The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

15698 posts / 0 new
Last post

Someone do a modern day, realistic-ish Good Guys vs. Bad *****

Someone do a modern day, realistic-ish Good Guys vs. Bad *****

I'll try it out tomorrow.

Good Guys vs Bad ***** 2022

 

Good Guys

 

Yes Duffy

Theo Campbell

Nelson Thomas

Cory Wharton

Tony Raines

Darrell Taylor

Tyler Crispen (BB20)

Anthony Douglas (BBCAN7)

 

KellyAnne Judd

Jonna Mannion

Georgia Harrison

Amber Borzotra

Michele Fitzgerald

Michaela Bradshaw

Kathryn Dunn (BB21)

Nina Twine (Survivor AUS 9)

 

Bad *****

 

Johnny Devanienzo

Wes Bergmann

Jordan Wisely

Paulie Califiorie

Turbo

Shane Landrum

Brett Robinson (BB20)

Rohan Kapoor (BBCAN9)

 

Kailah Casillas

Ashley Mitchell

Amanda Garcia

Cara Maria Sorbello

Esther Agunbiade

Berna Canbeldek

Liana Wallace (Survivor 41)

Tori Meehan (Survivor 42'

 

Alternates

 

Jay Starrett

Nia Moore

Fessy Shafatt

Sylvia Elsrode

having multiple people kicked out for violence on the Good Guys? a choice

(Cory, Darrell, Tony, Nelson, Kat)

Cory Nelson and Tony as good guys made me laugh.  Tony is one of the worst humans to be on the show. It's true that's the fake image all but Nelson pretend is true now but then Jordan should be a good guy for being friends with Nia. 

Tony one of the worse??? Ok lol

Tony one of the worse??? Ok lol

Displayed violence against men and women.  Was blatantly sexist. Cheated multiple times. Easily one of the worst.  There isn't even an argument against it. 

My take on a modern-day realistic THE CHALLENGE: THE INFERNO 4.

GOOD GUYS team

  • Ashley Cain (EOTB UK)
  • Gabo Szabó (Warsaw Shore)
  • Jay Starrett (Survivor)
  • Leroy Garrett (RW: Las Vegas)
  • Maddison McKibbin (TheAmazingRace 32)
  • Max Gentile (AYTO? 8 )
  • Nam Vo (Ultimate Beastmaster)
  • Turbo Çamkıran (Survivor Turkey)
  • Amber Borzotra (Big Brother)
  • Chanelle Howell (Survivor 42)
  • Da'Vonne Rogers (Big Brother)
  • Jenny West (Survival of the fittest)
  • KellyAnne Judd (RW: Sydney)
  • Michaela Bradshaw (Survivor)
  • Michele Fitzgerald (Survivor)
  • Nany Gonzalez (RW: Las Vegas)
  • BAD ***** team

  • Adam Pike (Big Brother Canada)
  • Derek Frazier (Big Brother 23)
  • Devin Walker-Molaghan (AYTO? 3)
  • Fessy Shafaat (Big Brother)
  • Johnny Bananas (RW: Key West)
  • Nehemiah Clark (RW: Austin)
  • Ray Gantt (Love Island)
  • Rogan O'Connor (EOTB UK)
  • Amanda Garcia (AYTO?3)
  • Esther Agunbiade (Big Brother Nigeria)
  • Jemmye Carroll (RW: New Orleans)
  • Kayleigh Morris (EOTB UK)
  • Nurys Mateo (AYTO?6)
  • Sylvia Elsrode (RW: Skeletons)
  • Tori Deal (AYTO?4)
  • Tori Meeham (Survivor 42)
  • Who are the alts for when Nam gets DQed during episode 1?

    My take on a modern-day realistic THE CHALLENGE: THE INFERNO 4.

    GOOD GUYS team

  • Ashley Cain (EOTB UK)
  • Gabo Szabó (Warsaw Shore)
  • Jay Starrett (Survivor)
  • Leroy Garrett (RW: Las Vegas)
  • Maddison McKibbin (TheAmazingRace 32)
  • Max Gentile (AYTO? 8 )
  • Nam Vo (Ultimate Beastmaster)
  • Turbo Çamkıran (Survivor Turkey)
  • Amber Borzotra (Big Brother)
  • Chanelle Howell (Survivor 42)
  • Da'Vonne Rogers (Big Brother)
  • Jenny West (Survival of the fittest)
  • KellyAnne Judd (RW: Sydney)
  • Michaela Bradshaw (Survivor)
  • Michele Fitzgerald (Survivor)
  • Nany Gonzalez (RW: Las Vegas)
  • BAD ***** team

  • Adam Pike (Big Brother Canada)
  • Derek Frazier (Big Brother 23)
  • Devin Walker-Molaghan (AYTO? 3)
  • Fessy Shafaat (Big Brother)
  • Johnny Bananas (RW: Key West)
  • Nehemiah Clark (RW: Austin)
  • Ray Gantt (Love Island)
  • Rogan O'Connor (EOTB UK)
  • Amanda Garcia (AYTO?3)
  • Esther Agunbiade (Big Brother Nigeria)
  • Jemmye Carroll (RW: New Orleans)
  • Kayleigh Morris (EOTB UK)
  • Nurys Mateo (AYTO?6)
  • Sylvia Elsrode (RW: Skeletons)
  • Tori Deal (AYTO?4)
  • Tori Meeham (Survivor 42)
  • Derek the new Josh then? Lol

    I put Cory and Tony as good guys cause they're parents now. Not the best reasoning but it's what I went with

    Presence, gameplay, and whether they are depicted as mean spirited or generally positive is the main criteria that matters. It's why people like Mike, Brad, Robin, and Julie were considered Good Guys. None of them were actively mean or confrontational people.

    Think of the Bad *** team on the Inferno 2. Everyone on that team was either mean spirited, confrontational, or played the game a certain way. Even the less mean people like Derrick and Tonya were always side eyed by many due to their unpredictable natures

    people like Tony, Cory and even Nelson, despite their questionable pasts, these days are depicted as being benevolent and almost wholesome? I think they might be right in putting them on the Good Guys based on Inferno 2 standards.

    I remember back in 2004 or whenever the Inferno 2 was casting, MTV.com made a poll of every single cast member in RW and RR history and you had to vote whether they were 'Naughty' or 'Nice'. Maybe that's what they'll need to do again if they ever repeat this theme lol, which I hope they do because it was one of my favorites.

    Yes if I was casting this in the trilogy era then I would have put them on bad ***** team

    Women:

    Amanda Bergmann (Wes's Wife)

    ​​​​Esther Agunbiade (BBN4)
    Michaela Bradshaw (Survivor 33)
    Olivia Kaiser (Love Island 3)
    Priscilla Anyabu (Love Island UK)
    Tamara Alfaro (Turbo's Girlfriend)
    Trina Njoroge (Love Island 3)

    Men:

    Atteh "Sir Dee" Tioluwa (BBN4)

    Charlie Lynch (Love Island 3)
    Chauncey Palmer (Amber's Boyfriend)
    Corey Lay (12 Dates of Christmas)
    Faysal "Fessy" Shafaat (BB20)
    Horacio Gutierrez Jr (Exalton)
    Jakk Maddox (EOTB: Peak of Love)
    Jay Starrett (Survivor 33)
    Kelechi "Kelz" **** (THTH)
    Ray Reinhardt (Amanda's Baby Daddy)
    Turabi "Turbo" Camkiran (Survivor Turkey)

    Twists:

    Darrell Taylor (RR11)

    Teams:

    1. Amanda B & Wes
    2. Amanda G & Ray
    3. Amber & Chauncey
    4. Cara Maria & Paulie
    5. Esther & Sir Dee
    6. Kailah & Sam
    7. Laurel & Jakk
    8. Michaela & Corey
    9. Michele & Jay
    10. Moriah & Fessy
    11. Nia & Jordan (TWIST)
    12. Nurys & Nelson
    13. Olivia & Horacio
    14. Priscilla & Kelz
    15. Tamara & Turbo
    16. Trina & Charlie
    17. Veronica & Darrell (TWIST)

     

    love & hate your cast

    The Challenge All Stars 4 (Most Underrated) 

    Guys

    Pete, Noor, CJ, Marlon, Ty, Frank S, Jamie Murray, Johnny Reilly, Shane Landrum, Jamie Banks, Leroy, Dustin

    Girls

    Janelle, Julie, Brittini, Jenn G, Theresa, Jill Z, Tori Hall, Jenna, Svetlana, Mandi, Coral, Cooke

     

    The Challenge All Stars 4 (Most Underrated) 

    Guys

    Pete, Noor, CJ, Marlon, Ty, Frank S, Jamie Murray, Johnny Reilly, Shane Landrum, Jamie Banks, Leroy, Dustin

    Girls

    Janelle, Julie, Brittini, Jenn G, Theresa, Jill Z, Tori Hall, Jenna, Svetlana, Mandi, Coral, Cooke

    It's not awful but Jenna's pregnant, Jamie Banks is a no for me, Svetlana still can't find her phone and I wish there were more true vets.

    Like Lori or Tara would be great additions.  Even 2x champ Roni.

    Love and War

    This is a popular challenge idea that always floats around. I did do it before myself but this time instead of it just being a team of Exes vs Couples, I made the Love team pairs of couples and close friends/Allies (to a degree) and the war team is composed of exes and rivals/enemies. Tried to make a cast with a good dynamic and loads of drama. Somewhat realistic as well (except for some who may have sort of retired)

    Rules: Start the game with both teams facing off against eachother for a few challenges. You stay with your partner the entire challenge. Winning team is safe from elimination. Losing team then votes in one pair from their team into elimination. Winning team votes in the second pair from the losing team to face off. Loser goes home, winner stays. After a few challenges break up the teams and make it pairs only for the remainder of the game. Winning pair of the challenge is safe from elimination and gets to send a team into elimination. That team then gets to choose the team they want to face off against. Final 3 teams will face off in the final challenge for $500,000. Only 1st place gets money. 

    War Team

    Shane Landrum/Da’Vonne Rogers (Rivals)

    Johnny Bananas /Morgan Willett (Exes)

    Jordan Wiseley/Tori Deal (Exes)

    Fessy Shafaat/Amanda Garcia (Exes)

    Emanuel Neagu/Michele Fitzgerald (Exes)

    Nelson Thomas/Ashley Mitchell (Exes)

    Jay Starrett/Michaela Bradshaw (Rivals)

    Wes Bergmann/Laurel Stucky (Rivals)

    Brad Fiorenza/Marie Roda (Rivals)

    Love Team

    Paulie Calafiore/Cara Maria Sorbello (Dating)

    Zach Nichols/Jenna Nichols (Married)

    Leroy Garrett/Kam Williams (Engaged)

    Sam Bird/Kailah Casillas (Married)

    CT Tamburello/Emy Alupei (Allies)

    Josh Martinez/Nany Gonzalez (Besties)

    Swaggy Williams/Bayleigh Dayton (Married)

    Tony Raines/Nicole Zanatta (Allies)

    Rogan O’Connor/Melissa Reeves (Allies)

    Thoughts??

     

    Going back to Tony and Nelson, you can def make a case (and it would be BS) from a productions stand point that they would justify putting them as Good Guys. Same with CT.

    Going back to Tony and Nelson, you can def make a case (and it would be BS) from a productions stand point that they would justify putting them as Good Guys. Same with CT.

    I want to hear the case for Tony...

     

    Going back to Tony and Nelson, you can def make a case (and it would be BS) from a productions stand point that they would justify putting them as Good Guys. Same with CT.

    I want to hear the case for Tony...

    it'll all depend on how they stack that side too, but there's a lot more recent guys that lesson Ton'ys bad asses-ness. They could easily sell the Tony Time redemption from Vendettas and Final Reckoning. Nelson has his noble deeds to Cory that they could spin. It wouldn't make sense given history but if we're being realistic then none of the decisions production makes a lot of sense and they have recency bias. 

    Going back to Tony and Nelson, you can def make a case (and it would be BS) from a productions stand point that they would justify putting them as Good Guys. Same with CT.

    I want to hear the case for Tony...

    it'll all depend on how they stack that side too, but there's a lot more recent guys that lesson Ton'ys bad asses-ness. They could easily sell the Tony Time redemption from Vendettas and Final Reckoning. Nelson has his noble deeds to Cory that they could spin. It wouldn't make sense given history but if we're being realistic then none of the decisions production makes a lot of sense and they have recency bias. 

    Tony wasn't a good guy on Vendettas or FR.  He treated women horribly.  He constantly lied and used people throughout the season.  I get the Nelson argument but they have nothing for Tony other than him saying he wants to be a better man.  Anything is possible--Brad was somehow a good guy as was John but Tony would be the biggest reach ever IMO.  Tony walking away with no money on Vendettas is still the best part of that chaotic nightmare of a season.

    If Julie can be considered a Good Guy then anybody can

    they def love portraying Tony as being some type of hometown hero when in reality he's just a buffoon. They've been trying to de-scümbag him ever since he became a father 

    Love and War

    This is a popular challenge idea that always floats around. I did do it before myself but this time instead of it just being a team of Exes vs Couples, I made the Love team pairs of couples and close friends/Allies (to a degree) and the war team is composed of exes and rivals/enemies. Tried to make a cast with a good dynamic and loads of drama. Somewhat realistic as well (except for some who may have sort of retired)

    Rules: Start the game with both teams facing off against eachother for a few challenges. You stay with your partner the entire challenge. Winning team is safe from elimination. Losing team then votes in one pair from their team into elimination. Winning team votes in the second pair from the losing team to face off. Loser goes home, winner stays. After a few challenges break up the teams and make it pairs only for the remainder of the game. Winning pair of the challenge is safe from elimination and gets to send a team into elimination. That team then gets to choose the team they want to face off against. Final 3 teams will face off in the final challenge for $500,000. Only 1st place gets money. 

    War Team

    Shane Landrum/Da’Vonne Rogers (Rivals)

    Johnny Bananas /Morgan Willett (Exes)

    Jordan Wiseley/Tori Deal (Exes)

    Fessy Shafaat/Amanda Garcia (Exes)

    Emanuel Neagu/Michele Fitzgerald (Exes)

    Nelson Thomas/Ashley Mitchell (Exes)

    Jay Starrett/Michaela Bradshaw (Rivals)

    Wes Bergmann/Laurel Stucky (Rivals)

    Brad Fiorenza/Marie Roda (Rivals)

    Love Team

    Paulie Calafiore/Cara Maria Sorbello (Dating)

    Zach Nichols/Jenna Nichols (Married)

    Leroy Garrett/Kam Williams (Engaged)

    Sam Bird/Kailah Casillas (Married)

    CT Tamburello/Emy Alupei (Allies)

    Josh Martinez/Nany Gonzalez (Besties)

    Swaggy Williams/Bayleigh Dayton (Married)

    Tony Raines/Nicole Zanatta (Allies)

    Rogan O’Connor/Melissa Reeves (Allies)

    Thoughts??

     

    love this idea but what's the point of having them stick in pairs when it's a 2-team season? like I don't want Da'Vonne going home if Shane loses yet another elimination...

    Pages