The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

I know, I just wrote those 3 girls because of their athletic background. I was going to put Camila, Sarah and Cara Maria. But I feel like they need to take a break. I feel like every guy elimination round would be good, if they have a guy cast like this. Same with the girls maybe except a couple, but I feel like the 6 first time rookies would hold their own.

[url=http://vevmo.com/vbimghost.php?do=displayimg&imgid=15109][img]http://vevmo.com/imagehosting/554350e0a8666406c.jpg[/img][/url] Yeah I had a lot of time on my hand today...;) 8 male and female competitors each.... Can you find them?;)

I'd love to see a Gauntlet IV. Although that may not happen, I still think we are likely to see the Veterans and Rookies lineup at some point. My ideal (yet realistic) lineup for a near future Veterans [U]GIRLS[/U] [B]Emily Schromm (RW: DC) Cara Maria Sorbello (Fresh Meat II) Mandi Moyer (Fresh Meat II) Camila Nakagawa (Spring Break) Coral Smith (RW: B2NY) Trishelle Cannatella (RW: Las Vegas) Elka Walker (RW: Boston)[/B], perhaps the only one on this list that would be iffy. She hasn't done one of these in eight years, but if Trishelle can be lured back, I'm sure our favorite rebellious Catholic can as well. Besides, I'd love to watch Elka, who is one of the strongest girls on both The Gauntlet and BOTS 1 beat Trishelle in an elimination round after Trishelle screwed her over on The Gauntlet due to her relationship with The Miz. Since Coral and Trishelle are apparently friends now, it'd be interesting to see how Coral and Elka would react since they were close as well. [B]KellyAnne Judd (RW: Sydney)[/B] I don't put Sarah Rice on here because she's done 6 in a row; that's a record with Veronica. If Sarah really wants to break this record, I think she's nuts. She needs to be put on a break. [U] MEN[/U] [B]Chet Cannon (RW: Brooklyn)[/B] [B]Wes Bergemann (RW: Austin)[/B] - he needs to put Frank in his place. Enough said. [B]JD Ordonez (RW: Brooklyn) Brandon Nelson (Fresh Meat II) Leroy Garrett (RW: Las Vegas 2011) Cohutta Grindstaff (RW: Sydney) Shane Landrum (RR: Campus Crawl),[/B] possibly a long shot considering the rumors stating that production does not want him back after Viewers' Revenge. However, since Ryan is his ex, it would be interesting to see what kind of drama would ensue if these two were on the same team. [B] Ryan Kehoe (Fresh Meat I) [/B]Rookies [U]GIRLS[/U] [B]Mallory Snyder (RW: Paris)[/B] - she says she wants to come back, and with MTV bringing back older school vets as of late (Syrus on the Ruins, Jillian on X-Treme, Abram on Cutthroat, Robin/Anessa/Rachel/Mark on Exes and Rivals), I think it's likely. [B]Marie Roda (RW: St Thomas)[/B] [B]Nany Gonzalez (RW: Back To Las Vegas)[/B] [B]Nia Moore (RW: Portland)[/B], seems like the best bet for anyone out of the Portland cast. [B]Kelley Limp (RW: New Orleans), [/B]I saw somewhere she wanted to do another one? She was a BEAST in the original BOTS. [B]Ashley Lindley (RW: DC) Lacey Buehler (RW: Austin) Laura Waller (RW: St Thomas)[/B] [U]BOYS[/U] [B]Zach Nichols (RW: San Diego 2011) Frank Sweeney (RW: San Diego 2011) Marlon Williams (RW: Portland)[/B], seems to be the best candidate from the Portland cast. [B]Issac Stout (RW: Sydney) Michael Ross (RW: Las Vegas 2011) Steven Hill (RW: Las Vegas 2002)[/B], This one may be a stretch, but if he was supposedly asked for BOTS and if they really want to bring back some old school rookies, Steven is a great choice. [B]Mike Manning (RW: DC)[/B] [B]Danny Roberts (RW: New Orleans),[/B] also a long shot, but I'd love to see him return as well along with Kelley. [B]Ryan Knight [/B](RW: Back To New Orleans)

The Inferno 4 Good Guys Girls Averey (RW: Portland) Diem (Fresh Meat) Emily (RW: Washington DC) Jillian (RR: X-Treme) KellyAnne (RW: Sydney) Kina (RR: X-Treme) Laura (RW: St. Thomas) Sarah (RW: Brooklyn) Guys Dustin (RW: Las Vegas 2011) Frank (RW: Las Vegas 2002) Johnny (RW: Key West) Landon (RW: Philadelphia) Leroy (RW: Las Vegas 2011) Mark (RR: USA 1) Marlon (RW: Portland) Tyler (RW: Key West) Bad ***** Girls Beth (RW: Los Angeles) Jenn (RW: Denver) Johanna (RW: Austin) Katie (RR: The Quest) Laurel (Fresh Meat 2) Marie (RW: St. Thomas) Nany (RW: Las Vegas 2011) Tina (RR: South Pacific) Guys CT (RW: Paris) Evan (Fresh Meat) Frank (RW: San Diego 2011) Kenny (Fresh Meat) Trey (RW: St. Thomas) Ty (RW: Washington DC) Wes (RW: Austin) Zach (RW: San Diego 2011)

[QUOTE=VegasAtSea;331318]I'd love to see a Gauntlet IV. Although that may not happen, I still think we are likely to see the Veterans and Rookies lineup at some point. My ideal (yet realistic) lineup for a near future Veterans [U]GIRLS[/U] [B]Emily Schromm (RW: DC) Cara Maria Sorbello (Fresh Meat II) Mandi Moyer (Fresh Meat II) Camila Nakagawa (Spring Break) Coral Smith (RW: B2NY) Trishelle Cannatella (RW: Las Vegas) Elka Walker (RW: Boston)[/B], perhaps the only one on this list that would be iffy. She hasn't done one of these in eight years, but if Trishelle can be lured back, I'm sure our favorite rebellious Catholic can as well. Besides, I'd love to watch Elka, who is one of the strongest girls on both The Gauntlet and BOTS 1 beat Trishelle in an elimination round after Trishelle screwed her over on The Gauntlet due to her relationship with The Miz. Since Coral and Trishelle are apparently friends now, it'd be interesting to see how Coral and Elka would react since they were close as well. [B]KellyAnne Judd (RW: Sydney)[/B] I don't put Sarah Rice on here because she's done 6 in a row; that's a record with Veronica. If Sarah really wants to break this record, I think she's nuts. She needs to be put on a break. [U] MEN[/U] [B]Chet Cannon (RW: Brooklyn)[/B] [B]Wes Bergemann (RW: Austin)[/B] - he needs to put Frank in his place. Enough said. [B]JD Ordonez (RW: Brooklyn) Brandon Nelson (Fresh Meat II) Leroy Garrett (RW: Las Vegas 2011) Cohutta Grindstaff (RW: Sydney) Shane Landrum (RR: Campus Crawl),[/B] possibly a long shot considering the rumors stating that production does not want him back after Viewers' Revenge. However, since Ryan is his ex, it would be interesting to see what kind of drama would ensue if these two were on the same team. [B] Ryan Kehoe (Fresh Meat I) [/B]Rookies [U]GIRLS[/U] [B]Mallory Snyder (RW: Paris)[/B] - she says she wants to come back, and with MTV bringing back older school vets as of late (Syrus on the Ruins, Jillian on X-Treme, Abram on Cutthroat, Robin/Anessa/Rachel/Mark on Exes and Rivals), I think it's likely. [B]Marie Roda (RW: St Thomas)[/B] [B]Nany Gonzalez (RW: Back To Las Vegas)[/B] [B]Nia Moore (RW: Portland)[/B], seems like the best bet for anyone out of the Portland cast. [B]Kelley Limp (RW: New Orleans), [/B]I saw somewhere she wanted to do another one? She was a BEAST in the original BOTS. [B]Ashley Lindley (RW: DC) Lacey Buehler (RW: Austin) Laura Waller (RW: St Thomas)[/B] [U]BOYS[/U] [B]Zach Nichols (RW: San Diego 2011) Frank Sweeney (RW: San Diego 2011) Marlon Williams (RW: Portland)[/B], seems to be the best candidate from the Portland cast. [B]Issac Stout (RW: Sydney) Michael Ross (RW: Las Vegas 2011) Steven Hill (RW: Las Vegas 2002)[/B], This one may be a stretch, but if he was supposedly asked for BOTS and if they really want to bring back some old school rookies, Steven is a great choice. [B]Mike Manning (RW: DC)[/B] [B]Danny Roberts (RW: New Orleans),[/B] also a long shot, but I'd love to see him return as well along with Kelley. [B]Ryan Knight [/B](RW: Back To New Orleans)[/QUOTE] If you are giving any reason for the Rookies to beat the Veterans and have bragging rights over vets for years to come, this challenge cast is it.

For me a Duel 3 needs to consist of at least these dudes.. Landon CT Johnny Kenny Derrick Brad Wes Evan Abram Darrell Alton Zach CJ Mark Leroy Dustin And women... Emily Laurel Ev Jenn Paula Aneesa Coral Rachel Susie Kelly Anne Nany Marie Camilla Diem Sarah Devyn (For the entertainment)

After Battle of the Exes and Battle of the Seasons, MTV completes their "Battle" trilogy with the "Battle of the Generations". 7 Teams spanning different generations of 'The Challenge' are assembled Team 1998-2000 Mark Long Eric Nies Veronica Portillo Beth Stolarczyk Team 2000-2002 Syrus Yarbrough Adam Larson Susie Meister Coral Smith Team 2002-2004 Abram Boise Alton Williams Rachel Robinson Tina Barta Team 2004-2006 CT Tamburello Derrick Kosinski Robin Hibbard Jillian Zoboroski Team 2006-2008 Johnny Devenanzio Wes Bergmann Evelyn Smith Jenn Grijalva Team 2008-2010 Evan Starkman Kenny Santucci KellyAnne Judd Shauvon Torres Team 2010-2012 Frank Sweeney Dustin Zito Laurel Stuckey Jasmine Reynaud

[QUOTE=RobbioRobbio;331535]After Battle of the Exes and Battle of the Seasons, MTV completes their "Battle" trilogy with the "Battle of the Generations". 7 Teams spanning different generations of 'The Challenge' are assembled Team 1998-2000 Mark Long Eric Nies Veronica Portillo Beth Stolarczyk Team 2000-2002 Syrus Yarbrough Adam Larson Susie Meister Coral Smith Team 2002-2004 Abram Boise Alton Williams Rachel Robinson Tina Barta Team 2004-2006 CT Tamburello Derrick Kosinski Robin Hibbard Jillian Zoboroski Team 2006-2008 Johnny Devenanzio Wes Bergmann Evelyn Smith Jenn Grijalva Team 2008-2010 Evan Starkman Kenny Santucci KellyAnne Judd Shauvon Torres Team 2010-2012 Frank Sweeney Dustin Zito Laurel Stuckey Jasmine Reynaud[/QUOTE] I think it would be better to watch competition-wise if Shauvon was subbed out for Emily and Jasmine was subbed out for Nany although Team 2010-2012 would have serious communication problems.

[QUOTE=RobbioRobbio;331535]After Battle of the Exes and Battle of the Seasons, MTV completes their "Battle" trilogy with the "Battle of the Generations". 7 Teams spanning different generations of 'The Challenge' are assembled Team 2006-2008 Johnny Devenanzio Wes Bergmann [B]Evelyn Smith[/B] Jenn Grijalva Team 2008-2010 [B]Evan Starkman Kenny Santucci[/B] KellyAnne Judd Shauvon Torres [/QUOTE] How exactly could this be justified?

[QUOTE=ChallengeGod;325914]That's unrealistic though because Susie, Tori, and Veronica are either pregnant or recently had kids, and Jodi, Kina, Cara, Alton and Coral are unlikely to do one. [/QUOTE] In Derrick's podcast from January 16th, 2012 w/ Coral & Laurel (that rhymes! anyways..) Coral said she'd be interested in coming back....I wouldn't count her out completely. I wish Jodi, Kina, & Cara would come back though :(

[

did u try and come up with the weakest vets guy team you could. better team would be johnny, evan, kenny, ct, derrick,landon,brad,wes

[QUOTE=RobbioRobbio;331535]After Battle of the Exes and Battle of the Seasons, MTV completes their "Battle" trilogy with the "Battle of the Generations". 7 Teams spanning different generations of 'The Challenge' are assembled Team 1998-2000 Mark Long Eric Nies Veronica Portillo Beth Stolarczyk Team 2000-2002 Syrus Yarbrough Adam Larson Susie Meister Coral Smith Team 2002-2004 Abram Boise Alton Williams Rachel Robinson Tina Barta Team 2004-2006 CT Tamburello Derrick Kosinski Robin Hibbard Jillian Zoboroski Team 2006-2008 Johnny Devenanzio Wes Bergmann Evelyn Smith Jenn Grijalva Team 2008-2010 Evan Starkman Kenny Santucci KellyAnne Judd Shauvon Torres Team 2010-2012 Frank Sweeney Dustin Zito Laurel Stuckey Jasmine Reynaud[/QUOTE] I agree that MTV could and may continue their 'Battle' saga, with some form of Generations, or Centuries. I don't think they would follow the exact format of BOTS, with teams of four. But I would like to see what they could pull off.

Just came up with a pretty cool challenge concept, although it will never happen because it does't consist of any new faces, it would be interesting to see. Similar rules to Rivals, alternated guy/girl elimination days with only 4 pairs making it to the finals, 2 guy pairs and 2 girl pairs. The Challenge: Champions Guy Pairs: Battle of the Seasons- Frank (RW: San Diego 2011) & Zach (RW: San Diego 2011) Rivals: Johnny (RW: Key West) & Tyler (RW: Key West) The Ruins: Derrick (RR: X-Treme) & Kenny (Fresh Meat) Fresh Meat: Landon (RW: Philadelphia) & Darrell (RR: Campus Crawl) The Duel: Wes (RW: Austin) & Evan (Fresh Meat) Cutthroat: Dunbar (RW: Sydney) & Brad (RW: San Diego) Girl Pairs: The Duel: Jodi (RR: X-Treme) & Rachel (RR: Campus Crawl) Rivals: Evelyn (Fresh Meat) & Paula (RW: Key West) The Gauntlet 2: Ibis (RR: X-Treme) & Susie (RR: Down Under) The Inferno: Katie (RR: The Quest) & Veronica (RR: Semester at Sea) The Gauntlet III: Tori (RR: Viewer's Revenge) & Jillian (RR: X-Treme) Battle of the Seasons: Ashley (RW: San Diego 2011) & Sam (RW: San Diego 2011)

If I could have recast Rivals and restart the 'Battle' Saga, only slight modifications: BATTLE OF THE RIVALS* Evelyn Smith and Paula Meronek Aneesa Ferreira & Robin Hibbard Jasmine Reynaud & Jonna Mannion Jenn Grijalva & Mandi Moyer Cara Maria Sorbello & Laurel Stucky Johanna Botta & KellyAnne Judd Parisa & Trisha Cummings Katie Doyle & Veronica Portillo Adam King & Chris Tamburello Kenny Santucci & Wes Bergmann Johnny Devenanzio & Tyler Duckworth Adam Royer & Leroy Garret Preston Charles & Ryan Leslie Davis & Mallory & Tyrie Ballard Evan Starkman & Nehemiah Clark Brandon Nelson & Ty Ruff would continue on to BATTLE OF THE EXES Chris Tamburello & Diem Brown Mark Long & Robin Hibbard Cohutta Grindstaff & KellyAnne Judd Wes Berhgmann & Johanna Bota Leroy Garret & Naomi Defensor Dustin Zito & Heather Marter Danny Jamieson & Melinda Stolp Alton Williams & Irulan Wilson Abram Boise & Cara Maria Sorbello Ty Ruff & Emily Schromm Zach Nichols & Ashley Kelsey Ryan Knight & Jemmye Carroll Dunbar Flinn & Paula Meronek Frank Roessler & Jillian Zoboroski

[QUOTE=RamblinMan;331640]If I could have recast Rivals and restart the 'Battle' Saga, only slight modifications: BATTLE OF THE RIVALS* Johanna Botta & KellyAnne Judd Katie Doyle & Veronica Portillo BATTLE OF THE EXES Danny Jamieson & Melinda Stolp Alton Williams & Irulan Wilson Frank Roessler & Jillian Zoboroski[/QUOTE] These pairs would have been nice to see. I would have loved to see KellyAnne and Wes though. They would have been the ultimate team from Cohutta/KellyAnne and Johanna/Wes (even though Cohutta beat Wes in The Ruins). Frank and Jillian could have easily beat Johnny Bananas and Camila. I would have loved to see that.

Battle of the Sexes 3: Original Score Board format from the original Battle of the Sexes with an inner circle every week. The player with the lowest points automatically goes into an elimination round. The Inner Circle of each team gets to pick another player to battle against them. A guy & a girl will go home each week. Girls: Coral Laurel Rachel R Veronica McKenzie Marie Devyn Sarah R Katie Nany Jillian Emily S Kim Collie Sarah B (RW Phili) Guys: Wes Mark L Frank (RW LV) Derrick Zach Frank (RW SD) CJ Landon Dustin Cohutta Isaac (RW Sydney) Davis Ryan (FM) Alton CT Abe I don't think I can do a cast because I wouldn't be able to get it down to the ones I'd want...a dream cast would be huge but I guess I can try to do two teams of 16. I realize I only have one newbie...and she is from Phili and it would be a stretch to get her...and pregnacy's aside this is my list...although there are a lot of 'dream' people I'd love to see on it (Elka, Anne RR NT, Sarah G, Jermey B, Ace, Irulan, etc...I tried to stay kind of realistic. I also hate Frank and Zach...but would love to see them get creamed by some true heavy hitters! I also loved Lacey, and would love to see her again, she had great commentary with Wes...but she didn't make this list. Same with Trishelle...although Trishele could take McKenzie spot.

I'm still relatively new...how do I delete a post? Sorry.....

[QUOTE=RamblinMan;331640]If I could have recast Rivals and restart the 'Battle' Saga, only slight modifications: BATTLE OF THE RIVALS* Katie Doyle & Veronica Portillo BATTLE OF THE EXES Cohutta Grindstaff & KellyAnne Judd Wes Berhgmann & Johanna Bota Alton Williams & Irulan Wilson Frank Roessler & Jillian Zoboroski[/QUOTE] Cohutta and KellyAnne would have been a freaking strong team! Katie & Veronica would have been a perfect Rivals pairing. Wes & jo would have been entertaining. Alton & Irulan would have been interesting to see how they get along, as would Frank & Jillian! [QUOTE=El Scorcho;331637]Just came up with a pretty cool challenge concept, although it will never happen because it does't consist of any new faces, it would be interesting to see. Similar rules to Rivals, alternated guy/girl elimination days with only 4 pairs making it to the finals, 2 guy pairs and 2 girl pairs. The Challenge: Champions Guy Pairs: Battle of the Seasons- Frank (RW: San Diego 2011) & Zach (RW: San Diego 2011) Rivals: Johnny (RW: Key West) & Tyler (RW: Key West) The Ruins: Derrick (RR: X-Treme) & Kenny (Fresh Meat) Fresh Meat: Landon (RW: Philadelphia) & Darrell (RR: Campus Crawl) The Duel: Wes (RW: Austin) & Evan (Fresh Meat) Cutthroat: Dunbar (RW: Sydney) & Brad (RW: San Diego) Girl Pairs: The Duel: Jodi (RR: X-Treme) & Rachel (RR: Campus Crawl) Rivals: Evelyn (Fresh Meat) & Paula (RW: Key West) The Gauntlet 2: Ibis (RR: X-Treme) & Susie (RR: Down Under) The Inferno: Katie (RR: The Quest) & Veronica (RR: Semester at Sea) The Gauntlet III: Tori (RR: Viewer's Revenge) & Jillian (RR: X-Treme) Battle of the Seasons: Ashley (RW: San Diego 2011) & Sam (RW: San Diego 2011)[/QUOTE] I really like this concept a lot! Jodi & Rachel would kill!

[QUOTE=Nightwolf;331568]How exactly could this be justified?[/QUOTE] well they always have a few reaches on the show (mike and leroy being rivals, combining 2 seasons of vegas), i thought it would be interesting casting to have johnny and wes on the same team and to have kenny and evan on a team with a weak player (shauvon) to hold them back :D

[QUOTE=RobbioRobbio;331725]well they always have a few reaches on the show (mike and leroy being rivals, combining 2 seasons of vegas), i thought it would be interesting casting to have johnny and wes on the same team and to have kenny and evan on a team with a weak player (shauvon) to hold them back :D[/QUOTE] Nightwolf is talking about how is it justified that Evelyn, Kenny, and Evan are all from the same season, but Evelyn is on the generation team before them...?

If I could have recast the original Ruins. I would have something like this... more so to balance out the power of the Champion guys, and give the Challengers more of a fighting chance: [U][B]CHAMPIONS [/B][/U]Wes Bergmann (RW: Austin) Kenny Santucci (FM: 1) Darrell Taylor (RR: Campus Crawl) Abram Boise (RR: South Pacific) Derrick Kosinski (RR: Xtreme) Johnny Devenanzio (RW: Key West) Mark Long (RR: USA) Evelyn Smith (FM: 1) Susie Meister (RR: Australia) Johanna Botta (RW: Austin) Veronica Portillo (RR: Semester at Sea) Tori Hall (RR: Viewers Revenge) Katie Doyle (RR: The Quest) Tonya Cooley (RW: Chicago) [U][B]CHALLENGERS [/B][/U]Chris Tamburello (RW: Paris) Cohutta Grindstaff (RW: Sydney) Dunbar Flinn (RW: Sydney) Scott Herman (RW: Brooklyn) Brad Fiorenza (RW: San Diego) Nick Brown (RW: Hollywood) Derek McCray (RR: Viewers Revenge) Jenn Grijalva (RW: Denver) Paula Meronek (RW: Key West) Robin Hibbard (RW: San Diego) KellyAnne Judd (RW: Sydney) Kimberly Alexander (RW: Hollywood) Brianna Taylor (RW: Hollywood) Sarah Rice (RW: Brooklyn)

[QUOTE=RamblinMan;331768]If I could have recast the original Ruins. I would have something like this... more so to balance out the power of the Champion guys, and give the Challengers more of a fighting chance: [U][B]CHAMPIONS [/B][/U]Wes Bergmann (RW: Austin) Kenny Santucci (FM: 1) Darrell Taylor (RR: Campus Crawl) Abram Boise (RR: South Pacific) Derrick Kosinski (RR: Xtreme) Johnny Devenanzio (RW: Key West) Mark Long (RR: USA) Evelyn Smith (FM: 1) Susie Meister (RR: Australia) Johanna Botta (RW: Austin) Veronica Portillo (RR: Semester at Sea) Tori Hall (RR: Viewers Revenge) Katie Doyle (RR: The Quest) Tonya Cooley (RW: Chicago) [U][B]CHALLENGERS [/B][/U]Chris Tamburello (RW: Paris) Cohutta Grindstaff (RW: Sydney) Dunbar Flinn (RW: Sydney) Scott Herman (RW: Brooklyn) Brad Fiorenza (RW: San Diego) Nick Brown (RW: Hollywood) Derek McCray (RR: Viewers Revenge) Jenn Grijalva (RW: Denver) Paula Meronek (RW: Key West) Robin Hibbard (RW: San Diego) KellyAnne Judd (RW: Sydney) Kimberly Alexander (RW: Hollywood) Brianna Taylor (RW: Hollywood) Sarah Rice (RW: Brooklyn)[/QUOTE] Paula and Brad have already won before so they would be champions.

Oh and Dunbar has won before also

[QUOTE=KChallenge10;331793]Oh and Dunbar has won before also[/QUOTE] I think this was meant to be at the time of the original Ruins, when Paula, Brad, and Dunbar had not won Rivals and Cutthroat yet.

[QUOTE=RamblinMan;331768]If I could have recast the original Ruins. I would have something like this... more so to balance out the power of the Champion guys, and give the Challengers more of a fighting chance: [U][B]CHAMPIONS [/B][/U] Abram Boise (RR: South Pacific) Mark Long (RR: USA) Tori Hall (RR: Viewers Revenge) [U][B]CHALLENGERS [/B][/U]Chris Tamburello Scott Herman (RW: Brooklyn) Derek McCray (RR: Viewers Revenge) Jenn Grijalva (RW: Denver) Paula Meronek (RW: Key West) Robin Hibbard (RW: San Diego) [/QUOTE] Abram and Mark would have been interesting selections. However, I feel those two are much stronger competitors than Evan and Syrus overall. I liked having Syrus there; it would have been nice though to see him intervene with the whole Tanya situation more. But with this revised cast and a lack of Evan, the Tonya situations may have never happened, thank God. Having Tori instead of Ibis would have massively changed the game. In my honest opinion, we would have seen Katie and Veronica gone sooner, and that would not be good for ratings: these two are two of the biggest Challenge personalities ever. Having Tori and Ev on the same team is like asking to have Laurel and Emily Schromm on the same team: it won't happen. It would have been nice to see Scott as some new blood, but if one were to have CT, it would only be appropriate to have Diem there. However, Diem had to leave early for her job, hence why she threw her Ruins to Tonya. Random site note, but, ironically, Jisela had to do the same thing in the Gauntlet II. I'm shocked Diem was brought back after doing that, since Jisela wasn't. The change in females was nice; Robin is very underrated as a competitor. I'm shocked she has only made one final. I'm assuming Paula was asked for the Ruins... but she likely said no, because she has been asked (and done) for every challenge since her debut, I'm pretty sure, besides The Ruins and the present Battle of the Seasons. Random question, does anyone know if a Key West team was actually due to form? I'm assuming not, since the only female I could think of that would actually be on the team would be Paula Walnuts herself. Svetlana is over MTV and Janelle hasn't been seen since Gauntlet III in which Jillian kicked her ***.

[B]Veterans or Old School[/B] CT Darrell Eric N. Evan Kefla Mark Syrus Wes [alt. add Landon, Abram or Nehemiah] Coral Katie Rachel Susie Trishelle Paula Robin Jillian [alt. add Sarah, Tina or Aneesa] [B]Rookies or New School[/B] CJ Dunbar Dustin Frank Leroy Noor Pete Zach [alt. add Ty, Mike R. or Isaac] -- Ashlee Ashley Emily Jonna KellyAnne Laurel Marie Nany [alt. add Aiiya, Carley or Theresa]

Gauntlet IV: Old School vs New School The teams would be divided based on their seasons. The Old School team would consist of cast members who were either on Road Rules (minus Viewers Revenge) or on RW 1-15 (Philadelphia). The New School Team would consist of Fresh Meat, Viewers Revenge, and cast members from RW: Austin to the present, since cast members from Austin made their debut on Fresh Meat. This is more of a fantasy lineup than a realistic lineup. There would be 36 cast members, with 9 members from each *** on each team. [B]OLD SCHOOL[/B] [I]Guys[/I][B] Mark Long (RR1) Timmy Beggy (RR2) Syrus Yarbrough (RW6) Abram Boise (RR12) Eric Nies (RW1) Dan Renzi (RW5) Kefla Hare (RR6)[/B] [B]Brad Fiorenza (RW14)[/B] [B]CT Tamburillo (RW13) Making it realistic:[/B] Timmy has retired, as has Eric and Brad as well I believe. I'd replace those with Darrell (RR11), Derrick (RR13) and Landon (RW15). [I] Girls[/I] [B]Veronica Portillo (RR8) Rachel Robinson (RR11) Julie Stoffer (RW9) Coral Smith (RW10) Susie Meister (RR6) Elka Walker (RW6) Katie Doyle (RR10) Jillian Zoboroski (RW13) Robin Hibbard (RW14) [/B] [B]Making it realistic:[/B] We very likely will not see Veronica ever again. If Trishelle were to be cast in Veronica's place, I could see Coral being cast. But Coral likely won't come back unless more of her friends with there, so I'd likely cast Anessa instead. We haven't heard from Elka in years, so she may not be likely, yet she still keeps in touch with cast members, so it's possible she could come back. I found her to be very entertaining and would love to see her and Trishelle on the same team. Katie's school may conflict. Possible alternates would include Cara (RR 12, hey, if Susie's on there...) or Anessa (RW 11). [B]NEW SCHOOL[/B] [I]Guys[/I] Wes Bergmann (RW 16) Chet Cannon (RW 21) Jonny Bananas (RW 17) Ryan Knight (RW 24) Dustin Zito (RW 25) Zach Nichols (RW 27) Frank Sweeney (RW 27) Eric Banks (Fresh Meat) Brandon Nelson (Fresh Meat) [B]Making it realistic: [/B]I doubt Big Easy will come back, but every team has to have a weak link. If he doesn't come back, they'll have Danny to fall back on. Otherwise, I think this cast is fairly realistic. Dustin may or may not be up in the air, but who knows. [I]Girls[/I] Ev Smith (Fresh Meat) Diem Brown (Fresh Meat) Melinda Stolp (RW 16) Jenn Grijalva (RW 18) Paula Meronek (RW 17) Emily Schromm (RW 23) Cara Maria Sorbello (FM2) Laurel Stucky (FM2) Nany Gonzalez (RW 25) [B]Making it realistic: [/B]Ev likely won't come back unless there is a Duel 3. Diem is hit or miss. Jenn claims to be done, and Laurel is busy with her work. So, in lieu of those four, I'd cast Marie Roda (RW 27), Mandi Moyer (Fresh Meat 2), Camila (Spring Break), and Sarah Rice (RW21). I want to say Tori, but I know she's likely never coming back. [B]Or... if they did Battle of the Seasons 3, like the original season... [/B][B]1) Real World LA: [/B]Jon and Beth[B] (let's hope they wouldn't lose first again) 2) Real World Boston:[/B] Syrus and Elka[B] 3) Real World Miami: [/B]Dan and Cynthia[B] 4) Real World Hawaii: [/B]Ruthie and Colin[B] 5) Real World NO: [/B]Julie and David B.[B] 6) Real World Chicago: [/B]Theo and Anessa[B] 7) Real World Las Vegas: [/B]Trishelle and Steven[B]8) Real World Paris: [/B]Mallory and CT[B] 9) Fresh Meat: [/B]Kenny and Diem[B] 10) Fresh Meat II: [/B]Laurel and Brandon[B] 11) Real World Austin: [/B]Wes and Melinda[B] 12) Road Rules X-Treme: [/B]Derrick and Jillian[B] 13) Road Rules Australia: [/B]Susie and Kefla[B] 14) Real World B2LV: [/B]Nany and Leroy[B] 15) RW St Thomas: [/B]Marie and Robb[B] 16) RW DC: [/B]Emily and Ty[B] OR If they did a Rivals 2... Girl Rivalries [/B] Jasmine/Jonna (Battle of the Seasons) Elka/Trishelle (Gauntlet) Coral/Julie (Inferno) Paula/Laurel (Rivals) Ashley/Sam (San Diego) Johanna/KellyAnne (Ruins) Emily/Erika (Real World: DC) [B] Guy Rivalries [/B]Wes/Vinny (Exes) Dustin/Frank (BOTS) Robb/Derek (BOTS) some Portland rivalry Davis/CT (Inferno 3) Abram/Adam (Viewers Revenge) Brad/Darrell (Ruins) Johnny/Tyler (Key West)

This is a three team, 10 player per team challenge. I guess it could be Cutthroat 2 but that format wasn't my favorite. The three teams are Past, Present & Future. I tried to make it as realistic as possible. [B]PAST:[/B] Abram Aneesa Beth Coral CT Darrell Derrick Katie Landon Susie [B]PRESENT[/B] Diem Evan Jenn Johanna Johnny KellyAnne Kenny Paula Tyler Wes [B]FUTURE[/B] Adam R. (If he is allowed back, if not then Dustin) Frank Jemmye Heather Laurel Leroy Mike (DC) Marie Nany Knight

[QUOTE=rwdenverfan;332414]This is a three team, 10 player per team challenge. I guess it could be Cutthroat 2 but that format wasn't my favorite. The three teams are Past, Present & Future. I tried to make it as realistic as possible. [B]PAST:[/B] Abram Aneesa Beth Coral CT Darrell Derrick Katie Landon Susie [B]PRESENT[/B] Diem Evan Jenn Johanna Johnny KellyAnne Kenny Paula Tyler Wes [B]FUTURE[/B] Adam R. (If he is allowed back, if not then Dustin) Frank Jemmye Heather Laurel Leroy Mike (DC) Marie Nany Knight[/QUOTE] Beth says "thank you" for the mention. ;)