The Challenge: All Stars (Season 2) - Early Speculation

4618 posts / 0 new
Last post

"He could still compete,"

yeah  I know you are desperate to see castmembers from pre Fresh Meat but I don't think it's a good idea to kill any of them to satisfy your nostalgic fetish  

people experiencing these types of symptoms with their lungs might have permanent damage and many takes months to feel like themselves  

but yeah it's  great idea for Danny to go chow down on Carolina repers, fall 30 feet onto water, and climb a mountain in thin air    

 

He was a long shot anyways but I'm pretty sure we can move Danny from RW New Orleans to no.  He's been posting on Instagram he has Covid and has major symptoms including burning of the lungs. Even after 3 weeks. He is HIV positive and has a weak immune system to begin with so there's no way he could compete on a challenge starting in a month.  

He could still compete. I'm sure it'll be out of his system by then. But regardless I'm not expecting Danny because he would be great casting.

 

 

I think people forget that it takes two to tango. Hear me out here: what if some cast members just don't want to return? I don't understand what production should do if someone does not want to come back? Grossly overpay them? What if they won't return for any amount of $$$? 

I get being disappointed - personally, my girlfriend and I like how the cast is shaping up - but there's this bizarre attitude that production doesn't reach out to a lot of those names. Those names have to say yes...

I think the majority of us understand. Whether we like them or not seeing Jodi Tina Eric Janelle and even Ryan and Tyler on a challenge in 2021 is a good thing and far better than the main show. 

This. Regardless, the producers are gonna (mostly) do what they feel is best to provide people something special.

Some fans understand but a lot don't and it happens with every show with returnees (RPDR, Survivor, Big Brother, etc.). People seem to forget that people move on, they have families, they have careers, or they just plain don't want to do it.

Well said. I'm just grateful for the names we saw in S1 and the names we'll potentially see in S2. It's like I'm a teenager all over again :) 

never cared for tina 

Keep in mind I will continue moving people yes to no , no to maybe and Maybe to either yes or no throughout this month.

By now you guys should know how this works and for those that are new I am pretty sure other long term members will explain our little dynamic.

Keep in mind I will continue moving people yes to no , no to maybe and Maybe to either yes or no throughout this month.

By now you guys should know how this works and for those that are new I am pretty sure other long term members will explain our little dynamic.

I've been a long-timer lurker (I tried signing up a couple of times and finally got accepted) so I know to be cautious with any names. I really appreciate your updates, by the way! 

 

He was a long shot anyways but I'm pretty sure we can move Danny from RW New Orleans to no.  He's been posting on Instagram he has Covid and has major symptoms including burning of the lungs. Even after 3 weeks. He is HIV positive and has a weak immune system to begin with so there's no way he could compete on a challenge starting in a month.  

He could still compete. I'm sure it'll be out of his system by then. But regardless I'm not expecting Danny because he would be great casting.

lol oldschooler be like "I want to see him **** his health if he die he die"

if it's that bad I'm sure he'll have some lingering effects geez

Its most likely not the theme but we do currently have an equal number of champs and challengers. Champions: Eric, Tyler, Janelle, and Jodi

Challengers: CJ, Ryan, Tina, and Jasmine

Its most likely not the theme but we do currently have an equal number of champs and challengers. Champions: Eric, Tyler, Janelle, and Jodi

Challengers: CJ, Ryan, Tina, and Jasmine

.....RIP challengers 

Keep in mind I will continue moving people yes to no , no to maybe and Maybe to either yes or no throughout this month.

By now you guys should know how this works and for those that are new I am pretty sure other long term members will explain our little dynamic.

Honestly this is the best part of spoilers...watching a yes become a no or vise versa. 

 

Keep in mind I will continue moving people yes to no , no to maybe and Maybe to either yes or no throughout this month.

By now you guys should know how this works and for those that are new I am pretty sure other long term members will explain our little dynamic.

Honestly this is the best part of spoilers...watching a yes become a no or vise versa. 

right, I enjoy this more than watching the show

 

I need both Hollys to come back. Athletic queens, one benevolent the other not so much 

YES! The Challenge All-Stars 2: Battle of the Hollies. They are team captains and get to pick their teams dodgeball style. They also both have immunity till the end.

@Chadwick Pelletier has this idea been pitched to yoir wife?

 

No but they are pushing hard to get her on this season. If she accepts, she is a lock. Not looking as good for me right now.

  • Some of you are too uptight...it's a petty nickname as joke. It's not serious.
  • Mad at a casting decision is not real life mad. Y'all need to understand that lol. Me saying it's bad casting has no impact on my real life. Just my opinion on the topic.
  • This cast outside of Tina is not anymore exciting than the regular season. We just saw Eric and he did nothing for me, he's just a weird hippie. Just cause I haven't seen Ryan in several years doesn't mean he is good casting. Dumb logic.
  • A lot of old schoolers have expressed interest in wanting to do this. They have the means to put together a good cast.
  • Whoever said they will put the best cast together and they know what they are doing knows nothing about MTV and BMP lol.
  • Keep in mind I will continue moving people yes to no , no to maybe and Maybe to either yes or no throughout this month.

    By now you guys should know how this works and for those that are new I am pretty sure other long term members will explain our little dynamic.

    I say let's just enjoy the speculation process. Plus who knows, people could surprise us. Tina could go on and pull a Beth and be more zen. And then another cast member could be like Kendal, who was pretty quiet and out of the drama previously could now be the most disliked cast member that season. Haha.

    The worst Challenge cast ever is about to wrap filming in Croatia

    The potential names on this cast look like The Inferno next to that garbage.

  • Some of you are too uptight...it's a petty nickname as joke. It's not serious.
  • Mad at a casting decision is not real life mad. Y'all need to understand that lol. Me saying it's bad casting has no impact on my real life. Just my opinion on the topic.
  • This cast outside of Tina is not anymore exciting than the regular season. We just saw Eric and he did nothing for me, he's just a weird hippie. Just cause I haven't seen Ryan in several years doesn't mean he is good casting. Dumb logic.
  • A lot of old schoolers have expressed interest in wanting to do this. They have the means to put together a good cast.
  • Whoever said they will put the best cast together and they know what they are doing knows nothing about MTV and BMP lol.
  • Expressing interest doesn't mean they'll do it and they aren't casting based upon what you think is a good cast. Bring mad about Jodi regardless of your opinion makes no sense. I don't like her at all but she's good casting 

     

     

    I need both Hollys to come back. Athletic queens, one benevolent the other not so much 

    YES! The Challenge All-Stars 2: Battle of the Hollies. They are team captains and get to pick their teams dodgeball style. They also both have immunity till the end.

    @Chadwick Pelletier has this idea been pitched to yoir wife?

     

    No but they are pushing hard to get her on this season. If she accepts, she is a lock. Not looking as good for me right now.

    LOL I'll respond hoping it's really Chadwick .   

    They need to scrap seasons and just do teams  Real World vs road rules / fresh meat  to get you on King.

    couldn't they team you and Holly together just due to you being husband-wife? Or can only one of you go due to children?

    damn it Susie Meister   Come back     .Holly would have Laterrian easy if she wants to do it  

     

     

     

    The fact that most of these people are even on a speculation thread in 2021 amazes me and makes me so freaking happy. 

    <3 

    Quit disappearing! I get eaten alive on here for loving and supporting OGs. We need more of our kind around here lol.

    lol sorry - I'm back to work full time but with speculation going on I'll be around to give the OG's more love!

     

  • Some of you are too uptight...it's a petty nickname as joke. It's not serious.
  • Mad at a casting decision is not real life mad. Y'all need to understand that lol. Me saying it's bad casting has no impact on my real life. Just my opinion on the topic.
  • This cast outside of Tina is not anymore exciting than the regular season. We just saw Eric and he did nothing for me, he's just a weird hippie. Just cause I haven't seen Ryan in several years doesn't mean he is good casting. Dumb logic.
  • A lot of old schoolers have expressed interest in wanting to do this. They have the means to put together a good cast.
  • Whoever said they will put the best cast together and they know what they are doing knows nothing about MTV and BMP lol.
  • Expressing interest doesn't mean they'll do it and they aren't casting based upon what you think is a good cast. Bring mad about Jodi regardless of your opinion makes no sense. I don't like her at all but she's good casting 

    Exactly. Expressing an interest can really mean "I would go back if the timing was right and/or if I get the money I ask for." Simply saying "I'm expressing an interesting" isn't enough to get the deal done. 

    @ KVM your opinion is that Chodi is good casting. I never found her interesting, even rewatching she is so bland. Bland people don't make good tv, imo. I don't find her some iconic staple of the show. She isn't Coral or Miz, besides a few stans no one is tuning in to see her again. So what do you think makes her great casting?

    So excited for Jodi! I have such a soft spot for the ladies of X-Treme! I always loved Jodi.

    so freaking sad about Anne! Ugh I hope she is a last minute flip - I want her back soooooo bad. I loved her back In the day!

    Casting come through and give the people what they want: Queen Elka!

    PR was Anne actually interested / asked? It was that just a random name thrown around you got confirmation for that wasn't in the running? Just curious lol

    My only experience with Anne was Sexes and she didn't do it for me. But she looks great and seems to be active and fun. I would have been excited to see her.

    @ KVM your opinion is that Chodi is good casting. I never found her interesting, even rewatching she is so bland. Bland people don't make good tv, imo. I don't find her some iconic staple of the show. She isn't Coral or Miz, besides a few stans no one is tuning in to see her again. So what do you think makes her great casting?

    Again--it's not whether or not you or I find her interesting.  I have no interest in seeing her despite the fact she's a great competitor.  She isn't Coral or Miz but no one is.  She was involved in drama on her first 2 seasons.  Inferno calling out Veronica, skinny dipping after losing the bet, crying over the vote swap, etc.  On The Gauntlet 2 she had drama with Danny Dias, she had drama with Mark, she had a showmance with Alton--and that was all with her not having any chance to be thrown in.   On The Duel she was quiet but just because you AND I don't care about the drama she had doesn't make her bland to everyone.  She's a champ that has multiple exes that could be on this season.

    Anne would be my last choice of the RR-Northern Trail girls.  Roni Martin is clearly the first choice followed by Tara IMO.

     

    @ KVM your opinion is that Chodi is good casting. I never found her interesting, even rewatching she is so bland. Bland people don't make good tv, imo. I don't find her some iconic staple of the show. She isn't Coral or Miz, besides a few stans no one is tuning in to see her again. So what do you think makes her great casting?

    Again--it's not whether or not you or I find her interesting.  I have no interest in seeing her despite the fact she's a great competitor.  She isn't Coral or Miz but no one is.  She was involved in drama on her first 2 seasons.  Inferno calling out Veronica, skinny dipping after losing the bet, crying over the vote swap, etc.  On The Gauntlet 2 she had drama with Danny Dias, she had drama with Mark, she had a showmance with Alton--and that was all with her not having any chance to be thrown in.   On The Duel she was quiet but just because you AND I don't care about the drama she had doesn't make her bland to everyone.  She's a champ that has multiple exes that could be on this season.

    I have a friend who loved the Challenge (hasn't watched in quite some time) and he flipped out when he heard Jodi was potentially cast lol

    i just love how he came up with Chodi and thinks it's so funny that it's been used 20 times on the last 3 pages. Lmao 

    OMG! Chodi went skinny dipping!! This LEGEND deserves to be on All-Stars, Season 38, and the 3rd spin-off!

    i just love how he came up with Chodi and thinks it's so funny that it's been used 20 times on the last 3 pages. Lmao 

    And I'll continue.

    oh that's fine you do you boo as long as you know no one thinks it's funny but you

     

    i just love how he came up with Chodi and thinks it's so funny that it's been used 20 times on the last 3 pages. Lmao 

    And I'll continue.

    I'm only here to entertain myself, not a bunch of anonymous strangers.

    Pages

    Topic locked