I don't think the list is "THAT" bad. Sub Evelyn in the top 10 for Sarah and change the order up and it's probably pretty good. They're hated but Evan and Kenny might be better than Derrick and Wes but that's debatable. Veronica, Coral and Susie are way too low. Yes is too high probably just based on All Stars. Diem & Dunbar being on the list are laughable. Devyn being on the list only makes sense because she was never sent home. Cory & Nelson being mad they aren't on the list is comical. Tori Hall should definitely be on the list and higher than Brad. Where the hell is Holly Shand and Jamie Murray? I mean...still there's been far worse lists
Yeah the top 10 is actually a very decent list. I just dont like how the top 10 is a very male dominated list. I wish both evelyn and cara maria were in there but then again I dont know who I would swap out to put them in.
I don't think the list is "THAT" bad. Sub Evelyn in the top 10 for Sarah and change the order up and it's probably pretty good. They're hated but Evan and Kenny might be better than Derrick and Wes but that's debatable. Veronica, Coral and Susie are way too low. Yes is too high probably just based on All Stars. Diem & Dunbar being on the list are laughable. Devyn being on the list only makes sense because she was never sent home. Cory & Nelson being mad they aren't on the list is comical. Tori Hall should definitely be on the list and higher than Brad. Where the hell is Holly Shand and Jamie Murray? I mean...still there's been far worse lists
Yeah the top 10 is actually a very decent list. I just dont like how the top 10 is a very male dominated list. I wish both evelyn and cara maria were in there but then again I dont know who I would swap out to put them in.
I don't think the list is "THAT" bad. Sub Evelyn in the top 10 for Sarah and change the order up and it's probably pretty good. They're hated but Evan and Kenny might be better than Derrick and Wes but that's debatable. Veronica, Coral and Susie are way too low. Yes is too high probably just based on All Stars. Diem & Dunbar being on the list are laughable. Devyn being on the list only makes sense because she was never sent home. Cory & Nelson being mad they aren't on the list is comical. Tori Hall should definitely be on the list and higher than Brad. Where the hell is Holly Shand and Jamie Murray? I mean...still there's been far worse lists
Yeah the top 10 is actually a very decent list. I just dont like how the top 10 is a very male dominated list. I wish both evelyn and cara maria were in there but then again I dont know who I would swap out to put them in.
My personal top10 would be:
1-Landon Lueck
2-John Devenanzio
3-CT Tamburello
4-Evelyn Smith
5-Darrell Taylor
6-Laurel Stucky
7-Jordan Wiseley
8-Emily Schromm
9-Kenny Santucci
10-Cara Maria Sorbello
I mean, there's no wrong here because there's a case for all of them to be top 10. I just don't see Cara as a top 10 because it took her a LONG time to be anywhere near that level. Sarah was better than Cara IMO the entire time they were both on the show together. Maybe Rachel Robinson goes into the top 10 if we have to add another one.
Think they were going off of stats which is why Sarah is so high (many finals, two wins) and Emily (never eliminated, win on her second or third try) not necessarily who's better than who.
Think they were going off of stats which is why Sarah is so high (many finals, two wins) and Emily (never eliminated, win on her second or third try) not necessarily who's better than who.
So why is Wes there and not Kenny for example? Kenny has like3 wins, 7 finals in just 8 challenges,
He has no doubt the better ratio out of anyone who has done this show
Rachel (I personally think she is THE best girl ever and Evelyn is smart for dodging challenge seasons with her)
Evelyn
Jordan
Laurel
The Miz
Camila (hate to admit it)
That's my top ten , wish Roni did more seasons back then I think she could've been an all time great, along with Kameelah. Ayanna definitely should've seen the elimination era, she'd be up there on the ranks too.
Ill give sort of a hot take...personally I don't think Emily should be in the top 10. If I were to swap her w anyone I'd say cara Maria, Ev or Rachel (interchangeable but lean more towards cara). Emily only won 1 and yes she is a beast no question. Ev all around beast I don't need to say anything else. Cara had that crazy streak of final appearances, made a final in a majority of shows (prob would've made it in FA without injury) and won a few. Pretty good elimination record and was a solo winner before. Rachael won a couple and outperformed everyone on duel 2 final. Emily has such a small sample size so really hard to put her as the best. Not saying she shouldn't be ranked high just not the best. IMO Ev, cara are above her and Emily/rachel interchangeable and then sarah
I've never understood the hype for Rachel as a competitor tbh I think of the time Kelly Anne smoked her effortlessly on the island in a face off. I think ppl hype up her potential more than anything else. I'll give her the Duel 2 final thing but ppl were overhyping her way before that. I would've liked to see her compete against Emily, Holly B and Holly S from the old-old school women to see how'd she fair against them.
Also Laurel was left out of the above poster's list but should def be included and I've noticed Jodi never gets mentioned as an elite competitor either despite being a beast and she-hulk. I'm not even rly a fan of hers but those are faxts, she's always a dominant competitor despite cracking under pressure at times.
The way they probably see it Emily did 4 challenges (counting the spin-off) made 2 finals in her first two shows and then won her next two shows. That's a Landon level stat even though she's lowkey overrated to me.
I agree about Rachel though easily top ten girl but I could see her getting squashed by a Laurel, Emily or Cara. I'd put her and Jodi on the same level IMO
Rachel (I personally think she is THE best girl ever and Evelyn is smart for dodging challenge seasons with her)
Evelyn
Jordan
Laurel
The Miz
Camila (hate to admit it)
That's my top ten , wish Roni did more seasons back then I think she could've been an all time great, along with Kameelah. Ayanna definitely should've seen the elimination era, she'd be up there on the ranks too.
Rachel (I personally think she is THE best girl ever and Evelyn is smart for dodging challenge seasons with her)
Evelyn
Jordan
Laurel
The Miz
Camila (hate to admit it)
That's my top ten , wish Roni did more seasons back then I think she could've been an all time great, along with Kameelah. Ayanna definitely should've seen the elimination era, she'd be up there on the ranks too.
rachel got beat by Kellyanne tho
I think Rachel should be #10 and shift everyone else up one. Ev is better, Laurel and then Camila (shes short af, but scrappy af - so for that. I think she'd beat rachel)
I've never understood the hype for Rachel as a competitor tbh I think of the time Kelly Anne smoked her effortlessly on the island in a face off. I think ppl hype up her potential more than anything else. I'll give her the Duel 2 final thing but ppl were overhyping her way before that. I would've liked to see her compete against Emily, Holly B and Holly S from the old-old school women to see how'd she fair against them.
Also Laurel was left out of the above poster's list but should def be included and I've noticed Jodi never gets mentioned as an elite competitor either despite being a beast and she-hulk. I'm not even rly a fan of hers but those are faxts, she's always a dominant competitor despite cracking under pressure at times.
I agree with a lot if this but it wasn't effortless by KellyAnne. Rachel was up there for a damn long time.
I've never understood the hype for Rachel as a competitor tbh I think of the time Kelly Anne smoked her effortlessly on the island in a face off. I think ppl hype up her potential more than anything else. I'll give her the Duel 2 final thing but ppl were overhyping her way before that. I would've liked to see her compete against Emily, Holly B and Holly S from the old-old school women to see how'd she fair against them.
Also Laurel was left out of the above poster's list but should def be included and I've noticed Jodi never gets mentioned as an elite competitor either despite being a beast and she-hulk. I'm not even rly a fan of hers but those are faxts, she's always a dominant competitor despite cracking under pressure at times.
I agree with a lot if this but it wasn't effortless by KellyAnne. Rachel was up there for a damn long time.
Kellyanne wasn't phased by the amount of time they were up there like Rachel was though
Yeah the top 10 is actually a very decent list. I just dont like how the top 10 is a very male dominated list. I wish both evelyn and cara maria were in there but then again I dont know who I would swap out to put them in.
He was called for all seasons. He wanted to do this one, but something happened. Season 1 covid stuff got in the way.
My personal top10 would be:
1-Landon Lueck
2-John Devenanzio
3-CT Tamburello
4-Evelyn Smith
5-Darrell Taylor
6-Laurel Stucky
7-Jordan Wiseley
8-Emily Schromm
9-Kenny Santucci
10-Cara Maria Sorbello
I mean, there's no wrong here because there's a case for all of them to be top 10. I just don't see Cara as a top 10 because it took her a LONG time to be anywhere near that level. Sarah was better than Cara IMO the entire time they were both on the show together. Maybe Rachel Robinson goes into the top 10 if we have to add another one.
Think they were going off of stats which is why Sarah is so high (many finals, two wins) and Emily (never eliminated, win on her second or third try) not necessarily who's better than who.
So why is Wes there and not Kenny for example? Kenny has like3 wins, 7 finals in just 8 challenges,
He has no doubt the better ratio out of anyone who has done this show
Per Jay/Liz, Derrick, Jonna, Nehemiah, Sylvia & Yes.
Kellyanne and Tina
sad no Nia!
I need a Veronica and Tina special.
4E4F5C13-EF61-4629-B42E-E487ED44AC29.jpeg
That's my top ten , wish Roni did more seasons back then I think she could've been an all time great, along with Kameelah. Ayanna definitely should've seen the elimination era, she'd be up there on the ranks too.
don't do Beth A. like that
PLS
Don't do Beth A. like that.
Ill give sort of a hot take...personally I don't think Emily should be in the top 10. If I were to swap her w anyone I'd say cara Maria, Ev or Rachel (interchangeable but lean more towards cara). Emily only won 1 and yes she is a beast no question. Ev all around beast I don't need to say anything else. Cara had that crazy streak of final appearances, made a final in a majority of shows (prob would've made it in FA without injury) and won a few. Pretty good elimination record and was a solo winner before. Rachael won a couple and outperformed everyone on duel 2 final. Emily has such a small sample size so really hard to put her as the best. Not saying she shouldn't be ranked high just not the best. IMO Ev, cara are above her and Emily/rachel interchangeable and then sarah
I've never understood the hype for Rachel as a competitor tbh I think of the time Kelly Anne smoked her effortlessly on the island in a face off. I think ppl hype up her potential more than anything else. I'll give her the Duel 2 final thing but ppl were overhyping her way before that. I would've liked to see her compete against Emily, Holly B and Holly S from the old-old school women to see how'd she fair against them.
Also Laurel was left out of the above poster's list but should def be included and I've noticed Jodi never gets mentioned as an elite competitor either despite being a beast and she-hulk. I'm not even rly a fan of hers but those are faxts, she's always a dominant competitor despite cracking under pressure at times.
The way they probably see it Emily did 4 challenges (counting the spin-off) made 2 finals in her first two shows and then won her next two shows. That's a Landon level stat even though she's lowkey overrated to me.
I agree about Rachel though easily top ten girl but I could see her getting squashed by a Laurel, Emily or Cara. I'd put her and Jodi on the same level IMO
rachel got beat by Kellyanne tho
I think Rachel should be #10 and shift everyone else up one. Ev is better, Laurel and then Camila (shes short af, but scrappy af - so for that. I think she'd beat rachel)
Yeah I also hate to say it but camila is good af. If she had the size of Laurel she would be unstoppable to be quite honest
I left out laurel bc I forgot lmao. She belongs in there for sure.
I agree with a lot if this but it wasn't effortless by KellyAnne. Rachel was up there for a damn long time.
Darrell and Landon are ranked way too high
Kellyanne wasn't phased by the amount of time they were up there like Rachel was though
Don't yall rank these idiots like every couple of months and split them into tiers? Who cares?
not me I usally never chime in on those debates boo lol
Like...I've seen dad (KVM) put them into tiers and I'm like...it's not that deep. But you know he's a little old so I gotta let him be.
Pages