Challenge Rookie Prospects

70 posts / 0 new
Last post
Josh Goldstein - Love Island USA 3 - He should've been on USA1 instead of the Cashel guy but Skye can fix her wrongs and cast this king! 
Alex Dourassof - Surviving Paradise (Netflix) - So if yall didn't watch this one season show all you have to know is the format is basically have or have nots. This man was the evil strategical gay i live for. We need messy hot gays back on the challenge!!

yesss!

Bryton from Squid Games. Reality tv hasn't had a villain like this in a long time. He is must.

Josh Goldstein - Love Island USA 3 - He should've been on USA1 instead of the Cashel guy but Skye can fix her wrongs and cast this king! 

Oh, he fine. 

@Sportsman, where is the one for Sam and Kaleb!

Skye is enjoying crossing off people on her list because Vevmo wants them

Skye is enjoying crossing off people on her list because Vevmo wants them

She gave me Sydney, Dee, Cedric, & Yeremi who I campaigned heavily for. She may hate me but she knows I'm right Smile

@Sportsman, where is the one for Sam and Kaleb!

I'll pull the ones up for them and Venus soon. Need that trio bad.

Who do we got from Big Brother before this season still worth mentioning? Chelsie, Reilly, Leah, maybe Cam? Maybe Jared? Anyone else?

Who do we got from Big Brother before this season still worth mentioning? Chelsie, Reilly, Leah, maybe Cam? Maybe Jared? Anyone else?

Cam? No thanks, he was a snooze. Jared isn't Challenge material. Leah...meh. I've seen way better suggestions on here for the limited spots.

Anyone from Australian Survivor? They had some great options a few seasons ago but they are probbaly too old now and I haven't seen any new seasons since David won All Stars.

Ty - Big Brother Canada - I'm still shocked he was able to win his season after all the fights he got into. Not afraid of an argument and won almost every competition 
Lete - Deal or No Deal Island - Lady ice queen. She was runner up on her season and just like Gabriel from 41 she's a WWE reject. When she got fired a bunch of the women celebrated cause apparently she was a diva lol. She's also pretty built 

Lete - Deal or No Deal Island - Lady ice queen. She was runner up on her season and just like Gabriel from 41 she's a WWE reject. When she got fired a bunch of the women celebrated cause apparently she was a diva lol. She's also pretty built 

Yes! I said she would be great from the second I saw her. I wouldn't mind seeing Maria Grace and Storm from that season either.

 

Lete - Deal or No Deal Island - Lady ice queen. She was runner up on her season and just like Gabriel from 41 she's a WWE reject. When she got fired a bunch of the women celebrated cause apparently she was a diva lol. She's also pretty built 

Yes! I said she would be great from the second I saw her. I wouldn't mind seeing Maria Grace and Storm from that season either.

Storm is a beautiful man! I didn't mention him cause he was cut pretty early so no idea if he'd be a dud or not but fully on board for his debut just for some eye candy.

Sam Phalen

Age: 25

First RTV Appearance:

Survivor 47

Sam has so much potential to be a staple on the franchise. He's got "leading man" swagger and good looks. He has a good physical game and a decent social game. But his bread and butter is the strategic game. Operation Italy was *chef's kiss*. And he has a flair for the dramatic. A great confessionalist and a natural public speaker (he's an NFL sideline reporter), Sam is exactly what The Challenge need moving forward: confident, young, athletic, and WANTS TO WIN.

He needs to get better at carnival games in general and he lacks life experience so he comes off a little immature but he's could be a staple on The Challenge for the next 5+ years. He honestly felt a little miscast for Survivor, in my opinion. Like Sydney, he has a cynical arrogant swagger that is much more adapted to The Challenge.

Best Quality for The Challenge: Personality - gamer, cutthroat, arrogant, smart.

Worst Quality for The Challenge: He's married. No hookups.

Venus Vafa

Age: 26

First RTV Appearance:

Survivor 46

Venus is as promising of a rookie as you could want on a show like this. She has an ethereal, almost unreal beauty. But that's not why she belongs here.

The woman does not have a filter and will not let go of an argument. She will tell you what's on her mind, no matter what. She's stubborn and strong-willed. She will not bend to others if she does not like the plan. She's a fantastic reality tv character.

She lasted as long as she did on 46 almost by mistake. She hated most of those people and did not hide it from them. She would flounder in a season with weak rookie numbers but in a cast of half rookies, she's gonna keep shit entertaining with her arguments. Not the most impressively athletically, but she has cardio and some agility from what I could tell. She's a must-have rookie from a drama perspective.

Best Quality for The Challenge: Loves to argue, MUST get the last word.

Worst Quality for The Challenge: Physically vulnerable in eliminations.

Id include puzzles as a weakness for Sam plus him being a bit undersized for the guys. 

Id include puzzles as a weakness for Sam plus him being a bit undersized for the guys. 

I think he's smart enough to work on puzzles if he gets the call. He might be a bit underweight but I don't think he's that undersized. He's 6'3".

Kaleb Gebrewold

Age: 30

First RTV Appearance:

Survivor 45

I don't think it's controversial to say that Kaleb is one of the most likable and charismatic people to ever play Survivor. Dude is charming as hell. His ommission from Season 50 is EGREGIOUS.

He has charisma for days. He was voted off for being too good at being liked. He also had a decent strategic game and was very good in challenges. And it wasn't like he went down without a fight. His SITD play was one of the best highlights of the entire new era. He's a super popular, dynamic choice for The Challenge. He's electric on-screen and insanely rootable. He would be a fan favorite on this show nearly overnight.

Best Quality for The Challenge: Almost a guaranteed lock to be a fan favorite.

Worst Quality for The Challenge: Tends to be a bit too trusting, which leaves him vulnerable to being backstabbed.

Tori Meehan

Age: 28

First RTV Appearance:

Survivor 42

Tori has admitted to getting calls for The Challenge USA2 and I'm pretty sure the only reason she didn't make the cut is because her name is "Tori". She's such an underrated villain. She's got that annoying, arrogant, "little sister" energy that just works on a show like The Challenge.

I don't know why she's gotten lost in the shuffle. She's very pretty and physically gifted enough to win an individual immunity. She would hold her own physically and socially on the show. She's not scared of confrontations at all. She runs towards them. 

Best Quality for The Challenge: Enjoys arguing and conflict.

Worst Quality for The Challenge: Hasn't been on tv in 3.5 years, she could have grown up and matured.

Id include puzzles as a weakness for Sam plus him being a bit undersized for the guys. 

I think he's smart enough to work on puzzles if he gets the call. He might be a bit underweight but I don't think he's that undersized. He's 6'3".

I didnt say he was a twig, he's just not as jacked as a lot of guys on the show are.

I love Venus, she'd truly make the most of the three episodes max shed last lol

I love Venus, she'd truly make the most of the three episodes max shed last lol

I don't know. Smaller people do better than we expect sometimes.

Big Lex from baddies. 

I love Venus, she'd truly make the most of the three episodes max shed last lol

I don't know. Smaller people do better than we expect sometimes.

Its not just her size it's that she'd certainly get herself thrown in early tbh

Lete is such an obviously amazing pick so there's no way in hell they'll ever cast her. 

SO MANY GOOD CHOICES FROM NETFLIX

like just ctrl-C, ctrl-V the Battle Camp cast and you're good. some people I'd love to see:

  • Tony (The Mole 2)
  • Avori (The Mole 1)
  • Nick (The Circle 3)
  • QT (The Circle 6)
  • Chase (Too Hot to Handle 2)
  • Lorenzo (Squid Game)
  • Trey (Squid Game)
  • Hannah (The Mole 2)
  • Xanthi (The Circle 5)
  • Will (The Mole 1)
  • Dom (The Mole 1)
  • Etc etc

    and let's not forget Big Brother Canada alumni:

  • Santina (BBCan11)
  • Adam (BBCan7)
  • Bayleigh (BBCan12)
  • Kayla (BBCan12)
  • Kuzie (BBCan11)
  • Jacey-Lynne (BBCan10)
  • Tychon (BBCan9)
  • Rohan (BBCan9)
  • Minh-Ly (BBCan8)
  • Lauren O'Connell

    Age: 28

    First RTV Appearance:

    Survivor 38: EoE

    Just cause I wrote this up last year and I'll give this one more shot! 

    Can someone please tell me why I have to beg to get Lauren O'Connell on this show? This gorgeous (she looks like she could be Rachel Weisz's little sister), bubbly queen literally grew up on her 37 days of Survivor, she was like a timid kid who grew up into a confident, strong woman. She was fun and sarcastic and sassy the whole way through. I find her very endearing and likable in general. She also stayed upbeat while her tribe absolutely sucked.

    Her alliance with Wentworth and rivalry with Chris Underwood (of USA2 fame) were super cute and in general, Lauren is just super rootable. Her only season of Reality TV was 6 years ago, but she's only 28 still and would be a very fitting and deserving rookie.

    Best Quality for The Challenge: Rootable, adorable, good in challenges, and relatable.

    Worst Quality for The Challenge: Her season ended 6 years ago? 

    Pages