American Idol Season 9 - Discussion

437 posts / 0 new
Last post
Anonymous
Anonymous's picture
I heart Jeff Goldford.
They are horrible as a group. I have actually seen Kansas (don't ask) and this was bad.
These guys sound awful. Insider I disagree. I am over the raspy singer guys. David Cook was enough for me.
Anonymous
Anonymous's picture
What? I thought Ben was good. :(
These groups need to get better fast. He was ok, I guess...I just don't like the raspy sound.
Simon is a ******. Haha. He is the show.
Mr. Jailbird looks like a fatter Tim Tebow.
Do any other judges just jump in and can a group or even an entrant? No... Simon does it all the time...
Anonymous
Anonymous's picture
WHAT. was all over her face?
I hope that bossy girl goes home.
I generally enjoy this part of the series and tonight I am using it to bridge to Lost. ;)
[QUOTE=Bacchus;156705]I generally enjoy this part of the series and tonight I am using it to bridge to Lost. ;)[/QUOTE] But men's figure skating is on! You told me that was your favorite.
[QUOTE=molds13;156707]But men's figure skating is on! You told me that was your favorite.[/QUOTE] Which is why I am saving that to my DVR, to savor - Forever.
Hope...she has a very interesting voice, but is off key at times (just slightly to my ear.) If she could be trained, she could be great as there is a re-verb quality to her singing that has gravity and is unique.
I am checking in between commercials...but they are dragging this stuff out and there really is nothing worth watching in my opinion....
Katie Stevens lives like 20 min from me. Local media coverage is increasing..
This Chris Golighty DQ is pretty interesting. He was originally part of the top 24 and was disqualified for having a record deal in the past, (something like that, forgot the exact details). Apparently he is hiring a laywer to combat the decision.
Idol is allowing the top 24 to keep their social networking profiles going during the show... well, i guess it's not really "theirs" since they all have AI9 in the address and they all seem to have started today, but if you want to follow them, check this out [url=http://www.ryanseacrest.com/blog/whats-happening/idol-clears-season-9-contestants-to-use-twitter-facebook-myspace/]Ryan Seacrest | What's Happening[/url]
Anyone else watching? I'm going to record Lost tonight and watch the rest of this with my grandmother. She is an Idol addict. ;)
I'm watching. So far I LOVED Crystal and Didi! Enjoyed Michelle and Lilly.
[QUOTE=aimhack;158022]I'm watching. So far I LOVED Crystal and Didi! Enjoyed Michelle and Lilly.[/QUOTE] Did was great. It was not the best song for her, but she is still my favorite. Lilly was in my top three as was Michelle. Michelle might be the Idol, as she is the real deal and has the full package, although a bit bubbly for me. Crystal is talented, but failed with that song. The moment she started, I said...I really wish I could be listening to Alanis Morissette right now. The part I liked was when she called out the rules and said that she was not allowed to do original songs (being Idol would not have a rights deal and thus they only allow songs that they can make money on.)
Didi was the only good 1. I hope the men are better or else this season is over for me.
Anonymous
Anonymous's picture
I finally got around to watching tonight. I loved Kaitlyn. I love her voice. I love her style. I love her hair. She has star power. I'm excited to see more of her.
I feel like they were pretty hard on the contestants tonight and it's really too bad that most of the public doesn't have an opinion of their own they just listen to the juges. As for tonight: Didi is my favorite Lilly was good Siobhan was good Kaitlyn I thought was really good Michelle was very good I love Haeley's voice but she did awful on that song Paige was good but bad song selection Janell and Ashley weren't good lacey Brown wasn't very good Crystal was good but she really can't play harmonica Katie has a great voice but they're right on that one she can't be singing standards my guesses on for who gets out would be Ashley and Janell although Janell may still have a solid fanbase from American boy. So maybe Lacey too.
Michelle by far did the best last night. Despite what the judges said i think Didi and Katie both did very well. I also liked Katelyn. I am already annoyed with Crystal, i dont think she is that good at all. I will be shocked if lacey isnt gone she was terrible.
I really do not see Ashley losing because of her online fan base. I do however see Lacey losing. For a season meant to be all about the girls that wasn't that great. However, it is the first week so hopefully they got their nerves out of the way. I enjoyed Katelyn, Didi, Lily and Crystal. I think Siobhan can potentially do really good.
Let's hope the men out perform last night's slow start.
Yeah I feel like there will be. Some of my favorites are in this group like so far.
Anonymous
Anonymous's picture
Todrick Hall... ok. I like the arrangement of the Kelly Clarkson song. I wasn't feelin the vocals. On a side note: He has beautiful teeth.
Interestingly enough, I agree with Simon 95% percent of the time. He calls it as he sees it.

Pages