The Challenge: All Stars (Season 2) - Early Speculation

4618 posts / 0 new
Last post

This

Is seasons confirmed or speculated? Who would Tina be with?

I hope its not a themed season already. Damn the first 3 or 4 should have no restricting theme, just focus on the cast for now.

but if i recall correctly that producer said they usually think of the theme/format first then fill the cast based on who would fit which is backwards imo

Is seasons confirmed or speculated? Who would Tina be with?

Definitely not confirmed....Jeremy

 

I know I'm in the minority but I still don't think she looks healthy. I feel like this environment would destroy her. Same with Brad honestly. 

Yeah, I wanted Svetlana on but she doesn't look well to me. You've got to consider people's issues and health before putting them in high-pressure situations. That's why I found it sad to watch Tonya and Robin eventually. Why Brad though? I just know about his custody fights with Tori.

The only reason I'd want a theme is so the chances of them randomly switching the format are lowered. Doesn't anyone else get a sick feeling thinking about times when they're randomly like "oh by the way, now it's double eliminations so.. pick a partner". It's annoying as **** and they think they're being cute. Wrong.

I think a theme like Seasons is too risky. There's too much risk in if someone drops. 

i agree, i think seasons is too risky. i see them doing good guys vs bad a*ses or champions vs challengers

i agree, i think seasons is too risky. i see them doing good guys vs bad a*ses or champions vs challengers

do they have enough champions to do that? 

And when Cynthia shows up? 

And when Cynthia shows up? 

She's out for blood, Ruthie better not be on this. She's dead if Cynthia & Ruthie are both there, period.

 

i agree, i think seasons is too risky. i see them doing good guys vs bad a*ses or champions vs challengers

do they have enough champions to do that? 

Lookimg off the up in the air list, we do have a decent amount but that's if they all said yes.

 

i agree, i think seasons is too risky. i see them doing good guys vs bad a*ses or champions vs challengers

do they have enough champions to do that? 

Eric, Yes, both Dan R, Jamie M, Syrus, Mark, Derrick, Bananas, Adam L, Darrell, Brad, Dunbar, Frank, Landon, Timmy, Tyler, Wes, Kefla

 

Cynthia, Anne, Piggy, Veronica, Julie, Coral, Elka, Roni, Sarah, Kendal, Katie, Jodi, Janelle, Evelyn, Laurel

 

I don't know who I missed but the girls are slim pickings depending on size and who might be missing, I also just included people who were on season 1

 

 

i agree, i think seasons is too risky. i see them doing good guys vs bad a*ses or champions vs challengers

do they have enough champions to do that? 

Eric, Yes, both Dan R, Jamie M, Syrus, Mark, Derrick, Bananas, Adam L, Darrell, Brad, Dunbar, Frank, Landon, Timmy, Tyler, Wes, Kefla

 

Cynthia, Anne, Piggy, Veronica, Julie, Coral, Elka, Roni, Sarah, Kendal, Katie, Jodi, Janelle, Evelyn, Laurel

 

I don't know who I missed but the girls are slim pickings depending on size and who might be missing, I also just included people who were on season 1

im sure if they are able to pull 7-8 champion guys and girls ( each ) they can do a Ruins 2 type format. It's all of the matter who days yes and no 

 

 

 

i agree, i think seasons is too risky. i see them doing good guys vs bad a*ses or champions vs challengers

do they have enough champions to do that? 

Eric, Yes, both Dan R, Jamie M, Syrus, Mark, Derrick, Bananas, Adam L, Darrell, Brad, Dunbar, Frank, Landon, Timmy, Tyler, Wes, Kefla

 

Cynthia, Anne, Piggy, Veronica, Julie, Coral, Elka, Roni, Sarah, Kendal, Katie, Jodi, Janelle, Evelyn, Laurel

 

I don't know who I missed but the girls are slim pickings depending on size and who might be missing, I also just included people who were on season 1

im sure if they are able to pull 7-8 champion guys and girls ( each ) they can do a Ruins 2 type format. It's all of the matter who days yes and no 

Exactly, and I wouldn't be mad about teams of 16. And I think it's do-able, plus I'm sure there's still people not on this lot who might say yes. Emily S? Not sure what she's up to but she may be interested and a champion.

 

 

 

 

i agree, i think seasons is too risky. i see them doing good guys vs bad a*ses or champions vs challengers

do they have enough champions to do that? 

Eric, Yes, both Dan R, Jamie M, Syrus, Mark, Derrick, Bananas, Adam L, Darrell, Brad, Dunbar, Frank, Landon, Timmy, Tyler, Wes, Kefla

 

Cynthia, Anne, Piggy, Veronica, Julie, Coral, Elka, Roni, Sarah, Kendal, Katie, Jodi, Janelle, Evelyn, Laurel

 

I don't know who I missed but the girls are slim pickings depending on size and who might be missing, I also just included people who were on season 1

im sure if they are able to pull 7-8 champion guys and girls ( each ) they can do a Ruins 2 type format. It's all of the matter who days yes and no 

Exactly, and I wouldn't be mad about teams of 16. And I think it's do-able, plus I'm sure there's still people not on this lot who might say yes. Emily S? Not sure what she's up to but she may be interested and a champion.

was she even called? I thought she was done 100%

I think a theme like Seasons is too risky. There's too much risk in if someone drops. 

Thats why they always have alternates

 

I think a theme like Seasons is too risky. There's too much risk in if someone drops. 

Thats why they always have alternates

yea but they need to make sure they have the right ones for each show and for how many guys / girls drop out. I think that will be too much for them

Just do real world vs road rules and bring it back to where it all started.

Just do real world vs road rules and bring it back to where it all started.

Just do real world vs road rules and bring it back to where it all started.

That's my ideal scenario. Plus it rules out FM. 

Just do real world vs road rules and bring it back to where it all started.

I think Champions vs Challengers would be the easy one to cast. Real World vs Road Rules would be a good throwback.

I like a Battle of the Seasons format. I just think it would be the most fun to watch, but it's going to be hard to cast.

They wouldn't have enough for a fresh meat team? I don't think I counted enough on the first page 

They wouldn't have enough for a fresh meat team? I don't think I counted enough on the first page 

they only have 5 people from Fresh Meat ( 1 & 2 )

I think Champions vs Challengers would be the easy one to cast. Real World vs Road Rules would be a good throwback.

I like a Battle of the Seasons format. I just think it would be the most fun to watch, but it's going to be hard to cast.

Champions vs challengers may end up being too lopsided...we dont need another ruins.

Real World vs Road Rules vs Fresh Meat would be so good

Real World vs Road Rules vs Fresh Meat would be so good

Aside from the FM part. We don't have enough guys for that for sure. Easy Ryan Luke Brandon Noor Pete doesn't work. And at least wait until Theresa comes back or the girls side sucks too. Evelyn and Laurel would be with people like Casey Mandi and ????

 

I think Champions vs Challengers would be the easy one to cast. Real World vs Road Rules would be a good throwback.

I like a Battle of the Seasons format. I just think it would be the most fun to watch, but it's going to be hard to cast.

Champions vs challengers may end up being too lopsided...we dont need another ruins.

Then Road Rulers might run all over the Real World like the old days too. lol. Let me look at that cast again...

Edit: I just realized there aren't THAT many Road Rulers on that list. Piles of Real Worlders, so it depends on how they narrow it down. Also, Real World competitors look more stacked than they did back in the Gauntlet/Inferno days. I actually used to say this as Real World seasons went by that it looked like they were casting more and more athletic looking people.

Something tells me they'll do a dynamic duos theme. That way they don't have to be from the same season. For example Amanda and Ashley would be a dynamic duo from 2 different starting seasons.

 

Pages

Topic locked