The Challenge: Unpopular Opinions

10051 posts / 0 new
Last post

I think in order the top 6 girls in challenge history are

 

evelyn

laurel

emily

rachel

cooke

jodi

 

LOOOL Cooke made one challenge and his already your top 6? overrated ftw...

I agree, we can't really judge her based on one appearance. What about Holly Shand?

Lets be real.

Devyn's hilarious, she made BOTSeasons so much easier to watch and I think she deserved the FA finale. I think she's considered a vet by now, but while she might not be the most athletic person on the show, she's funny as ****, and I think that's necessary in these shows half the time.

 

thank you.

Lets be real.

Devyn's hilarious, she made BOTSeasons so much easier to watch and I think she deserved the FA finale. I think she's considered a vet by now, but while she might not be the most athletic person on the show, she's funny as ****, and I think that's necessary in these shows half the time.

 

thank you.

i cant think of one person who can beat cooke in any elimenation round besides the 4 above her.. She is very smart, she solved almost all of the puzzles for rivals 2 final, very physically strong, and has great endurance. If you think cooke is overrated take a look at Nany, sarah, and cara maria

 

Cmon man eliminations aren´t everything, and not always the strongest win on those...

 

I would put most of Xtreme girls above Cooke anyday tho

No way Angela or Ibis is gonna beat Cooke.... Jillian and Kina only have a chance in maybe an endurance game.. Jodi is the only xtreme girl who has a chance but i still think that cooke is #5 and jodi is #6

and also about the Laurel vs Emily

Both are undefeated but laurel is 8-0 while Emily is 5-0

Both have made finals every challenge appearance but all of laurel's besides free agents have been 2nd place wins, while all of emilys have been 3rd

Both have won one challenge while Laurel's win was individual while Emily was partnered and Free agents had a much harder final.. 

Paula from KeyWest maybe in endurance or something like that, i think she doesnt give her self the credit she deserves, and i think she is stronger than what most "people" think she is...

Marie from Saint Thomas also looks strong but idk she needs more challenge time

 

 

I don´t know , about a top 6 female, i can´t really say because most of the challenges . what sticks in for most of the times are male wins/feuds/eliminations, females really cant have much of their highlights ( except for very few notorious ones : laurel,emily and Evelyn who basically was running solo vs JEK on The Island...

 

P.S : Being able to take out most competitors on a EM doesnt make you the strongest, just look at CT he is the beast that no one wants to face in a elimination but he is no the best competitor of the challenge, same for Beth, she got the size but doesnt mean she is the best

 

 

I just think that Cooke CARRIED Cara Maria through Rivals 2 which was awesome, even though i do not like cooke for treating Diem badly

I think it was mutual lol, cooke wouldnt reach the final with Naomi...just sayin

neither would Evelyn, Laurel, Emily or Rachel so whats your point

Cooke is a great competitor and def carried Caramaria on Rivals 2 but I think we need to see her on more challenges before we would put in top 6...

I understand why you guys think she should not be in top 6 but even Emily has said in an interview that if Rivals 2 was an individual challenge her only worry would be cooke.. although i do think that Emily would still beat Cooke

neither would Evelyn, Laurel, Emily or Rachel so whats your point

 

lol ... actually they would have had better chances, especially Evelyn and Laurel, they could keep out of eliminations with all that political power, my point is cooke is not that super-female beast that picture...she has done 1  challenge..ffs

 

despise the hate Camila deserves to be in a top 6 instead of Cooke...

No way... Not Camila......

I agree. She doesn't deserve to be top 6. **** she shouldn't even be on the actual show.

I think Cooke belongs in the top 6 I also think Cooke is one of the best females to run a final with because she probably has more endurance than anybody on the show.

I think The Duel 2 was the best challenge ever produced.... Along with Gauntlet 2

From the modern females, Camila is the second best IMO. Of all females, around 9-10.

Camila is definately one of the best girls.  She almost beat Laurel twice. That is very impressive to me. 

I really like Cooke...I feel like she would definitely solidify an Elite status if she ever comes back...from what I saw on her instagram it seems like she would've done Free Agents if she could go back & change her decision (based on what she said).

Holly S. is so underrated IMO & I think its because a lot of people here weren't hip to the challenges back then. She is definitely worthy of being apart of that "Elite" group of girls. Christena (South Pacific) is another one who I think would've been apart of that group but she never came back.

Camila.....smh. I think people try to make an excuse for her but imo she really tried in that elimination against Theresa but lost 100%. She just had a scapegoat in what was going on back home w/ her family to fall back on.

I just think that Cooke CARRIED Cara Maria through Rivals 2 which was awesome, even though i do not like cooke for treating Diem badly

 

Bad

I really like Cooke...I feel like she would definitely solidify an Elite status if she ever comes back...from what I saw on her instagram it seems like she would've done Free Agents if she could go back & change her decision (based on what she said).

Holly S. is so underrated IMO & I think its because a lot of people here weren't hip to the challenges back then. She is definitely worthy of being apart of that "Elite" group of girls. Christena (South Pacific) is another one who I think would've been apart of that group but she never came back.

Camila.....smh. I think people try to make an excuse for her but imo she really tried in that elimination against Theresa but lost 100%. She just had a scapegoat in what was going on back home w/ her family to fall back on.

I never did like Christena and I am glad she never came back. There was something about her that was just aggravating. 

I really like Cooke...I feel like she would definitely solidify an Elite status if she ever comes back...from what I saw on her instagram it seems like she would've done Free Agents if she could go back & change her decision (based on what she said).

Holly S. is so underrated IMO & I think its because a lot of people here weren't hip to the challenges back then. She is definitely worthy of being apart of that "Elite" group of girls. Christena (South Pacific) is another one who I think would've been apart of that group but she never came back.

Camila.....smh. I think people try to make an excuse for her but imo she really tried in that elimination against Theresa but lost 100%. She just had a scapegoat in what was going on back home w/ her family to fall back on.

Eh, I think she would have lost either way, but she definitely would have given Theresa a run for her money and been on offense a lot more. There's no way someone with the fire and heart to compete like she has would just roll over like that.

I really like Cooke...I feel like she would definitely solidify an Elite status if she ever comes back...from what I saw on her instagram it seems like she would've done Free Agents if she could go back & change her decision (based on what she said).

Holly S. is so underrated IMO & I think its because a lot of people here weren't hip to the challenges back then. She is definitely worthy of being apart of that "Elite" group of girls. Christena (South Pacific) is another one who I think would've been apart of that group but she never came back.

Camila.....smh. I think people try to make an excuse for her but imo she really tried in that elimination against Theresa but lost 100%. She just had a scapegoat in what was going on back home w/ her family to fall back on.

Eh, I think she would have lost either way, but she definitely would have given Theresa a run for her money and been on offense a lot more. There's no way someone with the fire and heart to compete like she has would just roll over like that.

Lol that's what i'm saying, she DID actually give it her all but Theresa is just the better one out of the two. But since she had stuff going on back home people made excuses like "oh she wasn't really trying her hardest, she could've beat Theresa but she had other stuff going on" etc. but yes Theresa would've beat her either way.

I really like Cooke...I feel like she would definitely solidify an Elite status if she ever comes back...from what I saw on her instagram it seems like she would've done Free Agents if she could go back & change her decision (based on what she said).

Holly S. is so underrated IMO & I think its because a lot of people here weren't hip to the challenges back then. She is definitely worthy of being apart of that "Elite" group of girls. Christena (South Pacific) is another one who I think would've been apart of that group but she never came back.

Camila.....smh. I think people try to make an excuse for her but imo she really tried in that elimination against Theresa but lost 100%. She just had a scapegoat in what was going on back home w/ her family to fall back on.

Eh, I think she would have lost either way, but she definitely would have given Theresa a run for her money and been on offense a lot more. There's no way someone with the fire and heart to compete like she has would just roll over like that.

Lol that's what i'm saying, she DID actually give it her all but Theresa is just the better one out of the two. But since she had stuff going on back home people made excuses like "oh she wasn't really trying her hardest, she could've beat Theresa but she had other stuff going on" etc. but yes Theresa would've beat her either way.

I don't think she did or that was just weird editing because I can't see Camila going out like that. If she would've put 100%, the elimination round would have been a lot closer.

I really like Cooke...I feel like she would definitely solidify an Elite status if she ever comes back...from what I saw on her instagram it seems like she would've done Free Agents if she could go back & change her decision (based on what she said).

Holly S. is so underrated IMO & I think its because a lot of people here weren't hip to the challenges back then. She is definitely worthy of being apart of that "Elite" group of girls. Christena (South Pacific) is another one who I think would've been apart of that group but she never came back.

Camila.....smh. I think people try to make an excuse for her but imo she really tried in that elimination against Theresa but lost 100%. She just had a scapegoat in what was going on back home w/ her family to fall back on.

Eh, I think she would have lost either way, but she definitely would have given Theresa a run for her money and been on offense a lot more. There's no way someone with the fire and heart to compete like she has would just roll over like that.

Lol that's what i'm saying, she DID actually give it her all but Theresa is just the better one out of the two. But since she had stuff going on back home people made excuses like "oh she wasn't really trying her hardest, she could've beat Theresa but she had other stuff going on" etc. but yes Theresa would've beat her either way.

I don't think she did or that was just weird editing because I can't see Camila going out like that. If she would've put 100%, the elimination round would have been a lot closer.

I think She would've lost either way honestly. She's not that good.

I really like Cooke...I feel like she would definitely solidify an Elite status if she ever comes back...from what I saw on her instagram it seems like she would've done Free Agents if she could go back & change her decision (based on what she said).

Holly S. is so underrated IMO & I think its because a lot of people here weren't hip to the challenges back then. She is definitely worthy of being apart of that "Elite" group of girls. Christena (South Pacific) is another one who I think would've been apart of that group but she never came back.

Camila.....smh. I think people try to make an excuse for her but imo she really tried in that elimination against Theresa but lost 100%. She just had a scapegoat in what was going on back home w/ her family to fall back on.

Eh, I think she would have lost either way, but she definitely would have given Theresa a run for her money and been on offense a lot more. There's no way someone with the fire and heart to compete like she has would just roll over like that.

Lol that's what i'm saying, she DID actually give it her all but Theresa is just the better one out of the two. But since she had stuff going on back home people made excuses like "oh she wasn't really trying her hardest, she could've beat Theresa but she had other stuff going on" etc. but yes Theresa would've beat her either way.

I don't think she did or that was just weird editing because I can't see Camila going out like that. If she would've put 100%, the elimination round would have been a lot closer.

I think She would've lost either way honestly. She's not that good.

So do I, that's what I've been saying lol.

The only game Camila had a chance against Theresa waas Oppenheimer

I think the Island format has potential to be good..It just needs better rules and a better cast.

I really like Cooke...I feel like she would definitely solidify an Elite status if she ever comes back...from what I saw on her instagram it seems like she would've done Free Agents if she could go back & change her decision (based on what she said).

Holly S. is so underrated IMO & I think its because a lot of people here weren't hip to the challenges back then. She is definitely worthy of being apart of that "Elite" group of girls. Christena (South Pacific) is another one who I think would've been apart of that group but she never came back.

Camila.....smh. I think people try to make an excuse for her but imo she really tried in that elimination against Theresa but lost 100%. She just had a scapegoat in what was going on back home w/ her family to fall back on.

I soooo agree with everything you said, especially for the Camila part. Everyone tries to discredit Theresa's win against Camila because she supposedly gave up, which I don't think it's true at all. 

Pages