Survivor: Generic Thread (No Spoilers)

6044 posts / 0 new
Last post

Chicken_breast wrote:
Rewatching Panama and something we need on the recent seasons is real drama and less gameplay talk.

the reason why real drama is lacking is because they feel the need to clutter the game with advantages. Gameplay talk would come more naturally instead of everyone stressing for 45 minutes about possible curveballs and how to navigate around them

I do agree there's too much "clutter" but ideally the drama (or most of it) would be surrounding the game in some aspect.

Chicken_breast wrote:
Rewatching Panama and something we need on the recent seasons is real drama and less gameplay talk.

Agree completely

Yea the show would benefit immensely from having less twists imo

Chicken_breast wrote:
Rewatching Panama and something we need on the recent seasons is real drama and less gameplay talk.

Disagree completely

Must suck for you then.

I could do without reward challenges. Maybe later in the game when everyone is already starved and tired and because having to choose people to take with you on rewards can cause some friction. But early on the season, when you have an hour to try and fit an immunity challenge, tribal council and screentime for 20 people, it just seems like a waste of time. 

I could do without reward challenges. Maybe later in the game when everyone is already starved and tired and because having to choose people to take with you on rewards can cause some friction. But early on the season, when you have an hour to try and fit an immunity challenge, tribal council and screentime for 20 people, it just seems like a waste of time. 

With Extinction Island airtime there definitely shouldn’t be any rewards challenges this season. 

I could do without reward challenges. Maybe later in the game when everyone is already starved and tired and because having to choose people to take with you on rewards can cause some friction. But early on the season, when you have an hour to try and fit an immunity challenge, tribal council and screentime for 20 people, it just seems like a waste of time. 

This or just have it immunity and reward challenge so they can shoot two birds with one stone.

I feel like recent seasons with real drama aren't good though like Worlds Apart was terrible

But I agree that the gamebot seasons like Game Changers have been dull

David vs Goliath was a pretty good mix

Worlds apart was legendary 

Worlds apart was legendary 

oh

Worlds apart was legendary 

Hali Ford was the legendary part of that season.

KlounV3 wrote:
Worlds apart was legendary 

Rodney was the legendary part of that season.

I would love a school yard pick tribe swap happen right before the Immunity challenge. But know the people they cast it would not be dramatic.

I haven't watched one second of Edge of Extinction & don't plan to lmaooo I'll wait to see next season's cast.

I think US Survivor needs to try Turkey's format for a season after seeing it more.

I haven't watched one second of Edge of Extinction & don't plan to lmaooo I'll wait to see next season's cast.I think US Survivor needs to try Turkey's format for a season after seeing it more.
same haven’t touched it lol who asked for this 

I haven't watched one second of Edge of Extinction & don't plan to lmaooo I'll wait to see next season's cast.I think US Survivor needs to try Turkey's format for a season after seeing it more.

It's kinda lame since the twist and returnees are on it. The newbies are intresting but due to editing they are going to be forgetable. 

I missed last weeks episode but I don’t have a desire to watch it. I’ll prob just look up the wiki to see who got voted out and stuff. Lol

I haven't watched DvG or EoE. Get rid of the pointless twists and ******** tribe separations

Omg watching Survivor Philippines and Abi was the star. Iconic.

Omg watching Survivor Philippines and Abi was the star. Iconic.

We been knew. 

i stopped watching this show w game lamers. that was an abomination with all the twists, the casting was trash, and the twistmageddon that got cirie out was so manufactured by production, it turned me off from the show for good. the show has WAY too many twists, like one hidden idol is find, but when you got whats his ******* name tai finding like 5 idols in a season, your show sucks. too many twists/advantages kill the game. i also hate how every vote they try to edit it as its some blindside, all it does it downplay when an actual blindside happens. 

i stopped watching this show w game lamers. that was an abomination with all the twists, the casting was trash, and the twistmageddon that got cirie out was so manufactured by production, it turned me off from the show for good. the show has WAY too many twists, like one hidden idol is find, but when you got whats his ******* name tai finding like 5 idols in a season, your show sucks. too many twists/advantages kill the game. i also hate how every vote they try to edit it as its some blindside, all it does it downplay when an actual blindside happens. 

David vs. Goliath was really good but otherwise you really haven't missed much. 

I think there should be an idol on each camp, but once it's played or someone leaves with it, DONT REHIDE THAT ****. Like you really had Ben in HvHvH playing an idol one episode, finding it the next episode and playing it that same episode, rinse and repeat. It really ruined what was a great season. 

Probst is really so out of touch with what fans want. 

Probst is really so out of touch with what fans want. 

Him and Grodner are tragic and delusional show runners.

nevidcm wrote:
Probst is really so out of touch with what fans want. 

Him and Grodner are tragic and delusional show runners.

I'd imagine BMP isn't too far behind

Probst is really so out of touch with what fans want. 

What I don't get is he knows fans hated redemption island anex trashes it yet they make a worse version with extinction island 

nevidcm wrote:
Probst is really so out of touch with what fans want. 

What I don't get is he knows fans hated redemption island anex trashes it yet they make a worse version with extinction island 

and i don’t know a SINGLE person that liked the firemaking at F4 twist so of course they brought it back

nevidcm wrote:
Probst is really so out of touch with what fans want. 

What I don't get is he knows fans hated redemption island anex trashes it yet they make a worse version with extinction island 

I liked Redemption Island but it was done poorly. If they wanted RI they should have kept it secret so people wouldn't have know about the twist to use it for strategy and lose it once the merge hits.

Just a reminder that Wendell is king on the island and in real life.

King of keeping the community together and alive.

This season's better than people are giving it credit for so far...we'll see how it plays out but it's really not bad at all.

Pages