The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

16756 posts / 0 new
Last post
The Challenge: The Duel 3 Instead of Rivals happening for Season 21, there would be a Duel 3 with the same cast. To make the cast the same size as The Duel 2 (13 of each ***) I am taking out Adam R and Katelynn. Guys: Adam Brandon CT Davis Evan Johnny Kenny Leroy Nehemiah Ty Tyler Tyrie Wes Girls: Aneesa Camila Cara Maria Evelyn Jasmine Jenn Jonna Laurel Mandi Paula Robin Sarah Theresa Duel Selection 1: CT & Aneesa, Adam, Jenn, Kenny, Paula, Johnny, Sarah, Evan, Laurel, Leroy, Jasmine, Tyrie, Jonna, Tyler, Mandi, Brandon, Cara Maria, Nehemiah, Theresa, Ty, Camila, Davis, Evelyn Left for the Duel: Wes and Robin Picked for the Duel: Davis and Paula The Duel: Guys: Winner: Wes Eliminated: Davis Girls: Winner: Paula Eliminated: Robin Duel Selection 2: CT & Evelyn, Leroy, Jonna, Tyler, Paula, Johnny, Jenn, Kenny, Laurel, Evan, Sarah, Adam, Aneesa, Wes, Mandi, Brandon, Theresa, Ty, Camila, Nehemiah, Cara Maria Left for the Duel: Tyrie and Jasmine Picked for the Duel: Kenny and Theresa The Duel: Guys: Winner: Kenny Eliminated: Tyrie Girls: Winner: Theresa Eliminated: Jasmine Duel Selection 3: Johnny & Paula, Kenny, Jenn, Evan, Laurel, Adam, Sarah, Leroy, Aneesa, Nehemiah, Jonna, Wes, Evelyn, Brandon, Cara Maria, CT, Mandi, Tyler, Theresa Left for the Duel: Ty and Camila Picked for the Duel: Brandon and Jonna The Duel: Guys: Winner: Ty Eliminated: Brandon Girls: Winner: Jonna Eliminated: Camila Duel Selection 4: Adam & Laurel, Kenny, Paula, Evan, Jenn, Johnny, Sarah, Tyler, Aneesa, Ty, Jonna, Leroy, Mandi, CT, Cara Maria, Wes, Evelyn Left for the Duel: Nehemiah and Theresa Picked for the Duel: Kenny and Mandi The Duel: Guys: Winner: Kenny Eliminated: Nehemiah Girls: Winner: Theresa Eliminated: Mandi Duel Selection 5: CT & Laurel, Adam, Aneesa, Johnny, Paula, Tyler, Sarah, Kenny, Jenn, Evan, Jonna, Leroy, Evelyn, Wes, Theresa Left for the Duel: Ty and Cara Maria Picked for the Duel: Leroy and Jonna The Duel: Guys: Winner: Leroy Eliminated: Ty Girls: Winner: Cara Maria Eliminated: Jonna Duel Selection 6: Wes & Evelyn, Leroy, Aneesa, Tyler, Paula, Johnny, Jenn, Adam, Laurel, Kenny, Sarah, CT, Cara Maria Left for the Duel: Evan and Theresa Picked for the Duel: CT and Laurel The Duel: Guys: Winner: CT Eliminated: Evan Girls: Winner: Laurel Eliminated: Theresa Duel Selection 7: Kenny & Evelyn, Leroy, Laurel, CT, Cara Maria, Wes, Aneesa, Tyler, Paula, Johnny, Jenn Left for the Duel: Adam and Sarah Picked for the Duel: Wes and Cara Maria The Duel: Guys: Winner: Wes Eliminated: Adam Girls: Winner: Cara Maria Eliminated: Sarah Duel Selection 8: Leroy & Laurel, CT, Aneesa, Wes, Evelyn, Kenny, Jenn, Johnny, Paula Left for the Duel: Tyler and Cara Maria Picked for the Duel: CT and Aneesa The Duel: Guys: Winner: CT Eliminated: Tyler Girls: Winner: Aneesa Eliminated: Cara Maria Duel Selection 9: Johnny & Paula, Kenny, Jenn, Leroy, Laurel, CT, Evelyn Left for the Duel: Wes and Aneesa Picked for the Duel: Leroy and Laurel The Duel: Guys: Winner: Wes Eliminated: Leroy Girls: Winner: Laurel Eliminated: Aneesa Final Duel Selection: Left for the Duel: CT & Laurel Picked for the Duel: Johnny & Evelyn The Duel: Guys: Winner: CT Eliminated: Johnny Girls: Winner: Laurel Eliminated: Evelyn Final Challenge: Winners: CT & Laurel 2nd: Kenny & Paula 3rd: Wes & Jenn
Good thing you took her out, Katelyn would be a waste of a spot for a duel. And I doubt Jonna could beat Camilla unless its a puzzle
Rivals 3 Guys: Knight/Frank Leroy/Wes CT/Johnny Chet/CJ Zach/Alton Ty/Adam Dustin/Mike Girls: Averey/Nia Marie/Sam Theresa/Jemmye Laurel/Paula Jenn/Cara Maria Nany/Diem Cooke/Heather Comment who you think would win, I'm curious.
[QUOTE=Squad;387418]Rivals 3 Guys: Knight/Frank [B]Leroy/Wes[/B] [B]CT/Johnny[/B] Chet/CJ [B]Zach/Alton[/B] Ty/Adam Dustin/Mike Girls: Averey/Nia Marie/Sam Theresa/Jemmye [B]Laurel/Paula[/B] Jenn/Cara Maria [B]Nany/Diem[/B] [B]Cooke/Heather[/B] Comment who you think would win, I'm curious.[/QUOTE] Bolded the final 3.. CT/Johnny and Laurel/Paula are my picks
[QUOTE=challenge13;387420]Bolded the final 3.. CT/Johnny and Laurel/Paula are my picks[/QUOTE] Actually I would say 3rd place: Leroy & Wes and Cooke & Heather 2nd place: CT & Johnny and Diem & Nany 1st place: Alton & Zach and Laurel & Paula for the WIN!
If Alton was in his old shape then I'd say he would win but Alton is half the competitor he used to be
The Ruins 2 Location New Zealand [COLOR="#FF0000"]Champions[/COLOR] Paula Katie Emily Ashley K Sam Janelle Emily Derrick Frank Dunbar CT Nehemiah Wes Zach [COLOR="#0000FF"]Challengers[/COLOR] Averey Kelly Anne Sarah Laurel Cooke Arielle Nany Scott Dustin Leroy Jordan Jay Cohutta Pete
[QUOTE=Challenge 17;387409]Good thing you took her out, Katelyn would be a waste of a spot for a duel. And I doubt Jonna could beat Camilla unless its a puzzle[/QUOTE] Or that Cara could beat Sarah or that Laurel could beat Evelyn.
Also Adam K winning a mission come on thats likely
[QUOTE=Challenge 17;387409]Good thing you took her out, Katelyn would be a waste of a spot for a duel. And I doubt Jonna could beat Camilla unless its a puzzle[/QUOTE] Yeah, and if I did leave her in there I would have just had her be the first girl eliminated. I was coming up with my own elimination rounds and the one that I had Jonna vs. Camila in was a puzzle. I came up with some of my own. Here the are: Bridge Builder- a carbon copy of Bridge It from the Island. Its a puzzle race. Both competitors start with an empty bridge and they need to find the pieces that fit into the corresponding spot to build their bridge to get across to the platform that has a flag. First person to get their flag wins. Played by Wes vs. Davis and Paula vs. Robin. Knock Off- a 10x10 platform suspended 5 feet in the air where you have to knock your opponent off 3 times to win. Played by Kenny vs. Tyrie and Theresa vs. Jasmine. Fix It- another puzzle type game where there is water running from a spout and you have to find the right pieces so that the water can run through the tubes to put out their opponents fire. First person to do this wins. Played by: Ty vs. Brandon and Jonna vs. Camila. Pass Me- another physical game similar to Hall Brawl, Corner Ball, and Balls In. One person has a ball and must get past the person playing defense and score. If they are tackled or if they fumble its dead ball. First person to score 3 times wins. Played by Kenny vs. Nehemiah and Theresa vs. Mandi. Tangled- Each player has a bundle of ropes that they must untie. Played by: Leroy vs. Ty and Cara Maria vs. Jonna. Was kinda desperate for ideas on this one. Under and Over- a structure built where each player has a rope attached to them and they must go under and over walls to get to the end. Played by: CT vs. Evan and Laurel vs. Theresa. Speed- there are two tredmills suspended 5 feet over a pool of water. TJ asks the players a series of trivia questions ranging from challenge trivia, geography, sports, etc. For every question they get wrong their tredmill speeds up. The first person to fall into the water loses. Played by: Wes vs. Adam and Cara Maria vs. Sarah. Ringer- pretty much exactly like X Battle, Rag Doll, or Ring Wrestle. First person to rip the ring from their opponents hand wins. Played by: CT vs. Tyler and Aneesa vs. Cara Maria. Break Out- there are two glass cases filled with water. There is a plexy glass screen with four pad locks locking the screen into place. There is a opening at the top of the tank where four keys and a metal ring are, a key opens each pad lock but it is unknown to the players which key opens which lock. Once a player unlocks all of the locks they must lift the plexy glass screen out from the tank, retrieve the metal ring and smash their way out of the water tank. First player to do so wins. Played by: Wes vs. Leroy and Laurel vs. Aneesa. Labyrinth- there is maze where two players start at the opposite end. The two players must find their way through the maze where they could run into each other. First person to get through the maze and exit out of their opponents entrance wins. Played by: CT vs. Johnny and Laurel vs. Evelyn.
So you think that cara maria could beat Sarah in trivia
[QUOTE=El Scorcho;387452]Tangled- Each player has a bundle of ropes that they must untie. Played by: Leroy vs. Ty and Cara Maria vs. Jonna. Was kinda desperate for ideas on this one.[/QUOTE] The ironic thing is, Jonna actually did this exact same mission on Endurance and won that mission.
[QUOTE=Youssarian;387458]The ironic thing is, Jonna actually did this exact same mission on Endurance and won that mission.[/QUOTE] Yeah, I can't see Jonna losing that to Cara either because Cara's would freak out
The gauntlet 4 Location South Africa [COLOR="#FF0000"]Veterans[/COLOR] Paula Sarah Laurel Mandi Casey Jasmine Nany Coral Johnny Wes CT Chet Derrick Dunbar Brandon Zach [COLOR="#0000FF"]Rookies[/COLOR] Averey Nia Marie Cooke Baya Jamie Sydney Jenna Pete Noor Corey Jordan Scott Johnny R Robb Mike M
[QUOTE=Fresh Meat;387445]Or that Cara could beat Sarah or that Laurel could beat Evelyn.[/QUOTE] Well if you read my comment below of the elimination rounds they face each other in. Cara Maria beat Sarah in a trivia/endurance elimination round that is anyone's game and Laurel beat Evelyn in a physical elimination round. And idk if you notice but Laurel has about 5 inches and probably 15-20 lbs on Evelyn. So it seems pretty plausible to me.
[QUOTE=Challenge 17;387455]So you think that cara maria could beat Sarah in trivia[/QUOTE] Well trivia is anyone's game. Depends on the luck of the questions.
Evelyn also kicked laurels *** in wrestling on FM2, a season Evelyn barely trained for
A random Duel 3 I came up with. [COLOR="#EE82EE"]Aneesa Ferreira (Real World: Chicago) Ashlee Feldman (Real World: New Orleans 2010) Camila Nakagawa (Spring Break Challenge) Carley Johnson (Fresh Meat 2) Coral Smith (Real World: Back to New York) Emily Schromm (Real World: DC) KellyAnne Judd (Real World: Sydney) Laurel Stuckey (Fresh Meat 2) Nia Moore (Real World: Portland) Rachel Robinson (Road Rules: Campus Crawl) Ruthie Alcaide (Real World: Hawaii) Sarah Rice (Real World: Brooklyn) Susie Meister (Road Rules: Down Under)[/COLOR] [COLOR="#0000FF"]CJ Koegel (Real World: Cancun) Darrell Taylor (Road Rules: Campus Crawl) Derrick Kosinski (Road Rules: X-Treme) Dustin Zito (Real World: Las Vegas 2011) Frank Sweeney (Real World: San Diego 2011) Johnny Devenanzio (Real World: Key West) Jordan Wiseley (Real World: Portland) Leroy Garrett (Real World: Las Vegas 2011) Michael Manning (Real World: DC) Noor Jehangir (Fresh Meat 2) Tyler Duckworth (Real World: Key West) Wes Bergmann (Real World: Austin) Zach Nichols (Real World: San Diego 2011)[/COLOR]
Battle of the Seasons 3. Not the most competitive cast, but I think it's very varied with a lot of interesting people we haven't seen in a while. [center][b]Road Rules Campus Crawl:[/b] [i]Shane Landrum & Rachel Robinson[/i] [b]Real World Las Vegas 2002:[/b] [i]Frank Roessler & Arissa Hill[/i] [b]Real World San Diego 2004:[/b] [i]Brad Fiorenza & Robin Hibbard[/i] [b]Real World Austin[/b] [i]Nehemiah Clark & Lacey Buehler[/i] [b]Real World Key West:[/b] [i]Johnny Devenanzio & Paula Meronek[/i] [b]Real World Sydney:[/b] [i]Cohutta Grindstaff & Ashli Robson[/i] [b]Real World Cancun:[/b] [i]CJ Koegel & Ayiiia Elizarraras[/i] [b]Real World DC:[/b] [i]Michael Manning & Erika Wasilewski[/i] [b]Fresh Meat 2:[/b] [i]Noor Jehangir & Carley Johnson[/i] [b]Real World NOLA 2010:[/b] [i]Preston Roberson-Charles & Ashlee Feldman[/i] [b]Real World Las Vegas 2011:[/b] [i]Dustin Zito & Naomi Defensor[/i] [b]Real World San Diego 2011:[/b] [i]Nate Stodghill & Ashley Kelsey[/i] [b]Real World St. Thomas:[/b] [i]Trey Weatherholtz & LaToya Jackson[/i] [b]Real World Portland:[/b] [i]Jordan Wiseley & Jessica McCain[/i][/center]
[QUOTE=Challenge 17;387485]Evelyn also kicked laurels *** in wrestling on FM2, a season Evelyn barely trained for[/QUOTE] Weren't they drunk? Lol didn't Leroy beat Marlon in some play play wrestling match then got laid out in an actual elimination? I don't think little kiddie stuff matters, they're just playing around. No one's fighting for their life in the game.
Battle of the Sexes 3, if it were filmed in place of the Duel. I tried to make the teams as fair as possible, and ideally it would include (have included? because it's theoretically in the past?) more gender-equal missions. [COLOR=#EE82EE][CENTER][SIZE=4][B]GIRLS[/B][/SIZE] Aneesa Ferreira (Real World: Chicago) Aviv Melmed (Fresh Meat) Beth Stolarczyk (Real World: Los Angeles) Coral Smith (Real World: Back to New York) Diem Brown (Fresh Meat) Evelyn Smith (Fresh Meat) Jillian Zoboroski (Road Rules: X-Treme) Jodi Weatherton (Road Rules: X-Treme) Kendal Sheppard (Road Rules: Campus Crawl) Kina Dean (Road Rules: X-Treme) Linette Gallo (Fresh Meat) Mallory Snyder (Real World: Paris) Paula Meronek (Real World: Key West) Rachel Robinson (Road Rules: Campus Crawl) Ruthie Alcaide (Real World: Hawaii) Sophia Pasquis (Road Rules: The Quest) Svetlana Shusterman (Real World: Key West) Tina Barta (Road Rules: South Pacific)[/CENTER] [/COLOR][CENTER] [COLOR=#0000FF][SIZE=4][B]BOYS[/B][/SIZE] Ace Amerson (Real World: Paris) Adam King (Real World: Paris) Adam Larson (Road Rules: The Quest) Brad Fiorenza (Real World: San Diego) Danny Jamieson (Real World: Austin) Eric Banks (Fresh Meat) Jesse Stark (Fresh Meat) Johnnie McBride (Fresh Meat) Johnny Devenanzio (Real World: Key West) Kefla Hare (Road Rules: Down Under) Kenny Santucci (Fresh Meat) MJ Garrett (Real World: Philadelphia) Nehemiah Clark (Real World: Austin) Randy Barry (Real World: San Diego) Ryan Kehoe (Fresh Meat) Shane Landrum (Road Rules: Campus Crawl) Steven Hill (Real World: Las Vegas) Syrus Yarbrough (Real World: Boston)[/COLOR][/CENTER]
[QUOTE=Youssarian;387491]Battle of the Seasons 3. Not the most competitive cast, but I think it's very varied with a lot of interesting people we haven't seen in a while. [center][b]Road Rules Campus Crawl:[/b] [i]Shane Landrum & Rachel Robinson[/i] [b]Real World Las Vegas 2002:[/b] [i]Frank Roessler & Arissa Hill[/i] [b]Real World San Diego 2004:[/b] [i]Brad Fiorenza & Robin Hibbard[/i] [b]Real World Austin[/b] [i]Nehemiah Clark & Lacey Buehler[/i] [b]Real World Key West:[/b] [i][B]Johnny Devenanzio & Paula Meronek[/B][/i] [b]Real World Sydney:[/b] [i]Cohutta Grindstaff & Ashli Robson[/i] [b]Real World Cancun:[/b] [i]CJ Koegel & Ayiiia Elizarraras[/i] [b]Real World DC:[/b] [i]Michael Manning & Erika Wasilewski[/i] [b]Fresh Meat 2:[/b] [i]Noor Jehangir & Carley Johnson[/i] [b]Real World NOLA 2010:[/b] [i]Preston Roberson-Charles & Ashlee Feldman[/i] [b]Real World Las Vegas 2011:[/b] [i]Dustin Zito & Naomi Defensor[/i] [b]Real World San Diego 2011:[/b] [i]Nate Stodghill & Ashley Kelsey[/i] [b]Real World St. Thomas:[/b] [i]Trey Weatherholtz & LaToya Jackson[/i] [b]Real World Portland:[/b] [i]Jordan Wiseley & Jessica McCain[/i][/center][/QUOTE] You're definitely not referring to Key West then.
[QUOTE=alaskak94;387494]You're definitely not referring to Key West then.[/QUOTE] Yeah, I figured I had to throw Johnny and Paula in there. I don't think they have many allies with a cast like that, though. It'd be interesting to see how they fare.
Johnny & Paula would easily win followed by Shane & Rachel
[QUOTE=TeamLandon;387492]Weren't they drunk? Lol didn't Leroy beat Marlon in some play play wrestling match then got laid out in an actual elimination? I don't think little kiddie stuff matters, they're just playing around. No one's fighting for their life in the game.[/QUOTE] There's a HUGE difference, Marlon was a division one linebacker in college. Do you really think he'd lose something involving tackling? Wrestling wasn't the goal in last chance it was to tackle your opponent and knock them down so they wouldn't ring the bell . Now it would be close between Evelyn and Laurel in a physical elimination but Ev would kill her in a puzzle or endurance
[QUOTE=Challenge 17;387501]There's a HUGE difference, Marlon was a division one linebacker in college. Do you really think he'd lose something involving tackling? Wrestling wasn't the goal in last chance it was to tackle your opponent and knock them down so they wouldn't ring the bell . Now it would be close between Evelyn and Laurel in a physical elimination but Ev would kill her in a puzzle or endurance[/QUOTE] I don't think it'd be close at all in a physical challenge between those two.. Y'all are seriously overrating Evelyn's abilities. Laurel would crush her.
delete
[QUOTE=Youssarian;387493]Battle of the Sexes 3, if it were filmed in place of the Duel. I tried to make the teams as fair as possible, and ideally it would include (have included? because it's theoretically in the past?) more gender-equal missions. [COLOR=#EE82EE][CENTER][SIZE=4][B]GIRLS[/B][/SIZE] Aneesa Ferreira (Real World: Chicago) Aviv Melmed (Fresh Meat) Beth Stolarczyk (Real World: Los Angeles) Coral Smith (Real World: Back to New York) Diem Brown (Fresh Meat) Evelyn Smith (Fresh Meat) Jillian Zoboroski (Road Rules: X-Treme) Jodi Weatherton (Road Rules: X-Treme) Kendal Sheppard (Road Rules: Campus Crawl) Kina Dean (Road Rules: X-Treme) Linette Gallo (Fresh Meat) Mallory Snyder (Real World: Paris) Paula Meronek (Real World: Key West) Rachel Robinson (Road Rules: Campus Crawl) Ruthie Alcaide (Real World: Hawaii) Sophia Pasquis (Road Rules: The Quest) Svetlana Shusterman (Real World: Key West) Tina Barta (Road Rules: South Pacific)[/CENTER] [/COLOR][CENTER] [COLOR=#0000FF][SIZE=4][B]BOYS[/B][/SIZE] Ace Amerson (Real World: Paris) Adam King (Real World: Paris) Adam Larson (Road Rules: The Quest) Brad Fiorenza (Real World: San Diego) Danny Jamieson (Real World: Austin) Eric Banks (Fresh Meat) Jesse Stark (Fresh Meat) Johnnie McBride (Fresh Meat) Johnny Devenanzio (Real World: Key West) Kefla Hare (Road Rules: Down Under) Kenny Santucci (Fresh Meat) MJ Garrett (Real World: Philadelphia) Nehemiah Clark (Real World: Austin) Randy Barry (Real World: San Diego) Ryan Kehoe (Fresh Meat) Shane Landrum (Road Rules: Campus Crawl) Steven Hill (Real World: Las Vegas) Syrus Yarbrough (Real World: Boston)[/COLOR][/CENTER][/QUOTE] Cool cast. The girls cast is stacked... For the guys I can see the F3 as Brad, Kenny and Johnny. The girls F3 is tougher... lots of good competitors. If I had to pick 3 I'd choose Evelyn, Coral and Rachel
Pretty weak guys cast.
The Legends guys would be too much to handle. They would dominate

Pages