The Challenge: What Ifs

1964 posts / 0 new
Last post

What if Nicole wins second redemption?

I think she would make the final. Let's say she gets Aneesa treatment and is sent to elimination right after coming back. Then she wins third redemption and next mission with puzzles. Robbed.

What if Amanda beat Jenna in redemption and her and Ashley would both still be there 

What if Amanda beat Jenna in redemption and her and Ashley would both still be there 

As much as I like them I think they'd only make it halfway or a little further. Dirty 30 had a lot of good girls voted in multiple times (Kailah, Aneesa and Camila). I can see them losing to them in the eliminations they were in. But would have been awesome if they won that puzzle redemption to come back. Probably would take Britini's spot. 

What if Simone and Shane never left.

First redemption would’ve happened after Briana and Derrick h went home, Darrell and Amanda win and a bunch changes 

 What if coral didn’t drop out, Darrell won the first redemption challenge....old school then could take complete control.  

 What if coral didn’t drop out, Darrell won the first redemption challenge....old school then could take complete control.  

darell would have won any of the eliminations looking back at it. And then he would have gotten win #5. Cara said her and him finished the Champs vs Pros final with at least half an hour until anyone came. He’s mentally strong enough also to endure a multiple day final. I see Coral linking up with Aneesa and Veronica just bc she knows them and none of them get along with Cara. I see her doing about the same as Veronica. She didn’t seem like she trained so idk if she would have made it to the final, although i would have LOVED her to 

What if Tyara, Sylvia and Anna (Bad Blood) was on Dirty 30 instead of Simone/LaToya/Britni.

What is Robbie, Dylan and Zach were on instead of Dario/Derrick H./Ammo

What if Tyara, Sylvia and Anna (Bad Blood) was on Dirty 30 instead of Simone/LaToya/Britni.

lets not disrespect Latoya 

thechallengemania wrote:

What if Tyara, Sylvia and Anna (Bad Blood) was on Dirty 30 instead of Simone/LaToya/Britni.

lets not disrespect Latoya 

Toya’s cool but NEVER makes it far I would much rather see Tya Wink

What if Rachel / Emily / Cooke / and Ev were all on Dirty 30....Cara Maria and Camila may not have gotten as far if there was a giant powerhouse of women. 

What if Rachel / Emily / Cooke / and Ev were all on Dirty 30....Cara Maria and Camila may not have gotten as far if there was a giant powerhouse of women. 

Bananas and Rachel would continue to go after each other like on the Island and Exes 2 lol.  

Psy4potato wrote:

What if Rachel / Emily / Cooke / and Ev were all on Dirty 30....Cara Maria and Camila may not have gotten as far if there was a giant powerhouse of women. 

Bananas and Rachel would continue to go after each other like on the Island and Exes 2 lol.  

queen Rachel would be ready this time and squash that bug and her and Queen V would reign again and the people would finally be at peace. 

Bananas was threatened by a strong female. During the time of The Island no girl played their own game and only played follow the leader. He was SHAKING during that vote off when his ass almost got sent home when Abram tried quitting LMFAOOOO.

What if Nicole wins second redemption?I think she would make the final. Let's say she gets Aneesa treatment and is sent to elimination right after coming back. Then she wins third redemption and next mission with puzzles. Robbed.

If Nicole won the 2nd redemption this is how I see it playing out very well for her. Let's say she did take Aneesas spot in the elimination vs Veronica. I am almost positive she beats Veronica in Web of Lies. After that elimination,  Jaliah had gunned for Cara/Camila so I can see Nicole flying under the radar for quite a bit. Even until the final purge. With the right male partner I say she wins that and goes to the final. All that to end up with a 3rd place finish. 

Bananas was threatened by a strong female. During the time of The Island no girl played their own game and only played follow the leader. He was SHAKING during that vote off when his ass almost got sent home when Abram tried quitting LMFAOOOO.

Never forget that glorious moment. I died when people still didn’t vote for Abram.  If only He stayed on the Island. That one decision changes the whole course of the show. That wouldn’t have been john’s First win. He wouldn’t have been a champ on the ruins etc. 

what if jordan made it to FA finale over Reily

He wins it and is a champ on his second season, an individual season. Very impressive.

And Johnny doesn't have his most impressive challenge win.

What if when Sydney was sent home on Seasons 2 they went back to the original plan of 2 vegas teams of Trishelle, Alton, Frank, Arissa & Dustin, Nany, Leroy, & Cooke?  And no Fresh Meat team.  

What if when Sydney was sent home on Seasons 2 they went back to the original plan of 2 vegas teams of Trishelle, Alton, Frank, Arissa & Dustin, Nany, Leroy, & Cooke?  And no Fresh Meat team.  

That season would have been even more iconic.

Psy4potato wrote:

What if when Sydney was sent home on Seasons 2 they went back to the original plan of 2 vegas teams of Trishelle, Alton, Frank, Arissa & Dustin, Nany, Leroy, & Cooke?  And no Fresh Meat team.  

That season would have been even more iconic.

agreed.   Any of the speculated teams instead of Fresh Meat would have made that season more Iconic than it has already turned out to be, but two LV teams or the Road Rules team would have been epic. 

Sydney should have never been sent home, had they been there over Fresh Meat it would have been the most iconic season. I will NEVER get over being deprived of Ashli on that season.

Psy4potato wrote:

What if when Sydney was sent home on Seasons 2 they went back to the original plan of 2 vegas teams of Trishelle, Alton, Frank, Arissa & Dustin, Nany, Leroy, & Cooke?  And no Fresh Meat team.  

That season would have been even more iconic.

What if they disqualified Cooke alongside Naomi on Rivals II and brought Cara Maria and Ayiiia as a replacement team? They’d probably flop and Aneesa and Diem would be our runner ups imo.

Because Brad is on vendetta I remembered 1 thing. What if Brad's ass didn't flop so hard in duel 2 final and won? The Ruins and Cutthroat would have been so much different and better because Evan wouldn't be on winning team and Brad/Tori possibly wouldn't do Cutthroat .

I honestly think if that was the case we wouldn't have had Ruins with that theme. Evan alongside with Kenny were the posterboys at that time and to have Evan in the opposite team wouldn't work for them. They would either go with veterans vs rookies again or they would have given a decent team of challengers to at least have Evan reach the final against his peers. 

If Toya was on Seasons instead of Lauren. Ashley, Erika, Josh, and Mike to replace Fresh Meat. ICONIC. 

If Toya was on Seasons instead of Lauren. Ashley, Erika, Josh, and Mike to replace Fresh Meat. ICONIC. 

Old School What If: 

What if Gauntlet Queen Sarah G lost her first Gauntlet?  That season would have had a comepltely different turn out for who was left

Old School What If: What if Gauntlet Queen Sarah G lost her first Gauntlet?  That season would have had a comepltely different turn out for who was left

I also don't think that season would be as good. That Sarah underdog story was it's heart.

Because Brad is on vendetta I remembered 1 thing. What if Brad's ass didn't flop so hard in duel 2 final and won? The Ruins and Cutthroat would have been so much different and better because Evan wouldn't be on winning team and Brad/Tori possibly wouldn't do Cutthroat .

Didn't brad flop because he was stuck with Aneesa? I dont remember clearly.

Pages