Cohutta, and Trey. Second tier threats could be Eric, Dan, perhaps Ace, even Davis or Will. Threats to Cooke could include Beth, Ruthie, KellyAnne, Arielle, and Ashlee. I could see second tier threats being Ashley Lindley, Averey, and Janelle.

[QUOTE=Youssarian;417319]I disagree. First, thoughts on the cast. I love rookies and I would like to see, in fact, a LOT of those people back on a Challenge... but not all together. It's just not a captivating enough group for me. That said, it is your fantasy cast so I respect your decision. I think that the competition would not be as clear-cut as previous posters make it seem to be. Threats for CJ could include Scott, Cory, Marlon, Brian, Cohutta, and Trey. Second tier threats could be Eric, Dan, perhaps Ace, even Davis or Will. Threats to Cooke could include Beth, Ruthie, KellyAnne, Arielle, and Ashlee. I could see second tier threats being Ashley Lindley, Averey, and Janelle.[/QUOTE] Cohutta isn't a threat--I know many love him but he's not beating anyone legit. People make way too big of a deal about him beating Wes in The Ruins--as Veronica clearly explained--Wes didn't have the help he needed. Marlon was far from impressive in his first challenge. Trey hasn't even been decent so far. Scott, Cory & Brian can't be judged yet. Ace sucks. He got a free pass once but other than that he was horrible. Beth & Ruthie are well passed their prime. KellyAnne would get crushed in anything physical and she's dumb as a rock. Very athletic but not truly a threat to Cooke. I'm still not sure how you're coming to these conclusions that newbies would be legit threats but given Ashlee's background there's some logic in this Basically, the attempt here was to put a bunch of mediocre to poor competitors together only 1 in each group is a clear cut favorite. Doesn't mean they'll win but there's a clear favorite.