The Challenge: What Ifs

1963 posts / 0 new
Last post

Psy4potato wrote:

El Lobito wrote:What if Rogan was brought back to replace Eddie on Vendettas, or one of the alternates was used (Corey Brooks from BB18 and Derrick K)?I don't see Rogan or Corey winning "Who's Got Balls, but DerricK could have. And #Vendettas could have been anyone's game.All 3 of them would be super hard to take out in elimination, though. They could handily beat Shane, Tony, and Devin. Good chance of taking out Johnny and Kyle too.What a wasted fucking opportunity Eddie was. I'm so mad.

Derrick K should have been brought on when Eddie left.  No reason not to. 

Hell no. Derrick can forever stay his ass at home.

Why? So a random spot could just be wasted on an AYTO cast member that just disspeared?  Derrick would have given the guys more competition and there wouldn't be a random spot not filled for no reason.  He was there, they should have used him. 

What If Emily B. didn't disappear and they cast her on The Gauntlet with Rachel and Veronica. 

I feel like Emily would have been interesting to see in a group format with one on one eliminations. I also would have loved to see her politics. 

What if Johnny was sent home instead of Abe on the Island....I like to think Queen Rachel would have lasted longer.  Also what if Jenn/Paula/Robin/Ryan beat the A holes on the island...that would have been such a better ending to that season.   

This is probably my biggest "what if". If Abram didn't have to leave the island, they likely would have sent Bananas home (the vote was 9-6 even though Abram asked everyone to send him home to handle a business transaction or something). Anyway that would have kept Bananas from winning his first challenge, which also would not have put Bananas on the Champs team on the Ruins. I also wish that Brad wasn't a drunk ass and got himself and Darrell DQ'ed that season. Or if Wes went against Dunbar instead of Cohutta in that spool elimination. 

Psy4potato wrote:

What if Johnny was sent home instead of Abe on the Island....I like to think Queen Rachel would have lasted longer.  Also what if Jenn/Paula/Robin/Ryan beat the A holes on the island...that would have been such a better ending to that season.   

This is probably my biggest "what if". If Abram didn't have to leave the island, they likely would have sent Bananas home (the vote was 9-6 even though Abram asked everyone to send him home to handle a business transaction or something). Anyway that would have kept Bananas from winning his first challenge, which also would not have put Bananas on the Champs team on the Ruins. I also wish that Brad wasn't a drunk ass and got himself and Darrell DQ'ed that season. Or if Wes went against Dunbar instead of Cohutta in that spool elimination. 

Yeah I would have loved to see Johnny get an early boot from The Island...would have changed everythign and I would have liked it.  And it would have changed the Ruins not having Johnny on the Champs team.

Wes vs Dunbar would have been very interesting on the Ruins...I think Wes could have pulled out a win.  I don't see Dunbar doing that challenge well for some resason and would have got more confused than Wes. 

KingoftheTrill wrote:

Psy4potato wrote:What if Johnny was sent home instead of Abe on the Island....I like to think Queen Rachel would have lasted longer.  Also what if Jenn/Paula/Robin/Ryan beat the A holes on the island...that would have been such a better ending to that season.   

This is probably my biggest "what if". If Abram didn't have to leave the island, they likely would have sent Bananas home (the vote was 9-6 even though Abram asked everyone to send him home to handle a business transaction or something). Anyway that would have kept Bananas from winning his first challenge, which also would not have put Bananas on the Champs team on the Ruins. I also wish that Brad wasn't a drunk ass and got himself and Darrell DQ'ed that season. Or if Wes went against Dunbar instead of Cohutta in that spool elimination. 

Yeah I would have loved to see Johnny get an early boot from The Island...would have changed everythign and I would have liked it.  And it would have changed the Ruins not having Johnny on the Champs team.Wes vs Dunbar would have been very interesting on the Ruins...I think Wes could have pulled out a win.  I don't see Dunbar doing that challenge well for some resason and would have got more confused than Wes. 

crazy how pivotal Abram leaving was. 

As for Dunbar and Wes I’m not sure how the outcome would’ve been. The whole cast was helping Cohutta out so Dunbar could’ve also had that but then again, he’s Dunbar lol

Psy4potato wrote:

What if Johnny was sent home instead of Abe on the Island....I like to think Queen Rachel would have lasted longer.  Also what if Jenn/Paula/Robin/Ryan beat the A holes on the island...that would have been such a better ending to that season.   

This is probably my biggest "what if". If Abram didn't have to leave the island, they likely would have sent Bananas home (the vote was 9-6 even though Abram asked everyone to send him home to handle a business transaction or something). Anyway that would have kept Bananas from winning his first challenge, which also would not have put Bananas on the Champs team on the Ruins. I also wish that Brad wasn't a drunk ass and got himself and Darrell DQ'ed that season. Or if Wes went against Dunbar instead of Cohutta in that spool elimination. 

If he didnt have to leave, he wouldn't have been in the elimination in the first place 

What if Sarah didn't stop to poop on Exes 2? Would they have had a bigger lead or would it made her uncomfortable and Theresa and Leroy got ahead

What if Rivals 2 didn’t have the “3rd place goes home” rule? What do you think the rankings would’ve been. I think Jordan & Marlon could’ve beaten at least Bananas & Frank

What if Kam didn't have to burry the log?

What if Rivals 2 didn’t have the “3rd place goes home” rule? What do you think the rankings would’ve been. I think Jordan & Marlon could’ve beaten at least Bananas & Frank

same. Swimming was Marlon’s weakness and I think they would have faired well in the rest of the final. CT/Wes would still win 

What if Kam didn't have to burry the log?

She finished 4th or still doesn't beat Kailah.  She had a 10 showing and said higher--she deserved to have to bury the log

What if Kam didn't have to burry the log?

Not sure. Kam was running way slower after Kailah passed her but not sure if she was gassed or discouraged. Kailah got a lot of shit for the final but she kept a good pace towards the end.

Pages