The Challenge: Favorite/Fantasy Casts

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;391904]Copying pinkrose's idea of exes cutthroat version Comment on what team would win [COLOR="#FF0000"]Red Team Marlon Pete Abram Darrell Wes Nany Jenn Coral Rachel KellyAnne [/COLOR][COLOR="#00FFFF"]Blue Team CT Johnny R Cory TY CJ Laurel Averey Jenny Paula Ashley K [/COLOR][COLOR="#00FF00"]Green Team Leroy Jordan Ace Zach Alton Theresa Sarah Mallory Jonna Janelle [/COLOR][/QUOTE] Only everyone isn't connected in mine like Pinkrose's was , just exes on cutthroat

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;391904]Copying pinkrose's idea of exes cutthroat version Comment on what team would win [COLOR=#FF0000]Red Team Marlon Pete Abram Darrell Wes Nany Jenn Coral Rachel KellyAnne [/COLOR][COLOR=#00FFFF]Blue Team CT Johnny R Cory TY CJ Laurel Averey Jenny Paula Ashley K [/COLOR][COLOR=#00FF00]Green Team Leroy Jordan Ace Zach Alton Theresa Sarah Mallory Jonna Janelle [/COLOR][/QUOTE] I like this, would be fun to watch since it's a very even playing field overall.

[QUOTE=CHIblackhawk;391943]I like this, would be fun to watch since it's a very even playing field overall.[/QUOTE] Thanks, who do you think would win?

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;391945]Thanks, who do you think would win?[/QUOTE] Very tough one to call since it's hard to find any clear weak links. I would guess the battle for 1st place would come down to red and blue, but I could see green doing good as well.

Cutthroat 2 Gold Team Jordan(Portland) Brian(Ex-Plosion) Knight(New Orleans 2) Ryan(Brooklyn) Derek(Cancun) Ashley(Ex-Plosion) Marie(St Thomas) Devyn(Brooklyn) Erika(DC) Kimberly(Hollywood) Silver Team Trey(St Thomas) Will(Hollywood) Jay(Ex-plosion) Chet(Brooklyn) CJ(Cancun) Kellyanne(Sydney) Ashley(San Diego 2) Jemmeye(New Orleans 2) Jonna(Cancun) Cooke(Las Vegas 2) Crystal Team Leroy(Las Vegas 2) Dustin(Las Vegas 2) Frank(San Diego 2) Ty(DC) Cory(Ex-Plosion) Nany(Las Vegas 2) Jenny(Ex-plosion) Sarah(Brooklyn) Nia(Portland) Latoya(St Thomas)

[QUOTE=Debut Album;391952]Cutthroat 2 Gold Team Jordan(Portland) Brian(Ex-Plosion) Knight(New Orleans 2) Ryan(Brooklyn) Derek(Cancun) Ashley(Ex-Plosion) Marie(St Thomas) Devyn(Brooklyn) Erika(DC) Kimberly(Hollywood) Silver Team Trey(St Thomas) Will(Hollywood) Jay(Ex-plosion) Chet(Brooklyn) CJ(Cancun) Kellyanne(Sydney) Ashley(San Diego 2) Jemmeye(New Orleans 2) Jonna(Cancun) Cooke(Las Vegas 2) Crystal Team Leroy(Las Vegas 2) Dustin(Las Vegas 2) Frank(San Diego 2) Ty(DC) Cory(Ex-Plosion) Nany(Las Vegas 2) Jenny(Ex-plosion) Sarah(Brooklyn) Nia(Portland) Latoya(St Thomas)[/QUOTE] I love the exotic colors. Crystal would be my pick to win with silver coming in 2nd.

Battle of the seasons 2 Location Barcelona Spain- Final in Siberia Comment on who you think will make the final. [COLOR="#FF0000"]DC Ashley L Mike Emily TY [/COLOR][COLOR="#00FF00"]Brooklyn Sarah Ryan C Baya Scott [/COLOR][COLOR="#0000FF"]Ex-plosion Arielle Brian Jenna Thomas [/COLOR][B]Portland Averey Jordan Nia Johnny R [/B][COLOR="#800080"]Las Vegas Nany Dustin Cooke Leroy [/COLOR][COLOR="#00FFFF"]Road Rules Veronica Derrick Rachel Abram [/COLOR][COLOR="#008000"]Sydney KellyAnne Issac Trisha Cohutta [/COLOR][COLOR="#000080"]Key West Paula Tyler Janelle Johnny [/COLOR]

Battle of the seasons 3 Ex-plosion Brian Cory Arielle Jenny Portland Jordan Johnny R Nia Averey San Diego (Hybrid) Brad Zach Robin Priscilla Vegas 2 Dustin Leroy Cooke Nany New Orleans Ryan Leslie Erick Ashley Sahar DC Ashley L Erika Mike Josh Cancun CJ Bronne Jonna Ayiiia Brooklyn Scott Chet Baya Sarah Sydney Isaac Dunbar Kelly Anne Ashlii

[QUOTE=PinkRose;391969]Battle of the seasons 3 Ex-plosion Brian Cory Arielle Jenny Portland Jordan Johnny R Nia Averey San Diego (Hybrid) Brad Zach Robin Priscilla Vegas 2 Dustin Leroy Cooke Nany New Orleans Ryan Leslie Erick Ashley Sahar DC Ashley L Erika Mike Josh Cancun CJ Bronne Jonna Ayiiia Brooklyn Scott Chet Baya Sarah Sydney Isaac Dunbar Kelly Anne Ashlii[/QUOTE] Without Emily DC doesn't stand a chance

[B]BATTLE OF THE EXES 2[/B] *I think this would be a great 26th season of the challenge to stick with the Exes madness one last time since fans seem to really like it! [B]Location:[/B] Somewhere in the Caribbean [B]Theme:[/B] Exes [B]Format:[/B] I think the format would need to be revamped into something more interesting and that could cause more drama than the first one. This upcoming format is very unique yet interesting. I came up with this... 1. Winning Team of that days mission is safe from The Dome 2. Last place & 2nd to last place teams are up for elimination and the rest of the teams (except the Winning Team) must choose 1 team to send in and another team to save 3. Then the Winning Team chooses their opponent for The Dome. 4. Also, I think the missions should be based on "keywords" that it takes to be couple or things that can hurt couples as well like Trust, Communication, Lying, Jealousy, Faithfulness, etc... 5. Only 1 team should win money in the end! $200,000. Up the stakes more but still 3 teams make the final! (1 day final challenge too) 6. Winning Teams have to go on a date to maybe spark some relationships back up! More romantic dates than those dinners on the first Exes. 7. Also, Domes are broken into Physical, Mental, Strategy, and Endurance but is randomly chosen. 8. I would like for there to be more twist in the format to really shake things up but I'm still thinking so let me know if you have any! :) [B]CAST[/B] [I][SPOILER]Cohutta & Nany (Supposedly but most likely hooked up on Season 25)[/SPOILER][I] [/I][SPOILER]Isaac & Devyn (Possibly but hopefully hooked up on Season 25)[/SPOILER][/I] [I]Brian & Jenny (Dated on Real World: Ex-Plosion)[/I] [I]Cory & Lauren (Dated on Real World: Ex-Plosion)[/I] [I]Jay & Jenna (Dated on Real World: Ex-Plosion)[/I] [I]Derek & Marlon (Hooked up on Rivals II)[/I] [I]Johnny R. & Averey (Dated on Real World: Portland)[/I] [I]Jordan & Nia (Hooked up on Real World: Portland)[/I] [I]Zach & Jonna (Dated on Battle of The Seasons)[/I] [I]Swift & Trey (Hooked up on Real World: St. Thomas)[/I] [I]Trey & Laura (Dated on Real World: St. Thomas)[/I] [I]Dustin & Heather (Dated on Real World: Back to Las Vegas)[/I] [I]Knight & Jemmye (Dated on Real World: Back to New Orleans)[/I] [I]Wes & Theresa (Hooked up on Fresh Meat II)[/I] [I]Dunbar & KellyAnne (Hooked up on Real World: Sydney according to Dunbar lol)[/I] I think this cast could bring A LOT of drama! It primarily New School and by season 26 we've seen what most of them can do so I think this cast will be more welcomed then Battle of The Seasons cast. Also, a lot of these Exes have unresolved issues or feelings but most of the cast is also single so that could add a lot of drama to the mix! Theres potential with this cast!

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;391970]Without Emily DC doesn't stand a chance[/QUOTE] Agreed. I would have liked to have seen DC on BOTS. Assuming that they'd have been in an alliance with San Diego, a team of Ashley/Emily/Mike/Ty could have dominated and won.

[QUOTE=TexasFight88;391976]Agreed. I would have liked to have seen DC on BOTS. Assuming that they'd have been in an alliance with San Diego, a team of Ashley/Emily/Mike/Ty could have dominated and won.[/QUOTE] It's been over a year and I'm still mad they weren't a part of that season. I'll always have a hard time understanding why production passed up on beast teams like DC and Road Rules for duds like Austin, New Orleans, and Fresh Meat/Spring Break. BOTS would have been lightyears better if DC and RR were there instead of any of those other teams.

[QUOTE=Livewitpeace;391974][B]BATTLE OF THE EXES 2[/B] *I think this would be a great 26th season of the challenge to stick with the Exes madness one last time since fans seem to really like it! [B]Location:[/B] Somewhere in the Caribbean [B]Theme:[/B] Exes [B]Format:[/B] I think the format would need to be revamped into something more interesting and that could cause more drama than the first one. This upcoming format is very unique yet interesting. I came up with this... 1. Winning Team of that days mission is safe from The Dome 2. Last place & 2nd to last place teams are up for elimination and the rest of the teams (except the Winning Team) must choose 1 team to send in and another team to save 3. Then the Winning Team chooses their opponent for The Dome. 4. Also, I think the missions should be based on "keywords" that it takes to be couple or things that can hurt couples as well like Trust, Communication, Lying, Jealousy, Faithfulness, etc... 5. Only 1 team should win money in the end! $200,000. Up the stakes more but still 3 teams make the final! (1 day final challenge too) 6. Winning Teams have to go on a date to maybe spark some relationships back up! More romantic dates than those dinners on the first Exes. 7. Also, Domes are broken into Physical, Mental, Strategy, and Endurance but is randomly chosen. 8. I would like for there to be more twist in the format to really shake things up but I'm still thinking so let me know if you have any! :) [B]CAST[/B] [I][SPOILER]Cohutta & Nany (Supposedly but most likely hooked up on Season 25)[/SPOILER][I] [/I][SPOILER]Isaac & Devyn (Possibly but hopefully hooked up on Season 25)[/SPOILER][/I] [I]Brian & Jenny (Dated on Real World: Ex-Plosion)[/I] [I]Cory & Lauren (Dated on Real World: Ex-Plosion)[/I] [I]Jay & Jenna (Dated on Real World: Ex-Plosion)[/I] [I]Derek & Marlon (Hooked up on Rivals II)[/I] [I]Johnny R. & Averey (Dated on Real World: Portland)[/I] [I]Jordan & Nia (Hooked up on Real World: Portland)[/I] [I]Zach & Jonna (Dated on Battle of The Seasons)[/I] [I]Swift & Trey (Hooked up on Real World: St. Thomas)[/I] [I]Trey & Laura (Dated on Real World: St. Thomas)[/I] [I]Dustin & Heather (Dated on Real World: Back to Las Vegas)[/I] [I]Knight & Jemmye (Dated on Real World: Back to New Orleans)[/I] [I]Wes & Theresa (Hooked up on Fresh Meat II)[/I] [I]Dunbar & KellyAnne (Hooked up on Real World: Sydney according to Dunbar lol)[/I] I think this cast could bring A LOT of drama! It primarily New School and by season 26 we've seen what most of them can do so I think this cast will be more welcomed then Battle of The Seasons cast. Also, a lot of these Exes have unresolved issues or feelings but most of the cast is also single so that could add a lot of drama to the mix! Theres potential with this cast![/QUOTE] Why punish people for doing well in missions? Also you made making the final completely worthless because you don't get money if you win. The cast would absolutely hate this.

[QUOTE=CHIblackhawk;391979]It's been over a year and I'm still mad they weren't a part of that season. I'll always have a hard time understanding why production passed up on beast teams like DC and Road Rules for duds like Austin, New Orleans, and Fresh Meat/Spring Break. BOTS would have been lightyears better if DC and RR were there instead of any of those other teams.[/QUOTE] They wanted DC, DC was all set to be there but Callie found out she was pregnant and Erika & Ashley L said no.

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;391981]Why punish people for doing well in missions? Also you made making the final completely worthless because you don't get money if you win. The cast would absolutely hate this.[/QUOTE] I wouldn't call it punishing them... its entertaining us though and that is also most important! As for the money thing I do get it but I think it would really make people think about who they can beat in a final verse bring friends/alliance members along. I'll budge for atleast 2nd place winning money! Do you like the cast & format though?

[QUOTE=CHIblackhawk;391979]It's been over a year and I'm still mad they weren't a part of that season. I'll always have a hard time understanding why production passed up on beast teams like DC and Road Rules for duds like Austin, New Orleans, and Fresh Meat/Spring Break. BOTS would have been lightyears better if DC and RR were there instead of any of those other teams.[/QUOTE] I think that Austin was there because they wanted to have more than one veteran team (Fresh Meat was the other, who replaced Sydney). But, yeah, New Orleans really didn't do anything for me. Preston and McKenzie were both boring, and aside from Knight and Jemmye having that scene at the bar when he told her he'd marry her, they didn't do all that much. With DC, you would have had 3 people (Mike, Ty, Ashley) who would have likely started some drama. You had Ty and Emily coming off of BOTS, and there was the chance that they could go at it, Ashley and Ty speak their minds, and the former probably would have ended up on Rivals II if she was anything like she was on DC, not to mention her being ****** at Ty for stiffing her on rent, and Mike isn't afraid to push peoples buttons. IIRC, Molds said the cast would have been Emily, Ty, Ashley and Josh, with Mike as an alternate. If true, why Josh? He brought nothing to the table on the DC season, and would have been the most boring person in the house.

**** Knight was around a lot of drama that season. Only guys to have more drama were probably Frank and Dustin. Knight even had a episode named after him so, it'd be crazy to say he didn't bring a lot of drama.

Battle of the Exes 2 1.Knight/Jemmye 2.Zach/Jonna 3.Leroy/Theresa 4.CT/Ana 5.Jordan/Sarah 6.Dustin/Cooke 7.Ty/Paula 8.Cory/Jenny 9.Thomas/Jamie 10.Trey/Laura 11.Robb/Marie 12.Jay/Jenna 13.Marlon/Nany 14.Johnny R./Averey

Honestly, I think that they had San Diego/St. Thomas there just because they were both recent seasons and hadn't yet had a chance to appear. I think they went with NOLA solely because of the potential drama between Jemmye and Knight. And I think they went with Austin because they were always such a popular season. I have no clue why Fresh Meat was the replacement team, though. They should've just called in Road Rules as the replacement...

[QUOTE=TexasFight88;391987]I think that Austin was there because they wanted to have more than one veteran team (Fresh Meat was the other, who replaced Sydney). But, yeah, New Orleans really didn't do anything for me. Preston and McKenzie were both boring, and aside from Knight and Jemmye having that scene at the bar when he told her he'd marry her, they didn't do all that much. With DC, you would have had 3 people (Mike, Ty, Ashley) who would have likely started some drama. You had Ty and Emily coming off of BOTS, and there was the chance that they could go at it, Ashley and Ty speak their minds, and the former probably would have ended up on Rivals II if she was anything like she was on DC, not to mention her being ****** at Ty for stiffing her on rent, and Mike isn't afraid to push peoples buttons. IIRC, Molds said the cast would have been Emily, Ty, Ashley and Josh, with Mike as an alternate. If true, why Josh? He brought nothing to the table on the DC season, and would have been the most boring person in the house.[/QUOTE] That still leaves the question of why Road Rules got stiffed for BOTS. They would have been a perfect team to add for veteran balance and a muche better choice than Austin and Fresh Meat/Spring Break if the rumored team of Derrick/Darrell/Rachel/Katie is what we would have seen. All 4 have been involved in past seasons drama and certainly would have given the newcomers a real push. It would seem the road rulers could have brought better ratings as well since a lot of them are fan favorites. It's really hard to understand the logic of production leaving them off if all 4 were down and ready to do the show.

[QUOTE=Youssarian;391992]Honestly, I think that they had San Diego/St. Thomas there just because they were both recent seasons and hadn't yet had a chance to appear. I think they went with NOLA solely because of the potential drama between Jemmye and Knight. And I think they went with Austin because they were always such a popular season. I have no clue why Fresh Meat was the replacement team, though. They should've just called in Road Rules as the replacement...[/QUOTE] Fresh Meat was there because Sydney had to be replaced. I would have loved to have seen the Road Rules team. I believe Derrick said on his podcast that the the team would have been himself, Darrell, Katie and Rachel.

[QUOTE=Youssarian;391992]Honestly, I think that they had San Diego/St. Thomas there just because they were both recent seasons and hadn't yet had a chance to appear. I think they went with NOLA solely because of the potential drama between Jemmye and Knight. And I think they went with Austin because they were always such a popular season. I have no clue why Fresh Meat was the replacement team, though. They should've just called in Road Rules as the replacement...[/QUOTE] The San Diego cast was actually eligible for Battle of the Exes too since Nate and Priscilla were there.

[QUOTE=CHIblackhawk;391995]The San Diego cast was actually eligible for Battle of the Exes too since Nate and Priscilla were there.[/QUOTE] Well, yes, but I was referring to the fact that none of the 4 people who were on Team San Diego had done a Challenge before, even though Nate and Priscilla were on Exes.

[QUOTE=Squad;391989]Battle of the Exes 2 1.Knight/Jemmye 2.Zach/Jonna 3.Leroy/Theresa 4.CT/Ana 5.Jordan/Sarah 6.Dustin/Cooke 7.Ty/Paula 8.Cory/Jenny 9.Thomas/Jamie 10.Trey/Laura 11.Robb/Marie 12.Jay/Jenna 13.Marlon/Nany 14.Johnny R./Averey[/QUOTE] Thomas & Jamie never broke up.

[QUOTE=Livewitpeace;391986]I wouldn't call it punishing them... its entertaining us though and that is also most important! As for the money thing I do get it but I think it would really make people think about who they can beat in a final verse bring friends/alliance members along. I'll budge for atleast 2nd place winning money! Do you like the cast & format though?[/QUOTE] The only parts of the format I like are the date, the winner picks who goes in and what the missions are based on. The rest is bad. And the thing about having second place in the mission have to maybe go in just because they did better then all but one team is it leads to people doing the bare minimum so they won't be last and won't be second. That to me is super boring and ruins the competition. The cast is terrible, I like some of them but absolutely hate who they are paired with, like KellyAnne & Dunbar.Plus you put Swift & Trey instead of LaToya.

[QUOTE=TexasFight88;391987]I think that Austin was there because they wanted to have more than one veteran team (Fresh Meat was the other, who replaced Sydney). But, yeah, New Orleans really didn't do anything for me. Preston and McKenzie were both boring, and aside from Knight and Jemmye having that scene at the bar when he told her he'd marry her, they didn't do all that much. With DC, you would have had 3 people (Mike, Ty, Ashley) who would have likely started some drama. You had Ty and Emily coming off of BOTS, and there was the chance that they could go at it, Ashley and Ty speak their minds, and the former probably would have ended up on Rivals II if she was anything like she was on DC, not to mention her being ****** at Ty for stiffing her on rent, and Mike isn't afraid to push peoples buttons. IIRC, Molds said the cast would have been Emily, Ty, Ashley and Josh, with Mike as an alternate. If true, why Josh? He brought nothing to the table on the DC season, and would have been the most boring person in the house.[/QUOTE] I didn't mind NOLA being on seasons. It wouldn't have been fair not to include them considering they hadn't been represented on a challenge yet despite ample opportunities on Rivals/Exes. Mckenzie was a dud and should have been the alternate instead of Ashlee. Ashlee would have made the team much better. Preston could've been swapped for Eric, but I feel Preston is underrated. Ultimately though Ashlee/Eric/Jemmye/Knight should have been the team. I loved the seasons cast, but in retrospect, this is the cast I wish we would have gotten: [COLOR="#B22222"][B]Team Las Vegas:[/B] Alton Frank R Arissa Trishelle[/COLOR] [COLOR="#66ccff"][B]Team San Diego:[/B] Randy Zach Ashley K Cameran[/COLOR] [COLOR="#FF0000"][B]Team Austin:[/B] Danny Wes Lacey Melinda[/COLOR] [COLOR="#000080"][B]Team Brooklyn:[/B] Chet JD Devyn Sarah[/COLOR] [COLOR="#006400"][B]Team Cancun:[/B] CJ Derek Emilee Jonna[/COLOR] [COLOR="#0000FF"][B]Team DC:[/B] Josh Mike Ashley L Emily[/COLOR] [COLOR="#808080"][B]Team New Orleans:[/B] Eric Knight Ashlee Jemmye[/COLOR] [COLOR="#FFD700"][B]Team Back to Las Vegas:[/B] Dustin Leroy Cooke Nany[/COLOR]

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;392002]The only parts of the format I like are the date, the winner picks who goes in and what the missions are based on. The rest is bad. And the thing about having second place in the mission have to maybe go in just because they did better then all but one team is it leads to people doing the bare minimum so they won't be last and won't be second. That to me is super boring and ruins the competition. The cast is terrible, I like some of them but absolutely hate who they are paired with, like KellyAnne & Dunbar.Plus you put Swift & Trey instead of LaToya.[/QUOTE] OMG I put Swift & Trey instead of LaToya. I meant LaToya & Swift and Trey & Laura. Also, why I choose Dunbar & KellyAnne is because I rather see KellyAnne with Dunbar because they hate each other their is possibly more another person for Cohutta to be with. And second place does not go in, the last 2 teams, 1 of them will go in. That will be chosen by the other teams. Just something different!

[QUOTE=Livewitpeace;392005]OMG I put Swift & Trey instead of LaToya. I meant LaToya & Swift and Trey & Laura. Also, why I choose Dunbar & KellyAnne is because I rather see KellyAnne with Dunbar because they hate each other their is possibly more another person for Cohutta to be with.[/QUOTE] Dunbar doesn't deserve to get a strong partner. I'd pair Wes & KellyAnne BC they actually dated unlike Theresa and him.

[QUOTE=TexasFight88;391987]IIRC, Molds said the cast would have been Emily, Ty, Ashley and Josh, with Mike as an alternate. If true, why Josh? He brought nothing to the table on the DC season, and would have been the most boring person in the house.[/QUOTE] I heard that Ashley and Ty/Josh still have a lot of drama after their season ended and that's why.

[QUOTE=Challenge 17;392006]Dunbar doesn't deserve to get a strong partner. I'd pair Wes & KellyAnne BC they actually dated unlike Theresa and him.[/QUOTE] Well what would be your ideal Battle of the Exes 2 cast realistically and format?