The Challenge: Create Your Own

I don't think thats too much AYTO.They've had 2 seasons so far so I think its fair to have 6 or 7 of them. And I replaced Ellie with Jenny.

Battle of the Exes 3

This time, exes play against each other on two separate teams, the "Good" Ex vs. the "Bad" Ex - a la Inferno, although this is subjective

Numbers correspond to exes

"Good" Exes

1. Coral Smith (RW: Back to New York)

2. Cohutta Grindstaff (RW: Sydney)

3. Melinda Stolp (RW: Austin)

4. Randy Barry (RW: San Diego)

5. Jenny Delich (RW: Ex-Plosion)

6. Landon Lueck (RW: Philadelphia)

7. Laura Waller (RW: St. Thomas)

8. Thomas Buell (RW: Ex-Plosion)

9. KellyAnne Judd (RW: Sydney)

10. Robb Schreiber (RW: St. Thomas)

11. Rachel Robinson (RR: Campus Crawl)

12. Davis Mallory (RW: Denver)

13. Ashley Kelsey (RW: San Diego 2)

14. Leroy Garrett (RW: Las Vegas 2)

"Bad" Exes

1. Abram Boise (RR: South Pacific)

2. Nany Gonzalez (RW: Las Vegas 2)

3. Danny Jamieson (RW: Austin)

4. Kina Dean (RR: X-Treme)

5. Cory Wharton (RW: Ex-Plosion)

6. Shavonda Billingslea (RW: Philadelphia)

7. Trey Weatherholtz (RW: St. Thomas)

8. Jamie Larson (RW: Ex-Plosion)

9. Wes Bergmann (RW: Austin)

10. Marie Roda (RW: St. Thomas)

11. Jenn Grijalva (RW: Denver)

12. Ryan Kehoe (Fresh Meat)

13. Zach Nichols (RW: San Diego 2)

14. Theresa Gonzalez (Fresh Meat 2)

I would switch Robb and Marie since Robb did dump Marie through phone. Also switch Thomas and Jamie and Zach/Ashley unless it was Zach/Jonna. But good idea.

Challenge: Cutthroat 2

The difference in this one from the original Cutthroat is that when the cast members assemble for the first time, they all do a blind vote to decide who the three captians are.  Then the captains get to do a draft for their team but instead of seeing who they are picking, the only see a sheet with data on it for each player (gender, 40 yd dash, bench, mile time, etc.) with a number not a name.

This is a possible team break up:

RED TEAM:                                                                              GREY TEAM:                                                                              BLUE TEAM:                                       

Bananas (Captain)                                                             Emily (Captain)                                                                       Sarah (Captain)

Laurel                                                                                      Zach                                                                                             Frank

Cory                                                                                         Cara Marie                                                                                  Theresa

Nia                                                                                            Leroy                                                                                            Dustin

Wes                                                                                          Nicole                                                                                           Nany

Jonna                                                                                     Johnny                                                                                         Jordan

Bruno                                                                                     Jenna                                                                                            Shanley

Jessica A.                                                                              Layton                                                                                          Scali

Cohutta                                                                                 Jacy                                                                                               LaToya

Ellie                                                                                         Chris T.                                                                                         Brandon

^ I really like this idea schaubeezy, great cast btw

Personally I would drop Cara Maria from the Brains tribe after watching the Smarty Pants challenge on Free Agents. She didn't even knew what a continent was. But overall it's a pretty good cast. 

The Challenge: Brains vs. Brawn vs. Beauty

 

After my previous attempt, I thought my cast had too many regulars in it, so I changed some things up and I guess I'll add the format and optional twist. (I still want to change this cast some more)

 

Brains:

Johnny "Bananas" Devenanzio (RW: Key West)

Cohutta Grindstaff (RW: Sydney)

Andrew Woods (RW: DC)

Frank Sweeney (RW: San Diego 2)

Thomas Buell (RW: Explosion)

 

Devyn Simone (RW: Brooklyn)

Jonna Mannion (RW: Cancun)

Cara Maria Sorbello (Fresh Meat 2)

Laurel Stucky (Fresh Meat 2)

Nia Moore (RW: Portland)

 

Brawn:

Scott Herman (RW: Brooklyn)

Zach Nichols (RW: San Diego 2)

Robb Schreiber (RW: St. Thomas)

Cory Wharton (RW: Explosion)

Bruno Bettencourt (RW: Skeletons)

 

Emily Schromm (RW: DC)

Ashlee Feldman (RW: New Orleans 2)

Marie Roda (RW: St. Thomas)

Jenny Delich (RW: Explosion)

Nicole Zanatta (RW: Skeletons)

 

Beauty:

Mark Long (RR: USA)

Greg Halstead (RW: Hollywood) (just for lolz & trollololz)

Jordan Wiseley (RW: Portland)

Brian Williams (RW: Explosion)

Tony Raines (RW: Skeletons)

 

KellyAnne Judd (RW: Sydney)

Ayiiia Elizarraras (RW: Cancun)

Nany Gonzales (RW: Las Vegas 2)

Averey Tressler (RW: Portland)

Violleta Milerman (RW: Skeletons)

 

Note: "Brains/Brawn/Beauty" is a good enough name. You don't need to blanket it with some half-ass name that doesn't even encompass the theme itself. Viewers will know what it means, don't worry.

 

Alternates who I considered: Landon, Darrell, Rachel, Abram, Coral, CT, Camila, Wes, Will, Mike, Erika, CJ, Trey, Dustin, Leroy, Cooke, Ashley K, LaToya, Marlon, Jamie L, Ashley M, the rest of Skeletons, and maybe some people from RR: VR like Ivory, Dan, and David. This means that AYTO can stay home.

 

FORMAT:

Missions: The winning team will earn $20,000 to be stored within their team bank account. There will also be a 2nd and 3rd place team. The 1st place team will choose 1 person, male or female, from the 3rd place team, to be safe from deliberation.

Deliberation: The 2nd and 3rd place teams will meet in a room together. One by one, they will privately vote, like in Cutthroat. Except, they will write down one male's name and one female's name separately. After that, TJ will read the votes, one-by-one, out loud. (This will create suspense) The individuals with the most votes from both teams will go into elimination. If there's ever a tie, the team will revote, but only for those that caused the tie.

The eliminations are 1 v 1. (I haven't figured out what kind of eliminations I'd do, and/or if I would include the system that BOTS2 used.) Winners return to their respective teams, losers leave empty-handed.

 

OPTIONAL TWIST: So I guess every challenge from here on out needs some twist, right? Ehh... well, if so, here's a twist for this challenge: Around halfway through the season, TJ will announce to everyone that they are no longer teams, and it's all individual. No one would know that the twist was coming, but instead would have been too busy getting rid of their weaker players. This twist will ultimately decide who from the Brains, the Brawn, and the Beauty, will come out on top.

--All of the money from each team will be stored to each player (from that team) within their own individual bank accounts. (Think of The Ruins)

--There will be one male winner and one female winner in the missions. They will publicly pick 1 person from their gender to automatically go into elimination. That person can then call out anyone of their gender, other than the winners, to go up against them in elimination. The male and female winners stay in the game, and will also take the money from the loser's bank accounts.

 

PAYOUT:

If the twist IS being used, this is the payout:

1st place M/F:     $100,000 each.

2nd place M/F:   $35,000 each.

3rd place M/F:    $15,000 each.

(+PLUS the money earned from individual bank accounts.)

(11 missions + final, 6 team, 5 individual. $120,000 total from team missions)

---------------

If the twist IS NOT being used, this is the payout:

1st place team: $200,000 to be split (+PLUS the money earned from the team bank account.)

Remaining teams: Split with what they've earned from the missions. Optional: 2nd place gets an additional $20,000.

(10 missions + final, $200,000 total from team missions)

 

Spoiler: Scott Herman wins. My sources told me so. huehuahue.

 

By the way, I wouldn't recommend quoting this entire post.

Personally I would drop Cara Maria frol the Brains tribe after watching the Smarty Pants challenge on Free Agents. She didn't even knew what a continent was. But overall it's a pretty good cast. 

I was thinking of replacing her with Sarah R or Hailey. It's kind of hard though since I'm one of the few here who like her. Plus, my brawn team is full and I don't plan on replacing anyone on that team.

 I love Cohutta but how is he a brain?