The Challenge: All Stars 4 Old Schooler Fantasy

668 posts / 0 new
Last post

Legend Kameelah & Legend Christena Pyle can make their appearances too!

i dont think abe is ever coming back after all the things with his life going on 

im just doing girls side:

coral, tori hall, theresa, devyn, jisela, ayanna, veronica, julie, beth, tina, kendall, kailah, katie, trishelle 

How are Holly and Chadwick? Have never watch any of their show but saw they were married lol

"Better than thou" types

 

How are Holly and Chadwick? Have never watch any of their show but saw they were married lol

"Better than thou" types

I probably would like them then lol

 

 

 

i want cara maria so badly 

I don't want her on all stars lol

well she's not being asked for the main show. Maybe they'll throw her a bone finally and do the jordan formula with her.

They like Jordan , they don't like working with Cara & dealing with her ways.

"dealing with her ways" is killing me. was she a pain to deal with on the show?

How are Holly and Chadwick? Have never watch any of their show but saw they were married lol

"Better than thou" types

I probably would like them then lol

Their criticism of Belou raising her kid on Seasons was...classic

What would be your ideal realistic cast? Keep in mind think about making the cast diverse and ppl you can actually see doing this.

Girls

1. Coral (Long shot she would accept & stick to it) 

2. Irulan

3. Paula 

4. Jenn

5. Jillian

6. Tori Hall

7. Ayiiia

8. Theresa (Long shot he would accept & stick to it)

9. Shauvon

10. Latoya

11.  Holly Brentson

12. Jisela

13. Ayanna

14. Veronica

Guys

1. Abram

2. Pete

3. Frank Sweeney

4. Dustin

5. Marlon

6. Kefla

7. Tony (Long shot he would accept & stick to it)

8. TY

9. Shane L

10. Chadwick11. Dan12. MJ

13. Steve

14. Alton

 

Love this cast PR...

Id drop Jisela and MJ for Tina and Cohutta

How are Holly and Chadwick? Have never watch any of their show but saw they were married lol

They neeeed to be on this. They were so athletic and religious yet mean spirited lmao. Holier than thou but also eviler than thou

100%

 

 

How are Holly and Chadwick? Have never watch any of their show but saw they were married lol

"Better than thou" types

I probably would like them then lol

They make for good tv that's for sure. I always like Chadwick on his shows. Holly on the other hand was a big no. But they played the villain roles amazing. 

What would be your ideal realistic cast? Keep in mind think about making the cast diverse and ppl you can actually see doing this.

Girls

1. Coral (Long shot she would accept & stick to it) 

2. Irulan

3. Paula 

4. Jenn

5. Jillian

6. Tori Hall

7. Ayiiia

8. Theresa (Long shot he would accept & stick to it)

9. Shauvon

10. Latoya

11.  Holly Brentson

12. Jisela

13. Ayanna

14. Veronica

Guys

1. Abram

2. Pete

3. Frank Sweeney

4. Dustin

5. Marlon

6. Kefla

7. Tony (Long shot he would accept & stick to it)

8. TY

9. Shane L

10. Chadwick11. Dan12. MJ

13. Steve

14. Alton

Im surprised by this PR. It's good but many have been long shots. Haha. I'll still keep hoping. Is Irulan a real possibility? I thought last we heard she said Arissa would need to be there.

Holly B was kinda like Tori Hall except much more athletic, more religious and more evil

Brad has one brain cell in comparison to Chadwick's smartass self

Holly B was kinda like Tori Hall except much more athletic, more religious and more evil

Brad has one brain cell in comparison to Chadwick's smartass self

Generally agree--the only thing I would say is Tori Hall was a great athlete she just lacked Holly B's competitive nature.  If Tori was a true competitor she could have been great.  She might be my least favorite Challenger ever in terms of personality but she was a great athlete.

I really hope jillian is on this

Just curious... Which dan pink?

 

Holly B was kinda like Tori Hall except much more athletic, more religious and more evil

Brad has one brain cell in comparison to Chadwick's smartass self

Generally agree--the only thing I would say is Tori Hall was a great athlete she just lacked Holly B's competitive nature.  If Tori was a true competitor she could have been great.  She might be my least favorite Challenger ever in terms of personality but she was a great athlete.

this is true. Also, despite priding herself on being Christian and a 'goodie two-shoe', Holly still knew she was a baddie and owned being a 'femme fatale', just like Chadwick owned being an evil mastermind. They walked around the Seasons 1 house like they were a movie-star couple from Hollywood.

 

 

Holly B was kinda like Tori Hall except much more athletic, more religious and more evil

Brad has one brain cell in comparison to Chadwick's smartass self

Generally agree--the only thing I would say is Tori Hall was a great athlete she just lacked Holly B's competitive nature.  If Tori was a true competitor she could have been great.  She might be my least favorite Challenger ever in terms of personality but she was a great athlete.

this is true. Also, despite priding herself on being Christian and a 'goodie two-shoe', Holly still knew she was a baddie and owned being a 'femme fatale', just like Chadwick owned being an evil mastermind. They walked around the Seasons 1 house like they were a movie-star couple from Hollywood.

Yupp...that's accurate for sure

I'm fully expecting BB or AYTO...this is the most incompetent production company of all-time. They can't do anything correct.

 

 

How are Holly and Chadwick? Have never watch any of their show but saw they were married lol

"Better than thou" types

I probably would like them then lol

Quote from Coral about Holly during Hands on Saturn mission in Battle of the Seasons.

"Holly melted the ice with her evil witch hands"

  • Beth RW2 
  • Julie RW9
  • Coral RW10
  • Lori RW10
  • Veronica RR8
  • Ayanna RR8
  • Katie RR10
  • Tina RR12
  • Cara RR12
  • Elka RW6
  • Irulan RW12
  • Holly RR9
  • Jisela RR10
  •  
  • David RW2
  • Landon RW15
  • Chadwick RR6
  • Adam RR10
  • Shane RR11
  • Pete FM2
  • Dan RW5
  • Jamie RW9
  • Theo RW11
  • Steven RW12
  • Kefla RR6
  • Steve RR10
  • Jeremy RR12
  • And I would do a team challenge bad asses vs good guys.

    Disregard

     

    I'm so over how stupid casting is. If Cynthia is considered a last resort because she's older and Dan is left as an alternate then there is no hope for these shows. It's obvious these people have never watched older seasons of The real World which are so much better than anything put out today. Do they even realize how someone like Cynthia effortlessly comes onto the show and is an immediate hit?  Probably not. They just go back to business as usual and shove people like Tori down the viewer's throats. I have said it several times before & I'll say it again, I hate this show. 

    I've like Cynthia since Miami but let's not pretend she added much.  We just like her.  You hate the show because they cater to casuals not us which has always been true.  Pretending any casting department would cast Cynthia over Tori is delusional at best.

    I'm all for more true OGs but we're going to get people like Jemmye Sylvia and Kailah for obvious reasons. 

    She was real.  She had a few funny one liners - her slicing open her body and wine flowing out being one of the main one liners from that season that sticks out.  I'd much rather someone laid back with litte funny comments here and there then people like Wes/Nehemiah who has horribe acting skills or people like Jemmye/Sylvia/Kailah who can still take time out of their life to do the flagship show. What seemed to be the point of this show was to have people like Cynthia back.  Not to give someone like Wes or Kailah an extra season on thier off time. 

    Why do yall ask for people on AS that should still be on the main show? Let us have our oldies on AS and don't subscribe if you hate entertaining personalities.

    THIS <3

    Yikes maybe we do need some of those irrelevant oldschoolers on season 4 so that these folks on here can be less miserable and more blessed *giggles*

    I don't understand why you even watch All Stars Flopnanas - you seem to hate old schoolers so much during all the casting processes of this seris.  Why not just stick with the flagship?  Not trying to be rude, just a legit question .

     

    Would this be the first season to include ayto in the mix?

    Legend Simone. 

    We don't need another bad actor/actress in the mixed.  She can stay gone off all of the shows but especially AS lol.  

    Hopefully all of AYTO stays far away from this show

    Just curious... Which dan pink?

    The one that was alternate on 3

    Just curious... Which dan pink?

    The one that was alternate on 3

    I still can't beleive he was made an alternate.  He always made for good TV.  I hated him during Inferno 2 for how he treated Jodi lol 

     

     

    Would this be the first season to include ayto in the mix?

    Legend Simone. 

    We don't need another bad actor/actress in the mixed.  She can stay gone off all of the shows but especially AS lol.  

    Hopefully all of AYTO stays far away from this show

    "Who is WE? We the people?"

     

    Yikes maybe we do need some of those irrelevant oldschoolers on season 4 so that these folks on here can be less miserable and more blessed *giggles*

    I don't understand why you even watch All Stars Flopnanas - you seem to hate old schoolers so much during all the casting processes of this seris.  Why not just stick with the flagship?  Not trying to be rude, just a legit question .

    I love svetlana and been waiting for over 15 years for her to come as well as coral to stop flaking so that's a BIG lie! We just need entertaining ones and not just any Oldschooler who y'all just want to come on bc of nostalgia Smile

    Pages

    Topic locked