The Challenge: Generic Thread

69913 posts / 0 new
Last post

Cutthroat had way too many filler people. Emilee, JD, Derek, Luke, Dan W and some others. It's like having a season now with 6-8 Christina L's and Nates. 

Luke Wolfe is the man. Trolled Camila before it was cool, but knew it needed to be done 

Cutthroat had way too many filler people. Emilee, JD, Derek, Luke, Dan W and some others. It's like having a season now with 6-8 Christina L's and Nates. 

Every season has a bunch of filler people though....okay, most seasons.  The first Duel really didn't

KChallenge10 wrote:

Cutthroat had way too many filler people. Emilee, JD, Derek, Luke, Dan W and some others. It's like having a season now with 6-8 Christina L's and Nates. 

Every season has a bunch of filler people though....okay, most seasons.  The first Duel really didn't

That season had a ton though. So did BOTS to an extent. Most seasons usually have 2-4 people that don't bring anything and are questionable as to why they were even chosen. Cutthroat they could have made a whole team with the fillers. 

kvm1977 wrote:

KChallenge10 wrote:Cutthroat had way too many filler people. Emilee, JD, Derek, Luke, Dan W and some others. It's like having a season now with 6-8 Christina L's and Nates. 

Every season has a bunch of filler people though....okay, most seasons.  The first Duel really didn't

That season had a ton though. So did BOTS to an extent. Most seasons usually have 2-4 people that don't bring anything and are questionable as to why they were even chosen. Cutthroat they could have made a whole team with the fillers. 

They were trying to give us "new people" which everyone constantly asks for.   They had to determine which FM2 people that wanted to have continue with the franchise so they ran with 7.   Only Luke didn't add anything but he did make a final.   Mandi at least had the Chet storyline.  Brandon, Cara & Laurel had major stories.   Theresa and Vinny were relevant to some degree.  I think everyone on the blue team was relevant aside from Derek/Emilee.   Dan Walsh and JD were relatively quiet.  Shauvon made her 2-3 episodes count (fought with Laurel, quit, picked the teams, etc).  Ayiiia hooked up with Melinda so she at least gave us that lol.  The red team was annoying but they all pretty much added to the show.  I don't think it was as bad as you're making it out to be.

I thought everyone loved Cutthroat :O

Chicken_breast wrote:

gamer73 wrote:I thought Cutthroat was garbage tbh. I remember looking at the cast numerous times ****** at how awful it was. 

Camilia was good on Cutthroat and then she became that monster.

She was trash on Cutthroat too.

I remember wondering who tf this ***** was & why was she cast when they had so many others to choose from. Im still wondering the same thing 8 years later......

I remember wondering who tf this ***** was & why was she cast when they had so many others to choose from. Im still wondering the same thing 8 years later......

They should have used Jonna or Brittni instead of Camila on Cutthroat.   That definitely would have helped the show long term.  I would have said Briana or Kimberly but I think Briana was barred from leaving the US at that time and Kimberly had definitely quit.  Aneesa would have even been a solid addition.  Actually, Aneesa on that season might have drastically changed future seasons

They should have used Jonna or Brittni instead of Camila on Cutthroat.   That definitely would have helped the show long term.  I would have said Briana or Kimberly but I think Briana was barred from leaving the US at that time and Kimberly had definitely quit.  Aneesa would have even been a solid addition.  Actually, Aneesa on that season might have drastically changed future seasons

I love both Jonna and Brittni but i dont see how having them on Cutthroat helps the show longterm. I hate Camila as much as the next person but she was still a fan favourite pre-Dirty 30 and even though it was the same shit every season, the casuals still loved the 'camilinator'.

kvm1977 wrote:

They should have used Jonna or Brittni instead of Camila on Cutthroat.   That definitely would have helped the show long term.  I would have said Briana or Kimberly but I think Briana was barred from leaving the US at that time and Kimberly had definitely quit.  Aneesa would have even been a solid addition.  Actually, Aneesa on that season might have drastically changed future seasons

I love both Jonna and Brittni but i dont see how having them on Cutthroat helps the show longterm. I hate Camila as much as the next person but she was still a fan favourite pre-Dirty 30 and even though it was the same shit every season, the casuals still loved the 'camilinator'.

We wouldn't have to put up with that *****'s bullshit for a dozen seasons afterwards. 

InterFan wrote:

kvm1977 wrote:They should have used Jonna or Brittni instead of Camila on Cutthroat.   That definitely would have helped the show long term.  I would have said Briana or Kimberly but I think Briana was barred from leaving the US at that time and Kimberly had definitely quit.  Aneesa would have even been a solid addition.  Actually, Aneesa on that season might have drastically changed future seasons

I love both Jonna and Brittni but i dont see how having them on Cutthroat helps the show longterm. I hate Camila as much as the next person but she was still a fan favourite pre-Dirty 30 and even though it was the same shit every season, the casuals still loved the 'camilinator'.

We wouldn't have to put up with that *****'s bullshit for a dozen seasons afterwards. 

I thought everyone loved Cutthroat :O

Only people with no taste dislike it. Kiss 2

Who called Dan Walsh filler?

InterFan wrote:

kvm1977 wrote:They should have used Jonna or Brittni instead of Camila on Cutthroat.   That definitely would have helped the show long term.  I would have said Briana or Kimberly but I think Briana was barred from leaving the US at that time and Kimberly had definitely quit.  Aneesa would have even been a solid addition.  Actually, Aneesa on that season might have drastically changed future seasons

I love both Jonna and Brittni but i dont see how having them on Cutthroat helps the show longterm. I hate Camila as much as the next person but she was still a fan favourite pre-Dirty 30 and even though it was the same shit every season, the casuals still loved the 'camilinator'.

We wouldn't have to put up with that *****'s bullshit for a dozen seasons afterwards. 

Now read the next sentence after the bolded.

I didn't dislike Cutthroat so to speak, but I **** sure wasn't watching it like that lol. During the time Cutthroat was airing was when I Love Money 4 rose from the grave & that was getting ALL of my attention. Plus at the time I was fed up with The Challenge in general (skipped out on most of FM2 & was highly annoyed by The Ruins) & as we all know, ILM was simply the better show.

BMP owes their lives to that evil ****** Ryan Jenkins.

Brittini sadly didn't want to do anymore shows after Duel 2; I'm guessing she simply didn't want to be known as a "reality TV girl" because she's said she enjoyed Duel 2.

Trash's spot had Ashley L. or even Callie's name all over it.

Does anyone kere know how to watch the old challenge dailies? I tried using the web.archive.org method but the videos keep erroring out.

Debut Album wrote:

InterFan wrote:

kvm1977 wrote:They should have used Jonna or Brittni instead of Camila on Cutthroat.   That definitely would have helped the show long term.  I would have said Briana or Kimberly but I think Briana was barred from leaving the US at that time and Kimberly had definitely quit.  Aneesa would have even been a solid addition.  Actually, Aneesa on that season might have drastically changed future seasons

I love both Jonna and Brittni but i dont see how having them on Cutthroat helps the show longterm. I hate Camila as much as the next person but she was still a fan favourite pre-Dirty 30 and even though it was the same shit every season, the casuals still loved the 'camilinator'.

We wouldn't have to put up with that *****'s bullshit for a dozen seasons afterwards. 

Now read the next sentence after the bolded.

I did and I don't give a shit. That ***** is a total shit stain on this show and she never should've been on it. I don't care how much of a Fan favorite she is.

Cutthroat was one of the better ones of that time period.

Cutthroat was a decent season but I agree it still could have been better cast. Take Camila/Vinny/Easy/Luke and some other pointless cast members from that season and replace them with Ashley L, KellyAnne, Hollywood people and it would have been so much better. 

I didn't dislike Cutthroat so to speak, but I **** sure wasn't watching it like that lol. During the time Cutthroat was airing was when I Love Money 4 rose from the grave & that was getting ALL of my attention. Plus at the time I was fed up with The Challenge in general (skipped out on most of FM2 & was highly annoyed by The Ruins) & as we all know, ILM was simply the better show.BMP owes their lives to that evil ****** Ryan Jenkins.

Same. Season 4 of ILM >>>> Cutthroat. 

Camila will always be one of the worst things about the show period.

It sucks Greg/Will/Ashley L/Ashlee Feldman in particular never got a shot. I was really wanting all 4 of them on the challenge. 

Do you guys have anyone you are shocked was never used for The Challenge or stopped getting called by production? I'm shocked Violetta has never been cast when I assumed she was production's new version of Svetlana. Then there is Averey who was being groomed to be the next IT girl after Nany and then they just seemed like they quit caring about her. I don't like Dylan snd Dione but I was also sure they were cast just to be on The Challenge but that never happened either.

Then you have people like CeeJai and Dean who come from athletic backgrounds but I knew they wasn't going to call. ☕

Then you have people like CeeJai and Dean who come from athletic backgrounds but I knew they wasn't going to call. ☕

You have to admit Dean was wack on his RW season. Not surprised he wasn't called. I honestly think they just don't **** with GBOGH except for Kailah who was the "hot" girl of the season. 

Then you have people like CeeJai and Dean who come from athletic backgrounds but I knew they wasn't going to call. ☕

Dean isnt surprising lol. Ceejai definitely is though and is a huge loss on their own part.

You have to admit Dean was wack on his RW season. Not surprised he wasn't called. I honestly think they just don't **** with GBOGH except for Kailah who was the "hot" girl of the season. 

I disliked Dean but I was sure they would try to replace Leroy at some point and Dean seemed to fit the description so I was shocked they didn't use him. 

One that always shocked me that never got on a challenge was Patrick from Road Rules X-Treme...Although he probably doesn't fit the question given he never came on due to his own accord but he was one of the MAIN ones from that season I was expecting on a challenge. 

Mary-Beth was one I was surprised about too.

Sarah From Philly as well...**** It. I'll make a list.

Ashley(DC)/Bronne/Dione/Dylan/Mike(Bad Blood)/Greg/Will(Hollywood)/Cara(Chicago)/Ivory/Mike..and there's some people I know I'm forgetting but those are ones that come to mind.

Pages