The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

[QUOTE=Buck05;275803]Trying to keep it as realistic as possible - meaning I'm not picking cast members who have zero interest in challenges (of what I'm aware): 1. Real World Austin - Wes & Melinda 2. Real World Key West - Johnny & Paula 3. Real World Sydney - Dunbar & KellyAnne 4. Real World Brooklyn - Chet & Sarah 5. Real World Cancun - CJ & Jonna 6. Real World DC - Ty & Emily 7. Real World New Orleans - Knight & Jemmye 8. Real World Las Vegas - Leroy & Cooke 9. Real World San Diego - any of the new kids (maybe Frank & Sam?) 10. Road Rules Campus Crawl - Darrell & Kendal (isn't Kendal interested still?) 11. Road Rules South Pacific - Abram & Tina (not sure if Tina is still interested, but after Cutthroat I wouldn't be surprised) 12. Road Rules X-Treme - Derrick & Jillian 13. Fresh Meat 1 - Kenny & Evelyn 14. Fresh Meat 2 - Brandon & Laurel Boom. Let's do it :)[/QUOTE] Nice. I think I would replace Tina with Christena (if she would agree), and Brandon with Noor or Pete. I like Brandon, but he has been on the last three challenges and I want to see how Noor would do with a good partner. I would also add in Real World Paris CT and Mallory (if she would agree). I think I heard somewhere that Johanna would not do another challenge, but it makes me laugh to think of her and Wes having to partner each other.

[QUOTE=lilabennet;275807]Nice. I think I would replace Tina with Christena (if she would agree), and Brandon with Noor or Pete. I like Brandon, but he has been on the last three challenges and I want to see how Noor would do with a good partner. I would also add in Real World Paris CT and Mallory (if she would agree). I think I heard somewhere that Johanna would not do another challenge, but it makes me laugh to think of her and Wes having to partner each other.[/QUOTE] I would love Christena and Mallory on another challenge - but I was trying to be realistic. Neither would do another one, I'm sure - especially Mallory.

[QUOTE=Buck05;275809]I would love Christena and Mallory on another challenge - but I was trying to be realistic. Neither would do another one, I'm sure - especially Mallory.[/QUOTE] I know, but it is fun to think about. Do you think any of the other girls from Paris would do it? CT really does draw ratings and that is what we need for the challenge to be renewed. Although, he would be knocked out right away if Leah was his partner, so that would just be a waste of an appearance fee.

[QUOTE=Buck05;275803]Trying to keep it as realistic as possible - meaning I'm not picking cast members who have zero interest in challenges (of what I'm aware): 1. Real World Austin - Wes & Melinda 2. Real World Key West - Johnny & Paula 3. Real World Sydney - Dunbar & KellyAnne 4. Real World Brooklyn - Chet & Sarah 5. Real World Cancun - CJ & Jonna 6. Real World DC - Ty & Emily 7. Real World New Orleans - Knight & Jemmye 8. Real World Las Vegas - Leroy & Cooke 9. Real World San Diego - any of the new kids (maybe Frank & Sam?) 10. Road Rules Campus Crawl - Darrell & Kendal (isn't Kendal interested still?) 11. Road Rules South Pacific - Abram & Tina (not sure if Tina is still interested, but after Cutthroat I wouldn't be surprised) 12. Road Rules X-Treme - Derrick & Jillian 13. Fresh Meat 1 - Kenny & Evelyn 14. Fresh Meat 2 - Brandon & Laurel Boom. Let's do it :)[/QUOTE] I don't think Tina 'would' do another challenge any time soon, if asked, strictly based off of her facebook. I haven't spoken to her in months (despite living all but down the street from her workplace and seeing her around town every so often). But her career seems to be doing well so I doubt she'd do a challenge.

I think they could do a battle of the seasons with a points format. The two teams with the overall most points and the winner of the challenge make up the inner circle and choose one team to face off against the team that has overall, the lowest amount of points. This way, there are no free rides and you have to do pretty well in challenges. RW: 16 Wes and Melinda RW: 17 Johnny and Paula RW: 19 Isaac and Kellyanne RW: 21 Scott and Sarah RW: 22 Bronne and Ayiiia RW: 23 Ty and Emily RW: 24 Knight and Ashlee RW: 25 Dustin and Nany RW: 26 Nate and Priscilla FM: 1 Kenny and Diem FM: 2 Pete and Laurel RR: 11 Darrell and Kendal RR: 12 Abe and Tina RR: 13 Derrick and Ibis

I have been kicking around an idea over the last week. It would be hard to put together as an actual challenge but I find it really exciting. If some form of this could take shape, I'd be all over it. First of all , for this challenge to go down, production will need to loosen up a bit and make the challenge environment fun again. That means a computer with internet, a few phone calls a week to loved ones, bring a book, bring music on an MP3 player, and weekly outing/activity for fun. Reason why I think they need that is so people will want to do the show. If they think it will be like a fun party they used to have back in the day, they will be more willing to come. Now on to the premise: We have had battle of the sexes, we have had battle of the seasons. Now we will have... [B]Battle of the Eras![/B] 3 Teams (similar to cutthroat) [B]The New Challengers[/B]: (Everybody from Fresh Meat up or anybody who is doing their first challenge) [B]The All-Stars:[/B] (All your favorite regulars from Fresh Meat II onward) [B] The Legends:[/B] (Anyone before fresh meat who played back in the day) Format: Team vs Team vs Team challenge. When elimination time comes up, each team sends in a representative. They battle it out 1 on 1 on 1. The winner of the battle royal gets a prize and money. The two losers do a round 2 where the winner stays the loser goes home. Possible team makeup: (5 guys 5 girls) [B] New Challengers[/B] Women: Camila Laurel Cara Marie Vegas/San Diego chicks Men Noor Leroy Brandon Vegas/San Diego dudes [B]All-Stars[/B] Women: Ev Paula KellyAnne Diem Johanna/Janelle etc. Men Wes Kenny Johnny Tyler Nehemiah/Frank/Evan (if he comes back)/Dunbar/Tyrie/etc Now the hope is that the funner atmosphere combined with the fact that this may be the final challenge will get some old favorite to come back. [B] Legends[/B] Women Jillian Kina Coral Anessa Rachel/Veronica/Robin/Susie/Roni/Iruleon/etc Men Mark Long Derrick Alton Darrell Abe a million others ---------------------------------------------------------- Now it would be very difficult to get the older people to sign on. Makr Long and Derrick seem available, Abe might be down but it would be really tough to get the Alton's Darrell's, and others back. Maybe all the legends would get a new contract that pays significantly more, I don't know. My hope is that seeing that this may be the last challenge, and it is kind of like an all encompassing challenge send off for the fan, some people may be willing to come back. Preferably I would like a slightly bigger roster but 30 is the most people I have seen I believe. As far as the actual challenges go, I would like see more back to basics set ups. We don't need these elaborate water gymnastics all the time, let's do some old school roll around in the dirt, run an obstacle course, type of challenges. They seem like they would be far cheaper as well. Why do they keep wasting money on these giant water contraptions? If you can't tell I really don't like these water challenges.

Thought of this today: [B]Rules:[/B] - 32 competitors: 16 male and 16 female. - There are no set teams, although there are teams. - Each mission will have 2 captains. The captains will be male on male elimination day and female on female elimination day. The two captains are determined by performance in the previous mission. The two people who do the best from the winning team during elimination day of the opposite *** will be captains for the next mission. - Teams will be picked prior to every mission, meaning there will be different teams throughout. Whoever placed first in the previous mission gets first pick. The choosing of the teams will be done in snake format so that whoever gets second pick goes again right after that. - There will be two eliminations per episode. Whoever does the worst from each team will automatically go into elimination. Then, each team will nominate one person from their own team to go in. Whoever is nominated from his own team gets to choose who he or she wants to go against. The other two left automatically face each other. - 12 people will make it to the finals: Six men and six women. The final captains will be determined by whoever performed the best throughout the competition. - Each person has an individual bank account. If you win a mission, you get money. If you lose it, you get no money. Money will transfer to someone's account if they lose in an elimination round. This format allows for a lot of different things. Now it's tougher to keep weak links until the end because of how the final will go down, considering you don't want to be on that person's team. It also splits up alliances since if you're on the other team, you can't throw the mission or else you'll go in.

Not sure if this has been mentioned... but on Wikipedia (yes i know they are wrong most of the time) it says that the new challenge will be The Island II filmed in Tsiombe, Madagascar how did this info come about?

I want the next challenge to be a Duel 3 or RW vs. RR vs. FM. Please no more pairs!

[QUOTE=202mitch;275845]Not sure if this has been mentioned... but on Wikipedia (yes i know they are wrong most of the time) it says that the new challenge will be The Island II filmed in Tsiombe, Madagascar how did this info come about?[/QUOTE] Lol what wikipedia page did you read that, and just look at the Notes where they got it from.

I want this new challenge with new format and more players.

My guess will be The Island II or The Battleground.

[QUOTE=rwrrmaster;275853]My guess will be [B]The Island II[/B] or The Battleground.[/QUOTE] I doubt if they'd do anything with a title even remotely similar to The Island because nobody would watch!! I think that one is on everyone's "Least Favorite Challenges" list although it was actually a game-changer because it was the birth of the alliance that we all hold so near and dear to our hearts. I loved the premise of The Island but I wish they would have put more thought into executing it differently, such as having some daily challenges and a mid-game bonfire in which they used Johnny as kindling (just kidding, of course). I do love the title of your other guess: The Battleground. Just that title alone conjures up all sorts of possibilities.

[QUOTE=dagr317;275864]I doubt if they'd do anything with a title even remotely similar to The Island because nobody would watch!! I think that one is on everyone's "Least Favorite Challenges" list although it was actually a game-changer because it was the birth of the alliance that we all hold so near and dear to our hearts. I loved the premise of The Island but I wish they would have put more thought into executing it differently, such as having some daily challenges and a mid-game bonfire in which they used Johnny as kindling (just kidding, of course). I do love the title of your other guess: The Battleground. Just that title alone conjures up all sorts of possibilities.[/QUOTE] I was making up challenge names months ago for made up challenges that I created and the Battlegrounds was the name I came up with for my challenge. Weird how some people think alike. I do think it is a good title for a challenge.

Hey guys, new here, first post but I've been watching the challenges since BOTS2. Since that was the first one I watched and really enjoyed it I've been thinking they should bring back the format. Obviously the first two were very lopsided but I think they could come up with some decent ideas for challenges that could put both males and females on an equal playing field. Also they would obviously have to add an elimination round rather than the pathetic 'voteoff' that the first two had. Here is my idea for a cast with a mix of veterans and newbs: BOTS III Males: 1. Mark 2. Kenny 3. Shane 4. Evan 5. Syrus 6. Eric 7. Brad 8. Ryan 9. Frank 10. Noor 11. Derrick 12. Luke 13. Abram 14. Brandon 15. Adam 16. Vinny 17, Ace 18. Johnny Females: 1. Aneesa 2. Tori 3. Beth 4. Casey 5, Rachel 6. Diem 7. Ruthie 8. Evelyn 9. Tonya 10. Laurel 11. Coral 12. Theresa 13. Tina 14. Mandi 15. Ibis 16. Katie 17. Kina 18. Veronica I think with the amount of money that MTV has to spend and this potentially being the last challenge, a lot of these veterans would come back. What do you guys think?

The Challenge: Battle of the Seasons 2 Austin: Danny & Johanna Key West: Johnny & Paula Sydney: Dunbar & KellyAnne Cancun: CJ & Jonna D.C.: Emily & Ty New Orleans: Ashlee & Knight Las Vegas: Cooke & Leroy The Quest: Adam & Katie Campus Crawl: Darrell & Rachel South Pacific: Abram & Cara X-Treme: Derrick & Jillian Viewer's Revenge: Dan & Tori Fresh Meat: Evelyn & Kenny Fresh Meat II: Pete & Theresa

[QUOTE=GiggidyGoo90;275543][B][U]Battle of the Seasons 2[/U][/B] Leroy and Cooke (RW Las Vegas) Knight and [B]Jemmye[/B] (RW New Orleans) Pete and Laurel (Fresh Meat 2) Sarah and Chet (RW Brooklyn) Dunbar and Kellyanne (RW Sydney) Wes and Johanna (RW Austin) Ty and Emily (RW DC) Tyler and Paula (RW Key West) Kenny and Evelyn (Fresh Meat) CJ and Jonna (RW Cancun) Zach and Ashley (RW San Diego) Derrick and Jillian (RR X-Treme)[/QUOTE] I like this!! But for me I'd put Ashlee on that team. [QUOTE=beecee;275696]Though this has no chance of happening I would love to see a Battle of the Sexes with Ev, Laurel, Emily and Cooke representing the girls. I really think they'd have an awesome chance of beating the boys.[/QUOTE] Agreed!!! If the competition was fair and not based too much on strength these girls would have a good chance to win!! [QUOTE=JEK & Wes;275804]Kenny & Evelyn would dominate that.[/QUOTE] I think they would definitely win!!!

[QUOTE=El Scorcho;276024]I was making up challenge names months ago for made up challenges that I created and the Battlegrounds was the name I came up with for my challenge. Weird how some people think alike. I do think it is a good title for a challenge.[/QUOTE] I came up with the name [B]The Challenge: Battlegrounds[/B] a few months ago also, my challenge concept was Team Real World vs Team Fresh Meat and have the challenge be like a war/military theme

[B][U]THE CHALLENGE: Battlegrounds.[/U][/B] [B][COLOR=blue]TEAM REAL WORLD [/COLOR][COLOR=black]VS [/COLOR][COLOR=red]TEAM FRESH MEAT[/COLOR][/B] [B][COLOR=#ff0000][/COLOR][/B] [B][U][COLOR=blue]TEAM REAL WORLD[/COLOR][/U][/B] [COLOR=#0000ff]CT (RW Paris)[/COLOR] [COLOR=#0000ff]Wes (RW Austin)[/COLOR] [COLOR=#0000ff]Leroy (RW Las Vegas)[/COLOR] [COLOR=#0000ff]Knight (RW New Orleans)[/COLOR] [COLOR=#0000ff]CJ (RW Cancun)[/COLOR] [COLOR=#0000ff]Dunbar (RW Sydney)[/COLOR] [COLOR=#0000ff]TY (RW DC)[/COLOR] [COLOR=#0000ff]Zach (RW San Diego)[/COLOR] [COLOR=#0000ff]Emily (RW DC)[/COLOR] [COLOR=#0000ff]Kellyanne (RW Sydney)[/COLOR] [COLOR=#0000ff]Ashlee (RW New Orleans)[/COLOR] [COLOR=#0000ff]Jonna (RW Canucun)[/COLOR] [COLOR=#0000ff]Cooke (RW Las Vegas)[/COLOR] [COLOR=#0000ff]Sarah (RW Brooklyn)[/COLOR] [COLOR=#0000ff]Jasmine(RW Cancun)[/COLOR] [COLOR=#0000ff]Ashley (RW San Diego)[/COLOR] [COLOR=#0000ff][/COLOR] [B][U][COLOR=red]TEAM FRESH MEAT[/COLOR][/U][/B] [COLOR=#ff0000]Kenny (FM1)[/COLOR] [COLOR=#ff0000]Evan (FM1)[/COLOR] [COLOR=#ff0000]Eric (FM1)[/COLOR] [COLOR=#ff0000]Pete (FM2)[/COLOR] [COLOR=#ff0000]Luke (FM2)[/COLOR] [COLOR=#ff0000]Vinny (FM2)[/COLOR] [COLOR=#ff0000]Brandon (FM2)[/COLOR] [COLOR=#ff0000]Noor (FM2)[/COLOR] [COLOR=#ff0000]Laurel (FM2)[/COLOR] [COLOR=#ff0000]Diem (FM1)[/COLOR] [COLOR=#ff0000]Evelyn (FM1)[/COLOR] [COLOR=#ff0000]Theresa (FM2)[/COLOR] [COLOR=#ff0000]Mandi (FM2)[/COLOR] [COLOR=#ff0000]Carley (FM2)[/COLOR] [COLOR=#ff0000]Cara Maria (FM2)[/COLOR] [COLOR=#ff0000]Casey (FM1)[/COLOR] [B][U][COLOR=#ff0000][/COLOR][/U][/B] [COLOR=#0000ff][/COLOR]

[QUOTE=GiggidyGoo90;276158]I came up with the name [B]The Challenge: Battlegrounds[/B] a few months ago also, my challenge concept was Team Real World vs Team Fresh Meat and have the challenge be like a war/military theme[/QUOTE] Add road rules to the fresh meat team, that way you can still have some classic road rules challengers and you don't have to fill it up with just fresh meat people.

[QUOTE=Skeet;276163]Add road rules to the fresh meat team, that way you can still have some classic road rules challengers and you don't have to fill it up with just fresh meat people.[/QUOTE] My thought for this challenge was for it to be a throw back to past challenges when it was Real World vs Road Rules. But now the former Road Rulers are kinda played out and even though yes Kenny, Evan, Evelyn, Laurel, Theresa, and Cara Maria are kinda played out too but I can still see thme in the next challenge. The only Road Rulers I'd see would come back are Katie, Abe, Dan, Derek, and Jill, but I really don't want to see them back.

[QUOTE=GiggidyGoo90;276169]My thought for this challenge was for it to be a throw back to past challenges when it was Real World vs Road Rules. But now the former Road Rulers are kinda played out and even though yes Kenny, Evan, Evelyn, Laurel, Theresa, and Cara Maria are kinda played out too but I can still see thme in the next challenge. The only Road Rulers I'd see would come back are Katie, Abe, Dan, Derek, and Jill, but I really don't want to see them back.[/QUOTE] I don't mind seeing Darrell, Veronica, Rachel, Susie, Abe, Katie, Kina or Jill back.

[B][U]The Ruins II[/U][/B] [B]Old School[/B] (people who competed in the challenge before The Ruins I) Mark Long Wes Darrell Abe Shane Kenny CT Trishelle KellyAnne Kimberly Veronica Katie Tonya Shavoun [B]New School[/B] Ryan - New Orleans Thor Dustin Leroy Brandon Knight Joey - Cancun Laurel Nany Ayiiia Jemmye Cara Maria Mackenzie Jasmine

[B]Old school vs New school[/B] or a [B]brand new individual challenge[/B] with the same cast Mark Darrell CT Wes Landon Derrick Theo Abe Coral Aneesa Beth Katie Brooke Veronica ruthie Trishelle New school Leeroy Mike (d.c) Zach (san diego) Dustin Nate(san diego) CJ Cohutta Pete Laurel Kelly anne Jasmine Ashlee (NOLA) or Nany Jonna Jeymee (NOLA) Cooke Emily (d.c)

Okay I'm gonna take a Crack at this "Old school vs New School" thing. The Gauntlet-Old School vs New School. Old School. Eric(New York) Syrus(Boston) Nathan(Seattle) Jaime(New Orleans) Mark(Road Rules) Dan(Northern Trail) Chadwick(Down Under) Yes(Semester At Sea) Jo(San Francisco) Ruthie(Hawaii) Beth(Los Angeles) Melissa(Miami) Kathryn(Maximum Velocity Tour) Holly(Latin America) Belou(Europe) Emily(Second Adventure) New School. Scott(Brookyln) Ty(DC) Knight(New Orleans 2) Leroy(Las Vegas 2) Adam(The Quest) Darrell(Campus Crawl) Dan(Viewer's Revenge) Patrick(X-TREME) Sarah(Brooklyn) Emily(DC) Kellyanne(Sydney) Jonna(Cancun) Christina(South Pacific) Kendall(Campus Crawl) Jisela(The Quest) Jodi(X-TREME)

[B]The Duel 3. [/B] Posted this cast before, but thought of something that might make it an interesting format. For each event, the worst performing challenger is automatically going into the duel. The next worst performing challenger is up for "nomination". The winner of each event gets to select any of the remaining players (excluding himself) for "nomination". The person automatically going in gets to select from these two players who they want to face. They go into the Duel. Winner stays. I originally said the two worst performing players should go in against one another, but this way, some strategy is still involved. Alliances still come into play, but it would be very tough for any alliance to take over the game. BMP, if you're listening... [B]GUYS[/B] Johnny Evan Kenny Wes CT Leroy Derrick Tyler Landon Darrell Brandon Danny Adam K. Mark Long Nehemiah [B]GIRLS[/B] Evelyn Laurel Cara Maria Paula Aneesa Diem Ruthie Heather Susie Cooke Theresa Camilla Sarah Nany Jonna

Completely new concept (doesn't effect me too much as long as these people are on it). [B][U]Girls:[/U][/B] Kellyanne - SY Trishelle - LV Laurel - FM2 Cooke - LV2 Jasmine - CC Sarah - BK Rachel - RR:CC Brooke -DN Susie - RR: DU Emily - DC Jemmye - NO2 Diem - FM [B][U]Guys:[/U][/B] Kenny - FM Wes - AU CT - PA Noor - FM2 CJ - CC Scott - BK Shane - RR:CC? Abram - RR:SP Dustin - LV2 Leroy - LV2 Derrick - RR:XT Ty - DC

The Duel 3: Landon Alton Darrell CT Mark Wes Evan Kenny Derrick Abram Johnny Noor Leroy Pete Brad KellyAnne Evelyn Laurel Rachel R. Tori Cara Maria Susie Brittini Jonna Svetlana Kina Jodi Aviv Sarah Veronica

This thread's made me realize there are a lot more JEK and LEC fans than I had originally thought....

Next Challenge: Real World vs. Road Rules/FM Real World: Nathan (Seattle) CT Landon Isaac Scott Bronne Knight Leroy Ruthie Trishelle Robin Kellyanne Emily Jemmye Ashlee Nany Road Rules/FM Darrell Shane Abram David Leetch Kenny Pete Noor Vinny Susie Christena Katie Kendal Jillian Diem Laurel Cara Maria