Carley getting a shot at All Stars 6 is MORE than fair.
No. She had a whole season and gave the energy of a 50 year old housewife high on pain pills. The girl had zero inflection in her voice. Gave zero drama or strategy. The way y'all will stan over anyone and ask for anyone is crazy.
If aviv of all people got 2 chances after she debut so should carley.
This is stupid logic. Just cause one bore got another chance it doesn't mean all bores should. Can we advocate for Julie and people that will bring something and not just waste a spot?
2 things can be true
Bring batshit crazy Julie back for the drama
Bring back Carley for a surprise. She is a hot champion.
Carley getting a shot at All Stars 6 is MORE than fair.
No. She had a whole season and gave the energy of a 50 year old housewife high on pain pills. The girl had zero inflection in her voice. Gave zero drama or strategy. The way y'all will stan over anyone and ask for anyone is crazy.
I don't stan her lol, I just think she could/should get 1 of 14 spots on All Stars 6.
I don't think they're ever gonna actually cast Julie. They would've done so already. But hopefully I'm wrong.
Why would they not? She is an icon?
She is. I've always wanted her back. But I remember in the older all stars threads, many of y'all always mentioning that Julie was considered a liability and never actually gonna be on the cast. But none of you are a fat blonde lesbian by the name of Sky, so what do any of us truly know.
I need Jay and Paulie to never be on my TV screens again.
I will almost 100% guarantee at least one of them will be there lol. Prob close to 80% for both.
You really dislike Jay? I thought he was perfectly fine on AS4. He competed well, volunteered when he needed a star, was there to play the game. You do need some normal people in a cast to play the game. You can't have 28 dramatic loonies.
I'm fine with him as long as Nicole's not there. I want to see him play a game free from her.
I need Jay and Paulie to never be on my TV screens again.
I will almost 100% guarantee at least one of them will be there. Prob close to 80% for both.
You really dislike Jay? I thought he was perfectly fine on AS4. He competed well, volunteered when he needed a star, was there to play the game. You do need some normal people in a cast to play the game. You can't have 28 dramatic loonies.
I don't hate him. I just don't think he adds anything entertaining to the show. I don't need 28 crazy personalities, but I prefer for the background players to be like Kefla and Darrell who offer a likable and light-hearted fun energy. Jay isn't dramatic, funny, or exciting in any kind of way. He's just there.
I need Jay and Paulie to never be on my TV screens again.
I will almost 100% guarantee at least one of them will be there. Prob close to 80% for both.
You really dislike Jay? I thought he was perfectly fine on AS4. He competed well, volunteered when he needed a star, was there to play the game. You do need some normal people in a cast to play the game. You can't have 28 dramatic loonies.
I don't hate him. I just don't think he adds anything entertaining to the show. I don't need 28 crazy personalities, but I prefer for the background players to be like Kefla and Darrell who offer a likable and light-hearted fun energy. Jay isn't dramatic, funny, or exciting in any kind of way. He's just there.
In my opinion, if All Stars is going to survive for more than a season or two more, you need to solve the problem of the continuously depleting potential returnee cast list. As in, more players are leaving the potential pool every year through disillusionment with the show or age/retirement than being added. Particularly since almost no one was retained from the USA/WC era and we have barely had rookies on the flagship since 2021/S37.
You will need players like Jay to fill out the cast, keep the competition level up, and play the game. He'll never be better than like Pick #12 in the non-vet casting pool, but in that male casting pool of non-vets that's gone from around 45 potential men to less than 30 men in the past 5 years, then, #12 is usually gonna be good enough to help fill out a cast.
30 that you deem better? Sure. But 30 can they still compete at ages 35 to 45 and will they say yes and actually commit to the show? I bet that number drops down to the mid-teens.
I need Jay and Paulie to never be on my TV screens again.
I will almost 100% guarantee at least one of them will be there. Prob close to 80% for both.
You really dislike Jay? I thought he was perfectly fine on AS4. He competed well, volunteered when he needed a star, was there to play the game. You do need some normal people in a cast to play the game. You can't have 28 dramatic loonies.
I don't hate him. I just don't think he adds anything entertaining to the show. I don't need 28 crazy personalities, but I prefer for the background players to be like Kefla and Darrell who offer a likable and light-hearted fun energy. Jay isn't dramatic, funny, or exciting in any kind of way. He's just there.
In my opinion, if All Stars is going to survive...
with all do respect, I feel like you say this quite often and with almost every season. She show has lasted five seasons already. It has a sixth on it's way. I feel like you keep trying to manifest it's demise.
Aviv is a pleasant, boring personality that got super lucky to get onto 40 due to a ton of the women of Era 2 retiring and has absolutely no business being on 41. She should do an All Stars like every third year. But Bananas needed his feet fetish filled.
She is legit the only cast member that was exciting for the 41 cast reveal for me.
Love you Potato, but you will be excited to see anyone that hasn't been on in 20 years regardless if they are good tv or not.
fair. When it comes to the Women I def am biased in that aspect. When it comes to the men I really have never cared for them - the women made the show for me since day 1.
In my opinion, if All Stars is going to survive...
with all do respect, I feel like you say this quite often and with almost every season. She show has lasted five seasons already. It has a sixth on it's way. I feel like you keep trying to manifest it's demise.
Uh...lol no? Do you even look at the first page of posts? I'm probably in the Top 5 people most excited the show lives. Every time Pink posted during AS 5 that the show was in trouble, most of the responses were like, "Well, it can die, I don't care..."
I'm trying to be forward thinking and get the show off of shaky ground. I'm not trying to manifest it's demise. World Championship died. USA died. All the international spinoffs died. All Stars IS two bad or (one REALLY bad) seasons from cancellation. They need to be more forward thinking. All Stars 5 was genuinely a mess. If not for Frank and Veronica, there's not even a narrative. The cast was an afterthought. The format, dailies, and eliminations even moreso.
I'm probably in the minority but I have enjoyed every All-Star so far, I'd say 3 is my least favorite but still liked it. I generally tune in the entire season and if I like the people left at the end I will also watch it.
I'm probably in the minority but I have enjoyed every All-Star so far, I'd say 3 is my least favorite but still liked it. I generally tune in the entire season and if I like the people left at the end I will also watch it.
Frank and Veronica (and to some extent Shane) genuinely turned the back half of All Stars 5 into a good season. But the first half was borderline unwatchable. Mostly due to an awful format, though the lackluster cast did not help.
4 was unwatchable to me. Kefla, Ayanna, and Flora were the only bright lights of that season to me. Sadly, I feel if it was edited diffrently it could have been great though
Nia finished the daily, I think she easily beats Jasmine. I legit don't think Jasmine is big enough to move that boat lol. Like Katie.
No. She had a whole season and gave the energy of a 50 year old housewife high on pain pills. The girl had zero inflection in her voice. Gave zero drama or strategy. The way y'all will stan over anyone and ask for anyone is crazy.
2 things can be true
Bring batshit crazy Julie back for the drama
Bring back Carley for a surprise. She is a hot champion.
I don't think they're ever gonna actually cast Julie. They would've done so already. But hopefully I'm wrong.
I don't stan her lol, I just think she could/should get 1 of 14 spots on All Stars 6.
Why would they not? She is an icon?
Carley isn't hot. Big bòòbs and blonde hair don't equal hot. It's a tv show, you need a personality to be on tv. Take off the nostalgia glasses.
She is. I've always wanted her back. But I remember in the older all stars threads, many of y'all always mentioning that Julie was considered a liability and never actually gonna be on the cast. But none of you are a fat blonde lesbian by the name of Sky, so what do any of us truly know.
Like Jay's first tweet since All Stars 4 lol. Maybe he's just manifesting...
Untitled.jpg
I need Jay to eliminate Paulie so there are no more excuses
I need Jay and Paulie to never be on my TV screens again.
I will almost 100% guarantee at least one of them will be there lol. Prob close to 80% for both.
You really dislike Jay? I thought he was perfectly fine on AS4. He competed well, volunteered when he needed a star, was there to play the game. You do need some normal people in a cast to play the game. You can't have 28 dramatic loonies.
I'm fine with him as long as Nicole's not there. I want to see him play a game free from her.
I don't hate him. I just don't think he adds anything entertaining to the show. I don't need 28 crazy personalities, but I prefer for the background players to be like Kefla and Darrell who offer a likable and light-hearted fun energy. Jay isn't dramatic, funny, or exciting in any kind of way. He's just there.
In my opinion, if All Stars is going to survive for more than a season or two more, you need to solve the problem of the continuously depleting potential returnee cast list. As in, more players are leaving the potential pool every year through disillusionment with the show or age/retirement than being added. Particularly since almost no one was retained from the USA/WC era and we have barely had rookies on the flagship since 2021/S37.
You will need players like Jay to fill out the cast, keep the competition level up, and play the game. He'll never be better than like Pick #12 in the non-vet casting pool, but in that male casting pool of non-vets that's gone from around 45 potential men to less than 30 men in the past 5 years, then, #12 is usually gonna be good enough to help fill out a cast.
I can think of 30 better options for Jay. Next.
30 that you deem better? Sure. But 30 can they still compete at ages 35 to 45 and will they say yes and actually commit to the show? I bet that number drops down to the mid-teens.
Balding Jay or RW Jay?
Jenna's Ex.
Jay Starret doesn't belong on this at all.
with all do respect, I feel like you say this quite often and with almost every season. She show has lasted five seasons already. It has a sixth on it's way. I feel like you keep trying to manifest it's demise.
fair. When it comes to the Women I def am biased in that aspect. When it comes to the men I really have never cared for them - the women made the show for me since day 1.
But Elka please and thank you.
Uh...lol no? Do you even look at the first page of posts? I'm probably in the Top 5 people most excited the show lives. Every time Pink posted during AS 5 that the show was in trouble, most of the responses were like, "Well, it can die, I don't care..."
I'm trying to be forward thinking and get the show off of shaky ground. I'm not trying to manifest it's demise. World Championship died. USA died. All the international spinoffs died. All Stars IS two bad or (one REALLY bad) seasons from cancellation. They need to be more forward thinking. All Stars 5 was genuinely a mess. If not for Frank and Veronica, there's not even a narrative. The cast was an afterthought. The format, dailies, and eliminations even moreso.
I'm probably in the minority but I have enjoyed every All-Star so far, I'd say 3 is my least favorite but still liked it. I generally tune in the entire season and if I like the people left at the end I will also watch it.
Frank and Veronica (and to some extent Shane) genuinely turned the back half of All Stars 5 into a good season. But the first half was borderline unwatchable. Mostly due to an awful format, though the lackluster cast did not help.
4 was unwatchable to me. Kefla, Ayanna, and Flora were the only bright lights of that season to me. Sadly, I feel if it was edited diffrently it could have been great though
4 was basically Laurel reading down Cara, which I love but it gets to a point lol
Laurel and Nicole's barf-fest ruined the back half of 4. And that awful final.
The show will always be garabage until they learn how to format, cast, and edit. But mainly edit.
Debatable. A good format can't carry a bad cast and edit.
Pages