How many times does someone have to tell y'all the shows title isn't some lame hashtag. it's been 3 seasons now.
Kailah and Sylvia are both Challenge Finalists there's not much that separates their "AllStar" resumes from any of the others except their age. which is such a dumb thing to care about
That's unfair because there's always some surprises. Who would have believed that Jisela, Teck & Ayanna reached a final? Veronica and Roni made very deep runs this time, Yes won. Out-of-touch old-schooerls like Leah & Cynthia will always have a high likelihood of going home first, but there has been a clear pattern of old-schoolers suceeding too.
I agree. The fact that we have a platform where we get to see Teck and Ayanna in a final is a gem. Yes won the whole thing. We get Tina back because of this show. It's a mix. And I've accepted that true old school heavy hitters like Miz and Coral aren't likely to be doing this. I'm not as angry as everyone else, I guess.
Having said all that, I do wish Holly S. and Dan had been given spots. People can argue they - especially Dan - wouldn't have lasted long, but it would have been nice to see him again over Tyler, just as it is to see Leah again for her brief time. I think the season 2 cast provides a great mix.
Yeah as an old school fan (maybe not as old school as others, but my first season that I saw live was Battle of the Sexes 1) it's been great seeing people I only saw briefly during an era of the show where things seemed more simple and carefree (like my life...)
That's unfair because there's always some surprises. Who would have believed that Jisela, Teck & Ayanna reached a final? Veronica and Roni made very deep runs this time, Yes won. Out-of-touch old-schooerls like Leah & Cynthia will always have a high likelihood of going home first, but there has been a clear pattern of old-schoolers suceeding too.
I agree. The fact that we have a platform where we get to see Teck and Ayanna in a final is a gem. Yes won the whole thing. We get Tina back because of this show. It's a mix. And I've accepted that true old school heavy hitters like Miz and Coral aren't likely to be doing this. I'm not as angry as everyone else, I guess.
Having said all that, I do wish Holly S. and Dan had been given spots. People can argue they - especially Dan - wouldn't have lasted long, but it would have been nice to see him again over Tyler, just as it is to see Leah again for her brief time. I think the season 2 cast provides a great mix.
Dan 100% should've been on over Tyler especially since Tyler was still injured from season 2.
The problem is that everyone has different "dream cast" its impossible to please everyone
I think this season came pretty **** close. When I saw it announced I thought it was a dream cast (yes even when John was a part of it). Problem with it is when before the game even begins you can predict who will make the final and when they actually do it just takes whatever fun out of it no matter how good the cast is. I could see if they couldn't get OGs that wanted to do the show but they have them willing and able. For a few seasons give us the familiar faces we haven't seen in a while before eventually people like Wes take over. 2 seasons wasn't enough for them to start so soon with the Wes and John show.
I guess a lot of people on here must be newer school fans....cause I am not super excited or loving this final 4 women. I feel like Kellyanne was boring on her last 3 shows.. Jonna 3 finals in a row and not really providing much of anything or seeing an elimination is boring.
I am a little excited to see how Nia has changed and grown from Exes 2. But Kailah was just on the main show 2 seasons ago...she doesnt have children or a career and is only like 28 years old... I dont really understand what shes doing on this show... she needs to stay on the main show.
I guess a lot of people on here must be newer school fans....cause I am not super excited or loving this final 4 women. I feel like Kellyanne was boring on her last 3 shows.. Jonna 3 finals in a row and not really providing much of anything or seeing an elimination is boring.
I am a little excited to see how Nia has changed and grown from Exes 2. But Kailah was just on the main show 2 seasons ago...she doesnt have children or a career and is only like 28 years old... I dont really understand what shes doing on this show... she needs to stay on the main show.
im not a new fan and I couldn't care less. I'd take Nia/Kailah/Jonna over the whole thing being canceled l.
I guess a lot of people on here must be newer school fans....cause I am not super excited or loving this final 4 women. I feel like Kellyanne was boring on her last 3 shows.. Jonna 3 finals in a row and not really providing much of anything or seeing an elimination is boring.
I am a little excited to see how Nia has changed and grown from Exes 2. But Kailah was just on the main show 2 seasons ago...she doesnt have children or a career and is only like 28 years old... I dont really understand what shes doing on this show... she needs to stay on the main show.
im not a new fan and I couldn't care less. I'd take Nia/Kailah/Jonna over the whole thing being canceled l.
Kailah shouldn't be on this. It's bad enough we have Sylvia. They should be on the main show
Sylvia hasn't been on since FR. If they weren't calling her for the main show, why shouldn't she come back to this one with less time?
This very strict who should/shouldn't be is wild to me given the fact that this didn't have to be funded in the first place. Now if y'all about to produce it then have at it.
Dont get me wrong I do feel like it should stick to RW/RR/FM for as long as possible(if there is a future) and that they should try to differentiate from the main cast as much as possible but complaining about what we did get is unwarranted IMO.
Y'all keep saying they should be on the main show when they get called to be on the main show. THEY DECLINE which means they obviously would rather do this spinoff than the regular challenge show which I don't blame them for. MTV isn't the reason Kailah/Sylvia aren't on the main show they aren't interested in that.
Y'all keep saying they should be on the main show when they get called to be on the main show. THEY DECLINE which means they obviously would rather do this spinoff than the regular challenge show which I don't blame them for. MTV isn't the reason Kailah/Sylvia aren't on the main show they aren't interested in that.
The main show needs to shorter and less toxic so that they can get good names on that and not desperate losers who would kill their own child to remain on the show like Josh, Devon, Tori, and Kasey.
Yeah I wonder why they don't have shorter season and maybe have an Old School team (that doesn't have to be the official name bc I know that'll be controversial lmaoo) vs the Newer People. Maybe the Old people interacting with the new people would make the newer cast more interesting lol
Hopefully the rumors are true for yalls sake that this shit is getting cancelled because it's just gonna get worse for yall oldies on who they cast for season 4
if I had a penny for every time someone used being old as an insult I'd be rich. Like get new material already. And you use it against people whose ages you don't even know. Make it make sense!
Yall should be thankful its just that because yall could get called much worse and then go into a bigger rage and clog up the threads with even more of yalls nonsense.
You do realize the entire reason this all started was because of a #WeWantOGs trend right? It was changed to All stars. I personally have no problem with the casting at all, but you're out here saying us old heads are "need to be thankful" because they got a few OGs.. This show wouldn't have even been a thing if it weren't for people wanting OGs.
This show wouldn't have been a thing if MTV didn't see value in it. Let's not pretend you twenty old school fans had any sort of impact on getting this on paramount plus. Lmaoooo Mark pitched this to MTV and they saw dollar signs so they green lighted it.
reading through a couple pages back and who is Tara??? I have never heard of her so that basically assures me the whole debate about her vs kailah shouldn't even be a thing..
The problem is that everyone has different "dream cast" its impossible to please everyone
I agree. The fact that we have a platform where we get to see Teck and Ayanna in a final is a gem. Yes won the whole thing. We get Tina back because of this show. It's a mix. And I've accepted that true old school heavy hitters like Miz and Coral aren't likely to be doing this. I'm not as angry as everyone else, I guess.
Having said all that, I do wish Holly S. and Dan had been given spots. People can argue they - especially Dan - wouldn't have lasted long, but it would have been nice to see him again over Tyler, just as it is to see Leah again for her brief time. I think the season 2 cast provides a great mix.
Yeah as an old school fan (maybe not as old school as others, but my first season that I saw live was Battle of the Sexes 1) it's been great seeing people I only saw briefly during an era of the show where things seemed more simple and carefree (like my life...)
Dan 100% should've been on over Tyler especially since Tyler was still injured from season 2.
I think this season came pretty **** close. When I saw it announced I thought it was a dream cast (yes even when John was a part of it). Problem with it is when before the game even begins you can predict who will make the final and when they actually do it just takes whatever fun out of it no matter how good the cast is. I could see if they couldn't get OGs that wanted to do the show but they have them willing and able. For a few seasons give us the familiar faces we haven't seen in a while before eventually people like Wes take over. 2 seasons wasn't enough for them to start so soon with the Wes and John show.
Nia and Nehemiah currently in first. Brad and Wes gassed out.
When is Dunbar's sexy *** coming to All Stars?
We don't need the worst winner in the history of this show
I want him to be my daddy.
I guess a lot of people on here must be newer school fans....cause I am not super excited or loving this final 4 women. I feel like Kellyanne was boring on her last 3 shows.. Jonna 3 finals in a row and not really providing much of anything or seeing an elimination is boring.
I am a little excited to see how Nia has changed and grown from Exes 2. But Kailah was just on the main show 2 seasons ago...she doesnt have children or a career and is only like 28 years old... I dont really understand what shes doing on this show... she needs to stay on the main show.
Again the hashtag is cute and all but when mark was pitching it he was asking for Tony so right from the start it's never been just ogs
#WeWantOGs
adding Svetlana to a cast and everyone would've been happy and content!
They really set this shit up for Wes. Clear as day. He had all the numbers going into it. Jordan almost got his *** out too.
im not a new fan and I couldn't care less. I'd take Nia/Kailah/Jonna over the whole thing being canceled l.
Same page
Kailah shouldn't be on this. It's bad enough we have Sylvia. They should be on the main show
Sylvia hasn't been on since FR. If they weren't calling her for the main show, why shouldn't she come back to this one with less time?
This very strict who should/shouldn't be is wild to me given the fact that this didn't have to be funded in the first place. Now if y'all about to produce it then have at it.
Dont get me wrong I do feel like it should stick to RW/RR/FM for as long as possible(if there is a future) and that they should try to differentiate from the main cast as much as possible but complaining about what we did get is unwarranted IMO.
For now at least
did someone really try to say they were 22 yet they have vivid and passionate memories of early 2000s reality tv?
Y'all keep saying they should be on the main show when they get called to be on the main show. THEY DECLINE which means they obviously would rather do this spinoff than the regular challenge show which I don't blame them for. MTV isn't the reason Kailah/Sylvia aren't on the main show they aren't interested in that.
EF59370F-73A2-4017-9CBE-9B1F5661024D.jpeg
The main show needs to shorter and less toxic so that they can get good names on that and not desperate losers who would kill their own child to remain on the show like Josh, Devon, Tori, and Kasey.
Yeah I wonder why they don't have shorter season and maybe have an Old School team (that doesn't have to be the official name bc I know that'll be controversial lmaoo) vs the Newer People. Maybe the Old people interacting with the new people would make the newer cast more interesting lol
You do realize the entire reason this all started was because of a #WeWantOGs trend right? It was changed to All stars. I personally have no problem with the casting at all, but you're out here saying us old heads are "need to be thankful" because they got a few OGs.. This show wouldn't have even been a thing if it weren't for people wanting OGs.
This show wouldn't have been a thing if MTV didn't see value in it. Let's not pretend you twenty old school fans had any sort of impact on getting this on paramount plus. Lmaoooo Mark pitched this to MTV and they saw dollar signs so they green lighted it.
Yes the fans being interested helped but y'all aren't the reason this is a thing.
reading through a couple pages back and who is Tara??? I have never heard of her so that basically assures me the whole debate about her vs kailah shouldn't even be a thing..
Pages