Well i've only seen from Austin plus so here are who i think learned the most:
RW Austin: Danny, he went through a lot but he also met his Wife.
RW Key West: yea had to be Paula, she went in there with some serious issues.
RW Denver: Tyrie, with the fight with Davis and arrest.
RW Sydney: Kelly Anne.
RW Hollywood: That one that was addicted to cocaine, forgot his name.
[QUOTE]eh. I dunno OPD. Something about her never sat well with me.[/QUOTE]
I think Irene definitely had her own issues, but in the end she didn't deserve to be slapped. One would wonder what she had been trying to accomplish by provoking Stephen like that, though, since she had lived with him and had to know he could flip the switch to totally nuts in a matter of seconds.
Either way, I wouldn't pick Irene for MVP. I'd go with David, probably, though Lindsay would be my sentimental favorite. I think her personality lit up that entire cast.
I agree with Landon for Philly.
I'd go with Brad for San Diego, because while Frankie was interesting to watch, I think I found a lot of the season great to watch in spite of her, not because of her. I'm sad that she's gone now, but at the time she made me want to bang my head against a wall. She's one of the people who I think had severe enough issues that I question the choice of casting her to begin with if she wasn't going to be receiving professional help for those issues while in the house. And...I mean, come on, Brad threatened to beat a guy up while dressed as a Super Mario brother and got arrested three times. And one of those three times, he walked out of the police station totally barefoot for no explicable reason. Contest over. But one of the reasons I think San Diego was so good was because of the overall cast chemistry, so that's worth noting.
I don't want to agree with Wes for Austin, but I'm having trouble picking someone to go with instead. I feel like Danny, Melinda, Jo, and Wes are probably all about even. I wouldn't pick one of the other three.
This is how it should be.
Season 1- Kevin
Season 2- Beth
Season 3- Pedro
Season 4- Jacinda
Season 5- Melissa or Flora
Season 6- Montana
Season 7- Irene
Season 8- Ruthie
Season 9- Melissa
Season 10- Coral
Season 11- Aneesa
Season 12- Alton
Season 13- CT
Season 14- Robin
Season 15- Karamo
Season 16- Johanna
Season 17- Paula
Season 18- Alex
Season 19- Parisa
Season 20- Brianna
Just stumbled upon this thread and thought I'd give my thoughts on the seasons I've seen and update it with the more recent seasons.
New York: Julie
LA: Tami
San Francisco: Pedro
Boston: Genesis
Hawaii: Ruthie
Las Vegas: Trishelle or Arissa
Philadelphia: Sarah or Landon
Austin: Danny
Key West: Paula
Denver: Brooke... maybe Davis or Jenn as well
Sydney: Kellyanne or Parisa
Hollywood: Brianna or Joey
Brooklyn: Ryan
Cancun: Ayiiia
DC: Mike, maybe Ashley
New Orleans: Jemmye
Las Vegas2: Nany or Dustin
San Diego2: Frank
St. Thomas: so far its Marie for me but it could be Brandon depending on how his stroy unfolds.
[QUOTE=andhoo;312370]
St. Thomas: so far its Marie for me but it could be[B] Brandon[/B] depending on how his stroy unfolds.[/QUOTE]
The only relevant person this season.
Not necessarily my favorites but the people I feel brought the most to the seasons,
New York: Julie
LA: Tami
San Francisco: Puck
London: Sharon
Miami: Flora
Boston: Kameelah
Seattle: No one stood out
Hawaii: Ruthie
New Orleans: Melissa
New York: No one stood out
Chicago: Cara
Las Vegas: Arissa
Paris: Leah
San Diego: Cameran
Philadelphia: Sarah
Austin: No one stood out
Key West: Paula
Denver: Brooke
Sydney: Parisa
Hollywood: No one stood out
Brooklyn: JD
Cancun: Ayiiia
DC: Ashley
New Orleans: Jemmye
Las Vegas2: Dustin
San Diego2: Frank
St. Thomas: Latoya
[QUOTE=ILoveRW;312382]Not necessarily my favorites but the people I feel brought the most to the seasons,
New York: Julie
LA: Tami
San Francisco: Puck
London: Sharon
Miami: Flora
Boston: Kameelah
Seattle: No one stood out
Hawaii: Ruthie
New Orleans: Melissa
[b] New York: No one stood out [/b]
Chicago: Cara
Las Vegas: Arissa
Paris: Leah
San Diego: Cameran
Philadelphia: Sarah
Austin: No one stood out
Key West: Paula
Denver: Brooke
Sydney: Parisa
Hollywood: No one stood out
Brooklyn: JD
Cancun: Ayiiia
DC: Ashley
New Orleans: Jemmye
Las Vegas2: Dustin
San Diego2: Frank
St. Thomas: Latoya[/QUOTE]
Coral and Mike most definitely stood out. A case could even be made for Nicole.
I'm gonna start from when I started watching.
Not sure what the definition of an MVP is for this show since it's not a challenge or anything...
DC: Emily
New Orleans: Ryan/Jemmye
Las Vegas2: Leroy
San Diego2: Sam
St. Thomas: Robb
[QUOTE=salt&vinegar;312389]Coral and Mike most definitely stood out. A case could even be made for Nicole.[/QUOTE]
Nicole was probably the most deserving of the MVP title but then I can't really remember what she did apart from 1 or 2 arguments. Coral and Mike only started making great TV when they got on the Challenges, for me.
Denver: Jenn, I'm only halfway done though, I have to see the rest
Sydney: I only watched this season occasionally, but Kellyanne stood out the most to me
Hollywood: did not watch
Brooklyn: Ryan
Cancun: Ayiiia
DC: Ashley
New Orleans2: Jemmye
Las Vegas 2: All of them, TBH
San Diego 2: Zach
St Thomas: La Toya
[FONT=Century Gothic][SIZE=2]I actually only started watching since Back2NY but re-watched all of the seasons since then…[/SIZE][/FONT]
[FONT=Century Gothic][SIZE=2]*note…. This is a list of people who, in my opinion brought the most to the season and not the ones I actually liked(well not always..)[/SIZE][/FONT]
[FONT=Century Gothic][SIZE=2][URL="http://vevmo.com/vbimghost.php?do=displayimg&imgid=14290"][IMG]http://vevmo.com/imagehosting/5543500c86a7b49f2.jpg[/IMG][/URL]
[/SIZE][/FONT]
^ interesting choices there. I heard from some people say Parisa was 'boring' during her season. I didn't watch that season entirely, I only watched it on occasion though, so IDRK, but from what I did see of Sydney she wasn't boring, she was shown a lot.
[QUOTE=Buck05;41601]Season 1 - Julie [I feel she learned the most]
Season 2 - Beth [duh]
Season 3 - Pedro [duh again]
Season 4 - Jacinda [does anyone really know anyone else from this cast?]
Season 5 - Dan [drama all over his forehead...great casting choice]
Season 6 - Montana [didn't watch, but I'll trust everyone else]
Season 7 - Irene [the story of the season was the slap]
Season 8 - Ruthie [alcoholism anyone?]
Season 9 - Julie [how could you not vote Julie for this season? She may suck now, but she owned that season]
Season 10 - Mike [he learned the most]
Season 11 - Tonya [I feel she's the obvious choice, but I almost put Cara here]
Season 12 - Trishelle [perfect RW house mate]
Season 13 - CT [he's crazy]
Season 14 - Cameran [so cute, so naive, perfect RW cast member]
Season 15 - Landon [i hated this season, but most everything seemed to revolve around him]
Season 16 - Danny [he got *** on during this season, with the punch, his mom, etc.... but he met Melinda so there's a plus]
Season 17 - Paula [nobody else is close]
Season 18 - Brooke [see above]
Season 19 - Parisa [the only intelligent one of the bunch]
Season 20 - Kimberly [I don't know, maybe I'm biased cuz I LOVE her][/QUOTE]
I'll add on to my original list:
Season 21 - Ryan
Season 22 - Ayiiia
Season 23 - Emily
Season 24 - Jemmye
Season 25 - Nany
Season 26 - Frank
Season 27 - We'll see...but it's looking like it'll be one of Trey/Laura/Robb/Marie at this point.
Interesting topic--and way late on my part but the Seasons I watched
MVP (Runner-up)
1. Julie (Eric)
2. Beth (Aaron-he was really the first to hate MTV)
3. Pedro (Rachel-I think she grew the most)
4. Jacinda (Neil)
5. Flora (Dan)
6. Elka (Sean)
7. I watched but none stand out--maybe Irene
8. Ruthie (Teck)
9. Melissa (Julie)
10. Coral & Mike as a duo
11. Tonya/Aneesa--tie
12. Trishelle (Arissa)
13. CT (Mallory)
14. Brad (Robin)
15. Again, I watched but none stood out--Landon due to the challenges
16. Danny & Melinda as a couple
17. Paula (Janelle)
[I]18. Never watched[/I]
[I]19. Never watched[/I]
20. Kimberly (Brianna)
[I]21. Never watched[/I]
22. Ayiiia (Jonna)
23. Emily (Callie)
24. Only Jemmye stood out IMO
[I]25. Never watched[/I]
26. Nate (Zach)
How has no one had Adam royer as their MVP for Vegas 2? I've been watching since brooklyn and he's without a doubt the most polarizing/entertaining/sociopathical person to be on the show in that time frame and probably ever on the show. I know he got kicked out early but give the dude props he is a good character
[QUOTE=ChallengeGod;312562]How has no one had Adam royer as their MVP for Vegas 2? I've been watching since brooklyn and he's without a doubt the most polarizing/entertaining/sociopathical person to be on the show in that time frame and probably ever on the show. I know he got kicked out early but give the dude props he is a good character[/QUOTE]
I guess it really boils down to one's criteria for an MVP. Some might go the hot mess/fights/drama route when determining their MVP, and others might look at personal growth and change among cast members. It is both interesting and slightly depressing to see how the show has evolved over the years.
[QUOTE=Treetrunk;312586]I guess it really boils down to one's criteria for an MVP. Some might go the hot mess/fights/drama route when determining their MVP, and others might look at personal growth and change among cast members. It is both interesting and slightly depressing to see how the show has evolved over the years.[/QUOTE]
But that's the point. Nobody really evolves on this show anymore, they don't come here for soul searching, they usually come for the screen time. Let's face it, our generation is made up of little ignorant b********, who do not give a da** about becoming a better person, at least not when they are 21:drinks:
Season 1 - Julie*
Season 2 - Beth*
Season 3 - Puck/Pedro*
Season 4 - Jacinda/Niel
Season 5 - Dan/Melissa/Mike
Season 6 - Montana/Genesis/Jason
Season 7 - David*
Season 8 - Ruthie*
Season 9 - Julie/Danny/Melissa
Season 10 - No one *did much until Coral and Mike did The Challenges*
Season 11 - Tonya/Cara/Aneesa
Season 12 - Steven/Arissa
Season 13 - CT*
Season 14 - Robin
Season 15 - Landon*
Season 16 - Wes
Season 17 - Paula*
Season 18 - Davis
Reunited- Irulan
Season 19 - Parisa
Season 20 - Brianna
Season 21- Katelynn
Season 22- Jasmine/Bronne
Season 23- Emily/ Mike
Season 24- Ryan/Jemmye
Season 25- Adam/Dustin
Season 26- Zach*
Season 27- Robb/Brandon *
New York: Eric
LA: Tami
San Francisco: Puck
London: Sharon
Miami: Flora
Boston: Elka
Seattle: David
Hawaii: Amaya
New Orleans: Danny
New York: Coral
Chicago: Cara
Las Vegas: Trishelle
Paris: Mallo
San Diego: Frankie
Philadelphia: Landon
Austin: Wes
Key West: Svetlana
Denver: Brooke
Sydney: KellyAnne
Hollywood: No one stood out
Brooklyn: No one stood out
Cancun: Bronne
DC: Emily
New Orleans: No one stood out
Las Vegas2: Dustin
San Diego2: Frank
St Thomas: Trey
New York: Has to be Coral
Chicago: Aneesa
Las Vegas: Trishelle has no competition here.
Paris: CT, he's an animal.
San Diego: Brad because that's when he was a wild drunk.
Philly: Landon, he's a beast.
Austin: Johanna made me want to watch this season.
Key West: Johnny, he's just Johnny.
Denver: Jenn, she's a crazy b****.
Sydney: Cohutta, funniest guy ever to be on the real world.
Hollywood and Brooklyn: 2 most boring seasons in real world history.
Cancun: Jasmine, what doesn't she bring to the table?
DC: Ty, rarely an episode without something major happening with him.
NO2: Knight, good story gettin over pain killers and always comedy.
Las Vegas 2: Leroy, everybody loves him.
SD2- Nate, he had the best charity cause through out the whole season.
Saint Thomas: Marie, no brainer.
[QUOTE=Ejballer31;322431]New York: Has to be Coral
Chicago: Aneesa
Las Vegas: Trishelle has no competition here.
Paris: CT, he's an animal.
San Diego: Brad because that's when he was a wild drunk.
Philly: Landon, he's a beast.
Austin: Johanna made me want to watch this season.
Key West: Johnny, he's just Johnny.
Denver: Jenn, she's a crazy b****.
Sydney: Cohutta, funniest guy ever to be on the real world.
[B]Hollywood and Brooklyn: 2 most boring seasons in real world history.[/B]
Cancun: Jasmine, what doesn't she bring to the table?
DC: Ty, rarely an episode without something major happening with him.
NO2: Knight, good story gettin over pain killers and always comedy.
Las Vegas 2: Leroy, everybody loves him.
SD2- Nate, he had the best charity cause through out the whole season.
Saint Thomas: Marie, no brainer.[/QUOTE]
You misspelled Paris and DC.
Who do you all think was the MVP of the most recent Portland season? I feel like its more a POE because it was a rough season
[B]Marlon[/B] was probably the most likable, but he wasn't very interesting to watch imo.
[B]Jessica[/B] was a desperate bore.
[B]Anastasia[/B] was a hypocritical bore and while Jessica's actions weren't really defendable, it would annoy me when she complained about how attention hungry Jessica was and then cry when no one paid attention to her.
[B]Jordan[/B] started the season as an arrogant, ignorant monster and ended the season as tolerable but it struck me as editing more than personal growth.
[B]Averey[/B] and [B]Johnny[/B] took the role of the couple. I guess they were interesting because she was hot and he was a very average looking m*******? I thought it was pretty funny how much pride she took in being a Hooters girl.
[B]Nia [/B]probably has the MVP title in the bag. She was a pretty dynamic monster. Before she arrived, it was just Jordan being an oddly judgey and a relatively mild irritant. But once she came, she proved herself as a charming, manipulative and seemingly well aware psychopath who offered "to suck skin off *****" and waltzed around in bra and panties antagonizing everyone. She was incorrigible and could not be defended cause all her actions throughout the show displayed little logic/reason and the blow dryer battle was hard to watch. But at least she was something to talk about?
[QUOTE=Rockstar;366160]Who do you all think was the MVP of the most recent Portland season? I feel like its more a POE because it was a rough season
[B]Marlon[/B] was probably the most likable, but he wasn't very interesting to watch imo.
[B]Jessica[/B] was a desperate bore.
[B]Anastasia[/B] was a hypocritical bore and while Jessica's actions weren't really defendable, it would annoy me when she complained about how attention hungry Jessica was and then cry when no one paid attention to her.
[B]Jordan[/B] started the season as an arrogant, ignorant monster and ended the season as tolerable but it struck me as editing more than personal growth.
[B]Averey[/B] and [B]Johnny[/B] took the role of the couple. I guess they were interesting because she was hot and he was a very average looking m*******? I thought it was pretty funny how much pride she took in being a Hooters girl.
[B]Nia [/B]probably has the MVP title in the bag. She was a pretty dynamic monster. Before she arrived, it was just Jordan being an oddly judgey and a relatively mild irritant. But once she came, she proved herself as a charming, manipulative and seemingly well aware psychopath who offered "to suck skin off *****" and waltzed around in bra and panties antagonizing everyone. She was incorrigible and could not be defended cause all her actions throughout the show displayed little logic/reason and the blow dryer battle was hard to watch. But at least she was something to talk about?[/QUOTE]
Clearly this page should now be nuked.
N** gets WFB from me, but I can't mention her name. She is in the same category as "he who shall not be named."
Pages