Yeah I remember it being reported that Robin was the hold up on San Diego Homecoming. For obvious good reasons.
I don't know if there were ever serious talks because of Robin but I know Jamie and Cameran really wanted to make it happen. I think they should do it now that Robin is better and Tori Hall and replace Frankie.
Yeah I remember it being reported that Robin was the hold up on San Diego Homecoming. For obvious good reasons.
I don't know if there were ever serious talks because of Robin but I know Jamie and Cameran really wanted to make it happen. I think they should do it now that Robin is better and Tori Hall and replace Frankie.
Elka was just very cool. She wasn't a goody-goody. She was feisty & assertive, but also very very relatable & sensitive. She didn't shy away from drama. Also, a total babe.
Can I workshop this with you guys, is there anyone I'm missing that was on AS 1 through 5, that is available (aka not pregnant or postpartum: Jenna/Sylvia), definitely wants to be on the next season (so not Kailah lol), is not on 41, and deserves to be on more than one or more of the people of the teams I have listed here?
Just vets of AS, rookies are a whole new bag of worms...
Can I workshop this with you guys, is there anyone I'm missing that was on AS 1 through 5, that is available (aka not pregnant or postpartum: Jenna/Sylvia), definitely wants to be on the next season (so not Kailah lol), is not on 41, and deserves to be on more than one or more of the people of the teams I have listed here?
Just vets of AS, rookies are a whole new bag of worms...
What's so great about Elka? Not being a hater, jw. Barely remember seasons or her episodes of the gauntlet. Was damn near a fetus when Boston aired.
Elka was simply likeable and relatable. Elka's father was overprotective likely due to her losing her mother. She had to sign a contract with him that she wouldn't do drugs, have sex, smoke, etc when she was on The Real World. You got to see her grow up on the show being surrounded by people that she wouldn't have met at home and stand up to her father. Like Julie on the first season, Elka was what the show was supposed to be about.
On the Challenge, Elka was a good competitor that didn't put up with nonsense and (even better) worked with Coral. Elka could have been a star for the show had she continued to do the show. She was great on The Gauntlet and Seasons 2.
Can I workshop this with you guys, is there anyone I'm missing that was on AS 1 through 5, that is available (aka not pregnant or postpartum: Jenna/Sylvia), definitely wants to be on the next season (so not Kailah lol), is not on 41, and deserves to be on more than one or more of the people of the teams I have listed here?
Just vets of AS, rookies are a whole new bag of worms...
Open to suggestions. If you tell me Amber deserves to be on the Champs more than Tori H and Carley, I'll listen to your argument!
I'd be happy with this cast--realistic changes to me would be
Champs Men--replace Zach will CT. I'd bump Yes or literally anyone not named Syrus.
Contenders Men--replace Marlon (I think that's Marlon top right) with Leroy--again being realistic.
Champs Women--replace Tori H with Tori D and replace Carley with Jonna--again being realistic. If it was fantasy use Elka.
Challangers Women--replace Nurys (thought production hated her) with Moriah or Olivia (ideally Irulan) and Melinda with Amanda (i hate her but she'd be good with that female challenger cast--fantasy with Lori or Mallory)
Can I workshop this with you guys, is there anyone I'm missing that was on AS 1 through 5, that is available (aka not pregnant or postpartum: Jenna/Sylvia), definitely wants to be on the next season (so not Kailah lol), is not on 41, and deserves to be on more than one or more of the people of the teams I have listed here?
Just vets of AS, rookies are a whole new bag of worms...
Open to suggestions. If you tell me Amber deserves to be on the Champs more than Tori H and Carley, I'll listen to your argument!
I'd be happy with this cast--realistic changes to me would be
Champs Men--replace Zach will CT. I'd bump Yes or literally anyone not named Syrus.
Contenders Men--replace Marlon (I think that's Marlon top right) with Leroy--again being realistic.
Champs Women--replace Tori H with Tori D and replace Carley with Jonna--again being realistic. If it was fantasy use Elka.
Challangers Women--replace Nurys (thought production hated her) with Moriah or Olivia (ideally Irulan) and Melinda with Amanda (i hate her but she'd be good with that female challenger cast--fantasy with Lori or Mallory)
Not bad suggestions, Kevin. But I truly want a season with no one from 41.
Elka was just very cool. She wasn't a goody-goody. She was feisty & assertive, but also very very relatable & sensitive. She didn't shy away from drama. Also, a total babe.
all of this - plus her mini argument with the Miz when he picked Trishelle over her was great. She deserves an All Stars spot
Elka was just very cool. She wasn't a goody-goody. She was feisty & assertive, but also very very relatable & sensitive. She didn't shy away from drama. Also, a total babe.
all of this - plus her mini argument with the Miz when he picked Trishelle over her was great. She deserves an All Stars spot
Lol speak for yourself *****. Many people want Julie on, even if your first name stealing *** thinks otherwise.
great cast! But when did Abe and Gladys get into it? I thought she disappeared after she was in sexes 1
Abe from her season that she beat up. Also add Belou vs Antoine to that list.
LOL
LOL
Lots of love for each other? I knew yall were homosexuals.
Yeah I remember it being reported that Robin was the hold up on San Diego Homecoming. For obvious good reasons.
I don't know if there were ever serious talks because of Robin but I know Jamie and Cameran really wanted to make it happen. I think they should do it now that Robin is better and Tori Hall and replace Frankie.
my bad - I was thinking of Abe from South Pacific lol
If Jamie was willing to do it they would have done it with just her. She answered in the Hollywood way of "I'll do it" but will never do it.
Lol
Wasn't Christian from RR Europe in the mix for AS4? Guessing they wanted him potentially to interact with Ayanna.
I'm curious if RW Seattle people were interested (Specifically Nathan and David).
honestly if this was the cast of All-Star six, I would be so freaking excited.
I refuse to rest until I get an Elka return. I deserve this.
agreed 100%
We aren't that lucky...they should have brought her back when she was calling them years ago
What's so great about Elka? Not being a hater, jw. Barely remember seasons or her episodes of the gauntlet. Was damn near a fetus when Boston aired.
Elka was just very cool. She wasn't a goody-goody. She was feisty & assertive, but also very very relatable & sensitive. She didn't shy away from drama. Also, a total babe.
She was really likable on the Guantlet. I'm pro her return.
Can I workshop this with you guys, is there anyone I'm missing that was on AS 1 through 5, that is available (aka not pregnant or postpartum: Jenna/Sylvia), definitely wants to be on the next season (so not Kailah lol), is not on 41, and deserves to be on more than one or more of the people of the teams I have listed here?
Just vets of AS, rookies are a whole new bag of worms...
Collage_2025-03-25_19_40_48.jpg
Collage_2025-03-25_19_39_38.jpg
Collage_2025-03-25_19_41_14.jpg
Collage_2025-03-25_19_40_15.jpg
Open to suggestions. If you tell me Amber deserves to be on the Champs more than Tori H and Carley, I'll listen to your argument!
lo melissa, nurys and the middle eastern guy...okay
Great cast. Drop Fessy for ANYONE LOL
Elka was simply likeable and relatable. Elka's father was overprotective likely due to her losing her mother. She had to sign a contract with him that she wouldn't do drugs, have sex, smoke, etc when she was on The Real World. You got to see her grow up on the show being surrounded by people that she wouldn't have met at home and stand up to her father. Like Julie on the first season, Elka was what the show was supposed to be about.
On the Challenge, Elka was a good competitor that didn't put up with nonsense and (even better) worked with Coral. Elka could have been a star for the show had she continued to do the show. She was great on The Gauntlet and Seasons 2.
I'd be happy with this cast--realistic changes to me would be
Champs Men--replace Zach will CT. I'd bump Yes or literally anyone not named Syrus.
Contenders Men--replace Marlon (I think that's Marlon top right) with Leroy--again being realistic.
Champs Women--replace Tori H with Tori D and replace Carley with Jonna--again being realistic. If it was fantasy use Elka.
Challangers Women--replace Nurys (thought production hated her) with Moriah or Olivia (ideally Irulan) and Melinda with Amanda (i hate her but she'd be good with that female challenger cast--fantasy with Lori or Mallory)
Not bad suggestions, Kevin. But I truly want a season with no one from 41.
all of this - plus her mini argument with the Miz when he picked Trishelle over her was great. She deserves an All Stars spot
All the Boston girls should come on All Stars
FB_IMG_1742968342935.jpg
Bumping MJ off and Brad to Alt and putting Mark on my cast. I appreciate his hustle.
Collage_2025-03-26_11_36_38.jpg
They only evaluate viewership for one night?
Pages