[QUOTE=kvm1977;381558]I think voting Monica out would have also made more sense because she'd have a better chance to beat the brothers[/QUOTE]
She'd probably get too paranoid that they were colluding together to beat her.
I really really really dislike Monica. Her paranoia is getting on my nerves. Kinda wish Tina made a fake idol and showed it to people. I feel like some of the newbies would have fell for it and possibly voted Monica.
[QUOTE=kvm1977;381522]I love Redemption Island because I like competition that has meaning. They could show show them the tape of tribals to get an accurate portrayal. All that said, I'd be all for Redemption Island just for the first half. Any season without Redemption Island is a waste to me[/QUOTE]
[QUOTE=molds13;381528]They got through 21 seasons of Survivor without RI. I think they did just fine without it.[/QUOTE]
The only argument I have for RI is that if I were on the show and got voted out, I'd want to turn right around and get back in the game immediately, wouldn't you? Redemption Island lets that happen, potentially.
There is no doubt RI dilutes the entire premise of Survivor, and I'm not a fan of it but I understand the concept. I prefer reward challenges any day of the week. Also RI means no Survivor Auction, which is one of my favorite parts to watch too :frown-new:
edit: You made a fantastic point about the Jury not getting to see the tribals molds! An uninformed jury may be even worse than a bitter one.
Pages